Tuesday, October 19, 2010

AYPD first session

The first AYPD session was on September 20, 2010.  Because we don't have any video of the teachers' own classrooms yet, we will spend the first few sessions watching other video - some from the Open Source Tutorials collection, some from Valerie, some from the summer, etc.  This will also give us some time to establish norms for discussing each other's video before any of the teachers is on the hot seat. We decided to show some Open Source Tutorials video first, because that's my stuff, so we can put ourselves out there first.  Also, I'm very comfortable leading discussions of that video, so it reduced my anxiety.  I thought it might be a bonus for some of the teachers that the instructional materials and the video collection are freely available, so I brought a box of the OST DVDs with me that night.  Here's one of the videos we discussed:


For over an hour we had a terrific conversation of this episode and one other episode of the same group.  Like the OST video discussions I am used to, it was full of interesting observations, claims, values, questions, and so on.  I was feeling pretty happy with the whole thing.  Then, right at the very very end of class, this happened.  The first speaker, who is off-camera, is an elementary science coach.  The second speaker is an elementary teacher who was sitting at the same table.  (There are a couple seconds of silence at the start - persist!)




Rachel:  Go ahead, and then I'm going to wind this up.
K:  One last thing.  Coming from the elementary, we do this a lot, but I kept thinking what kind of scaffolding is there around this room for them as they're having this conversation?  Just like, in an elementary classroom teachers would have all the forms of energy that they've been learning about, all the stuff they've been drawing and so forth, hearing about in lecture, on a chart somewhere.  To direct them back, "are we even talking about the energy right now?  or are we mixing that up with force, or work, or..."  And so, I just, so often, you know, the kids they don't have a lot of scaffolding.  They're just in a room with a worksheet to fill out and talking to each other and just, it seemed like they could have used... 
C:  And, I saw nothing that indicated any mental stimulation here.  They were discussing but there was nothing hands on, there were no analogies that they could make, there were no comparisons they could make with perhaps some prior knowledge.  What if it wasn't a person pushing against a wall, what if it was a machine?
Rachel: So that's the sort of analogy you would have liked to have seen.

I remember that I began to hit the ceiling (internally.... it is amazing to me how calm I look on video) when C said, "I saw nothing that indicated any mental stimulation."  What is she saying - the students are morons?  Comatose?  At "nothing hands-on," I thought, does she perhaps think that "mental stimulation" requires manipulatives?  When she said "no analogies they could make, no comparisons they could make with their prior knowledge," I was just plain confused, because that stuff is all over their discourse.  Perhaps she meant no teacher-provided analogies?  While I was struggling to understand what she might mean, and also struggling with my own emotional response, she went on.




C: I just didn't see any excitement.  I question the worksheet.  I question the assignment.  What is the validity, what is the learning goals that this instructor has for these students?  Because they didn't have any [one?] that I could see, except getting it done.  
Rachel:  Hm.  Did other people see that same lack, disconnect between what they were, the physics they were talking about and anything else that they might have related it to?  Seemed like you were talking about them struggling to make that relationship, but maybe not successfully, is what you're saying?
C: I would think that these students walk away from this thinking, "Bleh bleh [inaudible]."
[laughter]
someone: Physics is so
Rachel: Biology is so *whew*
[more laughter]
Rachel: I gotta close this up here, but this is actually a good note to end on, because [cut]


It was NOT a good note to end on - that was sheer sleight of hand on my part.  Nor do I have any idea what C said that we all laughed at; nothing was funny to me; the laughing, for me, was pure tension.  But whatever, we had to end class, so I diverted - I said something like, "It's worth pointing out that we don't have to agree on whether this is an exemplary episode in order to have a good discussion about the student thinking that is in it," and somehow got us out of there.

Even if there had been time, though, I could not have thought clearly enough to locate an appropriate response, if there even is one.  The students weren't doing shit, was what I heard, and it's the instructor's fault for putting them in a situation that ignores the most basic pedagogical requirements.  In other words, we can blame this pedagogical shambles on the instructional design's "validity" and the instructor's incompetence.  I was boiling sea of inappropriate responses combined with an intense urge to run out of the room.  In my favor, at least I knew I was flooded.  Although I thought of all kinds of things to say (for example, spitting back at them that this is MY worksheet and what did they think of THAT), I was pretty sure that whatever I said would be coming from a bad place, so I did my best to say basically nothing at all.  I pathetically packed up my free DVDs.

Later, when I had calmed down some, I tried to think over why the things these teachers said had gotten under my skin so much.  Part of it is surely that I am not so sure about my own legitimacy and competence as an AYPD instructor.  Another part of it, I think, is that they were dismissing an episode I love and find worthwhile.  I was saying, "Hey, look, see what I brought!" and they were saying, "That's garbage. You should know better."  And it's not just the episode I love, it's the students in that episode.  I love them!  I delight in their free-ranging conversation, the connections they make, their friendly skepticism.  And they were telling me that they are not delightful, not lovable.  Just in that offhand way like "You can't be cold, it's perfectly warm in here."  They can't do that to my students!  But they did, and seemed to think nothing of it, and I got confused and defensive and stuck.

Stamatis and I talked about it and agreed that this had been rough, but that it was much better that it was me rather than one of the teachers, and that it would provide a heck of a basis for us to establish the norms for future video discussions.  We agreed that the next AYPD session would make explicit use of what had happened.  You can imagine how much I was looking forward to that.  Not.

AYPD general plan, 2010-11

I had been thinking of this blog as mainly for thinking about the summer, but of course it ought to be about all of our work with the teachers -- all the more so since many of the researcher-videographers who are part of the project aren't here during the academic year.  And maybe you all out there could help!  So I am going to try to document and summarize what's been going on with the teachers in the evening academic-year professional development (AYPD) sessions.

The Energy Project team decided that as the summer focused on learning about energy, the AYPD should focus on learning to attend to student ideas.  Not too surprisingly, we decided that the most effective way to do this would be for the teachers to spend a good fraction of the AYPD sessions watching video of students discussing their ideas, especially ideas about energy, and ideally the participating teachers' own students - a video club.  Then, while I was out of the room, everyone else decided that I should be one of the primary instructors for the evening sessions, especially for the video club part.  (Stamatis is the other instructor.  Eleanor attends when she can.)  This is a big challenge for me, because while I'm pretty comfortable leading sessions in which other people (including teachers) discuss a video episode in detail, I've never led sessions in which teachers were looking at video of themselves.  That seems importantly different for at least three reasons that I can think of:

  1. Putting your own classroom in front of colleagues for discussion is a big risk.  I don't feel like I have much experience in doing what it takes to insure a safe environment for everyone, so that we can do worthwhile work and not hurt anyone or just be unproductive.
  2. This is work that engages the teachers as teachers, rather than as physics learners.  It's a little embarrassing for me to admit this, but I have almost no experience with that. 
  3. The last time I did field work, the classroom video that I collected did not include much that would support attention to student ideas.  Student ideas weren't being made visible.  I'm worried I won't be able to find episodes worth discussing.
There are also some logistical difficulties that I think are going to make life harder:  Video clubs that I know of have been fairly intimate little learning teams, maybe 4-10 teachers, and we have 15-25 teachers at each session.  Worse, it's not the same people at every session, because the teachers don't have to attend all of them to earn credit.  It seems like it might be really hard to have an atmosphere of trust under these conditions.

That said, I can't think of anything that I think would be better to do with these sessions, and I can't think of anyone else who I think would be better at running them.  (Actually I very much can, but those people aren't here.)  So we're going for it.  Through Rosemary Russ I know that Miriam Sherin's group has a major focus on teacher learning with video:  I am learning as much as I can from what they do, and we are adopting their theoretical framework.  I also had a reassuring conversation with Emily van Zee when I was in Oregon over the weekend.  

Do you all know of more published work, or other people, that might help us in our planning?

Monday, September 27, 2010

Updated Swackhamer paper

While looking for something else entirely, I stumbled upon this version of the Swackhamer paper we've been passing around:

http://modeling.asu.edu/modeling/CognitiveResources-Energy.pdf

It was updated in 2005, 2 years later than the draft we've been reading. I don't have time to look at the changes carefully, but it does look like it's been updated quite a bit, and has a clearer explanation of a lot of the metaphor stuff.

Also, the site where I found this has a whole list of resources for teaching energy, which may or may not be useful to us:

http://modeling.asu.edu/modeling/CognitiveResources-Energy.pdf

Telling Stories about Energy (a lunchtime conversation between Brian and me)

I finally get around to blog about an interesting conversation that I had with Brian, over a week ago. We had lunch together, and a conversation about events that happened during the "Intuitive Quantum Physics" labs erupted and soon found its way to the topic energy.

We started talking about energy transfer in the case of light waves, and the Poynting vector. Pretty soon, our conversation went to more everyday things like kinetic and potential energy. I was wondering if we really need to introduce the concept "field" in order to be able to talk about potential energy, or if we can just say that an object has potential energy. This was the start of our conversation, which was then spread out over about two days.

Along the way we considered these stories describing physical scenarios (as well as others):

1. I had energy (in me) and when put in effort to lifting the ball, the energy left me and went to the ball.

2. The ball had energy when it was held up high in the air. When I let go, it hit the ground and the ball's energy went into the earth.

3. As the ball fell, it changed its energy from potential to kinetic.

The first two stories are similar. One kind of story we tell with energy is how it gets from one location (or object) to another location (or object). The first story relates energy to the everyday experience with effortful lifting, and the second story tells a story where the results of my efforts (the energy in the ball) went after the ball hit the ground. The results of my effort are now distributed across the earth. They got there through the process of the ball coming into contact with the surface of the earth.

The third story is very different. The third story is about potential changing to kinetic, and how that happens coincidently with the ball moving downward. This is not a story about energy going from one object to another. It is a story about energy changing within an object and that object changing location.

One question for these stories might be this: why does lifting cause energy to change objects and falling cause energy to change kind? Another question might be, do we need two kinds of stories? One attempt to unify the stories is introduce the concept of a "field". Lifting the ball makes energy go to the field; as the ball falls, energy goes from the field to the ball; and when the ball hits the earth, energy goes from the ball to the earth. Lifting, falling, and hitting are all processes that allow energy to go from one object to another. Now lifting and falling do the same thing.

We also touched upon other stories, such as energy going from the sun to the earth (via the process of radiation). We could ask "where was the energy when it was not in the sun and not in the earth?"  We might, for example, begin to fill in the gaps of the story by telling how energy went from the sun to the light, which is a new object in our story. We might then again ask about the process by which energy went from the sun to the light, and maybe we'd tell a process story of "electron" dropping energy levels. Now we are back to the potential energy issue again?

From this conversations we came away wondering many things:

We wondered if "asking where the energy is during a process" is essentially trying to fill in the gaps of an energy story. We wondered if this "filling in" requires some new object in the energy story.

We also wondered about the epistemic value of "objects fall" and the energy story from above? The story doesn't seem to explain anything about why objects fall.

We wondered if "energy moves from places where it is dense to places where it is sparse" is the explanatory base (or primitive) for energy narratives. The hot coffee is dense with energy and so the energy goes into the room where the energy is relatively sparse. This is another shot in the leg to the energy falling story.

We wondered if "energy" having some phenomenological correspondence is also a primitive explanatory idea. The coffee is hotter so it is denser in energy. The light is brighter when the energy flowing through it is denser. The spring is strained when it is compressed, and so has energy. Potential energy of the ball is weird, because the ball is not different (only its relationships to other objects is. In this sense, motion is also weird, but we won't get into that for now.

I hope that this collection of thoughts makes sense to you. It is a reconstruction of the conversation by Brian and me, and might not contain crucial steps that might be important for your understanding. So, if there is something missing, please ask away!

Also, I apologize for posting this with such a delay. I now that some people have been waiting for this post for quite some time...

Oh, and one more thing, I'd like to share and hear your opinions about something else that came up in our discussion. It's just a notion, not really a well thought-out and argued point:
We talk a lot about energy as a possession of objects (having substance-like qualities) and distinguish this "definition" from Feynman's. But "energy as a substance" together with "conservation" implies "accounting" (keeping track of something that happens to be conserved). So somehow the two definitions, Feynman's and the substance-like-thing one, are not that different!?

Thursday, September 9, 2010

Energy movie.

We can't easily do live theater in my 100-student class, so we're scripting movies of how energy blobs move and I'm tying it in with our PSET diagrams...  Here's one (a brake slowing down a spinning wheel).-  I can post others that we create (using clickers and shout-outs in lecture) if folks are interested.

Thursday, August 26, 2010

Printing and Saving Energy Project PERC proceedings papers

Some of you might have wondered if you can somehow print or save the PERC proceedings papers that are hosted by googleDocs on the Energy Project Hub web page. It turns out that there is a relatively easy way to do this:

1. Click on the title of the paper you want to print/save.
2. Once the document is loaded, click in the URL line of your browser and bring the cursor to the end of the URL by hitting the right arrow key of your keyboard.
3. Then add the string "&chrome=true" to the URL (without the quotation marks, and without any blanks!) an hit Enter.
4. The page reloads with Download and Print buttons at the top.

Friday, August 20, 2010

Dedra's thoughts and episodes from Friday

Ok - so this will be my last post for a while. I would have liked to have finished the transcripts for the episodes I found interesting, but as I clipped 6 today, including 20 mins of last night's instructor meeting, that's not going to happen.

I found the discussion that Rachel, Hunter, Sam, Benedikt and I had after lunch to be very fruitful. As we talked about this mechanism issue, Rachel and Hunter keyed in on an important point - this is an emotional issue - when a person is satisfied that they have found 'causation' that is really an issues of personal view. For example, do you think evaporation is a cause, or is that not a word you'd accept as a cause? I think that depends highly on whether or not you trust the person using it thoroughly understands the word (and implied agrees with your understanding). A second example: If a person says the reason this charge moved is because of that one over there, the implication of cause is coulomb's law - that may be fine unless A) you don't think the person understands electric interactions, or B) you're needing an explanation that goes deeper, like QED. But in either case - there is no 'correct' - back to the nature of science. A mechanism, cause, explanation... is only as good as it is to make the person FEEL satisfied with it...

Please add to comments on this one...

So my feelings that there is something interesting going on here with negotiation of meaning about cause and mechanism is quite tied to the fact that they feel compelled to throw out the word force in order to discuss energy. So I see a few angles here: what is mechanism, how does their meaning negotiation relate to the depth of their need for understanding/comfort/emotional state..., and what constraints is ET putting on the idea space if it is limiting them from drawing on force resources? (And it really isn't - they use force all the time... but seem to think their final 'answer' can't have force in it)

So I will mull over these things. Here's a brief synopsis of the episodes I captured today since I won't transcribe them or give them their own posts:

E1 100819 1502 Instructor meet mechanism modeling consensus.mov

This is a 24 minute clip of the instructor meeting where SV talks about being unclear with the use of the word mechanism, but I expanded it to also include the topic of consensus building. I would have to look at this fresh - but it seems very related, and at minimum starts to give the instructor side of this story. There's discussion in here about whether or not the broader physics community even has consensus about the word mechanism - an idea Hunter echoed this afternoon in an even stronger way - that it may not even be a 'scientific' term (my wording, not his).

E1 100820 0931 Tim_value_of_social_learning.mov

This was one of the first discussions of Friday morning. This is only a 3 min clip. There is a discussion going on briefly about whether to discuss things in forces vs. energy, and also the benefit of ah-ha moments, and how that solidifies ideas. (the mic quality isn't good) social learning is explicitly mentioned - but not taken up by the group as being off topic, but they discuss there being value in having the participants figure things out. they mention early frustration about the class - and whether everyone gets it now - they seem to think it's been a huge benefit. there's discussion about the instructors being aware of where things were going. I'm not sure how useful this clip is... comments of interest are brief and sound quality isn't great.

E1 100820 0931 Tim_workshop_purpose.mov

a bit later they again start talking about purpose. This clip is 8 mins long. Here they were explicitly prompted to discuss what's useful. "the instructor avoids defining any damn thing" you can't do that - need to put structure to it.. but need to give kids genuine opportunities to put ideas together on their own and be the guide on the side, and (compare formulations around the room). they're talking explicitly about the content and activities in the workshop really helped promote the kind of conversations they needed - brought out their ideas - gained fundamental insights about how energy works... consensus making process is great - they talk here about the need for MORE consensus... they also talk about tricking the students into thinking some meta-discussion is a 'fun side discussion' (my words) so the students are engaged thinking they're stealing time away from boring stuff, but it's actually the discussion the teacher wants them to have. I find this really ironic because IT IS EXACTLY WHAT IS HAPPENING in the moment for them! they're no longer answering the given prompts in their group, but they're having the meta-discussion about teaching that the workshop is 'really' about... This is a nice clip for thinking overall about the purpose of the workshop and their buy-in....

E1 100820 0931 Tim_reflecting_on_teaching.mov

Here again they're asked explicitly to reflect on the teaching in the workshop. This is a 7 min clip. They say they had to 'invent the objective' - Two participants say something explicit about knowing SV and trusting his teaching methods, and wondering if he did these things on purpose. They like the tools but found their use a bit vague at times "that huge highway could have been made a bit narrower" They express some frustration about concrete things they came to consensus on but never got back to. ('a disconnect') They also say they would have rather known the objective up front. They also think that the participants are homogeneous - want similar goals, but in their own classrooms they have to deal with different interest levels. 6 mins or so in, there is brief mention of why energy is a good topic for the course - that there are several different formats for discussing it. I wish this point had gone further. An interesting point they make is how without a standard for representations (on whiteboards) they were able to interpret other people's work. I'm not sure how directly useful this clip is to me, but probably useful to thinking about ET goals.

The last two clips interest me most (each about 3-4 mins long)

E1 100820 1031 Tim_force_energy_causation.mov

In this one the F=ma is explicitly stated - and ironically Tim who says they should keep it in context of energy (he's the one that used the word force and bruce argued he shouldn't the day before!!) Arny goes back to this energy/force confusion - he asks pointedly what role the force plays - doesn't the rubber band just stand for elastic potential energy? Arny uses the word 'cause' in a way that seems really provocative (is that REALLY what causes it?) - Tim seems to agree but one group member answers with the same force argument they just made. Then someone says that the removal of the string creates an unbalanced force that then allows the energy to be released. Arny wants more clarification... and he gets a simple physics answer - i don't think that's what he wanted...

E1 100820 1031 Tim_cause_mechanism_discussion.mov

Here they have an analogy of the rubber band in space. Tim uses the word push a lot, it's the mechanism for transferring that energy. Very briefly someone says 'do we have to have an object?' - unfortunately this line is dropped... There seem to be two levels of discourse (at least) within the group, and a lot of interesting statements are dropped for re-stated force explanations. Arny says the rubber band in outer space is like the car upside-down, which is really nice. Then they go back to 'what is the cause' - they seem to find that point difficult - but settle on it being the push "F=ma".

These last two clips are from about 15 mins of discussion they had about the rubber band launch. They were asked: 'what is the funder, what object is exerting the force, what causes the launch" There seems to be Tim and Arny trying to have a deeper discussion about cause and mechanism, where Tim and Janel keep repeating F=ma based reasoning. I'm not sure where Mary's ideas are here...

Anyway - food for later thought - time to return to Oregon!!