Showing posts with label cause. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cause. Show all posts

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Do we care WHY forces are there?

On Wednesday afternoon (8/7/13) in E1, a switch was made from energy to forces.  The class was taken to square one: considering the forces acting on a person sitting in a chair.  Surprisingly, this led to a nearly one hour conversation, both in small groups and the whole class.  In this video segment, Table 3 is presenting their whiteboard, which shows a representation of the forces acting on the chair.

During a previous whiteboard, Lane (the class instructor) brought forth an interesting example.  First, he shook hands with another teacher in the class and asked about the interactions.  The class responded that each hand exerts a force on the other.  Then he posed: what if the other person no longer existed?  There would no longer be a force of one hand on the other.  This example was then shifted to the earth/chair interaction.  What would happen if the earth is gone?


Rob poses this very question at the beginning of the video.


I am not so much interested in the exact physics details here.  Trevor makes an astute observation that in order for the chair and floor to interact, something would need to “push” them together now that gravity is no longer doing so.  He comments that part of the issue here is that “we haven’t talked about what causes the normal force.”

What interests me the most, and is directly related to the comment above, is the question posed at the very end.  Mikes asks: “We’re talking about the forces, we’re not necessarily talking about why they’re there, right?”

In the moment, I wanted to jump out of my seat and say, “Yes!  We DO care about why the forces are there!”  I think we NEED to know the origin of any given force, or else we cannot possibly include it in our diagram correctly.  For the most rudimentary force diagram of the chair on the ground, we could certainly draw an unidentified force vector pointing down which is balanced by an unidentified force vector pointing up.  However, this picture is unsatisfying.  It shows no insight into “what is really going on.”

This requires that we have a class consensus definition for each different force.  We must agree upon the definition of a normal force.  To do that, we should be looking at the CAUSE of the normal force, down to compression at the molecular level.  Once the class is on the same page, then the word normal force can be used with comfort. Similarly, we must agree upon the definition of the gravitational force.  We must agree that the CAUSE is two (or more) objects interacting with each other via an attractive force at a distance. 

The moral of my story: knowing WHY the forces are there is crucial in order to draw an accurate force diagram.  And the WHY can be determined simply by coming to a class consensus early on.

Full video title: E1 130807 1256 T3-1