Showing posts with label energy cubes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label energy cubes. Show all posts

Friday, August 9, 2013

E1 - Negotiation + Roles + Representations

E1 used Energy Cubes for the first time in Tuesday (first week). In table 6 (3 woman -Emma, Krista, and Barbara- and 1 man -Tracy-) there seems to be some roles involved in their dynamics. The three girls actively discuss a lot to figure out the energy in the scenario, while Tracy plays a role as a consultant for them. When they have a content question, they ask directly to Tracy to know the answer.

Ending the planning of the energy cubes


This team had a difficult time planning the cubic energy dynamics. Here we can see how both Emma (on the left) and Barbara (on the right) ask for Tracy's approval as they move in the decision making. They discuss the presence of potential energy in the scenario. They talk about potential energy being present, but is there other potential energy? They decide to left out gravitational potential energy (as consensus).
When Tracy considered what would happens if they consider it "although..." they both reject the idea to include it, they say "we are ready to move on (Barbara)" "I am not ready for that Tracy [...] I can't go there yet (Emma)".

Is he being considered as a reference in the group instead of an active member from it? He expressed the curiosity to discuss on the potential energy and how it goes to the floor. Yet when he observe the reaction he decides to abandon it, "I didn't go there" as saying he also thinks is difficult. I think Tracy is being responsive to his team situation. He has been attending to the group participation and reacting to that. He first say he dismissed it, but they he try to discuss it. At the end, after presenting his personal position he decides to not go there.

I decided to add the last seconds of this video to show how their dynamics, even after that tension with the energy cubes, still seem to be in a good environment of collaboration.

On the other hand, I am intrigued... what to they mean when they talk about potential energy? Emma talks about gravitational potential and then ask Tracy if he thinks there is other potential energy not due to gravity... I have observed potential energy being particularly difficult while doing ET. I don't know if Lane has established some rules on the use of the label potential energy.

Comparison with the other representations
They are talking to Adam (instructor) about the differences between using energy theater and Energy Cubes (EC).

At the beginning Tracy is saying things that could implement while doing Energy Theater (ET) (sitting down to have agreements on what will happen). [00:50] Barbara seems to notice a similarity, but she says for her it is not the same. According to Krista comment [1:13], she seems to connect easily what is done in ET into using cubes to explain it. [1:20] Emma "we want a diagram". They all agree the diagram is useful to make the decisions.
[1:32] Emma presents the concern that doing ET allows people who doesn't know stay in a passive role while the other do the thinking and tell you what to do. She consider that working with EC, since it is a smaller group, it involves a more active role from all of the participants and it adds more complication (since everyone is involved in the decisions]. Adam present his personal reaction to be told what to do [1:54] "I would say why?, I am the guy who push back". Emma still believe that if you don't want anyone to know you don't know it would be easy to not participate in ET. Barbara answer to that "But then when people started talking, everybody started talking".
Now I wonder... How were they acting during their ET? Is their comments related to what they experience... I would like to know if Emma actively participated during the decision making in the ET. What I liked about this video is that during the process of the EC everyone was into the analysis of what was happening, they questioned each other in every step they made for the representation. They were so meticulous and got frustrated more than once, they seemed to be very exhausted by the end of the planning (shown in this episode). I am amazed on the engagement they shown during this activity despite the frustration they got.

Thursday, May 30, 2013

Group A reflection

Reflection on “Representing energy. II. Energy tracking representations”

One of the joys of teaching at the University of New England (in southern Maine) is its proximity to the ocean.  With the semester over, I’ve had the luxury of reading these I-RISE articles on the beach.  With the sun now setting, I’ve returned home to write up some thoughts.

First, a brief background on my experience with energy.  Throughout my undergraduate and graduate studies I received traditional energy instruction, i.e. NO diagrammatic representations whatsoever!  Upon my hire at UNE, I participated in a two-week workshop on Modeling Instruction, since all physics instructors at my university work in studio classrooms and utilize the Modeling method.  During week 2 of that workshop, I was exposed to energy pies.  This way of diagrammatically representing energy opened my eyes forever.  For three years I’ve been joyfully using pie charts. 

Therefore, I was taken aback when the article “Representing Energy I” suggested that pie charts are nice but really don’t get the job done.  That was yesterday.  Today, after having a good night’s sleep and reading “Representing Energy II,” I feel open to the Energy Theater, Energy Cubes, and a whole host of new possibilities.  I’ve been asking my students to answer the same questions that are posed over and over again in these articles: where is the energy at the beginning, what is the energy doing, and how does the energy change?  This is a slow process and we take our time.  The discussion takes place in words and then the energy pies are drawn as a conclusion.  All seems well.  However, when exam time arrives, students consistently show that they struggle with any situation that has more than three forms of energy present.  Most students can only handle simple conservation of energy calculations.  Anything more abstract vexes them greatly.  So much for bringing in sociopolitical issues or crosscutting multiple sciences!

I see the Energy Theater (ET) as a way to bring the previously only-in-words discussions about identification and tracking to life.  My only foray into embodied representations has been asking groups of students to “act out” position vs. time and velocity vs. time graphs.  This has always been an activity that students favor.  The possibility of doing the same thing with energy is exciting.  However, I am not yet willing to abandon energy pies.

As I was completing the article and considering Energy Tracking Diagrams (ETD) and energy animations, an activity sequence came to mind.  My classroom has four tables that seat six students each.  I can ask each group of six to choreograph an ET for their given example.  Once they have successfully acted out their ET performance, I would have them design and submit a “write-up,” in this case an ETD (like that shown in Figure 4).  Finally, if there is a numerically solvable variable, I would ask students to simplify the ETD to an appropriate series of energy pies that would enable them to solve the problem.  I feel that the great strength of pie charts is in simplifying a situation to only the most relevant parts.

Frankly, I am just as excited about the possibility of using Energy Cubes, which I felt received short thrift in this article.  I see cubes as a means of creating an energy animation.  Given that at least one student in any group has an iPhone (which I know is true since I ask them to utilize these for video analysis), cubes offer a perfect opportunity for “stop animation” movies.  Using the cubes, they can track energy transforms and transfers on their whiteboard playing field, taking a snapshot of each change.  They can then send 5-10 images to their email, download and enter into Powerpoint (each table has two iMacs), and make a slideshow flipbook.  This eliminates the need for programming skills and puts the students back in control.  I’m wondering if the Energy Project team has seen this approach/activity in the past.

Posted by Brad (for some reason, I do not see my name posted with this entry on google groups)