Showing posts with label negotiation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label negotiation. Show all posts

Monday, August 12, 2013

The Most Interesting Energy Theater in the World

Context: These groups are planning and performing energy theater to represent a diver compressing a box of air. There is intense discussion of the definitions of and relationships among temperature, thermal energy, and kinetic energy. Brad takes on some of Stamatis' language to ask "how we know" there is thermal energy or kinetic energy in the box. Julie seems to catalyze an "a-ha" moment for several other members of the group by suggesting that kinetic energy is a property of individual gas molecules while thermal energy is a property of the gas as a whole.

Comment: It was very hard for me to choose a short clip from this 35 minute energy theater. What I ended up doing was synching up my field notes with the longer clip, which is saved as a separate episode on the server ("Thermal Energy Theater".) Anyone interested in thermal/kinetic issues, gestures, negotiation, or really transparent learning will find something to like in the longer clip. Highly recommended. :)

Transcript/Field Notes of entire 35-min energy theater (short clip above begins at about 10:30 of the longer clip)

[00:00:15.11]Steve: Because the size of the box changes, we are compressing the air so the air is now running into itself much more often. [00:00:26.20]It's a little more complicated than just adding some kinetic energy; we're not just thumping a few of the molecules...
[00:00:34.03]Wendy: Well, kinetic turns into thermal...

[00:00:49.01]Julie: The moving purple ball is transforming into heat...I guess it would have to be kinetic and thermal
[00:01:20.04]Steve: We have some heat energy that we're starting off with. They're definitely moving, they're above absolute zero.
[00:01:36.18]Julie: (referring to Don and Allie slapping their hands together, which they first said represented pressure) Maybe this is heat? It has to be elastic.
[00:01:51.03]Steve: The fact that they're hitting each other, the fact that they're moving, is the very definition of heat, of temperature.
[00:01:58.00]They are moving, therefore they have temperature
[00:02:04.05]Don: They're moving faster, therefore they have more thermal energy.
[00:02:47.18] Debra What's changing is the increasing bouncing, so that's the only other thing that's changing, we're not adding any energy...
[00:03:00.13]Julie: It's almost like that's teh first domino
[00:03:03.07]DEbra: There's no heat added, there's no cold added...There's nothing else going on except the volume decreases
[00:03:10.28]Steve: And the wall is moving towards us; there is some kinetic energy coming into the system
[00:03:30.13]Wendy: When we push that wall, that adds the kinetic energy, which is then manifasted as heat, temperature
[00:03:42.13]Allie: (rubs hands together)
[00:03:47.21]Wendy: We're acknowledging that there's kinetic that transfers to kinetic, because the whole body of gas moves
[00:04:07.04] and then the result is that goes to thermal
[00:04:13.27]This is that whole/part conversation
[00:04:30.12] The gas as a whole increases its kinetic energy when it's pushed, but then it doesn't increase it any more
[00:04:41.00] Allie: We have kinetic energy entering, but then it turns into something else (rubs hands together)
[00:05:07.12]Sid: The speed of the molecules is constant...and that's temperature?
[00:05:24.06]When we squish the box, the temperature goes up. So the speed of those molecules has changed
[00:05:37.02]But then once the box stops squeezing, they stay the same speed.
[00:05:47.22] Where is the energy coming from?
[00:05:52.29] Is that box losing heat...energy...?
[00:06:18.01] is the heat energy the same as the kinetic energy?
That's the question! people say
[00:06:30.23] Steve: I'm gonna change what I said earlier. Just the wall moving...but I'm gonna change that. i think it really is providing all the heat energy. that's the only source of energy.
sid: It's giving more kinetic energy to the molecules
[00:07:21.14] at the same time, temp is going up, which i'm hearing people say is an increase in heat energy. [00:07:52.12]did i increase in size kinetically?
[00:08:05.23]allie: scuba steve uses his muscles...
[00:08:16.14]brad: can i ask a question? is there thermal energy in the box right now? how do we know that?
[00:08:28.17]steve: you can see the motion
[00:08:34.18]brad: how do you know there's thermal energyFLAG imperceptibility of thermal energy
[00:08:37.04]don: it has temperature. we can measure it.
[00:08:40.24]sid: that's my question, is kinetic and thermal the same?
[00:10:16.11]julie--i don't think it's the hand--i think something is happening internally, inside here that results in hotness, increased something-ness
[00:10:46.13]1035 BRad--the indicator for KE and thermal is the same...Why is there the same answer for two different questions?
[00:11:30.01]but Brad thinks the distinction between single and group--[00:12:02.08] Stam said we need to go all big or all small but don't intermix.
[00:12:52.29]Julie THE INDIVIDUAL MOLECULES HAS KE BUT THE GAS AS A WHOLE HAS THERMAL
[00:13:10.24]--Wendy says HUGE!! Sid says I have to write this down.
[00:14:37.22]If there's no man, the box will stay the same size. (Still wokring on Julie's question from 1034.)
[00:15:02.03]Brad--debra wanted to do beginnign and end--but they're the same. ha.
[00:16:57.13]wendy: i know the box goes up in temperature but does the little ball go up in temperature? FLAG HEAT, PART VS WHOLE
the temperature relates to the collisions
[00:20:09.00]Steve goes through the simulation again on the proejector. [00:20:30.06]People say "You can see it! The wave of energy!"
[00:20:50.20]What if the closeness matters? No, I think it's the collisions.
[00:20:58.16]Wendy: I think it's the collisions (FLAG Jesper, collisions vs. KE of particles with temp--this whole ET should be flagged for that)
[00:23:57.11]Allie: As far as energy theater goes, temperature is not energy
[00:24:13.22]I think that's a red herring.
[00:24:22.28] the momentum of the particle... wendy: don't say momentum  [00:24:33.17]Steve: it's kinetic energy is the thermal energy. i think at a particle levle they're the same thing.
[00:25:40.04]Julie As the space between particles decreases, waste is decreased?
FLAG THERMAL ENERGY LOSS
heat loss. decreasing amount of lost heat
[00:25:59.12] rachel: you're (julie) saying when particles collide, thermal energy is lost. that's different than someone else, who said that a single particle doesn't have thermal energy.  you are proposing another scenario--two purple balls colliding HOLY COW-  THIS IS INTERESTING !!!yes it is.
1052 rachel is drawing a diagram on the board--dude, wall, all the gas in the tank for one scenario; dude, wall, one blue ball in another
1054 Sid suggests it coudl be constant K--t--K--t back and forth
debra: lets break into two groups and do the cubes for big and small
I think the question is whether thermal energy is a form of kinetic energy OR it is a warmth unrelated to the kinetic
10:56 Negotiation of different scenarios
Rachel draws three different options on the board - the group is going to split up and discuss different things.
aren't we in agreement on the blue? rachel--i would say you haven't done it so you don't know. debra--ok let's do it.
10:58 Debra suggests that they do the ET on the Blue option and then negotiate the red scenario upon completion of the the ET
1058 guess what--they don't agree. :) (miscommunication) - FLAG _ JUST TELL ME WHAT TO DO. (LIKE JEAN--feels different to me though. Jean was just frustrated and felt clueless. I think Julie does have an idea, but she sees that her idea is getting in the way of understanding someone else's idea.) True - but might be interesting to contrast the two interactions! totes.

Friday, August 9, 2013

Just Make Another Hole (Negotiation and Humor)

Context: This group is working on their diagram based on Energy Theater for the water wheel/light bulb scenario. Brad is uncomfortable with the use of the word "conduct" to describe the mechanism of energy transfer from the generator to the wire (I think--it's hard to tell without seeing the diagram they are pointing to.)

Before the clip begins: Brad asks, "Does that imply what we want it to? Does that conduct electricity? Oh wait, we do say that…Why does that feel bad in my head?" Wendy suggests, "Because we haven't used it in that particular meaning before. But what does it mean…? It means things are…touching and something is transferring…" The group then summarizes their understanding of the diagram so far. Then the clip begins.

During the clip: Brad expresses his discomfort with the term, which seems to be based on a risk of confusion between what they later call electrical conduction and thermal conduction. The group tries negotiates through the best name for this mechanism. I noticed many uses of humor throughout this negotiation. I'm interested in how the use of humor helped or hindered this group from understanding each others' concerns. One other thing to notice is Wendy's role in the conversation--she says very little, and everything she says is phrased as a question, but she seems to me to be leading the conversation toward the instructor-provided goal (generating names for the mechanisms for the energy transfers).

Instances of the Use of Humor
1. Wendy asks "What is an English definition of 'conduct'?" Steve mimes conducting an orchestra; Don says, "An English definition of conduct? Like conduct yourself appropriately?" He seems to be smiling.  (My interpretation is that while Steve was explaining how the light bulb worked, the two men had forgotten about the discussion about the word "conduct". They don't understand her question, and both make a facetious response. What other interpretations could there be? What other data might inform those interpretations?)

2. Brad tries to give a Latin etymology of the word, and Don chimes in. Both men seem to be using a silly "faux-scholarly" voice.

3. Brad expresses discomfort with the word "conduct" but then seems to dismiss his feeling: "I don't know if it's not enough coffee…or too much coffee…"


4. Brad says Stamatis' suggests "helps discriminate" the different types of conduction; Wendy says "We don't like discrimination!" Perhaps a politically charged joke?

Transcript
 [00:00:00.00]Brad: Is that something that would be a problem
[00:00:04.06]if I say hey we're conducting, from here to here, electrical energy
[00:00:08.12]and later I say we're conducting thermal to thermal...
[00:00:12.05]actually we're radiating cause this is a vac--oh no
[00:00:14.18]Don: That's radiation there
[00:00:21.10]Steve: There's usually argon in there
[00:00:23.04]to keep the filament from burning 
[00:00:26.05]Brad: But also to keep the bulb from popping
[00:00:28.01]Steve: Riiiight...if you had it in a vacuum
[00:00:31.03]gas would permeate through the glass 
[00:00:33.23]Wendy: So what is an English definition of conduct?
[00:00:38.03](Steve mimes conducting an orchestra)
Don: An English definition of conduct?
[00:00:42.24]Like conduct yourself appropriately?
[00:00:47.16]Brad: From the Latin, meaning to drive, to push, to co-direct, to direct
[00:00:57.25]-so if you're conducting someone you're...
-Wendy: So why not?
[00:01:00.22]Brad: Oh I'm not disagreeing, just my concern is
[00:01:03.20]-we've used it in different contexts...
-Wendy: twice
[00:01:06.09]is that going to be a problem?
[00:01:11.20]My gut feeling is that it is
[00:01:13.10]but I don't know why it would be yet
[00:01:16.01]I don't know if it's not enough coffee...
[00:01:18.15]or too much coffee...
[00:01:21.25]Stamatis: So could you have thermal conduction and electrical conduction?
[00:01:24.19]Brad: Just put in an adjective and use it that way?
[00:01:30.10]That would definitely discriminate them
[00:01:33.11]Wendy: We're against discrimination, aren't we?
[00:01:35.23]Brad: No, science is for discrimination!
[00:01:38.03]Don: It's a pigeonhole thing, just add another hole.
[00:01:47.29]Brad: A pigeonhole thing? Like trying to pigeonhole somebody?
[00:01:50.09]Well I did, I just added a new hole.
[00:01:52.22]Don: Well, if you're trying to take something and fit it through a hole
[00:01:56.09]and it won't fit, just make another hole
[00:01:59.21]make a broader definition
[00:02:02.13]Wendy: Ok, so what are you gonna call thermal to light?
[00:02:08.25]Steve: I'd call it radiation, but haven't really talked about that yet
[00:02:12.26]how that works and all that stuff
[00:02:14.12]Brad: Again, same, so we'll call it...
[00:02:17.15]light radiation versus thermal radiation
[00:02:19.28]cause we used radiation and thermal before, right?
[00:02:22.21]so again the same sort of thing, we'll have to put an adjective up front...

E1 - Negotiation + Roles + Representations

E1 used Energy Cubes for the first time in Tuesday (first week). In table 6 (3 woman -Emma, Krista, and Barbara- and 1 man -Tracy-) there seems to be some roles involved in their dynamics. The three girls actively discuss a lot to figure out the energy in the scenario, while Tracy plays a role as a consultant for them. When they have a content question, they ask directly to Tracy to know the answer.

Ending the planning of the energy cubes


This team had a difficult time planning the cubic energy dynamics. Here we can see how both Emma (on the left) and Barbara (on the right) ask for Tracy's approval as they move in the decision making. They discuss the presence of potential energy in the scenario. They talk about potential energy being present, but is there other potential energy? They decide to left out gravitational potential energy (as consensus).
When Tracy considered what would happens if they consider it "although..." they both reject the idea to include it, they say "we are ready to move on (Barbara)" "I am not ready for that Tracy [...] I can't go there yet (Emma)".

Is he being considered as a reference in the group instead of an active member from it? He expressed the curiosity to discuss on the potential energy and how it goes to the floor. Yet when he observe the reaction he decides to abandon it, "I didn't go there" as saying he also thinks is difficult. I think Tracy is being responsive to his team situation. He has been attending to the group participation and reacting to that. He first say he dismissed it, but they he try to discuss it. At the end, after presenting his personal position he decides to not go there.

I decided to add the last seconds of this video to show how their dynamics, even after that tension with the energy cubes, still seem to be in a good environment of collaboration.

On the other hand, I am intrigued... what to they mean when they talk about potential energy? Emma talks about gravitational potential and then ask Tracy if he thinks there is other potential energy not due to gravity... I have observed potential energy being particularly difficult while doing ET. I don't know if Lane has established some rules on the use of the label potential energy.

Comparison with the other representations
They are talking to Adam (instructor) about the differences between using energy theater and Energy Cubes (EC).

At the beginning Tracy is saying things that could implement while doing Energy Theater (ET) (sitting down to have agreements on what will happen). [00:50] Barbara seems to notice a similarity, but she says for her it is not the same. According to Krista comment [1:13], she seems to connect easily what is done in ET into using cubes to explain it. [1:20] Emma "we want a diagram". They all agree the diagram is useful to make the decisions.
[1:32] Emma presents the concern that doing ET allows people who doesn't know stay in a passive role while the other do the thinking and tell you what to do. She consider that working with EC, since it is a smaller group, it involves a more active role from all of the participants and it adds more complication (since everyone is involved in the decisions]. Adam present his personal reaction to be told what to do [1:54] "I would say why?, I am the guy who push back". Emma still believe that if you don't want anyone to know you don't know it would be easy to not participate in ET. Barbara answer to that "But then when people started talking, everybody started talking".
Now I wonder... How were they acting during their ET? Is their comments related to what they experience... I would like to know if Emma actively participated during the decision making in the ET. What I liked about this video is that during the process of the EC everyone was into the analysis of what was happening, they questioned each other in every step they made for the representation. They were so meticulous and got frustrated more than once, they seemed to be very exhausted by the end of the planning (shown in this episode). I am amazed on the engagement they shown during this activity despite the frustration they got.

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Snapshot! Timeframe in Energy Theater




(This definitely has subtitles in it on my computer but I can't see them when I put them here.)

This clip shows the very first Energy Theater in the E2 class. The scenario is a ruler being bent back and released to hit a ring. Some members of the group are struggling with whether they should be representing a "snapshot" (either an instant or a short time interval) or the "entire movie" (referring to the short video clip shown to the class.

Narrative of Video

Debra is the major proponent of the "snapshot" idea. She begins by saying it's impossible to portray the whole movie: "You can't do the whole thing, you just pick one piece." She claims they need to choose among individual instants or short time intervals in which energy is transferred from one object to another object:

[00:00:22.21] Debra: you can say that the energy scenario or snapshot we're gonna do when you're pulling back the stick? that's it?
[00:00:30.24]or it could be letting go of the stick--but the ring hasn't let go
[00:00:36.17] or it could be that the stick is here but the ring is moving

In a later class discussion, Debra suggests that to her, "snapshot" means a short time interval ("it's not a still shot, frozen.") However, it's not clear to me why Debra thinks that the shorter process of pulling back the stick can be represented by energy theater, but the entire process cannot. She says (in the later class discussion) that "doing step one, two, three is a slippery slope" but doesn't explain why.) It seemed like maybe she's thinking that each of these "snapshots" has a defined set of energy transformations that occur. I'm not sure if she thinks showing the whole "movie" would be too complicated, or if it actually would not be possible.

Brad and Bryan express the desire to show the "whole movie"--Bryan seems to imply that in fact the "snapshot" would be "going into it too deep" and that it would be simpler to show the entire process as shown in the video: "From stick back to ring stopped." Don arrives late to the conversation and breaks it up with a joke that seems to settle the argument in Brad and Bryan's favor, but Debra is not deterred.

[00:01:23.13] Debra: I think it would be much quicker, much shorter to do
[00:01:26.15] This is the stick with all the stored elastic energy in it
[00:01:31.19] and the snapshot starts when we let go

Bryan appears to be frustrated, holding his face in his hands; Brad seems to give in ("Right on; I agree."). However, a few moments later, it seems like Brad hadn't quite understood what Debra was saying:

[00:01:34.07] Debra: And it's pushing the ring forward and then that's where we stop.
[00:01:37.14] it's transferred energy to the ring and the ring hasn't let go yet
Brad: Oh you just want to do the first part!

Debra is still seeing the process as being broken up into segments that should be (or must be?) separated from each other. Brad seems not to have understood this; Bryan also does not seem to have fully considered it either. Later when Debra says that "most of the energy would still be in the ring, because the ring hasn't let go yet" Bryan chuckles with surprise and delight. "You're right!"

Thoughts
Energy Theater Logistics
I was surprised that the learners were sent immediately into Energy Theater without even a short discussion of what it was, how it worked, what were the conventions, etc. Of the three ETs I have observed so far, two of them were largely taken up with how to represent objects, types of energy, time (as in this clip), etc. Only by the third was most of the conversation primarily related to the physics rather than the mechanics of the energy theater.

Group Dynamics
I also noticed that of the seven people in the group, only 3 speak (not counting Don's joke as he enters the group). The three non-speakers positioned themselves at the other side of the lobby from the four speakers. (At the very beginning of the clip, you can see Gail "crossing over" to the other side.) After the end of this clip, Don does speak a few more times about physics content. Later in this session, Jean tries to ask a question several times but is ignored. Finally she refuses to participate in the theater because she doesn't "understand what's going on." The other two women (Gail and Melanie) never speak at all during the entire Energy Theater. [I showed my E2 I-RISE buddies an extended version of this clip that shows some of this conflict but didn't post it here--I felt like I had enough with the first three minutes to write about!]

Talking about Timeframe (or not)
What is most stunning to me is the way the speakers talk at each other. The "snapshot" and "movie" advocates don't seem to ask each other about why they think their method is better. Interestingly, the only reason offered by the proponents of each method is that their way is easier. Debra says the snapshot would be "much quicker, much shorter to do"; Brad wants the video because "that's what I did [in his diagram] so I want to make it easier on me"; Bryan thinks the snapshot would be "going into it too deep." My hunch is that each group also thinks their way is more accurate or more complete but this is not discussed. The other groups members are not asked their opinion, nor do they volunteer it. Don makes a joke based on a snippet of conversation he hears ("Eye on the ring") that diffuses some of the tension but does not move the conversation. My sense here is that a lot of the conversation is focused on how and not why.

Thursday, August 12, 2010

What is the purpose for whiteboards? or Creating and Inequality of Access

I’ve used whiteboards a lot in teaching LAs. I’m usually very visual when learning and teaching. I view whiteboards as a common work place for people to visually share their ideas with their groups so they are “on the same page” so to speak. Yet I almost always have groups present their whiteboards as well. Therefore I see two roles that whiteboards can take:

1. Shared workspace

2. Presentation spaces (economical poster-boards)


In this clip from Tuesday of E2, table 6 is working to understand the refrigerator scenario. The clip is about half and hour into the process. For approximately two minutes prior to this clip, Linda has been explaining and revising her diagram which she had been working on privately in her notebook for several minutes prior to explaining it. During Linda's explanation, Lezlie asks a lot of clarifying questions and thoughts on how to revise the diagram. Liz listens but doesn't ask a lot of questions. This clip is longer than the key exchange (which occurs at :53) because I want to show Liz's body language which I think conveys a lot about how she is feeling.

There are two things that strike me about this clip. First, Liz and Linda appear to be operating with two very different understandings of the purpose of whiteboards. Liz appears to have the first purpose listed above in mind (whiteboards as shared workspaces). She views the whiteboard as a place to write down ideas so they can be shared by the group. This is supported by the fact that she is constantly writing and erasing things on the board, and often trying to draw other group member's verbal descriptions on the board. On the other hand, Linda appears to agree more with the second purpose of whiteboards (they are presentation spaces). Therefore she is unwilling to put what she considers to be a unfinished product (her current diagram) on the whiteboard. For Linda, the workspace, or place for ideas which are in development, is her notebook. I think this relates to the idea which Rachel has mentioned earlier (here) that some students want time to think about their ideas privately before sharing with the whole class. For Linda, writing in her notebook appears to be the opportunity to think privately before writing on the whiteboard which would be producing something for "public" consumption. I worry that, as instructors, our use of gallery walks and whiteboard presentations has prevented students like Linda from using the whiteboard as a group workspace.

The reason I am concerned about this is the second thing that strikes me about this clip. There appears to be an equity issue centered around the whiteboard and it's use or lack thereof. One of the reasons that whiteboards work so well as a shared workspace is that they are centrally located and encourage big writing which everyone in the group can see. When everyone in the group can see the visual representation of what is being discussed then everyone has the opportunity to equally participate in the discussion (I'm not saying that using whiteboards will lead to full and equal participation for every group member, only that it provides the opportunity for this). When Linda switches to using her notebook as the workspace she affects the access other members of the group have to the discussion. For Lezlie this change is not very noticeable since she appears to have no problem seeing the diagram over Linda's shoulder. Yet for Liz the change is profound. Because the focus has moved to Linda's notebook, Liz can no longer see what Linda and Lezlie are pointing to and therefore cannot follow the discussion. Liz tries to address this by asking Linda to redraw her diagram on the whiteboard, but Linda's discomfort with putting an unfinished product on the whiteboard prevents her from following through on Liz's request (Linda very likely does not realize that Liz can't see and therefore is probably not intentionally blocking Liz from the conversation). I think Liz's feelings of not being part of the discussion, her repeated attempts to reengage in the conversation, and her eventual disengagement from the conversation are visible in her body language.

As Rachel pointed out, it is also possible that it is not Linda's view of the purpose of whiteboards but her familiarity with writing in her notebook (from her previous experiences in PbI) which creates the inequality of access.

I think this clip suggests that while as instructors we may want to use whiteboards for both of the purposes listed above, our use of whiteboards as presentation spaces may inhibit some students' from later using whiteboards as work spaces. I think this clip also suggests that inequality in access to a tool can influence participation.