Showing posts with label metaphor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label metaphor. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Suck on a Straw: Talking about Differentials

Context: This clip is from small group discussion during Book Club on the Energy Theater paper. This group (Mary, Sid, Bryan, and Wendy) were talking about how doing Energy Theater has made them aware of the challenge of reconciling micro and macro views of scenarios, which leads them back into discussing the piston scenario from that morning, which Mary has been pondering over lunch. The group discusses whether the word "elastic" could be used to describe the scenario, and discuss several examples of "differentials" in energy scenarios.

Interesting Features:
--Mary shows some anxiety about being "off-topic", saying, "I was thinking about this...well I guess I'm not talking about the article..." and later, "But remember the hand-held...is it ok that's we're ignoring..."(gesturing to the paper), I mean..." (she throws a conspiratorial look at Sid)..."the handheld flashlight..." Wendy reassures her, "We're not! We said, it's the micro/macro where we get messed up, and that we see that, and now we're exploring that."

-Some group members seem to be thinking of elastic as meaning a differential of any kind, because a differential produces a "spring-like" effect:
Sid: And so the reason why this works is the differential in pressure?
Wendy: Is that elastic energy then? I don't know.
Bryan: (with certainty) Yes.
Wendy: You think?
Bryan: Sure!...It's spring-like.
Wendy: It is, I mean I think it is
Bryan: It's returning...
Wendy: To a natural state
Bryan: To its original...to its equilibrium

-Other group members give examples that contradict this idea:
Mary: The handheld flashlight, the reason it worked was the temperature differential, but we didn't say there was an elastic energy there.
Sid: Cause there was no physical compression going on.
Wendy: There was no distortion.
Bryan: So there was no kinetic in the flashlight, is what you're saying, it was all thermal. Does that make sense?
...
Wendy: And you know, I don't think it is elastic, because when you suck on a straw, the reason the liquid comes up is the pressure differential, and they don't call that elastic.

-The group generates some alternative piston scenarios to help them try to understand how it works:
Mary: If you somehow made the room's pressure match this pressure...I'm ignoring this (points to article)...it wouldn't do anything

Mary: What if you had the piston not compressed, but the machine could somehow still move its handle? I don't know how that would be. But then you took the room outside of it, and took air out of it, so you lowered its pressure.
Bryan: It would work.
Mary: So you didn't actually compress this.
Bryan: You did the opposite. 

And Sid's question at the beginning  ("so the reason why this works is the differential in pressure?") is satisfyingly mirrored by Bryan's conclusion at the end ("There's gotta be a difference.")

Transcript
Mary: I was thinking about this...well I guess I'm not talking about the article...
If you somehow made the room's pressure match this pressure...I'm ignoring this (points to article)...it wouldn't do anything
It's something to do with the pressure difference between outside and inside
Sid: And so the reason why this works is the differential in pressure?
Wendy: Is that elastic energy then? I don't know.
Bryan: (with certainty) Yes.
Wendy: You think?
Bryan: Sure!...It's spring-like.
Wendy: It is, I mean I think it is
Bryan: It's returning...
Wendy: To a natural state
Bryan: To its original...to its equilibrium
Mary: But remember the hand-held...is it ok that's we're ignoring (the paper), I mean...(conspiratorial look) the handheld flashlight!
Wendy: We're not! We said, it's the micro/macro where we get messed up, and that we see that, and now we're exploring that.
Mary: The handheld flashlight, the reason it worked was the temperature differential, but we didn't say there was an elastic energy there.
Sid: Cause there was no physical compression going on.
Wendy: There was no distortion.
Bryan: So there was no kinetic in the flashlight, is what you're saying, it was all thermal. Does that make sense?
Mary: What if you had the piston not compressed, but the machine could somehow still move its handle? I don't know how that would be. But then you took the room outside of it, and took air out of it, so you lowered its pressure.
Bryan: It would work.
Mary: So you didn't actually compress this.
Bryan: You did the opposite. (Bryan talks about pistons in a car for a while)
Mary: So if the air was a lower pressure than the piston, the handle would get pushed in?...I mean if the air was higher pressure...
Sid: (Draws a picture) If I had low pressure here, and high pressure here, it would go in.
Bryan: There's gotta be a difference.
Wendy: And you know, I don't think it is elastic, because when you suck on a straw, the reason the liquid comes up is the pressure differential, and they don't call that elastic.
Mary: I think it just comes down to, you're increasing this contact between objects, this concentration of...

Thursday, August 8, 2013

The Micro: Analogies for Dropping the Ball




Context
Akbar has just joined the class in the middle of Day 2. His new group has explained that they saw a video of a bowling ball dropping and are trying to make an energy diagram and label the mechanisms. The group explains the diagram to Akbar. They are trying to describe and explain the interaction between the ball and the ground, and the resulting bounce. Don says he doesn't know how to show the bounce-back, but the group proceeds to do just that, using several interesting analogies.

Interesting Features
Three different vivid analogies are used to describe the encounter between the ball and ground.

1. "This would be compressing the molecules or something like a spring--like each little molecule would be like a little spring and it would come down and shoot it off." --Don
2. "I guess it's sort of like when you clap your hands you can feel it in both hands so you've got the same amount of feeling in both hands as they clap together" --Jean
3. "It's like a car hitting a brick wall, they're both gonna feel the same impact, right?" --Jean

After these three metaphors are rattled off in quick succession, Akbar says "And so the ground is moving?" This makes me think that these analogies (maybe in particular Jean's) have helped him understand that the ball has an impact on the ground even if it is not as obvious as the ground's impact on the ball.

Another feature that is interesting to me is Don's comment that "we're not even getting into the micro, what's really happening in there". I have noticed this too, that there is not a lot of discussion about movement of molecules. At another point in the class, I heard Rachel say to a group that you could also do "particle theater" about all of these scenarios, but that it would look different than the energy theater. I find myself very curious about the relationship between the two--I think I may still be confusing, for example, the movement of particles with kinetic energy itself. Jean goes on to talk to Akbar about how she had to explain to her students that while the molecules within an object might be moving, the object itself might not. This is especially interesting because (I believe) later in the same class, Jean stated that she felt that she did not understand what was meant by "bulk movement". In this clip it seems to me that she is describing exactly that concept.

Transcript
[00:00:00.00]Akbar: Now here, this kinetic to thermal is...
[00:00:04.21] Jean: From the air.
[00:00:06.10]Akbar: The air moving?
[00:00:08.27]Jean: The ball moving against the outside air, so that
[00:00:12.01] Akbar: Causing air to move
[00:00:18.01]So this kinetic here would be the air moving
[00:00:26.15]Melanie: So how would you like to represent the ground push-back to the ball?
[00:00:31.09]Don: Just the heat part? You would just put a K and then a T.
[00:00:42.00]Akbar: So kinda reverberation, like *unh*?
[00:00:47.01]Don: Actually the bowling ball bounced, and it hit the ground and it bounced back up
[00:00:52.09]but we didn't--we're not worried about the bounce-back.
[00:01:03.06] -Melanie: Then after it's in the...
-Don: I'm not even sure how you would show the bounce-back.
[00:01:08.00]-What would be going on to make that ball go back up
-Jean: Well it would just happen again
[00:01:12.03]only less and less
[00:01:15.15]Don: This would be compressing the molecules or something
[00:01:20.00]like a spring--like each little molecule would be like a little spring
[00:01:26.21]and it would come down and shoot it off
[00:01:30.26]Melanie: Would you like this leaving the ball after
[00:01:34.07]or do you want it to just hang out in the ball?
[00:01:36.02]Jean: I guess it's sort of like when you clap your hands
you can feel it in both hands
[00:01:40.08]so you've got the same amount of feeling in both hands as they clap together
[00:01:43.26]which is sort of like how I picture the ball hitting the grass
[00:01:48.21]while the grass may deform and the ball doesn't
they're still hitting
[00:01:54.18]it's like a car hitting a brick wall, they're both gonna feel the same impact, right?
[00:02:00.00]Akbar: And so the ground is moving?
[00:02:02.17]Jean: The ground is moving.
[00:02:04.11]The ball is moving, cause it's pushing against the ground.
[00:02:08.06]But the ground is still gonna push back.
[00:02:12.26]Don: It's just remarkable how complex
[00:02:16.01]something so simple is
[00:02:21.11]and actually we're not even getting into
[00:02:23.27]the micro, what's really happening in there
[00:02:28.02]Akbar: I remember we were having that conversation last year
[00:02:31.27]...is it still moving?...so it's still moving!
[00:02:39.11]Jean: Yeah and I got into it a little bit with my students last year about
[00:02:42.02]"well, the object is moving because the molecules are moving"
[00:02:46.20]and I said, "No, this is where we have to separate the molecules from the object"
[00:02:51.29]and I said, "This is where it starts getting hard"
[00:02:53.19]and they're going "Ugh!"
[00:03:02.08]Akbar: I would differentiate cause it's like, technically, [00:03:05.15]we're all moving now even while we're staying still

[00:03:09.12]Jean: But the object is not moving