Tuesday morning, for the four of us who observe during the afternoon, was a technical session to get our episodes ready. For me to find an episode was a matter to go back to my Monday field notes and look for the FLAG tags I used. Then I checked the video on those and decided which episode was worth to share.
Context:
The activity started in a very non traditional way. They were talking about travel agency, they were asked to imagine what features they needed to include in a travel webpage, and then what values will be included for each feature (for example, a feature was transportation, the values were airplane, train, car, etc.).
Then they were asked to do the same for energy. I copy our (Brad and I) field notes on the instructions:
I didn't focus on the confusion around the activity because I was not familiarized with the expectations of that activity. But I got super interested in how they were proposing work as a feature of energy. The way they discuss work and also on their description on why/how potential gravitational energy is doing work (it is only a couple seconds they talk about this).
At the beginning they are pretty sure on work happens in a lot of different forms of energy, they quickly list them. They all seem to agree (or at least no one objects or question them). Will (with the khaki shorts) and John (in the back to the right) are listing the different energy where you can find work. Then Fred (next to will with the name tag) tries to introduce the formal definition of work.
In the past summer teaching seminar they worked on trying to distinguish between work and energy, while here they are trying to label energy as always involving work (at the beginning of the conversation shown).