Showing posts with label thermal. Show all posts
Showing posts with label thermal. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Using ET as a reconciliation tool... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 3)

This is the third (and probably last) video from the Lowering ball saga.

Right before this episode, Barbara was explaining her reasoning on how is the energy story while lowering the bowling ball at a constant speed. Her story focuses on the ball having lots of potential gravitational energy at the beginning, and as it is lowered it loses potential energy, which is transformed into kinetic (since it is moving). Since they are working to define the ET they will represent for this scenario, some of the group members let her know that they can not lose energy (since it is conserved), nor can add extra kinetic energy (since it is constant speed). Since the discussion was not leading to a change, they decide to explore Barbara's idea while acting her ET.

**Warning: this video contains some noise in the audio. 
It is 3+ minutes, but I think it has a lot of things to discuss about - meaning: it is worth it!**

[00:00:01.08] Trevor: So if I am potential and somebody is kinetic and we are moving in the air, so this is the beginning right? 
[00:00:08.10] Barbara: Are you the ball or...
[00:00:09.03] Trevor: This (the rope) is the ball, and we are going to ignore everything else just focus on this. As the ball moves down more I have to do something (noise)
[00:00:21.20] Barbara: You changed to kinetic.
[00:00:22.69] Trevor: OK, now don't we have more kinetic energy than we started with?
[00:00:27.28] Krista: So we will be going faster like () it will be dropping faster?
[00:00:30.27] Trevor: We have to be going faster
[00:00:31.26] Barbara: Well you need, the guy is... No because the guy is putting resistance.
[00:00:38.16] Krista: So then we have to include the man our-
[00:00:40.24] Barbara: You use less pot- No, you use less potential and that became kinetic and, and it still can fall so-
[00:00:44.74] Trevor: But where do I (potential) go?
[00:00:49.00] Barbara: To kinetic, and you ended up staying there (the ball).
[00:00:51.26] Krista: But now we have () kinetic energy, because now we are both kinetic.
[00:00:55.11] Barbara: No, they were both potential and they both went to kinetic, that's (Trevor: No) what I am saying.
[00:00:59.20] Krista: So, I think we need more people.
[00:01:01.21] Barbara: Ok, so you have one kinetic, two potential and you all three are potential. No! You need more of your because the three of you- you need five, four.
[00:01:09.22] Krista: Hypothetically, go ahead. Walk us here.
[00:01:12.21] Barbara: Four potential, before it starts lowering. But one- When it's moving say one kinetic, three potential
Trevor: Ok
Krista: Ok, so what happens when 
[00:01:23.04] Barbara: And then one other changes to kinetic. And it still moves past the waist.
[00:01:30.03] Trevor: Are we still moving faster 'cause we have two kinetics, and we started with one?
[00:01:35.05] Barbara: Maybe one can go to thermal.
[00:01:36.19] Trevor: So you think thermal's in the ball?
[00:01:40.28] Barbara: Thermal in the- I don't know where, not in the ball. () in the air...
[00:01:43.02] Krista: Where do I (kinetic) go?
[00:01:44.06] Barbara: Maybe call it in the air. Some kinetic in here (the ball), thermal and kinetic in here. Very simplified.
[00:01:56.22] Barbara: (Maggie is transferred and transform into thermal in the arm) No! We need potential in here (the ball).
**Different voices at the same time**
[00:02:06.29] Emma: So far in the examples we've seen, this is the problem I am having. When we have some kinetic energy and some thermal energy exiting to the air from an object that's usually a really small portion of the energy. And so I am really hesitant to say that of all the potential energy in the ball- 
[00:02:25.17] Barbara: But it still moving when it is here, so you can have kinetic energy in the ball.
[00:02:29.10] Emma: But you can't have more than you started with because the ball speed is constant. So you can't gain kinetic energy, which means you have to be given energy.
[00:02:34.10] Barbara: Well, so what _you_ guys want to do. 
[00:02:39.15] Trevor: I think we need to put these people who are changing from potential to something else have to go into the arm. Because if you ima-
[00:02:46.00] Barbara: Not from the ball.
[00:02:48.22] Trevor: From the ball (Other voices: from the ball).
[00:02:51.24] Krista: Maybe is not a direct path like that kinetic- No, potential. Go ahead.
[00:02:56.07] Barbara: Would you say it again, what you-?
[00:02:57.09] Trevor: So I am saying potential, from the ball, has to go into the arm and I think it's thermal, because the arm doesn't get going faster either.
Emma: Yeah.
[00:03:07.16] Barbara: So the potential from the ball goes into the arm.
[00:03:09.27] Krista: I mean through a chemical process is heating up the arm, not directly-
[00:03:14.28] Trevor: I think it's kind of directly
[00:03:16.26] Krista: I mean, but it is a direct reaction to what is happening (Barbara: the ATP). So it's causing the arm to heat up.
[00:03:24.11] Barbara: And whenever ATP (is hydrolyzed?), it changes the shape of the molecule. That's how the body gets work done. 
[00:03:33.14] Barbara: But you know what, I want to see what- You guys play yours now.

I presented this video in the I-RISE Congress, and basically I could use this video for 10 different purposes. But what I (personally) am more interested of, is how they decide to use the ET as a tool of conciliation with Barbara. Instead of remain in a discussion trying to persuade her (we consider Barbara and the group initially were talking of different things), they decided to understand where is she coming from, and then question her in the blank spot that she has not addressed. I consider this group dynamic shows responsiveness and I can almost see how with the ET performance I can observe the accommodation and assimilation process of Barbara (magic to my eyes). And I simply love how Barbara, after all the questioning they made to her model, the modifications she decide to include, and the addition of new elements, at the end she stills recognize that ET as her own.

Some other issues that we discussed with this episode is how they see thermal energy as the answer to conserve the energy in the system, but they have problems trying to explain where should it go, or why it happens.
ATP shows up again, if it weren't because of KD explanation, I wouldn't be aware of it (long time since I had bio classes). Now I realized that it is a thing while trying to explain the scenarios during E1 and E2, but I could not say if this is a sign that the instruction of the PD should address or if they prefer to simply mention it with no further details (those two positions has been brought up in more than one occasion).
We also noticed the implication of representing kinetic energy as the people jogging. Rachel said she doesn't like it because it allows to mix the substance and level energy ontology. In my personal opinion, I liked it because I was able to see she sometimes tried to mixed both ontology, but she also notices it and go back to her regular pace.

This is the end of the Saga. I share the other links if you are interested in more details, or simply get more information of what happened before.
Conceptual understanding vs Equations (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 1)
Forces vs Energy... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 2)
I-RISE Congress - Lowering at a constant speed

I-RISE Congress - Lowering at a constant speed

Thank you again for such a great experience! I am sharing the slides of the congress presentation.


I am the first I-RISE Scholar coming from México. I show you where I am exactly from.

During High School, in a aptitudinal test they told me I had good aptitudes to go for a exact science carreer or for humanities. In my mind that didn't make sense, how can you mix them both? I decided to study a B.Sc. in Physics Engineering. A couple years after, I discovered there was a PER group in my University and decided to join them. It was in that moment that I realized that there was a way to mix both of my strengths, since then I decided PER is was I would do.

Basically, I started doing my fists steps in PER as an undergrad. Then I decided to go for a Ph.D. in PER, continuing working with Genaro Zavala, now as my adviser. Two summers ago Rachel went to my university for a summer workshop about video analysis. In that moment I decided that was what I wanted to do. I arrived to Seattle on April for a six month research visit to develop my qualitative research skills (my PER group do not use video analysis that much).




Due to time limitations, I could not analyze both days as I planned originally. I wanted to see what were the differences that made one day more productive than the other. Instead I decided to study in detail the second day (more productive than the first). As a clarification, E1 has already worked in ET in previous days, but not during afternoon. So it was the first time I observed them doing ET alive, but not their first time doing ET.

I share the video here, but for more detail please check the post: Forces vs Energy... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 2)
**Warning: There is wind noise in the audio**


I share the video here, but for more detail please check the post: Using ET as a reconciliation tool... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 3)
**Warning: there is also some noise in this one**





As conclusion, thank you for helping me developing my qualitative research skills. I really appreciate having a space where people get engage in this kind of discussions and gives you productive feedback to improve your opportunity areas.I am really wishing I have the opportunity to keep working with this two ET, because I felt I needed more time to finish the analysis.

Thursday, August 15, 2013

ATP: An electrical impulse thing and a little zap

This is more on the theme of “getting hot while dropping your balls.”  As a refresher, in E1 on Monday morning (8/12/13), the class began the day by drawing diagrams for the two scenarios considered the previous Friday: raising a bowling ball at constant velocity and lowering the ball at constant velocity.  The group I am considering in this episode is: Jeff (in blue), John, Sara (in green), and Emma.  In the first half hour of class, they drew a diagram representing the energy theater.

Their diagram includes instances of chemical energy converting to thermal energy, and they recognize this as a process that includes ATP, but they do not know how to account for it.  Now that they have finished, Adam comes to the table to check on them and see how they are doing.  What follows is a discussion regarding what they think about the scenarios they have just looked at. 


I love that each member of the group had a chance to weigh in on the matter, even Sara who is typically rather quiet.  To each of them, the processes involved in going from chemical energy (ATP) to muscle movement to thermal energy, are a mystery, and each of them has a different way of expressing their befuddlement.  Jeff at 0:13 says “I need to scratch my head and go wow.”  John, at 1:13, adds “It gets super fancy, which I don’t even want to get into.”  Even one of the instructors, Adam, can’t hold back his relationship with biology at 1:25.  “I’m a physics guy, so when I hear ATP I kind go…” and he apparently makes a face or a twitch or something. 

At 2:14, Sara enters in and continues off of John’s wonderment at “an electrical impulse thing” and “a little zap that we’re not accounting for.”  She wants to keep separate the energy story and the processes of ATP.  “The electrical is part of the chemical.”  She sees that for kids, it wouldn't make sense to have chemical go to electrical and so on.  Emma fleshes this out with a long montage of chemical to electrical to new chemical to new electrical.  Without even knowing the exact process, she sees the weaving that might happen.  “Having a separate story, I think, is a good thing,” she adds at the end.

Finally, at 2:54 Sara suggests, “I don’t think understanding this way is a misconception.”  This is an interesting way to phrase her idea.  I wonder how she thinks of physics and biology misconceptions.  Beyond that, what is clear to me here is that all four teachers agree that energy theater shouldn't (and maybe even can’t) address all of the steps that may exist as chemical energy transforms to thermal. 

“If you don’t understand where the energy comes from, call it chemical.”  This is quite common in physics.  I certainly do this in my classes with the simple examples I use that might need such a designation, such as a car driving or a person pushing an object.  Honestly, I've rarely made an attempt to develop a picture that is deeper than this.  It is fascinating to watch a group of people attempt to dig at this deeper picture and essentially come up baffled and prepared to stick with “chemical to thermal, let’s move on.”  I wonder if this might be a valuable class exercise for my students.  Let them struggle to build a more complex picture, to give them a greater appreciation for hiding some details in their energy representation.


Full video: E1 130812 0814 T6-1

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Do you get hot dropping your balls?

In E1 on Monday morning (8/12/13), the class began the day by drawing diagrams for the two scenarios considered the previous Friday: raising a bowling ball at constant velocity and lowering the ball at constant velocity.  The group I am considering in this episode is: Jeff (in blue), John, Sara (in green), and Emma.  In the first half hour of class, they drew the following diagram:


Then they were asked to consider the following two questions: 1) How does the change in chemical energy compare and 2) How does change in thermal energy compare?  What we can note directly from their diagram is that more chemical energy units are initially shown in the lifting case than the lowering case, whereas more thermal energy is generated in the lowering case than the lifting.  What is clear is that they decided on using 8 total units or parcels of energy in both pictures, which may be causing some trouble in their minds.  This episode picks up early on in their conversation, as they wrestle with what their diagram tells them about what is happening.  Jeff, a few moments earlier, says: “We don't end up with as much thermal energy when we lift.  We seem to imply that we don't get as hot lifting something as lowering.”  This leads the group to considering what would happen if they introduced more energy units.  Lane has joined the table and the group is explaining what they have drawn as well as thinking out loud.


This is a tough conversation to follow and I've had to listen a few times.  Jeff begins by suggesting that if they started with more energy units, then more C’s would be left at the end of the raising picture and more T’s would be left at the end of the lowering picture.  Emma chimes in with the idea that if they want to truly represent the inefficiency of human processes (which is something that was suggested earlier in their conversation), then they need to have more C’s transform directly to T’s.  Particularly, it seems that she notices in lowering they show G to T and C to T, whereas in lifting they only show C to T (this can be seen on the diagram).  She says: “we ought to have some parcels of chemical energy converting into thermal energy separate from this [the shown C to T] conversion.”  She notes that by showing more conversions of C to T, then a balance could occur between both pictures, which could lead to equal thermal energy being generated, or maybe even more in the lift.  This is a neat suggestion from her, because it breaks from the mold of every energy unit being fully understood.  It acknowledges that something occurs in the body that we don’t understand but must be accounted for so that our picture makes sense at the end. 

John joins in to describe to Lane the issue that they are having, which is that their picture shows different amounts of thermal energy at the end, but they feel in real life that would not be the case.  He feels bound by the number of “actors” in the diagram.  Again, this appears to be a moment of transition in translating ET to an energy diagram.  He (and his group) started by thinking about a set number of actors, like ET.  They feel confined by this.  Sara adds that the person lifting and lowering the ball should have the same amount of chemical at the beginning of each diagram, since it’s the same person.  Again, a further refinement.  The group is finding ways in which their diagram does not work for them and suggestions solutions. 

Since they are already saying that more energy units would be helpful, Lane bumps them forward with this idea at 1:56, pondering what it would be like if they had an infinite number of actors.  John and Emma continue to express, with more confidence, what the group has been saying these past few minutes.

The final part of the video is really interesting.  It highlights their challenge in resolving their diagram with what they intuitively feel should be true.  At 2:51 Lane asks, “So would you then in the lowering scenario end up with a bigger change in thermal energy?”  John, Emma, and Sara all offer evidence that YES you would end up with more thermal energy when lowering.  Lane, at 3:46, then asks, “Does that seem intuitively right?”  Emma and Jeff both immediately respond NO.  The episode ends here, but two minutes later John adds, “That gravitational energy makes more thermal doesn't make sense to me.  It's just weird.”  This is a fantastic example of cognitive dissonance.  Everyone in the group keeps pointing to their diagram and describing how it shows more thermal energy in the lowering case, yet they keep saying this feels all wrong to them. This swing back and forth happens throughout the 4 minutes, indeed throughout their 45 minute small group discussion.


This dissonance is not resolved in small groups, nor do I think it gets resolved in the whole class discussion, where it comes up again in full strength.  The conversation does go deeper at this point and Lane even brings research evidence to bear.  No general conclusion is reached, but the class appears to agree with moving on.  I hope to pull an episode from the full class discussion as well.

Full episode: E1 130812 0814 T6-1

The Penguin Metabolism Saga


On Wednesday of the first week, I followed Mary, Allie, AJ, and Madonna as they worked with the "penguin climbing up a hill" scenario. Originally it was supposed to be a person, but I am so glad Rachel could only find a clip of penguins climbing a hill, because it brought up all sorts of interesting questions about homeostasis. (Of course humans do homeostasis too--but I think it's a little more obvious to people because penguins live in cold weather.)

My understanding is this: Organisms have a basal metabolism--a series of chemical reactions required to keep the organism alive. (Let's talk about animals because I am most familiar with them.) These chemical reactions require activation energy to be carried out (that's a type of energy we haven't discussed!) and are completed best at certain optimal temperatures, so thermal energy is required as well. But these reactions also generate thermal energy, some of which is lost to the environment, and some of which may be retained by the organism, especially an endotherm ("warm-blooded" organism. Thermoregulation (maintaining an optimal body temperature for chemical reactions) is a confusing part of basal metabolism for endotherms because it costs energy and generates energy and the animal stores energy and this is all to save energy...or something. It's confusing!

Organisms will also perform activities that take them beyond their basal metabolism--for example, climbing up a hill. Eventually this group will consider how you might figure out how much energy is required to get the animal up the hill, on top of whatever basal metabolism there is.

Segment 1: This is longest and probably the most boring to watch. A lot of the conversation sounds like "C turns to T, and T turns to K", which I can't follow very well especially without seeing the diagram. Nevertheless, I think there must be a lot of hints interesting about what their questions are and how they start to think about the problems. Here are two important exchanges:

Exchange 1 (at 1:13)
This is the first reference I saw to what the group will later discuss as respiration and metabolism.

AJ: Should C turn into T first?
Allie: No...I don't think so...because the ATP in your muscles gets broken up and used, and that's what makes your muscle move! So the chemical really does kinda go straight to the kinetic.


Exchange 2 (at 3:48)
Mary first addresses the idea of thermoregulation in the penguin. The group is discussing whether the penguin's thermal energy comes from the penguin's movement from "the previous step". (One confusing or interesting thing here is that the way the group uses "step" it could apply to the "acts" of Energy Theater, to the literal steps taken by the penguin, or to both simultaneously.)

Mary: And as we go higher, we'll be taking on more thermals too, right? I wouldn't think the thermal would be constant.
Madonna: So this thermal should be the first thermal to leave.
Allie: So you're saying you would not radiate on the first step.
AJ: It's pretty much already moving. So this T came from here, on the last step.
Allie: So what you're saying is he's already got his elevated temperature…
Mary: And he's gonna get warmer and warmer to a point.
Allie: But if we're saying he's already in motion, then maybe he's already reached his elevated temperature and he's radiating.

Segment 1

Segment 2: In this segment, Mary begins to discuss homeostasis. This is a little confusing, because the temperature of the penguin stays more or less constant, but the rate of generation of thermal energy (I think this is what she is thinking about) is not constant. 

Mary: You know what? You know how he stays at a constant temperature, is he's probably kicking off more Ts...So it's not really a constant...thermal...
Allie: He gets hotter?
Mary: He gets hotter but his body regulates by kicking off more Ts. 

Segment 2

Segment 3: This is the segment I shared with the I-RISE group last Friday. Here Allie is proposing that all C to K transformations (which they call "metabolism") are accompanied by some quantity of C to T transformations (which they call "respiration"). As a high school biology teacher, I would define metabolism as "all the chemical reactions that happen within an organism" and respiration as "the controlled release of energy from organic molecules". This is not the way these learners are using those words, and I will do my best to be clear about which definition is being used in a given context.

At 0:26, Allie says, "when you draw the circle of ATP, you do end up radiating energy at certain steps". In biological systems, "free energy becomes available for metabolism by the conversion of ATP→ADP, which is coupled to many steps in metabolic pathways" (College Board, AP Biology Curriculum Framework.) ADP can be combined with inorganic phosphate to regenerate ATP during cellular respiration. When Allie refers to "the circle of ATP", I believe she may be referring to a diagram like this.

At about the 1 minute mark, Stamatis tries to get the group to quantify the ratio of C to T transformation compared to C to K transformation; in other words, how efficiently is the penguin converting its chemical energy into the work of walking up hill. For this snippet, remember that to these learners, "metabolism" means C to K and "respiration" means C to T.

01:13.19]Allie: What's our bond energy on ATP?
[00:01:17.13]I don't know
[00:01:20.00]I should hope that this is more efficient
[00:01:23.03]I should hope there's more metabolism to respiration
[00:01:26.09]Stamatis: More C to K than C to T
[00:01:28.18]Allie: Otherwise we're pretty inefficient machines
[00:01:31.18]I mean we are pretty inefficient

Allie's comment really struck me because biological organisms are, I assume, EXTREMELY inefficient compared to mechanical systems. I believe in the process of cellular respiration there IS in fact more C to T than C to K. This comment made me consider biology as a kind of "engineering", where living things are evolution's various solutions to the "design problems" of life.

At 1:48, Stamatis asks, "How could a physicist think about this question?" Allie explains that they already HAVE looked into this question systematically and quantitatively.

[00:01:59.26]Allie: We looked at a research paper, and I think that's where we got the numbers
[00:02:08.25]ATP...they've got the circles for it and they'll tell you how much energy,
[00:02:14.16]how many Joules are released at each stage in the process, I think
[00:02:23.06]but I dont know...they don't usually tell you [00:02:28.04]how many, the energy that goes toward the muscle movement
[00:02:31.25]they just tell you how much energy is lost

A diagram like the one Allie is referring to might look like this:

Finally, Madonna brings up the concept that I would call basal metabolic rate--the amount of energy required to perform the chemical reactions that keep the organism alive. 

[00:02:50.25]Madonna: Or you could have the penguin just stand there
[00:02:53.17]Allie: And see how hot he is?
[00:02:55.12]Madonna: And see how much energy it requires, just standing there
[00:03:00.21]Stamatis: And we know that about me, right?
[00:03:02.24] Madonna: And you could see how much more energy it requires for it to be moving

Segment 3

Segment 4: This clip is almost immediately following Segment 3. The group considers some of methods they might use to calculate how much energy would be needed to get Stamatis up Mount Everest. (I don't know why Stamatis changed the scenario from penguins to himself, other than that Stamatis must have a paralyzing phobia of penguins and doesn't like to talk about them.)

The discussion of basal metabolic rate continues:
Allie: C to T, this is just what we need to maintain our body temperature, right? So that would be our resting body temperature. 
Madonna: It's energy lost to the environment

There is also an intriguing digression into body fat--I'm not so clear why it matters to their question, which is how much energy would be used--would it matter whether it comes from new food or from stored body fat? But it is a great example of how freakin complicated this system is!

Madonna: You probably also have to take into consideration body fat. 
Stamatis: I'm assuming you would be getting thinner. 
Allie: You might be burning off fat--the energy that they use is energy in their body.
Madonna: A substantial amount of the energy that they use is the energy in their body before they start. The calories that they’re eating while they're climbing aren’t necessarily all the calories...
Allie: We could try and eliminate that by finding someone who already is in good shape so if they hit hardships and they're in a snowstorm they're gonna be burning off their reserves. But I think if you find a person who is healthy and well-prepared for their trip, they're not gonna be losing a lot of weight.

Segment 4

I don't have a conclusion about all this yet. Maybe it needs to simmer.

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

A Biologist Tries to Think...About Energy in Animals




After our discussion about the penguin walking uphill, which I will have to make a post about (how did that not happen?), I've been thinking about endothermy ("warm-bloodedness") and ectothermy ("cold-bloodedness." Endothermic creatures work very hard to keep their body temperature at an ideal level for their metabolic activities; this means they can be active in a much wider variety of physical and temporal environments than ectotherms can, but they require several times as much food at the same body size. Ectotherms on the other hand are more vulnerable to environmental changes, but don't need to eat as much.

In flagrant violation of Energy Project principles, I started with definitions from the College Board's AP Biology Curriculum Framework:

Endothermy: The use of thermal energy generated by metabolism to maintain homeostatic body temperature 
Ectothermy: The use of external thermal energy to regulate and maintain body temperature

Then I tried to draw an "energy diagram" for an endothermic animal. As I've mentioned before, a lot of the transformations that biologists consider most important don't look like transformations to a physicist at all. There's a lot of chemical to chemical going on here. There is thermal energy "lost" at each step (by which I think I mean the chemical products contain less usable energy than the reactants...is that what I mean?) An endotherm is pretty good at retaining some of that thermal energy, but still a lot is "lost" to the environment. 


After this I was going to draw an ectotherm, but as I started to think about it, I realized that none of the transformations are actually different in an ectotherm. The difference is in the amount of food consumed, and the amount of thermal energy generated and maintained. Endotherms have body structures (fat, blubber, fur, feathers) and behaviors (shivering, sweating) that help them keep their body temperatures at optimal level. These structures and behaviors require energy, but also can provide a "payoff". 


My thinking here led me to question College Board's definition.


I'm wondering if this endothermy/ectothermy is one more example of a false dichotomy. I had a brainsplosion recently that ionic and covalent bonds are really points on a spectrum. Maybe endo and ectothermy are the same--an animal gets some proportion of its thermal energy from the environment and some proportion from metabolism. I bet those proportions could even change!!

One postscript; here is the footnote to the Glucose (C) to ATP (C) pathway.


I work a lot in my class to distinguish between where the matter in a reaction comes from vs where the energy comes from. Maybe a future blog post...

Monday, August 12, 2013

The Most Interesting Energy Theater in the World

Context: These groups are planning and performing energy theater to represent a diver compressing a box of air. There is intense discussion of the definitions of and relationships among temperature, thermal energy, and kinetic energy. Brad takes on some of Stamatis' language to ask "how we know" there is thermal energy or kinetic energy in the box. Julie seems to catalyze an "a-ha" moment for several other members of the group by suggesting that kinetic energy is a property of individual gas molecules while thermal energy is a property of the gas as a whole.

Comment: It was very hard for me to choose a short clip from this 35 minute energy theater. What I ended up doing was synching up my field notes with the longer clip, which is saved as a separate episode on the server ("Thermal Energy Theater".) Anyone interested in thermal/kinetic issues, gestures, negotiation, or really transparent learning will find something to like in the longer clip. Highly recommended. :)

Transcript/Field Notes of entire 35-min energy theater (short clip above begins at about 10:30 of the longer clip)

[00:00:15.11]Steve: Because the size of the box changes, we are compressing the air so the air is now running into itself much more often. [00:00:26.20]It's a little more complicated than just adding some kinetic energy; we're not just thumping a few of the molecules...
[00:00:34.03]Wendy: Well, kinetic turns into thermal...

[00:00:49.01]Julie: The moving purple ball is transforming into heat...I guess it would have to be kinetic and thermal
[00:01:20.04]Steve: We have some heat energy that we're starting off with. They're definitely moving, they're above absolute zero.
[00:01:36.18]Julie: (referring to Don and Allie slapping their hands together, which they first said represented pressure) Maybe this is heat? It has to be elastic.
[00:01:51.03]Steve: The fact that they're hitting each other, the fact that they're moving, is the very definition of heat, of temperature.
[00:01:58.00]They are moving, therefore they have temperature
[00:02:04.05]Don: They're moving faster, therefore they have more thermal energy.
[00:02:47.18] Debra What's changing is the increasing bouncing, so that's the only other thing that's changing, we're not adding any energy...
[00:03:00.13]Julie: It's almost like that's teh first domino
[00:03:03.07]DEbra: There's no heat added, there's no cold added...There's nothing else going on except the volume decreases
[00:03:10.28]Steve: And the wall is moving towards us; there is some kinetic energy coming into the system
[00:03:30.13]Wendy: When we push that wall, that adds the kinetic energy, which is then manifasted as heat, temperature
[00:03:42.13]Allie: (rubs hands together)
[00:03:47.21]Wendy: We're acknowledging that there's kinetic that transfers to kinetic, because the whole body of gas moves
[00:04:07.04] and then the result is that goes to thermal
[00:04:13.27]This is that whole/part conversation
[00:04:30.12] The gas as a whole increases its kinetic energy when it's pushed, but then it doesn't increase it any more
[00:04:41.00] Allie: We have kinetic energy entering, but then it turns into something else (rubs hands together)
[00:05:07.12]Sid: The speed of the molecules is constant...and that's temperature?
[00:05:24.06]When we squish the box, the temperature goes up. So the speed of those molecules has changed
[00:05:37.02]But then once the box stops squeezing, they stay the same speed.
[00:05:47.22] Where is the energy coming from?
[00:05:52.29] Is that box losing heat...energy...?
[00:06:18.01] is the heat energy the same as the kinetic energy?
That's the question! people say
[00:06:30.23] Steve: I'm gonna change what I said earlier. Just the wall moving...but I'm gonna change that. i think it really is providing all the heat energy. that's the only source of energy.
sid: It's giving more kinetic energy to the molecules
[00:07:21.14] at the same time, temp is going up, which i'm hearing people say is an increase in heat energy. [00:07:52.12]did i increase in size kinetically?
[00:08:05.23]allie: scuba steve uses his muscles...
[00:08:16.14]brad: can i ask a question? is there thermal energy in the box right now? how do we know that?
[00:08:28.17]steve: you can see the motion
[00:08:34.18]brad: how do you know there's thermal energyFLAG imperceptibility of thermal energy
[00:08:37.04]don: it has temperature. we can measure it.
[00:08:40.24]sid: that's my question, is kinetic and thermal the same?
[00:10:16.11]julie--i don't think it's the hand--i think something is happening internally, inside here that results in hotness, increased something-ness
[00:10:46.13]1035 BRad--the indicator for KE and thermal is the same...Why is there the same answer for two different questions?
[00:11:30.01]but Brad thinks the distinction between single and group--[00:12:02.08] Stam said we need to go all big or all small but don't intermix.
[00:12:52.29]Julie THE INDIVIDUAL MOLECULES HAS KE BUT THE GAS AS A WHOLE HAS THERMAL
[00:13:10.24]--Wendy says HUGE!! Sid says I have to write this down.
[00:14:37.22]If there's no man, the box will stay the same size. (Still wokring on Julie's question from 1034.)
[00:15:02.03]Brad--debra wanted to do beginnign and end--but they're the same. ha.
[00:16:57.13]wendy: i know the box goes up in temperature but does the little ball go up in temperature? FLAG HEAT, PART VS WHOLE
the temperature relates to the collisions
[00:20:09.00]Steve goes through the simulation again on the proejector. [00:20:30.06]People say "You can see it! The wave of energy!"
[00:20:50.20]What if the closeness matters? No, I think it's the collisions.
[00:20:58.16]Wendy: I think it's the collisions (FLAG Jesper, collisions vs. KE of particles with temp--this whole ET should be flagged for that)
[00:23:57.11]Allie: As far as energy theater goes, temperature is not energy
[00:24:13.22]I think that's a red herring.
[00:24:22.28] the momentum of the particle... wendy: don't say momentum  [00:24:33.17]Steve: it's kinetic energy is the thermal energy. i think at a particle levle they're the same thing.
[00:25:40.04]Julie As the space between particles decreases, waste is decreased?
FLAG THERMAL ENERGY LOSS
heat loss. decreasing amount of lost heat
[00:25:59.12] rachel: you're (julie) saying when particles collide, thermal energy is lost. that's different than someone else, who said that a single particle doesn't have thermal energy.  you are proposing another scenario--two purple balls colliding HOLY COW-  THIS IS INTERESTING !!!yes it is.
1052 rachel is drawing a diagram on the board--dude, wall, all the gas in the tank for one scenario; dude, wall, one blue ball in another
1054 Sid suggests it coudl be constant K--t--K--t back and forth
debra: lets break into two groups and do the cubes for big and small
I think the question is whether thermal energy is a form of kinetic energy OR it is a warmth unrelated to the kinetic
10:56 Negotiation of different scenarios
Rachel draws three different options on the board - the group is going to split up and discuss different things.
aren't we in agreement on the blue? rachel--i would say you haven't done it so you don't know. debra--ok let's do it.
10:58 Debra suggests that they do the ET on the Blue option and then negotiate the red scenario upon completion of the the ET
1058 guess what--they don't agree. :) (miscommunication) - FLAG _ JUST TELL ME WHAT TO DO. (LIKE JEAN--feels different to me though. Jean was just frustrated and felt clueless. I think Julie does have an idea, but she sees that her idea is getting in the way of understanding someone else's idea.) True - but might be interesting to contrast the two interactions! totes.

Friday, August 9, 2013

Energy Theater: Where is the thermal energy?

On Thursday afternoon (8/8/13) in E1, the class enacted its second energy theater; this time for the mousetrap car.  In this pair of video episodes, I am showing a group that was formed by taking 2 members from each of the four tables (in Noah’s ark style?).  These clips focus on their attempts at determining where the thermal energy will be present.

In the first episode, Tanya (white blouse) is the lead voice.  “Yeah, let’s ignore the air,” is her big remark at 0:18, with immediate agreement from Maggie.  “Air is minimal, we don’t have to put it into the equation.”  The group seems to be in agreement without needing further clarification.  “It’s like a frictionless track,” she adds.  Again, the group seems okay with this, but Lane interjects, “hold on.”  As Lane attempts to draw out a more detailed description, Tanya adds more and says “it’s minimal and it won’t change a variable between our experiments and it would be very small compared to what we’re doing.”  At the end she brushes it aside with a sweep of the arm, “let’s eliminate one thing.”  Again, the group is happy; except for Jeff (blue shirt).  A long “eeeehhhh,” escapes his lips.  But at this point, they are moving on.


For the next three minutes, they discuss how to demonstrate elastic energy and how to show elastic transforming into kinetic and how that transfers from the “drive train” to the body of the car.  This video picks up as Tanya shows herself as changing from elastic to kinetic, moving to the body of the car, and then at 0:20 says “since I’m scraping against the floor, I’m done.  I’m heat.”  Finally, Jeff speaks up: “I’m going to disagree.  I think there’s a fundamental difference between the car and the hockey puck.  We have static friction and not…”  At that moment, Tanya gives a little gasp.  Jeff goes on to say “I think wind resistance is going to stop this car more than friction.” 

“But if we don’t have friction, how will it move forward?” Tanya asks.  She’s not convinced.  Jeff goes on to describe how he thinks its static friction with the floor that results in rolling and that no heat would be generated.  He ends his explanation with a satisfied clap of his hands at 1:12.  Other members of the group chime in and start asking questions, looking for further clarification.  At 1:34, Tanya begins looking around.  She goes and finds the spare rope not in use and sets it up as the air; she’s bought into the idea.

** Video should be here.  I'm having problems with errors.  
Go to folder 2013 E1 Episodes and watch "E1 130808 I think its the Air"**

I think this pair of episodes shows the power of Energy Theater.  If a group is willing to engage in open dialog, then members have a safe place to share their ideas.  Tanya made some great arguments, but there was room for Jeff to speak up as well and present what a more accurate representation. 

These episodes also represent an evolution in thinking as one moves from the idea of sliding friction to rolling.  Sliding friction is the easiest way to think of friction, and this naturally leads people to the conclusion that the floor receives the largest thermal energy piece.  But a more advanced representation demands looking at rolling and the physics at play between the ground and the tires.  Also, the possible friction in the axles was mentioned.  It was interesting to see these teachers navigate the ever expanding complexity of the problem, recognizing different components that might lead to thermal energy.  While a 100% “correct” answer is not possibly, an appreciation for the complexity is apparent.


Full video: E1 130808 1257 T7&outside-1 

Friday, May 31, 2013

Group B reflection

Topic: Energy degradation and dissipation
Articles: “Conserving Energy in Physics and Society” and “Matter Scatter…”

After reading the article, “Conserving Energy…,” my first thoughts were “Do we really want to go there?” and “How in the world do we organize this learning experience?”  Let me back up a moment and fill in a few more details about my experiences with energy instruction coming into this summer.  My Group A post summarizes how I came to energy pies as the focal point of my energy instruction.  The Modeling materials I work from separate the energy unit into closed and open systems.  First we start with the closed system, where everything that is part of an interaction is included in the system.  Therefore, the conservation of energy holds true.  After about two weeks of that, we then shift to open systems.  Now, an agent that does work or has work done to it can be outside of the system.  Energy is not conserved in this case.  Instead, we say that the work done adds to or subtracts from the total energy of the system.  Simply put, in closed systems we don’t talk about work, in open we do.

I thought this was brilliant on paper.  It made perfect sense.  The energy pies were a quick, clean, and simple way to diagram situations.  However, after five semesters following this format, I don’t like parts of it.  Specifically, open systems.  I think that idea confuses students to no end.  In fact, I've slowly been phasing that idea out to focus on closed systems for describing every situation.  This is certainly what is being suggested in this article. 

On one hand, I really like the Energy Tracking Diagram (ETD) depicted here.  It really does a great job of summarizing all of the nuts and bolts.  On the other hand, do ETDs ask for too many details?  Do we really need to follow thermal energy as it spreads to the hand, environment, and spring?  Is it important to have students follow thermal energy everywhere it could possibly go (such as spreading to more and more objects or spreading spatially)?  Or is that losing precious time with “meaningless arguments” about how much thermal is here and how much is there, when there might be a final computation that is a primary outcome, or there might be five other examples I want to look at? 

These are all rhetorical questions, of course.  I've found myself wrapped in conversation with my colleagues for long stretches of time on very similar issues; for instance, a clay ball that is released and “splats” on the ground.  Where does more thermal energy end up, in the ground or in the deformed clay ball?  One of my colleagues and I still don’t agree.  But is that a question I want my students to tackle, or am I simply interested in having them draw an energy pie scenario that goes from gravitational à kinetic à thermal as the ball is released, arrives just above the floor, and hits the floor, respectively?


Finally, my second initial question was “How do we organize this learning experience?”  Rather than taking more time here to answer that, I’d like to see what is done this summer.  I’m quite intrigued by Ross’ “Matter Scatter” article and the notion of starting first thing with the 2nd Law and with a concept like “available energy” or “free energy.”  I’m curious if the directors have found a good sequence.  I’m also interested in experimenting with possible sequences myself.  It may be one of my research interests this summer.