Showing posts with label simplify. Show all posts
Showing posts with label simplify. Show all posts

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Let's Keep It Simple

Context

Monday morning the E1 students went outside and were told to find some situation that had something to do with energy. They were then to come back in and draw a diagram of the situation they observed. Their directions were intentionally vague. This is the first step in the Algebra Project pedagogy. 

The Video

Table 3 struggled a bit to reach a consensus on what to chose for their scenario. Rob (man leaning on the railing) pushed several times for a simple situation. He especially wanted something that dealt with motion because he felt like he understood the energy related to motion. Here are the two times that he mentioned his desire to keep things simple
The rest of the group supported his decision to go with a simple scenario (with the possible exception of Margaret, the woman in the red shirt). 

Why is This Interesting?

I think this interaction is interesting because it suggests something about how this group is framing the task, the project, and physics in general. What I see them doing is activating a very common physics resource (I am apparently in the mood to channel the Maryland PER group today). In physics we usually try to stick to simple situations and to break things down, and make assumptions, and throw out irrelevant details. In physics, this is usually a good thing. But the issue is that most physics students don't do this. Our students tend to be interested in the fun, complicated, messy situations. This is what makes Energy Theater so great (okay, one of the things) - it allows us to talk about the messy, complicated situations of everyday life and analyze them from an energy perspective. So in some ways I think this group is doing a great job of doing physics, but it's actually not what we want them to be doing here.

The second interesting thing is the way this group is trying to position themselves. They appear to be attempting to position themselves as "knowers" or "physics experts" instead of as "learners". Rob admits that he doesn't feel comfortable with the basics of physics. Therefore he wants to chose a situation he feels comfortable with. I find it interesting that he wants to chose a situation that he knows rather than taking this opportunity to learn about something he finds interesting. For instance, he says he finds the waves fascinating but he is intimidated by hydro-physics.  Margaret (the woman in the red shirt, with her back to the camera) appears to be positioning herself very differently from the rest of the group (I'll probably talk more about this in a different post).

Wednesday, August 7, 2013

The difference between and/or simultaneity of energy transfer and transformation

In education, I personally feel that using transparent words and phrases is very beneficial when students learn new concepts.  As learners go deeper into topics, then they can further develop their understanding of jargon in the field.  But that jargon can be an impediment early on.  On one hand, we want to introduce students to the proper (i.e. accepted, traditional, etc.) vocabulary as early as possible.  On the other hand, if the vocabulary is an impediment to learning, then it might be best to steer clear.

The video segment below takes place during the first day (8/5/13) of Energy 1.  The task assigned to the groups was to build a list of the “features” and “values” of energy.  For instance, the example given in class was “feature” = starting form and “values” = light, chemical, gravity, magnetic, etc.  Then small groups took 15 minutes to create a list of features and values.  When the full class resumed, features suggested were transformation, transfer, ending value of energy, type of system, and matter effects. I have attached the group's whiteboard for reference at the end of the entry.


The following segment considers a 4 minute conversation at Table 7.  This conversation focuses on establishing the meaning of the words transfer and transformation.  When the video picks up, they have already been talking about this for about 5 minutes and it is clear that not everyone is on the same page.  Jeff and Tanya are the leading voices in attempting to describe the difference; Jeff is giving pretty good examples. Cynthia is the most vocal person in this video, loudly and clearly trying to make sure she gets the difference between the two.  In fact, she seems to be trying to determine if transfer and transformation can occur simultaneously. 


At one point she says, “This is just a question, that you also have transfer when you have transformation.”  Later she asks, “Is our definition of transfer broad enough to include transfer within transformation? Because I’m having trouble making the distinction and I’m not sure if the distinction is important.”

This conversation brings up a few different thoughts in me.  The initial one that I was pulled toward when listening to the conversation live was: do they even know what they are talking about?  It seemed to take some time to establish meanings for the words transfer and transformation.  The fact that this conversation continued for fifteen minutes means, to me, that there is a lack in clarity in what they are talking about.  Are the words transfer and transformation too confusing?  I see my students tripping over these words.  I see even these teachers grappling with these words, looking for the right meaning.  Should we simplify the way we speak?  Instead of saying transformation, could we say “form change?”  Instead of saying transfer, could we say “object change?”  The fact that both words contain “trans” may be adding an impediment that could be avoided.

After listening to this conversation a few more times, one gets the sense that Cynthia has a solid grasp on the difference between transfer and transformation.  What she really wants to grasp now is whether or not both can happen simultaneously.  Consider the statement: When an object is pushed, chemical energy in the body is transformed to kinetic energy in the object.  But this sentence shows both “form change” AND “object change.”  Form goes from chemical to kinetic.  Energy moves from body to object.  Is there a temporal order here?  How important is that ordering in understanding a given situation?  This video clearly shows the challenge inherent in simply vocalizing this issue, much less determining an answer to the question (if there even is a satisfactory answer).  I think later experiences with energy tracking diagrams may lead to deeper analysis of this question.

Full video title: E1 130805 1453 T7-1

Group 7's whiteboard for this activity: