Showing posts with label energy forms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label energy forms. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Suck on a Straw: Talking about Differentials

Context: This clip is from small group discussion during Book Club on the Energy Theater paper. This group (Mary, Sid, Bryan, and Wendy) were talking about how doing Energy Theater has made them aware of the challenge of reconciling micro and macro views of scenarios, which leads them back into discussing the piston scenario from that morning, which Mary has been pondering over lunch. The group discusses whether the word "elastic" could be used to describe the scenario, and discuss several examples of "differentials" in energy scenarios.

Interesting Features:
--Mary shows some anxiety about being "off-topic", saying, "I was thinking about this...well I guess I'm not talking about the article..." and later, "But remember the hand-held...is it ok that's we're ignoring..."(gesturing to the paper), I mean..." (she throws a conspiratorial look at Sid)..."the handheld flashlight..." Wendy reassures her, "We're not! We said, it's the micro/macro where we get messed up, and that we see that, and now we're exploring that."

-Some group members seem to be thinking of elastic as meaning a differential of any kind, because a differential produces a "spring-like" effect:
Sid: And so the reason why this works is the differential in pressure?
Wendy: Is that elastic energy then? I don't know.
Bryan: (with certainty) Yes.
Wendy: You think?
Bryan: Sure!...It's spring-like.
Wendy: It is, I mean I think it is
Bryan: It's returning...
Wendy: To a natural state
Bryan: To its original...to its equilibrium

-Other group members give examples that contradict this idea:
Mary: The handheld flashlight, the reason it worked was the temperature differential, but we didn't say there was an elastic energy there.
Sid: Cause there was no physical compression going on.
Wendy: There was no distortion.
Bryan: So there was no kinetic in the flashlight, is what you're saying, it was all thermal. Does that make sense?
...
Wendy: And you know, I don't think it is elastic, because when you suck on a straw, the reason the liquid comes up is the pressure differential, and they don't call that elastic.

-The group generates some alternative piston scenarios to help them try to understand how it works:
Mary: If you somehow made the room's pressure match this pressure...I'm ignoring this (points to article)...it wouldn't do anything

Mary: What if you had the piston not compressed, but the machine could somehow still move its handle? I don't know how that would be. But then you took the room outside of it, and took air out of it, so you lowered its pressure.
Bryan: It would work.
Mary: So you didn't actually compress this.
Bryan: You did the opposite. 

And Sid's question at the beginning  ("so the reason why this works is the differential in pressure?") is satisfyingly mirrored by Bryan's conclusion at the end ("There's gotta be a difference.")

Transcript
Mary: I was thinking about this...well I guess I'm not talking about the article...
If you somehow made the room's pressure match this pressure...I'm ignoring this (points to article)...it wouldn't do anything
It's something to do with the pressure difference between outside and inside
Sid: And so the reason why this works is the differential in pressure?
Wendy: Is that elastic energy then? I don't know.
Bryan: (with certainty) Yes.
Wendy: You think?
Bryan: Sure!...It's spring-like.
Wendy: It is, I mean I think it is
Bryan: It's returning...
Wendy: To a natural state
Bryan: To its original...to its equilibrium
Mary: But remember the hand-held...is it ok that's we're ignoring (the paper), I mean...(conspiratorial look) the handheld flashlight!
Wendy: We're not! We said, it's the micro/macro where we get messed up, and that we see that, and now we're exploring that.
Mary: The handheld flashlight, the reason it worked was the temperature differential, but we didn't say there was an elastic energy there.
Sid: Cause there was no physical compression going on.
Wendy: There was no distortion.
Bryan: So there was no kinetic in the flashlight, is what you're saying, it was all thermal. Does that make sense?
Mary: What if you had the piston not compressed, but the machine could somehow still move its handle? I don't know how that would be. But then you took the room outside of it, and took air out of it, so you lowered its pressure.
Bryan: It would work.
Mary: So you didn't actually compress this.
Bryan: You did the opposite. (Bryan talks about pistons in a car for a while)
Mary: So if the air was a lower pressure than the piston, the handle would get pushed in?...I mean if the air was higher pressure...
Sid: (Draws a picture) If I had low pressure here, and high pressure here, it would go in.
Bryan: There's gotta be a difference.
Wendy: And you know, I don't think it is elastic, because when you suck on a straw, the reason the liquid comes up is the pressure differential, and they don't call that elastic.
Mary: I think it just comes down to, you're increasing this contact between objects, this concentration of...

A Biologist Tries to Think...About Energy in Animals




After our discussion about the penguin walking uphill, which I will have to make a post about (how did that not happen?), I've been thinking about endothermy ("warm-bloodedness") and ectothermy ("cold-bloodedness." Endothermic creatures work very hard to keep their body temperature at an ideal level for their metabolic activities; this means they can be active in a much wider variety of physical and temporal environments than ectotherms can, but they require several times as much food at the same body size. Ectotherms on the other hand are more vulnerable to environmental changes, but don't need to eat as much.

In flagrant violation of Energy Project principles, I started with definitions from the College Board's AP Biology Curriculum Framework:

Endothermy: The use of thermal energy generated by metabolism to maintain homeostatic body temperature 
Ectothermy: The use of external thermal energy to regulate and maintain body temperature

Then I tried to draw an "energy diagram" for an endothermic animal. As I've mentioned before, a lot of the transformations that biologists consider most important don't look like transformations to a physicist at all. There's a lot of chemical to chemical going on here. There is thermal energy "lost" at each step (by which I think I mean the chemical products contain less usable energy than the reactants...is that what I mean?) An endotherm is pretty good at retaining some of that thermal energy, but still a lot is "lost" to the environment. 


After this I was going to draw an ectotherm, but as I started to think about it, I realized that none of the transformations are actually different in an ectotherm. The difference is in the amount of food consumed, and the amount of thermal energy generated and maintained. Endotherms have body structures (fat, blubber, fur, feathers) and behaviors (shivering, sweating) that help them keep their body temperatures at optimal level. These structures and behaviors require energy, but also can provide a "payoff". 


My thinking here led me to question College Board's definition.


I'm wondering if this endothermy/ectothermy is one more example of a false dichotomy. I had a brainsplosion recently that ionic and covalent bonds are really points on a spectrum. Maybe endo and ectothermy are the same--an animal gets some proportion of its thermal energy from the environment and some proportion from metabolism. I bet those proportions could even change!!

One postscript; here is the footnote to the Glucose (C) to ATP (C) pathway.


I work a lot in my class to distinguish between where the matter in a reaction comes from vs where the energy comes from. Maybe a future blog post...

Monday, August 12, 2013

The Most Interesting Energy Theater in the World

Context: These groups are planning and performing energy theater to represent a diver compressing a box of air. There is intense discussion of the definitions of and relationships among temperature, thermal energy, and kinetic energy. Brad takes on some of Stamatis' language to ask "how we know" there is thermal energy or kinetic energy in the box. Julie seems to catalyze an "a-ha" moment for several other members of the group by suggesting that kinetic energy is a property of individual gas molecules while thermal energy is a property of the gas as a whole.

Comment: It was very hard for me to choose a short clip from this 35 minute energy theater. What I ended up doing was synching up my field notes with the longer clip, which is saved as a separate episode on the server ("Thermal Energy Theater".) Anyone interested in thermal/kinetic issues, gestures, negotiation, or really transparent learning will find something to like in the longer clip. Highly recommended. :)

Transcript/Field Notes of entire 35-min energy theater (short clip above begins at about 10:30 of the longer clip)

[00:00:15.11]Steve: Because the size of the box changes, we are compressing the air so the air is now running into itself much more often. [00:00:26.20]It's a little more complicated than just adding some kinetic energy; we're not just thumping a few of the molecules...
[00:00:34.03]Wendy: Well, kinetic turns into thermal...

[00:00:49.01]Julie: The moving purple ball is transforming into heat...I guess it would have to be kinetic and thermal
[00:01:20.04]Steve: We have some heat energy that we're starting off with. They're definitely moving, they're above absolute zero.
[00:01:36.18]Julie: (referring to Don and Allie slapping their hands together, which they first said represented pressure) Maybe this is heat? It has to be elastic.
[00:01:51.03]Steve: The fact that they're hitting each other, the fact that they're moving, is the very definition of heat, of temperature.
[00:01:58.00]They are moving, therefore they have temperature
[00:02:04.05]Don: They're moving faster, therefore they have more thermal energy.
[00:02:47.18] Debra What's changing is the increasing bouncing, so that's the only other thing that's changing, we're not adding any energy...
[00:03:00.13]Julie: It's almost like that's teh first domino
[00:03:03.07]DEbra: There's no heat added, there's no cold added...There's nothing else going on except the volume decreases
[00:03:10.28]Steve: And the wall is moving towards us; there is some kinetic energy coming into the system
[00:03:30.13]Wendy: When we push that wall, that adds the kinetic energy, which is then manifasted as heat, temperature
[00:03:42.13]Allie: (rubs hands together)
[00:03:47.21]Wendy: We're acknowledging that there's kinetic that transfers to kinetic, because the whole body of gas moves
[00:04:07.04] and then the result is that goes to thermal
[00:04:13.27]This is that whole/part conversation
[00:04:30.12] The gas as a whole increases its kinetic energy when it's pushed, but then it doesn't increase it any more
[00:04:41.00] Allie: We have kinetic energy entering, but then it turns into something else (rubs hands together)
[00:05:07.12]Sid: The speed of the molecules is constant...and that's temperature?
[00:05:24.06]When we squish the box, the temperature goes up. So the speed of those molecules has changed
[00:05:37.02]But then once the box stops squeezing, they stay the same speed.
[00:05:47.22] Where is the energy coming from?
[00:05:52.29] Is that box losing heat...energy...?
[00:06:18.01] is the heat energy the same as the kinetic energy?
That's the question! people say
[00:06:30.23] Steve: I'm gonna change what I said earlier. Just the wall moving...but I'm gonna change that. i think it really is providing all the heat energy. that's the only source of energy.
sid: It's giving more kinetic energy to the molecules
[00:07:21.14] at the same time, temp is going up, which i'm hearing people say is an increase in heat energy. [00:07:52.12]did i increase in size kinetically?
[00:08:05.23]allie: scuba steve uses his muscles...
[00:08:16.14]brad: can i ask a question? is there thermal energy in the box right now? how do we know that?
[00:08:28.17]steve: you can see the motion
[00:08:34.18]brad: how do you know there's thermal energyFLAG imperceptibility of thermal energy
[00:08:37.04]don: it has temperature. we can measure it.
[00:08:40.24]sid: that's my question, is kinetic and thermal the same?
[00:10:16.11]julie--i don't think it's the hand--i think something is happening internally, inside here that results in hotness, increased something-ness
[00:10:46.13]1035 BRad--the indicator for KE and thermal is the same...Why is there the same answer for two different questions?
[00:11:30.01]but Brad thinks the distinction between single and group--[00:12:02.08] Stam said we need to go all big or all small but don't intermix.
[00:12:52.29]Julie THE INDIVIDUAL MOLECULES HAS KE BUT THE GAS AS A WHOLE HAS THERMAL
[00:13:10.24]--Wendy says HUGE!! Sid says I have to write this down.
[00:14:37.22]If there's no man, the box will stay the same size. (Still wokring on Julie's question from 1034.)
[00:15:02.03]Brad--debra wanted to do beginnign and end--but they're the same. ha.
[00:16:57.13]wendy: i know the box goes up in temperature but does the little ball go up in temperature? FLAG HEAT, PART VS WHOLE
the temperature relates to the collisions
[00:20:09.00]Steve goes through the simulation again on the proejector. [00:20:30.06]People say "You can see it! The wave of energy!"
[00:20:50.20]What if the closeness matters? No, I think it's the collisions.
[00:20:58.16]Wendy: I think it's the collisions (FLAG Jesper, collisions vs. KE of particles with temp--this whole ET should be flagged for that)
[00:23:57.11]Allie: As far as energy theater goes, temperature is not energy
[00:24:13.22]I think that's a red herring.
[00:24:22.28] the momentum of the particle... wendy: don't say momentum  [00:24:33.17]Steve: it's kinetic energy is the thermal energy. i think at a particle levle they're the same thing.
[00:25:40.04]Julie As the space between particles decreases, waste is decreased?
FLAG THERMAL ENERGY LOSS
heat loss. decreasing amount of lost heat
[00:25:59.12] rachel: you're (julie) saying when particles collide, thermal energy is lost. that's different than someone else, who said that a single particle doesn't have thermal energy.  you are proposing another scenario--two purple balls colliding HOLY COW-  THIS IS INTERESTING !!!yes it is.
1052 rachel is drawing a diagram on the board--dude, wall, all the gas in the tank for one scenario; dude, wall, one blue ball in another
1054 Sid suggests it coudl be constant K--t--K--t back and forth
debra: lets break into two groups and do the cubes for big and small
I think the question is whether thermal energy is a form of kinetic energy OR it is a warmth unrelated to the kinetic
10:56 Negotiation of different scenarios
Rachel draws three different options on the board - the group is going to split up and discuss different things.
aren't we in agreement on the blue? rachel--i would say you haven't done it so you don't know. debra--ok let's do it.
10:58 Debra suggests that they do the ET on the Blue option and then negotiate the red scenario upon completion of the the ET
1058 guess what--they don't agree. :) (miscommunication) - FLAG _ JUST TELL ME WHAT TO DO. (LIKE JEAN--feels different to me though. Jean was just frustrated and felt clueless. I think Julie does have an idea, but she sees that her idea is getting in the way of understanding someone else's idea.) True - but might be interesting to contrast the two interactions! totes.

Saturday, August 10, 2013

Sound as Kinetic Energy

On Tuesday afternoon (8/6/13) in E1, the class activity was to identify all forms of energy that were present in the morning example of a puck being flung across the floor by a bent back meter stick, as well as stating evidence for each type of energy.  At this point in the video, kinetic energy (as in the motion of the puck) and thermal energy had already been identified and categorized.  As the video begins, sound was suggested as a third energy.  Lane begins this episode by asking for evidence.

Emma laughs after posing that our evidence is simply that we hear something.  We’re left to wonder if other people in the class would have carried this line of thinking further or if Lane would have pushed Emma for something more.  Instead, Barbara chimes in with a very interesting point.


Barbara: But that's kinetic energy, though, right?  Sound and uh...I mean, it's a form of kinetic energy.
Lane: A very special kinetic energy. 
Barbara: But it still is a form.
Tracy: But that goes back to the argument that EVERYTHING is kinetic energy. 
Barbara: Exactly.
Emma: So just like earlier we were specific about motion, now we're gonna be specific about sound.
Barbara: So we're gonna say kinetic sound energy, maybe, I mean, wouldn't we?  I don't know, I mean, I would think we would.
{Long silence}
Barbara: I was suggesting to put kinetic in front of sound, since it's a type of kinetic.

After another brief pause, Lane points out that standards suggest there are two broad categories that all types of energy fall under: kinetic and potential.  He goes on to create a third column in their categorization table – the micro story – that will allow for a description of what is occurring at the molecular level.

I’m interested in this episode because sound energy is not one that I hear (pun) discussed often.  And when I do discuss it, I roll it in the broad category of thermal energy.  Yet here, Barbara suggests placing it in the category of kinetic energy.  Then they would have kinetic: motion and kinetic: sound.  Lane bypasses this with the new micro story column.  I’m curious about her characterization of sound as kinetic rather than sound as thermal because it is not incorrect.  It’s just a different way of organizing.

In fact, I’m surprised that earlier in the discussion when thermal energy was first brought up, no one considered the category of kinetic: thermal.  To my thinking, that’s even more obvious than sound as kinetic.  I wonder if that is because of the order the forms were offered.  Thermal was suggested first and heating was the evidence.  Then kinetic was second.  Were these reversed, I wonder if the class might have been prone to bring up the idea that temperature and heating are related to motion of particles.  A little later in the class, Lane asks them to “act out” the molecular motion of each type of energy, so they eventually discuss this.  But it took further prompting to get there.


Full video: E1 130806 1253 T6-1