Showing posts with label chemical. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chemical. Show all posts

Thursday, August 15, 2013

ATP: An electrical impulse thing and a little zap

This is more on the theme of “getting hot while dropping your balls.”  As a refresher, in E1 on Monday morning (8/12/13), the class began the day by drawing diagrams for the two scenarios considered the previous Friday: raising a bowling ball at constant velocity and lowering the ball at constant velocity.  The group I am considering in this episode is: Jeff (in blue), John, Sara (in green), and Emma.  In the first half hour of class, they drew a diagram representing the energy theater.

Their diagram includes instances of chemical energy converting to thermal energy, and they recognize this as a process that includes ATP, but they do not know how to account for it.  Now that they have finished, Adam comes to the table to check on them and see how they are doing.  What follows is a discussion regarding what they think about the scenarios they have just looked at. 


I love that each member of the group had a chance to weigh in on the matter, even Sara who is typically rather quiet.  To each of them, the processes involved in going from chemical energy (ATP) to muscle movement to thermal energy, are a mystery, and each of them has a different way of expressing their befuddlement.  Jeff at 0:13 says “I need to scratch my head and go wow.”  John, at 1:13, adds “It gets super fancy, which I don’t even want to get into.”  Even one of the instructors, Adam, can’t hold back his relationship with biology at 1:25.  “I’m a physics guy, so when I hear ATP I kind go…” and he apparently makes a face or a twitch or something. 

At 2:14, Sara enters in and continues off of John’s wonderment at “an electrical impulse thing” and “a little zap that we’re not accounting for.”  She wants to keep separate the energy story and the processes of ATP.  “The electrical is part of the chemical.”  She sees that for kids, it wouldn't make sense to have chemical go to electrical and so on.  Emma fleshes this out with a long montage of chemical to electrical to new chemical to new electrical.  Without even knowing the exact process, she sees the weaving that might happen.  “Having a separate story, I think, is a good thing,” she adds at the end.

Finally, at 2:54 Sara suggests, “I don’t think understanding this way is a misconception.”  This is an interesting way to phrase her idea.  I wonder how she thinks of physics and biology misconceptions.  Beyond that, what is clear to me here is that all four teachers agree that energy theater shouldn't (and maybe even can’t) address all of the steps that may exist as chemical energy transforms to thermal. 

“If you don’t understand where the energy comes from, call it chemical.”  This is quite common in physics.  I certainly do this in my classes with the simple examples I use that might need such a designation, such as a car driving or a person pushing an object.  Honestly, I've rarely made an attempt to develop a picture that is deeper than this.  It is fascinating to watch a group of people attempt to dig at this deeper picture and essentially come up baffled and prepared to stick with “chemical to thermal, let’s move on.”  I wonder if this might be a valuable class exercise for my students.  Let them struggle to build a more complex picture, to give them a greater appreciation for hiding some details in their energy representation.


Full video: E1 130812 0814 T6-1

Wednesday, August 14, 2013

Do you get hot dropping your balls?

In E1 on Monday morning (8/12/13), the class began the day by drawing diagrams for the two scenarios considered the previous Friday: raising a bowling ball at constant velocity and lowering the ball at constant velocity.  The group I am considering in this episode is: Jeff (in blue), John, Sara (in green), and Emma.  In the first half hour of class, they drew the following diagram:


Then they were asked to consider the following two questions: 1) How does the change in chemical energy compare and 2) How does change in thermal energy compare?  What we can note directly from their diagram is that more chemical energy units are initially shown in the lifting case than the lowering case, whereas more thermal energy is generated in the lowering case than the lifting.  What is clear is that they decided on using 8 total units or parcels of energy in both pictures, which may be causing some trouble in their minds.  This episode picks up early on in their conversation, as they wrestle with what their diagram tells them about what is happening.  Jeff, a few moments earlier, says: “We don't end up with as much thermal energy when we lift.  We seem to imply that we don't get as hot lifting something as lowering.”  This leads the group to considering what would happen if they introduced more energy units.  Lane has joined the table and the group is explaining what they have drawn as well as thinking out loud.


This is a tough conversation to follow and I've had to listen a few times.  Jeff begins by suggesting that if they started with more energy units, then more C’s would be left at the end of the raising picture and more T’s would be left at the end of the lowering picture.  Emma chimes in with the idea that if they want to truly represent the inefficiency of human processes (which is something that was suggested earlier in their conversation), then they need to have more C’s transform directly to T’s.  Particularly, it seems that she notices in lowering they show G to T and C to T, whereas in lifting they only show C to T (this can be seen on the diagram).  She says: “we ought to have some parcels of chemical energy converting into thermal energy separate from this [the shown C to T] conversion.”  She notes that by showing more conversions of C to T, then a balance could occur between both pictures, which could lead to equal thermal energy being generated, or maybe even more in the lift.  This is a neat suggestion from her, because it breaks from the mold of every energy unit being fully understood.  It acknowledges that something occurs in the body that we don’t understand but must be accounted for so that our picture makes sense at the end. 

John joins in to describe to Lane the issue that they are having, which is that their picture shows different amounts of thermal energy at the end, but they feel in real life that would not be the case.  He feels bound by the number of “actors” in the diagram.  Again, this appears to be a moment of transition in translating ET to an energy diagram.  He (and his group) started by thinking about a set number of actors, like ET.  They feel confined by this.  Sara adds that the person lifting and lowering the ball should have the same amount of chemical at the beginning of each diagram, since it’s the same person.  Again, a further refinement.  The group is finding ways in which their diagram does not work for them and suggestions solutions. 

Since they are already saying that more energy units would be helpful, Lane bumps them forward with this idea at 1:56, pondering what it would be like if they had an infinite number of actors.  John and Emma continue to express, with more confidence, what the group has been saying these past few minutes.

The final part of the video is really interesting.  It highlights their challenge in resolving their diagram with what they intuitively feel should be true.  At 2:51 Lane asks, “So would you then in the lowering scenario end up with a bigger change in thermal energy?”  John, Emma, and Sara all offer evidence that YES you would end up with more thermal energy when lowering.  Lane, at 3:46, then asks, “Does that seem intuitively right?”  Emma and Jeff both immediately respond NO.  The episode ends here, but two minutes later John adds, “That gravitational energy makes more thermal doesn't make sense to me.  It's just weird.”  This is a fantastic example of cognitive dissonance.  Everyone in the group keeps pointing to their diagram and describing how it shows more thermal energy in the lowering case, yet they keep saying this feels all wrong to them. This swing back and forth happens throughout the 4 minutes, indeed throughout their 45 minute small group discussion.


This dissonance is not resolved in small groups, nor do I think it gets resolved in the whole class discussion, where it comes up again in full strength.  The conversation does go deeper at this point and Lane even brings research evidence to bear.  No general conclusion is reached, but the class appears to agree with moving on.  I hope to pull an episode from the full class discussion as well.

Full episode: E1 130812 0814 T6-1