Showing posts with label whiteboards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label whiteboards. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 13, 2013

A Biologist Tries to Think...About Energy in Animals




After our discussion about the penguin walking uphill, which I will have to make a post about (how did that not happen?), I've been thinking about endothermy ("warm-bloodedness") and ectothermy ("cold-bloodedness." Endothermic creatures work very hard to keep their body temperature at an ideal level for their metabolic activities; this means they can be active in a much wider variety of physical and temporal environments than ectotherms can, but they require several times as much food at the same body size. Ectotherms on the other hand are more vulnerable to environmental changes, but don't need to eat as much.

In flagrant violation of Energy Project principles, I started with definitions from the College Board's AP Biology Curriculum Framework:

Endothermy: The use of thermal energy generated by metabolism to maintain homeostatic body temperature 
Ectothermy: The use of external thermal energy to regulate and maintain body temperature

Then I tried to draw an "energy diagram" for an endothermic animal. As I've mentioned before, a lot of the transformations that biologists consider most important don't look like transformations to a physicist at all. There's a lot of chemical to chemical going on here. There is thermal energy "lost" at each step (by which I think I mean the chemical products contain less usable energy than the reactants...is that what I mean?) An endotherm is pretty good at retaining some of that thermal energy, but still a lot is "lost" to the environment. 


After this I was going to draw an ectotherm, but as I started to think about it, I realized that none of the transformations are actually different in an ectotherm. The difference is in the amount of food consumed, and the amount of thermal energy generated and maintained. Endotherms have body structures (fat, blubber, fur, feathers) and behaviors (shivering, sweating) that help them keep their body temperatures at optimal level. These structures and behaviors require energy, but also can provide a "payoff". 


My thinking here led me to question College Board's definition.


I'm wondering if this endothermy/ectothermy is one more example of a false dichotomy. I had a brainsplosion recently that ionic and covalent bonds are really points on a spectrum. Maybe endo and ectothermy are the same--an animal gets some proportion of its thermal energy from the environment and some proportion from metabolism. I bet those proportions could even change!!

One postscript; here is the footnote to the Glucose (C) to ATP (C) pathway.


I work a lot in my class to distinguish between where the matter in a reaction comes from vs where the energy comes from. Maybe a future blog post...

Thursday, August 11, 2011

What makes it to the board: assessment via whiteboard

What initially sparked my interest in Group 6's discussion of rights and responsibilities on Day One was an exchange between Melanie and Ingrid where Melanie states "I have the right to be dumb every once in awhile. Please be nice to me if I'm on the wrong track." Ingrid then restates as "The right to be ignorant," which to me was a fascinating way to put this idea. Yet, what was ultimately put on their whiteboard was the right "To not know everything." As I blogged the last week (here), this prompted me to begin to notice the negotiation of the group in deciding what to put on the whiteboard.

There have been other posts that have dealt with interesting aspects of whiteboard collaboration, such as Kara's post from last summer about inequality of access (here) and from the PHSYLRNR listserve on "The Power of the Marker" (here). Unlike the phenomena these posts discuss, Group 6 is actually working collaboratively and productively. They are using the whiteboard as both a collaboration tool - where they can revise and refine what they have written as a group - and as a presentation space - where they are consciously thinking about how to succinctly summarize a right or a responsibility that they all recognize. Also, although there is some evidence of "the power of the marker," they are pretty good about sharing power among the group members. Thus, instead of issues of inequality of access or the power dynamics, what captured me is the idea of the whiteboard as an incomplete assessment tool. What happens to our assessment if what makes it to the whiteboard is a thin representation of an incredibly rich interaction?

The whole discussion of rights and responsibilities was about 15 minutes and this was the whiteboard they had produced at the end:
I want to focus on just a few pieces of this longer conversation, so to provide some context, below is a breakdown of how the conversation progressed (anything in quotes is something that is actually on the board):
  1. "Listen" followed by a discussion of whose R & R's to focus on
  2. "Participate/be active" and "Be Respectful"
  3. "To not know everything" (i.e. the right to be ignorant)
  4. "Turn off phone" and "Be on time
  5. "To ask questions" and "To tolerate differences"
  6. off-topic
  7. "To apply information"
  8. shoptalk
  9. not just give answers (Clip 1)
  10. "Stay on task"
  11. "guide discussion" and "wait time"
  12. "receive information" (Clip 2)
  13. Be patient
  14. Discussion of the role of videographers
Originally, there were several of pieces of this conversation that I wanted to share, but I have narrowed it down to #9 and #12 (noted as Clip 1 and Clip 2 above). There are a few other clips on the server if you are interested (#5, #7, #13).

I chose these two because Clip 1 is an example of an interesting conversation about pedagogy that never actually made it onto the board in that form and Clip 2 is a fairly lengthy conversation boiled down to a single, somewhat ambiguous phrase ("receive information"). What makes it more interesting is that these two conversations are on either side of adding "guide discussion" and "wait time" to the board and for both of these phrases, someone proposed the point and it was written right away with no elaboration or discussion.

Note: I haven't transcribed them yet, so let me know if that is necessary.

Clip 1: The responsibility to not just give answers




Clip 2: The right to receive information



Just to restate what captured my attention: we often use whiteboards as a tool for assessment, but it is not always an accurate reflection of the interactions that actually occur. How does this or even should this influence the way that we use whiteboards in our assessment of group work?

Friday, July 1, 2011

Story-Board Stories, part II

In Story-Board Stories, part I, I posted images of whiteboards in progress and for public presentation from the different groups in UE2. I couldn't get them all in that post, so here are the rest.

Elevator (Lisa, Margaret) note: their understanding progressed considerably as they continued to work, so what they presented to the class (which interestingly they did _not_ do as Energy Theater) is quite different than this. I don't know that we have a still image of their final presentation board, but we definitely have video, and maybe I can extract a still from that video to include here.

at lunch break:


at end of day:


Even though we don't have an intermediate board from them, I've included Alia and Akbar's final board here.

Falling Book (Alia, Akbar)
final presentation board (Alia used this for the Energy Theater):

Story-Board Stories, part I

(my first post!)

The white boards have lots of uses. Two of the frequent ones in UE2 are as a workspace and as a presentation space. Early in the week, Hunter introduced (or maybe reminded?) the participants about "Energy Storyboarding". The context here is very similar to the storyboards done for movie pre-production. One idea was this would help the teams "direct" the Energy Theater for their projects. Since the teams had a long time to work on their projects, they had a lot of time on the white-boards, and it's interesting to see the progressions (in thinking though that's hard for me to make much sense of from static images, in purpose from workspace to presentation space) and also the many different representations. On Tuesday, we were able to take pictures of whiteboards at the lunch break and then again at the end of the day. I've shown all the whiteboards here except for Alia & Akbar, for whom we only have the final storyboard (but I'll talk about their storyboard in a different post). Also, every group that has so far directed an Energy Theater has used their storyboard in some fashion. Here they are:

Toaster (Charlene, Meg, Michelle)
at lunch break:














at end of day/ for Energy Theater:


Pump/Air/Balloon (Cindy) <-- note that many people have commented favorably about Cindy's artistic abilities at various points through the week.
at lunch break:

at end of day (I think this is the same as what she uses for her Energy Theater):


Guitar String Sound (Joe, Elyse)
at lunch break:

at end of day/for Energy Theater:


Earthquake (Anne, Scott)
at lunch break:

at end of day:


(to be continued...)

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Teaching Seminar: Continuation of Leaves in the Street episode

I'm finally getting around to blogging about the Teaching Seminar from 2/7, where the teachers discussed another 12 minutes of Matt's class. I had some technical difficulties, so there was a good chunk of time I wasn't able to listen, and then then battery on the mic died at some point, so I don't know how much of the discussion we actually have audio for. Too bad, because it may have been an interesting discussion. Also, I was so excited about the video myself (I had not seen it before class) that I had a hard time going meta and analyzing their discussion of it.

What excited me about the video: Lots of language about energy that I didn't understand. Using strange grammar and making strange distinctions like "It has a source of energy" and "Does it have energy or does it just use energy?" I suspect that the students are implicitly using some other metaphor for energy, but I'm not sure what it is.

Also, one thing that came up the next week in our research group meeting when we discussed the video: There's a point when Matt says, "So it's not necessarily that an object that is moving has energy, it just takes energy to cause something to move?" He's listening to what the students are saying and he's noticing a distinction that most experts wouldn't even see, because to an expert, those things are the same. Someone argued that he's been primed to hear that distinction because he's been in our summer courses and teaching seminars for two years, where we've talked in great detail about these distinctions. But if that's true, is this a piece of evidence that our course is actually having an impact on a teacher's classroom practice? Or maybe Matt would have done this even if he'd never been part of this course.

What may be interesting about the teaching seminar: Lots of rich discussion about what students were thinking. I caught teachers saying a lot of things that seemed too simplistic to me, like they weren't really getting what students were thinking, but at the same time, they were really talking the whole time about what students might be thinking. If we want to write a paper about how teachers' attention to student thinking changes over the course of the teaching seminar, there's probably some good data here, but I'd have to watch it again to know what to pick out.

Thursday, August 12, 2010

What is the purpose for whiteboards? or Creating and Inequality of Access

I’ve used whiteboards a lot in teaching LAs. I’m usually very visual when learning and teaching. I view whiteboards as a common work place for people to visually share their ideas with their groups so they are “on the same page” so to speak. Yet I almost always have groups present their whiteboards as well. Therefore I see two roles that whiteboards can take:

1. Shared workspace

2. Presentation spaces (economical poster-boards)


In this clip from Tuesday of E2, table 6 is working to understand the refrigerator scenario. The clip is about half and hour into the process. For approximately two minutes prior to this clip, Linda has been explaining and revising her diagram which she had been working on privately in her notebook for several minutes prior to explaining it. During Linda's explanation, Lezlie asks a lot of clarifying questions and thoughts on how to revise the diagram. Liz listens but doesn't ask a lot of questions. This clip is longer than the key exchange (which occurs at :53) because I want to show Liz's body language which I think conveys a lot about how she is feeling.

There are two things that strike me about this clip. First, Liz and Linda appear to be operating with two very different understandings of the purpose of whiteboards. Liz appears to have the first purpose listed above in mind (whiteboards as shared workspaces). She views the whiteboard as a place to write down ideas so they can be shared by the group. This is supported by the fact that she is constantly writing and erasing things on the board, and often trying to draw other group member's verbal descriptions on the board. On the other hand, Linda appears to agree more with the second purpose of whiteboards (they are presentation spaces). Therefore she is unwilling to put what she considers to be a unfinished product (her current diagram) on the whiteboard. For Linda, the workspace, or place for ideas which are in development, is her notebook. I think this relates to the idea which Rachel has mentioned earlier (here) that some students want time to think about their ideas privately before sharing with the whole class. For Linda, writing in her notebook appears to be the opportunity to think privately before writing on the whiteboard which would be producing something for "public" consumption. I worry that, as instructors, our use of gallery walks and whiteboard presentations has prevented students like Linda from using the whiteboard as a group workspace.

The reason I am concerned about this is the second thing that strikes me about this clip. There appears to be an equity issue centered around the whiteboard and it's use or lack thereof. One of the reasons that whiteboards work so well as a shared workspace is that they are centrally located and encourage big writing which everyone in the group can see. When everyone in the group can see the visual representation of what is being discussed then everyone has the opportunity to equally participate in the discussion (I'm not saying that using whiteboards will lead to full and equal participation for every group member, only that it provides the opportunity for this). When Linda switches to using her notebook as the workspace she affects the access other members of the group have to the discussion. For Lezlie this change is not very noticeable since she appears to have no problem seeing the diagram over Linda's shoulder. Yet for Liz the change is profound. Because the focus has moved to Linda's notebook, Liz can no longer see what Linda and Lezlie are pointing to and therefore cannot follow the discussion. Liz tries to address this by asking Linda to redraw her diagram on the whiteboard, but Linda's discomfort with putting an unfinished product on the whiteboard prevents her from following through on Liz's request (Linda very likely does not realize that Liz can't see and therefore is probably not intentionally blocking Liz from the conversation). I think Liz's feelings of not being part of the discussion, her repeated attempts to reengage in the conversation, and her eventual disengagement from the conversation are visible in her body language.

As Rachel pointed out, it is also possible that it is not Linda's view of the purpose of whiteboards but her familiarity with writing in her notebook (from her previous experiences in PbI) which creates the inequality of access.

I think this clip suggests that while as instructors we may want to use whiteboards for both of the purposes listed above, our use of whiteboards as presentation spaces may inhibit some students' from later using whiteboards as work spaces. I think this clip also suggests that inequality in access to a tool can influence participation.