Sunday, November 14, 2010

Teaching Seminar, fourth session

Note the new name for the academic-year evening professional development sessions.  We decided AYPD was cryptic and offered no sense of purpose.  We like the image of a “seminar” as an intense, in-depth, small-group discussion of a topic of interest.

For this session, we wanted to watch what I call the “Beer” episode, which is below.


Sam has presented this episode to other research groups as an example of unsuccessful Energy Theater.  She has had that characterization challenged rather strongly, so maybe it’s not that bad, but I was still nervous about showing an episode in which I pretty much dislike what happens.  The first hundred times I saw this episode, what I saw was “Blaine” (with the cup) rudely and repeatedly mowing down “Laura’s” efforts to actually engage in the assigned activity.  However, our group has done some work to see things more from Blaine’s perspective, and my interpretation  now is that Blaine is just trying to have a little fun with it.  This is not so bad; shouldn’t there be room for some playfulness, even some theatricality, in an activity called Energy Theater?  This episode was very early on in the 2009 course, so we were all really just working out what Energy Theater even is.

For the Teaching Seminar, Stamatis and I decided to frame the episode with the premise that science learning should be fun, and ask the teachers what one ought to do to make it more fun.  I enjoyed thinking about what people might say and what underlying beliefs about science the answers would reveal:  for example:

  • “Lighten up!” - This is what I see Blaine trying to do.  I think it suggests an underlying belief that scientists have sticks up their butts. (What I wrote on the white board in my office was “excess rectitude,” which I am still giggling at.)
  • “Get your hands dirty!” - This is how I characterized people’s feeling that what makes science fun is more “hands-on” activities.  I think it suggests an underlying belief that science tends to be too sterile and remote.
  • “Be nice!” - This is mine.  I think that a major reason that science is not fun for many people is that we (unwittingly) make people miserable: we discourage them, we hurt their feelings, we make them anxious, and that is no fun.  I think the underlying belief suggested here is that science itself is fun, but the fun is blocked by our lousy interpersonal interactions.

In class, things didn’t really go in a direction that led to my sharing those ideas with the teachers.  Asked to white-board about what would make science learning more fun, they wrote things that sounded to me like they came from their professional training:  “hands-on,” “interactive,” “relevant,” “exciting.”  Stamatis (in what I thought was a terrific move) asked them to close their eyes and imagine a personal experience in which they had experienced deep learning and it had been fun.  This changed the tenor of their conversation totally; I heard more than one table talk about having a trusted colleague to work out ideas with, which seemed to me to go in the direction of my “be nice” in the sense that it was about the value of safe interpersonal interactions.

In watching the Beer episode, the teachers were (to me) remarkably positive about the whole thing.  Not only did they see Blaine having fun, they saw Laura having fun, which to me was almost unbelievable (I had thought Laura was clearly frustrated).  Laura wasn’t there, but I shared the episode with her remotely and asked her whether she was having fun during it.  She said (in an email), “It seemed like we were having more fun than I remembered.”  So she remembers it as not having been fun, but thinks she looks like she was having fun in the video?  Odd.

The teachers’ observations of the video were ... observations!  They noticed interesting things that happened.  They pointed out the timing of events, the wording, the body language.  They made reasonable evidence-based interpretations of the things they heard people saying and saw them doing.  I wish I remembered more of the substance of what they said - it’s been too long since the class, I should have written sooner.  I remember that they saw Blaine and Laura as changing their language as to what represented the energy: was it the people, or the beer that the people were drinking, or the flow, or ...?  And I remember that they wanted to talk a lot about “Cara’s” nonparticipation.  I was heartened that we had a discussion that was free of insults.  The flags have been taken up as a symbol; if people didn’t have a flag at hand they would wave a pretend flag at each other, especially in small groups, when they heard someone saying something judgmental.  Maybe that’s easier to do in a face-to-face interaction than in the “ref” position.

Carl Rogers on education, part III

This is the third post on Carl Rogers' statement of the conditions for "significant learning."  Part I is here.  Part II is here.

Rogers has a lot to say about the role of evaluation in schooling.
In therapy, the examinations are set by life.  The client meets them, sometimes passing, sometimes failing.  He finds that he can use the resources of the therapeutic relationship and his experience in it to organize himself so that he can meet life’s tests more satisfyingly next time.
In [an education modeled on the therapeutic paradigm], the requirements for many life situations would be part of the resources the teacher provides.  The student would have available the knowledge that he cannot enter engineering school without so much math; that he cannot get a job in X corporation without a college diploma; that he cannot become a psychologist without doing independent doctoral research; that he cannot be a doctor without knowledge of chemistry; that he cannot even drive a car without passing an examination on rules of the road.  These are requirements set, not by the teacher, but by life.  The teacher is there to provide the resources which the student can use to learn so as to be able to meet these tests.
There would be other in-school evaluations of a similar sort.  The student might well be faced with the fact that he cannot join the Math Club until he makes a certain score on a standardized mathematics test; that he cannot develop his camera film until he has shown an adequate knowledge of chemistry and lab techniques; that he cannot join the special literature section until he has shown evidence of both wide reading and creative writing.  The natural place of evaluation in life is as a ticket of entrance, not a club over the recalcitrant.  Our experience in therapy would suggest that it should be the same way in school.  It would leave the student as a self-respecting, self-motivated person, free to choose whether he wished to put forth the effort to gain these tickets of entrance.

I think the Energy Project has an advantage shared by a lot of teacher professional development programs, which is that the teachers are mostly not recalcitrant (and do not need clubbing).  I think they mostly have the attitude that the measure of their success will be their improved performance as teachers.  So, while we do give them an exam at the end of the summer course, I think it is understood as informative for them and for us, rather than being for the purpose of judgment.

Carl Rogers on education, part II

This is the second post on Carl Rogers' statement of the conditions for "significant learning."  Part I is here.

3. Acceptance and understanding
Another implication for the teacher is that significant learning may take place if the teacher can accept the student as he is, and can understand the feelings he possesses.  ...The teacher who can warmly accept, who can provide an unconditional positive regard, and who can empathize with the feelings of fear, anticipation, and discouragement which are involved in meeting new material, will have done a great deal toward setting the conditions for learning.  ...It will perhaps disturb some that when the teacher holds such attitudes, when he is willing to be acceptant of feelings, it is not only attitudes towards school work which are expressed, but feelings about parents, feelings of hatred for brother or sister, feelings of concern about self - the whole gamut of attitudes.  Do such feelings have a right to exist openly in a school setting?  It is my thesis that they do.  They are related to the person's becoming, to his effective learning and effective functioning, and to deal understandingly and acceptantly with such feelings has a definite relationship to the learning of long division or the geography of Pakistan.

I feel like I have not gotten to actively thinking about this issue yet in my observations.

4. Provision of resources
In therapy the resources for learning one's self lie within.  There is very little data which the therapist can supply which will be of help since the data to be dealt with exist within the person.  In education this is not true.  There are many resources of knowledge, of techniques, of theory which constitute raw material for use.  It seems to me that what I have said about therapy suggests that these materials, these resources, be made available to the students, not forced upon them.  Here a wide range of ingenuity and sensitivity is an asset.
I do not need to list the usual resources which come to mind - books, maps, workbooks, materials, recordings, work-space, tools, and the like.  Let me focus for a moment on the way the teacher uses himself and his knowledge and experience as a resource.  If the teacher holds the point of view I have been expressing then he would probably want to make himself available to his class in at least the following ways:
He would want to let them know of special experience and knowledge he has in the field, and to let them know they could call on this knowledge.  Yet he would not want them to feel that they must use him in this way.
He would want them to know that his own way of thinking about the field, and of organizing it, was available to them, even in lecture form, if they wished.  Yet again he would want this to be perceived as an offer, which could as readily be refused as accepted.
He would want to make himself known as a resource-finder.  Whatever might be seriously wanted by an individual or by the whole group to promote their learning, he would be very willing to consider the possibilities of obtaining such a resource.
He would want the quality of his relationship to the group to be such that his feelings could be freely available to them, without being imposed on them or becoming a restrictive influence on them.  He thus could share the excitements and enthusiasms of his own learning, without insisting that the students follow in his footsteps; the feelings of disinterest, satisfaction, bafflement, or pleasure which he feels toward individual or group activities, without this becoming either a carrot or a stick for the student.  His hope would be that he could say, simply for himself, “I don’t like that,” and the student with equal freedom could say, “But I do.”

One of the suggestions that stands out to me is the idea that the instructor ought to make all his expertise and knowledge and views of the subject available to the students, without imposing it on them.  It seems to me that the focus of many reform efforts has been to stop the instructor from imposing his views on the students.  As for making our expertise available to the students, though, I think we (at least I) tend to be rather withholding.  I think at some level, I believe that an instructor’s ideas will always be a “restrictive influence” on the students.

I’m experimenting with being a little less rigid on this point.  There is a teacher in the Teaching Seminar who demands, pretty much every time, that I “tell her the right answer” (my words, not hers) before we try to understand student ideas about some topic.  In the moment, I am very resistant to her request.  I feel like she’s not supposed to need to know that, or I’m not supposed to tell it to her, or both.  But she really demands it... so, I have tried to understand why she wants to know.  And darned if she doesn’t have actually pretty understandable reasons.  I don’t remember how she put it (hopefully it’s on video somewhere), but I remember feeling like I could see where she was coming from when I recalled that I appreciated Rogers a lot more after I was informed that before Rogers, psychology was pretty much all Freud.  When someone gave me a big picture of American psychology, I could appreciate Rogers’ originality a lot more.

Speaking of Freud, my image of an aloof and neutral PER instructor who doesn’t divulge her own expertise (but who silently diagnoses and interprets the students’ misconceptions) reminds me of an aloof and neutral therapist who listens to clients free-associate and diagnoses their neuroses.

Carl Rogers on education, part I

To me, the great majority of what Carl Rogers has to say seems highly relevant to education.  He also has a chapter in On Becoming a Person titled "Significant Learning in Therapy and Education," in which he lays out what he feels are the criteria for "learnings which are functional, which make a difference, which pervade the person and his actions."  I'll be quoting extensively... and I think it's too much for a single post, so, this is part I.

1. Contact With Problems
Significant learning occurs more readily in relation to situations perceived as problems.  ...The student in the regular university course, and particularly in the required course, is apt to view the course as an experience in which he expects to remain passive or resentful or both, an experience which he certainly does not often see as relevant to his own problems.  Yet it has also been my experience that when a regular university class does perceive the course as an experience they can use to resolve problems which are of concern to them, the sense of release, and the thrust of forward movement is astonishing.
When a whole nation perceives itself as being faced with an urgent problem of being behind - in agriculture, in industrial production, in scientific development, in weapons development - then an astonishing amount of significant learning takes place.
So the first implication for education might well be that we permit the student, at any level, to be in real contact with the relevant problems of his existence, so that he perceives problems and issues which he wishes to resolve. 

The Energy Project is in a good position to put students in contact with problems they care about and/or that are of national concern (e.g., sustainability), and in fact this was one of the motivations for forming the Energy Project in the first place.

2.  The Teacher's Real-ness
Learning will be facilitated, it would seem, if the teacher is congruent.  This involves the teacher's being the person that he is, and being openly aware of the attitudes that he holds.  It means that he feels acceptant towards his own real feelings.  Thus he becomes a real person in the relationship with his students.  He can be enthusiastic about subjects he likes, and bored by topics he does not like.  He can be angry, but he can also be sensitive or sympathetic.  Because he accepts his feelings as his feelings, he has no need to impose them on his students, or insist that they feel the same way.  He is a person, not a faceless embodiment of a curricular requirement, or a sterile pipe through which knowledge is passed from one generation to the next.

The need for what Rogers calls "congruence" is based in his experience that human beings are keen perceivers of any kind of emotional falseness, remoteness, ambiguity, or mixed messages, and that when we perceive them, we tend to be confused and distrustful.  Then we don't show ourselves, and we avoid exploring risky territory because we don't feel safe, and "significant learning" is unlikely.  The effort toward "congruence" is most of what Rogers tries to do himself as a therapist:  If he can accept his own feelings and be completely transparent with his client, then he can be "almost sure the relationship will be a helpful one."

My experiences with the teachers in the Teaching Seminar (as we are now calling it) feel like an illustration of this to me.  Links to that sequence:  First session, second session, third session.

Continued in part II.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Energy in a Refrigerator, continued

We started a few days ago.  Here is our current analysis.

T is Thermal energy, P is Phase energy (which we made up; it's the kind of energy that is greater for a gas than for a liquid), E is Electrical energy, and M is Motion or Mechanical or Motor, as the mood strikes us.  I made two colors of arrows because I thought it made the diagram easier to parse, but then when I looked at it, I realized that the green arrows are when the energy is being carried by the material fluid, and the black arrows are heat and work.  Mostly.  I was not consistent.

We'll start in the evaporator (top left).  There is cold cold fluid, some of which is liquid and some of which is gas.  (You can't see the fluid in the diagram, because this is an energy diagram; but anywhere there's a P, there's gas.  We could have had more Ps for gas than for liquid, but instead we chose to have liquid be the baseline = no Ps.)  The cold fluid in the evaporator takes in thermal energy from the food; that thermal energy transforms into phase energy, meaning that some liquid evaporates.  (Hence: evaporator.)  You could say this as, "The hot food helps evaporate the cold fluid," and that tells you something about refrigerant (the interior of a fridge is "hot" as far as it's concerned).  Some of the refrigerant was gas already.  We'll get to that.

The gas goes into the compressor chamber (bottom left, right half of box).  In the compressor device itself (left half of box), electrical energy is transformed into M energy, squeezing the gas in the chamber, doing work on it and thus transferring thermal energy to it (first law).  Thus is the gas made hot.

The hot gas flows to the condenser (bottom right), carrying its Ps and Ts with it.  In the condenser, Ps transform to Ts (hot gas turns to hot liquid), and the proper number of Ts are radiated (or convected or whatever) off into the room.  Now we have a merely warm liquid.

The warm liquid flows to the expansion valve (top right), where it is forced through a small opening ("throttled"), spraying out droplets and a bit of gas.  The production of droplets is no big deal energetically (mere van der Waals interactions) and we neglect it.  The dominant energy process is the partial evaporation: Ts turn to Ps.  The result is cold gas.  This cold gas goes to the evaporator.  Remember we said there was already gas in the evaporator, and that it was colder than the food?

It seems to me that we would only need seven actors (plus maybe a few extras) to do this as Energy Theater, and I would like to do that, to see if anything new comes up when we make it dynamic.

Some remaining questions:
1. What is special about refrigerant, or about various specific refrigerants?
2. What does enthalpy have to do with it?
3. What does entropy have to do with it?
4. How does this diagram compare to the heat flow diagram common in textbooks, or to other refrigerator diagrams?
5. What are the names and thermodynamic laws associated with all the processes represented?

6. Are we right about partial evaporation being the dominant process in the expansion valve?

Relational discourse

Benedikt watched the first fifteen minutes of video of one of Chris Blea's classes today, and saw.... everything and nothing, in a way I will try to articulate.  First of all, technically it was fine, which was good to know, and skimming through the video it very much appears to be a high-discourse classroom, so there is a good hope of actually getting to see students discussing their ideas together during this session.  If that is the case, it'll be a first for this project, and a big score.

In the fifteen minutes that we watched at normal speed (neither skimming nor analyzing), the students talk about the camera.  A lot.  "The camera!  The camera!  We're on TV!  Remember that permission slip we signed, that's for the class that she is taking!  I want to be on TV!"  They look up at the camera, they do little dance moves, etc.  Chris starts class by saying, "Today we are going to finish up this activity.  We are going to do part 2.  Homework is your conclusion paragraph.  Reread part 2 of the lab to begin."  It's all procedural; I don't remember her even saying anything about what topic it is.  They open their lab books, but the ones on camera don't really read.  More camera antics (but quieter ones).  Chris, for the next several minutes, keeps up a fairly continual patter of, "So guys, right now you are reading the lab.  You are rereading the lab.  You are trying to figure out what we're doing.  You are not talking."  Myself, I would find it hard to read with her talking, but I don't know what it takes to hold together a room of 6th graders so I am not one to judge.

The fact that they attend to the camera for so very long is a drag on the one hand, because I'm sorry to have disrupted Chris's class.  On the other hand, though, camera effects are something about which I have a theoretical perspective.  My perspective (and I think I have references for this? better check) is that people stop attending to the camera when they have something more interesting to do.  Conversely, if they keep attending to the camera, they don't have anything more interesting to do.  Thus, the activity Chris is trying to start is not interesting to them.  Chris's reiterating "You are reading the lab, you are not talking," seems to me to be additional evidence for this; they must be pretty easily diverted from the desired activity, or she wouldn't have to harp at them constantly to keep doing it.

Benedikt, Hunter, and I tried to put our finger on what the problem is with the activity that Chris is presenting, such that the students are almost aggressively not interested.  We thought of a lot of things that we're not sure answer the question, such as:  The instructions are all procedural, "read this page"; there is little sense of purpose.  The activity is presented as very literal, with no invitation to use your imagination.  The instructor is talking kind of like a robot rather than showing personal enthusiasm for the topic.

Trying to bring (my understanding of) a Rogerian perspective to the analysis, I remembered that one of the key relational issues is:  As human beings we seem to need to know where the other person is coming from.  We (clients, students) need people in helping relationships (therapists, teachers) to be genuine and transparent, or we get anxious.  If we don't know who we are talking to, we don't want to reveal ourselves.  We'd rather leave, actually, or if we can't leave, we opt out in some other way.  So is Chris not being "genuine"?  After some discussion we decided that Chris is not really being Chris, here, not being her unique Chris self; instead, she is being a local representative of some remote authoritarian voice.  "Now You Will Read."  It may as well be over the public address system.  The person in the room (Chris) is not the entity that is addressing us.  That entity is remote and invisible, and actually so is Chris.  So, in a Rogerian sense, no wonder the students are opting out.  The whole thing is very dislocated.

To regain the students' attention, in this perspective, one would need to be present in the room, as oneself.  And one would need to address the students out of that presence, and also be addressing the students as unique people who are in the room with you, rather than as representatives of Studenthood.  There would need to be what I'm going to call a relational discourse, where the relation is between the unique teacher-person and the unique student-person, in that present moment.  I realize I sound very new agey.  I think I am stuck with it.

The idea of "relational discourse" seems to me to be totally critical to formative assessment, especially the kind of moment-to-moment formative assessment that I'm looking for (but rarely finding) in short bursts of video.  The only way you're going to get information about the students you're interacting with is if they are willing to share themselves with you.  If we are with Rogers, then they are going to share with you best when you are at your most genuine and transparent, when you yourself are most immediately present with them.  Then on top of that you need to have the other things that Rogers cites as key to a helping relationship: warmth (unconditional positive regard) and empathy (seeing things through their eyes).  


The usual definition of FA is something like "using evidence about students' understanding to make informed decisions about the next step or steps in instruction."  Using that definition to spot FA, you have to do this multistep analysis:  Did the teacher elicit student ideas?  Was the teacher informed by hearing the student ideas?  Did the teacher put those student ideas to use in an instructional decision?  It feels very intellectualized.  Relational discourse, on the other hand, feels like the sort of thing that we as human beings are very attuned to, and that makes it potentially a very useful concept.  If I can hook my FA-episode-selection-process to something I'm humanly attuned to, I'm going to be better at spotting relevant episodes.  


(I think attunement in general is extremely important for qualitative analysis in general, because there is just so much data and it's so overwhelmingly rich, you need the help of your instincts to spot the good stuff.  We should take every opportunity to harness our selective attention to our holistic sense of what's what.)

E2 Refrigerator Energy Theater

Benedikt and Hunter and I spent some time with two minutes of Energy Theater video today, in which the E2 people did ET for a refrigerator.   This ET session came after about ten hours of discussion spread over three days, and was pretty much the conclusion of their study of refrigerators.  The video below is of their first walk-through.


Three objects in the scenario are denoted with string loops:  the food, the coolant, and the electrical outlet.  The surrounding environment (say, the kitchen) is understood to be outside the loops.  Thermal energy people fan themselves, people with their arms circled over their heads are "phase energy" (which is the kind of energy that gases have more of than liquids), and people with twinkle hands are electrical energy.  The coolant that is represented here is not all of the coolant at once; instead, it is a packet of coolant that moves around the coolant-circuit as the action proceeds.

We are still figuring out the significance of what all they do.  Why do some of the phase-energy people walk down the stairs when the electrical-energy people enter the coolant (i.e., when the coolant-packet is in the condenser)?  Is it significant that the thermal-energy people that go out into the room when the coolant is in the condenser are the same people that were originally in the food?  Did they skip the evaporator at the end?  Plus there is a lot of lovely interactional stuff we barely touched on, like:  When are people taking direction from Matt and when are they acting independently?  Which people know what's going on?  When do people drop their arms?  When does Matt consult the white board?  What is Lisa's contribution?  What is Hunter's role?

This is all about stuff that happens during this short episode, which is natural for me since that's all I've seen.  Hunter and Benedikt have more of a sense of the conceptual development that happened over days, and have posted thoughts about that on their own blogs.