Friday, August 16, 2013

Drawing IS Writing


These clips show moments in the class that Katie and I were very excited by when they were occurring, and both marked with so many flags that when Brad started talking, I accidentally wrote Blag and we both contracted a nearly terminal case of the giggles.

But--I'm not sure they're exciting as episodes per se--I don't know that I could really say "something interesting HAPPENED". I think they are exciting because the *ideas* that the teachers are communicating are exciting to us! I see these clips as showing us not the process of learning, but a demonstration of some of the learning that has occurred over the past several weeks.

It seems to me that the teachers are expressing that writing is not the only way, or even the best way, to represent an abstract idea. Akbar points out that drawing using symbols but so does writing, "so in a way, drawing IS writing." Julie takes it even further: "Drawing is even MORE abstract" and less prone to "BS-ing" using what Brad calls "the conventions of writing". I don't think it's a stretch to say that these views may have been influenced by the teachers' participation in energy theater, which uses ways other than written language to communicate ideas about abstraction. I also have felt the importance of escaping the "conventions of written language" over the past two weeks--I can see how when my students use words like "respiration" and "metabolism", it is too easy to assume that they mean what I mean when I use those words. Having students represent their ideas in other ways might give me--and them--a better insight into what they are truly thinking. This is a very powerful idea that *I* have learned over the past few weeks!

Transcripts
Clip #1
Akbar: With drawing, when you're learning something it's easier to see it...You see it here (gestures out, as if to a piece of paper) and then you see it here (gestures in). And then you're able to draw what you see. It's easier to see it than say it. And so writing is like saying it, and drawing is like seeing it. So sometimes it's easier to see it.(continues gestures) And then once you see it very well, now it's easier to say it.  Drawing is a good segue into writing, like a first line of defense, or first thing to do. Like BOOM--ok, I'm going to gather what I'm seeing in my mind's eye. And then from here, now, if you're able to talk about it...then it would be easier to put it into writing.  Drawing is real good tool...A lot of times kids are fearful of writing...say they may have language barriers or other things, and they may not have the right words to say it, or the appropriate words.  But drawing is almost universal, there's not like a Somalian eye or a Russian eye; we all see!

Clip #2
Akbar: So in drawing, basically, you use symbols, and in writing you use symbols, so in essence, so drawing IS writing.

Julie: ...more abstract way. I think as teachers...I think *I* have viewed kids drawing as sort of a cop out - they don't want to write. And somehow we think drawing is less academic, but in fact it really is MORE abstract...than BSing their way through...

Brad: There are fewer conventions in drawing. A lot of times kids have trouble writing because they have difficulty with all the conventions of writing, not the articulation of ideas in a cohesive fashion. And so it can be a cop-out--just like writing can be a cop-out. If you know the conventions, you can bullshit your way through something. Versus...you could cop out of a drawing as well, but the conventions of drawing, particularly when you're not given any requirements...it's just so raw that it frees you up to try things...I already have the vision, I just wanna get that vision out...F


Debra: The assessment of what they know is crippled by how they write. I'm assessing their thinking, not their writing. So to me...if you can draw it, and tell me about it, then I know you know it.


Thursday, August 15, 2013

Boring: see civil engineers

Today, Stamatis brought up Count Rumford's experiment, which is often pointed out as empirical evidence that the caloric theory of heat (heat as a conserved sunstance-like quantity) was wrong. Rumford argued that you appear to be able to generate an infinite amount of heat by boring a hole in an object. Therefore heat cannot be a finite substance-like thing that is stored in objects. The competing theory was that heat is a kind of motion, which later was incorporated into thermodynamics.

Well, this reminded me of the classic UK yellow pages entry in the 90's: "Boring: see civil engineers":

http://www.apnewsarchive.com/1996/Civil-Engineers-No-Longer-Boring-Yellow-Pages-Says-So/id-fbef506d8ad666d913ccdd5588c7e698

ATP: An electrical impulse thing and a little zap

This is more on the theme of “getting hot while dropping your balls.”  As a refresher, in E1 on Monday morning (8/12/13), the class began the day by drawing diagrams for the two scenarios considered the previous Friday: raising a bowling ball at constant velocity and lowering the ball at constant velocity.  The group I am considering in this episode is: Jeff (in blue), John, Sara (in green), and Emma.  In the first half hour of class, they drew a diagram representing the energy theater.

Their diagram includes instances of chemical energy converting to thermal energy, and they recognize this as a process that includes ATP, but they do not know how to account for it.  Now that they have finished, Adam comes to the table to check on them and see how they are doing.  What follows is a discussion regarding what they think about the scenarios they have just looked at. 


I love that each member of the group had a chance to weigh in on the matter, even Sara who is typically rather quiet.  To each of them, the processes involved in going from chemical energy (ATP) to muscle movement to thermal energy, are a mystery, and each of them has a different way of expressing their befuddlement.  Jeff at 0:13 says “I need to scratch my head and go wow.”  John, at 1:13, adds “It gets super fancy, which I don’t even want to get into.”  Even one of the instructors, Adam, can’t hold back his relationship with biology at 1:25.  “I’m a physics guy, so when I hear ATP I kind go…” and he apparently makes a face or a twitch or something. 

At 2:14, Sara enters in and continues off of John’s wonderment at “an electrical impulse thing” and “a little zap that we’re not accounting for.”  She wants to keep separate the energy story and the processes of ATP.  “The electrical is part of the chemical.”  She sees that for kids, it wouldn't make sense to have chemical go to electrical and so on.  Emma fleshes this out with a long montage of chemical to electrical to new chemical to new electrical.  Without even knowing the exact process, she sees the weaving that might happen.  “Having a separate story, I think, is a good thing,” she adds at the end.

Finally, at 2:54 Sara suggests, “I don’t think understanding this way is a misconception.”  This is an interesting way to phrase her idea.  I wonder how she thinks of physics and biology misconceptions.  Beyond that, what is clear to me here is that all four teachers agree that energy theater shouldn't (and maybe even can’t) address all of the steps that may exist as chemical energy transforms to thermal. 

“If you don’t understand where the energy comes from, call it chemical.”  This is quite common in physics.  I certainly do this in my classes with the simple examples I use that might need such a designation, such as a car driving or a person pushing an object.  Honestly, I've rarely made an attempt to develop a picture that is deeper than this.  It is fascinating to watch a group of people attempt to dig at this deeper picture and essentially come up baffled and prepared to stick with “chemical to thermal, let’s move on.”  I wonder if this might be a valuable class exercise for my students.  Let them struggle to build a more complex picture, to give them a greater appreciation for hiding some details in their energy representation.


Full video: E1 130812 0814 T6-1

Debunking the assumption that "giving students the right answer shuts them down."

I am particularly interested in what happens when an instructor gives the participants "the right answer" and the participants recognize that this is happening.  I became interested (last summer) for two reasons:
  1. I noticed that sometimes 'getting the right answer' promotes really productive conversations, whereas I think our community often assumes that 'getting the right answer' will shut students down.
  2. I noticed that in cases in which 'getting the right answer' seems to shut participants down, I can look at the situation and see clues about why that might have happened.  (For example, participants communicate the expectation that the answer should be simple, whereas the answer is actually quite complex and/or takes a long time to communicate.)
Someone (Stamatis?) mentioned to me that Rachel had given a 'mini-lecture' in E2 and that they had caught an interesting conversation about Julie's experience of the lecture on tape.  So I clipped it!

Context: The first clip below shows the moment that the participants communicated to Rachel that they wanted an answer:


Teacher (in background): [Can you say if gravity is different than pressure?]
Rachel: Yes, gravity is different than pressure.
Teacher: Gravity is different from pressure, okay.
Rachel: Yes, Deb.
Debra: Would this be a time where you might just say, 'Okay, in the scientific community, this is what blah blah blah.'
Rachel (laughing): Debra is making a suggestion [...].
Debra: Can we just get the answer, yeah. (laughter)

I'm actually not sure which question they are asking Rachel to answer, but, for the next 10-15 minutes, Rachel shares her answer to this question and others that teachers ask intermittently throughout.

My best reconstruction is that the teachers have just done 'particle theater' (like energy theater, but tracking the matter through the system, rather than the energy) for the 'two-piston scenario.'  In this scenario, there are two equal-temperature (equal-N) pistons of gas side by side.  The gas in one of the pistons has been compressed more than the other.  In past iterations of this scenario, the participants have been asked which of the pistons will push a block further when released.  (Abby or E2 folks, am I getting this right?)

Rachel begins her lecture by discussing whether or not there is potential energy in the gas (that is inside the compressed pistons).  She says that if there were PE in the gas, it might be like particles 'squishing' when they bump into one another (in particle theater).  She says that she was raised to believe that the atoms of a (ideal) gas in fact are not squishy, although she acknowledges that if they were talking about a real gas, things would be different.

She goes on to say that another thing she was raised to believe is that gas particles are mostly in empty space, so that most of what happens is free travel between the walls of the container (as opposed to many collisions between gas particles).  In the smaller (more compressed) container, the number of collisions increases, and we (not sure if she means the teachers or the scientific community) conceptualized that as pressure.  She explains that each "bonk" exerts a push, and pressure is more like a push than an energy, even though pressure and energy are not unrelated.  She says that pressure hasn't been represented in either particle or energy theater.

Mary then interjects a question: If you were trying to show the difference between the more-compressed and less-compressed pistons in energy theater, would the difference be in the rate of transfer of energy?  Rachel responds that she thinks the difference would be in amount transferred, rather than how fast the transfer happened.  She says she'll have to think about the rate thing, but she's not ready to do that on her feet.  She draws the ETD below (including only air in chamber, piston, and block boxes), explaining her thinking as she goes:


She tells the teachers that there are the same number of Ts in the gas in the less- and more-compressed cases.  The Ts transform into Ks in the piston and are then transferred to the block.  In the more-compressed case, more Ts transform to Ks.  This accounts for it getting colder in the more-compressed case.  She states that this explanation does not account for the springiness in the two pistons, and it would need to.

Rachel also shares the reason that the instructors gave them this scenario: the two pistons are similar in many ways -- they have the same amount of energy to start -- but one transfers a lot of its energy.  In life, we want to move the block more, and the instructors would like the participants to be able to understand what it is about a scenario that gives us the opportunity to move the block more.  Rachel ends by saying that she feels "completely nude" because she gave them a ton of answers as well as the instructors' reason for asking them to think about this scenario.

Debra then requests that Rachel add the hand and the piston to her diagram for the more-compressed scenario.  (You can see that she does in the picture above.)  Rachel begins to talk through what this adds: There are Cs in the hand, Ks in the hand, Ks in the piston, etc.  Debra asks Rachel if the same number of Ks go into the piston for both the less- and more-compressed cases.  Rachel points out that she has to leave time for the system to come to equilibrium, since the hand that compresses the piston more is going to add more Ts, whereas Rachel has said that both pistons start with the same number of Ts.  (So she has to wait for the excess Ts to leave the system.)  Debra responds that this is confusing, and Rachel agrees.  They briefly discuss whether the Ts that are in the gas/air come from (did all of them come from the hand, or were some already in the gas?). 

Rachel instructs them to write in their notebooks silently for ten minutes.  The clip below starts just after this writing time.  Rachel approaches the table with (CCW from right) Julie, Don, Gail, and Jean.  Rachel sheepishly admits that she's not used to giving away answers, Julie responds by saying that she wasn't paying attention, Rachel leaves the table, and Julie and Don discuss the scenario in more depth.  Watch and enjoy!

Participants' response to 'getting the right answer':


Rachel: I never did that before [...].
(Julie laughs.)
Julie: What, just said straight out?
Rachel: Yeah.
Julie: You know what's funny is that I actually, my brain sort of turned off.  Which is probably why we say that's what we want but we don't actually want that.
Rachel: Mmhm.
Julie: Cause then I was like, 'Well, I don't agree with that cause we just did all this.'  And so what?  It doesn't have any meaning for me.
Rachel: Yeah.
Julie: And so I'm glad that...
Rachel: And [meanwhile] I just stand up there and you guys are like (stares off).
Julie: (Making noise and pretending to write something down.)  Yeah, writing it all down.  Totally.
Rachel laughs.
Rachel: Sorry [...] (walks away)
Don: For me, when she, see I needed to see those Ts go over, and once those Ts went over, and I saw that the energy was the same, then I started writing, cause that was the piece that I wasn't getting.
Julie: Wait, say, I'm...
Don: Well, do you see how there's 5 Ts in both.  See, the energy is the same in both of those...
Julie:...I agree...
Don:...The thermal energy is the same whether it's compressed or not, and that's what these guys were saying at the very beginning, and I wasn't agreein' with it.  And so as soon as we saw that transfer, and there was more energy was transferred...
Julie:...Oh I see, I see...
Don:...Then I was able to start to put this thing together.
Julie: And what was your, what's your thinking as to why more energy transferred?
Don: Why did more energy transfer? (Pause) Huh! (Laughs)
Julie: Right?
Don: Why did more energy transfer?
Julie: And then that's when we get confused with the force story because we say, "Pressure!"
Don: Yeah.
Julie: And pressure is a force and we can't say it.
Don: Right.  The reason why more energy transferred is more energy was put into it by the hand to begin with.
Julie: But we just said there's five Ts in both.
Don: Right.  You're right.  Never mind.
Julie laughs.
Julie: Do you see what I'm sayin'?  We still don't know.
Don: I know.  Then you get to that point when you can't. 
Julie: Yeah.
Don: It's like what do you do with it?
Julie: Right.
Don: Then you have to bring in particle theory.
Julie: Right, cause we both, we both got to a place where we can say, 'In the more compressed, more thermal is converted to movement, kinetic.'
Don: Mmhm.
Julie: And then we're good.  But then if we actually take that a step...
Don:...Yeah...
Julie:...Deeper.
Don: What causes the transfer?...
Julie:...Right...
Don: ...The number of hits per unit of time?
Julie: Right, which we don't even know what that really mean.  I mean, it doesn't mean a whole lot yet.
Don: Yeah, it's just like the drummer.  (Hits the table quickly, makes high-frequency noise:) Brrrrrr. Versus boink, boink, boink (hits table more slowly).
Julie: Except we said instead of it going boink, boink, boink, boink (hits table slowly, same-strength hits), it was actually like (hits table at different frequencies with different strengths).
Don: Yeah, all sorts of different random. 
Julie: Yeah, right.
Don: But if you look at it as a whole, it's more.
Julie: The take-away for me, it's mind-blowing to think that the speed didn't, that the change in speed wasn't necessarily directly related to the pressure component.  That it was more about collisions than it was, directly speaking.
Don: Mmhm.
Julie: There had to be like that half-step in between, you know?
Don: Yeah because we saw that the speed was the same in both of these, it wasn't about the speed, it was just the number of, more collisions more frequently.

What I see in this video: My interpretation of what is happening in this video is that:
  1. Julie says she immediately tuned out when Rachel started giving her answer.  She attributes this to her disagreeing with Rachel's answer in light of her own thinking, so that Rachel's answer "didn't have any meaning for her."  I'm not sure whether she means that Rachel was answering a question that she did not have, whether she disagreed with Rachel's answer (and thus did not value it, although this doesn't seem right to me knowing Julie), or if she could not connect Rachel's answer to her own and so lost interest. 
  2. Don, on the other hand, says that Rachel's answer responded to a 'need' that he had.  He says that (part of) Rachel's answer matched what another group said that he originally disagreed with.  It's not clear to me whether Rachel's authority convinced him, or whether she filled in a missing piece for him that made the other group's answer sensible.  (I'd guess the latter, because he points to a specific piece of Rachel's explanation that helped him to "put this thing together.")
  3. Julie then asks Don a question about mechanism -- why does more energy transfer?  I LOVE Don's response.  His tone and facial expression when he says "Huh!" suggest to me that he is amused that he thought he got it but now recognizes that there is more for him to understand.  Julie and Don then engage in a beautiful discussion about why the more-compressed case transfers more energy.  Although they hedge a lot, their answer is mechanistic and thoughtfully negotiated: there are more collisions in the more-compressed case than in the less-compressed case.  I see so much physics in what they say: they negotiate that it can't be speed of the particles, since the two gases are the same temperature, so it must be the frequency; they use their fists to communicate how the strength and frequency of the collisions is different in the more- and less-compressed gases, and Julie (oh, Julie!) points to a distribution of strengths (speeds) and frequencies (Maxwell distribution, anyone?); and they reflect on the limits of their understanding as they go.
I can't decide whether this clip is an example of the answer 'shutting students down' or not.  On the one hand, Julie admits that she stopped listening when Rachel started 'lecturing,' and Don accepted the 'answer' without pushing for mechanism.  On the other hand, Don's noticing what he learned from Rachel's answer inspired Julie's question, which began this lovely exchange.  I think this would require more careful study -- including understanding what happened around this conversation -- so I'm flagging it for future reference.

I Don't Give Any Tests

Jeff and Trevor both teach middle school and are having a conversation about the middle school, specifically 6th grade. Trevor plays with his Rubik’s Cube while talking to Jeff and he talks about fixing kids and then they go to their teachers who are fine with students memorizing. This leads into a conversation about grades

Trevor- I did not give any test this year and I taught math and science. It was not based on the correctness of their work. For me it is about motivating them to get the work done. I am rebel in that regard.



After the video Jeff starts a conversation on standards and about how large his classes are (…”I have so many kids”)

T- my honors kids want to please.. They are tied to their grades. If I say you are not really giving me what I need…. The honors kids want to satisfy.  He talks about his substitute assignments and how much the kids like them because the plan is clear.


I just thought this was an interesting clip that showcased two teachers talking informally about how they grade and what they value in terms of how and why they grade.

Energy in AP Bio Curriculum Framework

This is a resource post for anyone interested in the new AP Biology curriculum framework and how it talks about energy. I just went through the document and copy-n-pasted almost all the references to energy. (I tried to delete exact duplicates.) Maybe this can help us understand what "free energy" means to the College Board, and if there are other kinds of energy besides free energy that are important to understand in the context of AP Biology.

Other intriguing terms I see here are: entropy; energy-capturing process; energy availability; high energy electrons; metabolic fitness; and metabolic strategies. I would guess that the average--or even above-average--AP Biology teacher might struggle to define or give examples of some of these concepts. I would bet there might be a market for professional development on understanding and teaching these ideas.

The formatting has been completely lost (note the use of passive voice and third person to obscure agency here), so the hierarchy of Big Ideas, Enduring Whatsits, and Essential Doodads might be somewhat unclear.  You can always refer to the original document here.

Big Idea 2: Biological systems utilize free energy and molecular building blocks to grow, to reproduce and to maintain dynamic homeostasis.
Living systems require free energy and matter to maintain order, grow and reproduce. Organisms employ various strategies to capture, use and store free energy and other vital resources. Energy deficiencies are not only detrimental to individual organisms; they also can cause disruptions at the population and ecosystem levels.
Autotrophic cells capture free energy through photosynthesis and chemosynthesis. Photosynthesis traps free energy present in sunlight that, in turn, is used to produce carbohydrates from carbon dioxide. Chemosynthesis captures energy present in inorganic chemicals. Cellular respiration and fermentation harvest free energy from sugars to produce free energy carriers, including ATP. The free energy available in sugars drives metabolic pathways in cells. Photosynthesis and respiration are interdependent processes.

Enduring understanding 2.A: Growth, reproduction and maintenance of the organization of living systems require free energy and matter.
Living systems require energy to maintain order, grow and reproduce. In accordance with the laws of thermodynamics, to offset entropy, energy input must exceed energy lost from and used by an organism to maintain order. Organisms use various energy-related strategies to survive; strategies include different metabolic rates, physiological changes, and variations in reproductive and offspring-raising strategies. Not only can energy deficiencies be detrimental to individual organisms, but changes in free energy availability also can affect population size and cause disruptions at the ecosystem level.
Several means to capture, use and store free energy have evolved in organisms. Cells can capture free energy through photosynthesis and chemosynthesis. Autotrophs capture free energy from the environment, including energy present in sunlight and chemical sources, whereas heterotrophs harvest free energy from carbon compounds produced by other organisms. Through a series of coordinated reaction pathways, photosynthesis traps free energy in sunlight that, in turn, is used to produce carbohydrates from carbon dioxide and water. Cellular respiration and fermentation use free energy available from sugars and from interconnected, multistep pathways (i.e., glycolysis, the Krebs cycle and the electron transport chain) to phosphorylate ADP, producing the most common energy carrier, ATP. The free energy available in sugars can be used to drive metabolic pathways vital to cell processes. The processes of photosynthesis and cellular respiration are interdependent in their reactants and products.

Essential knowledge 2.A.1: All living systems require constant input of free energy.
1. Order is maintained by constant free energy input into the system.
2. Loss of order or free energy flow results in death.
3. Increased disorder and entropy are offset by biological processes that maintain or increase order.

Living systems do not violate the second law of thermodynamics, which states that entropy increases over time.
1. Order is maintained by coupling cellular processes that increase entropy (and so have negative changes in free energy) with those that decrease entropy (and so have positive changes in free energy).
2. Energy input must exceed free energy lost to entropy to maintain order and power cellular processes.
3. Energetically favorable exergonic reactions, such as ATP→ADP, that have a negative change in free energy can be used to maintain or increase order in a system by being coupled with reactions that have a positive free energy change.
Energy-related pathways in biological systems are sequential and may be entered at multiple points in the pathway. • Krebs cycle • Glycolysis • Calvin cycle • Fermentation

d. Organisms use free energy to maintain organization, grow and reproduce.
1. Organisms use various strategies to regulate body temperature and metabolism.
• Endothermy (the use of thermal energy generated by metabolism to maintain homeostatic body temperatures)
• Ectothermy (the use of external thermal energy to help regulate and maintain body temperature)
• Elevated floral temperatures in some plant species
2. Reproduction and rearing of offspring require free energy beyond that used for maintenance and growth. Different organisms use various reproductive strategies in response to energy availability.
• Seasonal reproduction in animals and plants
• Life-history strategy (biennial plants, reproductive diapause)
3. There is a relationship between metabolic rate per unit body mass and the size of multicellular organisms — generally, the smaller the organism, the higher the metabolic rate.
4. Excess acquired free energy versus required free energy expenditure results in energy storage or growth.
5. Insufficient acquired free energy versus required free energy expenditure results in loss of mass and, ultimately, the death of an organism.
Changes in free energy availability can result in changes in population size.
Changes in free energy availability can result in disruptions to an ecosystem.
• Change in the producer level can affect the number and size of other trophic levels.
• Change in energy resources levels such as sunlight can affect the number and size of the trophic levels.

Essential knowledge 2.A.2: Organisms capture and store free energy for use in biological processes.
a. Autotrophs capture free energy from physical sources in the environment.
1. Photosynthetic organisms capture free energy present in sunlight.
2. Chemosynthetic organisms capture free energy from small inorganic molecules present in their environment, and this process can occur in the absence of oxygen.

b. Heterotrophs capture free energy present in carbon compounds produced by other organisms.
1. Heterotrophs may metabolize carbohydrates, lipids and proteins by hydrolysis as sources of free energy.
2. Fermentation produces organic molecules, including alcohol and lactic acid, and it occurs in the absence of oxygen.

c. Different energy-capturing processes use different types of electron acceptors.
• NADP+ in photosynthesis • Oxygen in cellular respiration

d. The light-dependent reactions of photosynthesis in eukaryotes involve a series of coordinated reaction pathways that capture free energy present in light to yield ATP and NADPH, which power the production of organic molecules.
1. During photosynthesis, chlorophylls absorb free energy from light, boosting electrons to a higher energy level in Photosystems I and II.
2. Photosystems I and II are embedded in the internal membranes of chloroplasts (thylakoids) and are connected by the transfer of higher free energy electrons through an electron transport chain (ETC).
3. When electrons are transferred between molecules in a sequence of reactions as they pass through the ETC, an electrochemical gradient of hydrogen ions (protons) across the thykaloid membrane is established.
4. The formation of the proton gradient is a separate process, but it is linked to the synthesis of ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate via ATP synthase.
5. The energy captured in the light reactions as ATP and NADPH powers the production of carbohydrates from carbon dioxide in the Calvin cycle, which occurs in the stroma of the chloroplast.

f. Cellular respiration in eukaryotes involves a series of coordinated enzyme-catalyzed reactions that harvest free energy from simple carbohydrates.
1. Glycolysis rearranges the bonds in glucose molecules, releasing free energy to form ATP from ADP and inorganic phosphate, and resulting in the production of pyruvate.

g. The electron transport chain captures free energy from electrons in a series of coupled reactions that establish an electrochemical gradient across membranes.

h. Free energy becomes available for metabolism by the conversion of ATP→ADP, which is coupled to many steps in metabolic pathways.

Passive transport does not require the input of metabolic energy because spontaneous movement of molecules occurs from high to low concentrations; examples of passive transport are osmosis, diffusion, and facilitated diffusion. Active transport requires metabolic energy and transport proteins to move molecules from low to high concentrations across a membrane. 

Translation involves energy and many steps, including initiation, elongation and termination.

Some genes are continually expressed, while the expression of most is regulated; regulation allows more efficient energy utilization, resulting in increased metabolic fitness.

Matter, but not energy, can be recycled within an ecosystem via biogeochemical cycles. Energy flows through the system and can be converted from one type to another, e.g., energy available
in sunlight is converted to chemical bond energy via photosynthesis.

Mitochondria specialize in energy capture and transformation. 

Chloroplasts are specialized organelles found in algae and higher plants that capture energy through photosynthesis. The structure and function relationship in the chloroplast allows cells to capture the energy available in sunlight and convert it to chemical bond energy via photosynthesis.

Energy flows, but matter is recycled.

Many adaptations of organisms are related to obtaining and using energy and matter in a particular environment.

Cooperation within organisms increases efficiency in the use of matter and energy.

Essential knowledge 4.B.2: Cooperative interactions within organisms promote efficiency in the use of energy and matter.

Organisms have areas or compartments that perform a subset of functions related to energy and matter, and these parts contribute to the whole.

Interactions among cells of a population of unicellular organisms can be similar to those of multicellular organisms, and these interactions lead to increased efficiency and utilization of energy and matter.

Energy in the Science Practices

The student is able to measure and collect experimental data with respect to volume, size, mass, temperature, pH, etc. In addition, the student can estimate energy procurement and utilization in biological systems, including ecosystems.

The student draws on information from other sciences to explain biological processes; examples include how the conservation of energy affects biological systems; 

Energy in sample test questions:

11. Which of the following statements most directly supports the claim that different species of organisms use different metabolic strategies to meet their energy requirements for growth, reproduction, and homeostasis?
(A) During cold periods pond-dwelling animals can increase the number of unsaturated fatty acids in their cell membranes while some plants make antifreeze proteins to prevent ice crystal formation in tissues.
(B) Bacteria lack introns while many eukaryotic genes contain many of these intervening sequences.
(C) Carnivores have more teeth that are specialized for ripping food while herbivores have more teeth that are specialized for grinding food.
(D) Plants generally use starch molecules for storage while animals use glycogen and fats for storage.

16. Additional observations were made on day 21, and no yellow-leaved seedlings were found alive in either dish. This is most likely because
(A) yellow-leaved seedlings were unable to absorb water from the paper towels
(B) taller green-leaved seedlings blocked the light and prevented photosynthesis
(C) yellow-leaved seedlings were unable to convert light energy to chemical energy
(D) a higher rate of respiration in yellow-leaved seedlings depleted their stored nutrients

29. Experimental evidence shows that the process of glycolysis is present and virtually identical in organisms from all three domains, Archaea, Bacteria, and Eukarya. Which of the following hypotheses could be best supported by this evidence?
(A) All organisms carry out glycolysis in mitochondria.
(B) Glycolysis is a universal energy-releasing process and therefore suggests a common ancestor for all forms of life.
(C) Across the three domains, all organisms depend solely on the process of anaerobic respiration for ATP production.
(D) The presence of glycolysis as an energy-releasing process in all organisms suggests that convergent evolution occurred.


Teachers Discuss Workshop Pedagogy



Participants Recognize Characteristics of the Learning Style  (Video: E1 130808  822 T7)

This is a series of sequential clips showing a conversation between four teachers in response to the following prompt placed on the overhead by Lane and Adam

Task shown on the screen:

Consider the following two approaches to science instruction:
1. Students bring a wide array of misconceptions to their science classrooms.  We need to provide opportunities for them to work through these misconceptions so that they do not interfere with their understanding of science concepts.

2. Students bring a wide array of ideas and experiences to their science classrooms.  We need to help them use these ideas and experiences to construct and test meaningful scientific models.  

What are the strengths and limitations of each approach to science instruction.  How would the two approaches influence the moment by moment decisions of a science teacher?

How have these two approaches been apparent within this workshop thus far?

The participants are talking about these questions and discussing what has been explicit and not explicit to them during this class.

In the first segment, Tanya, Jeff, and Mike sit at the table and Mike and Jeff converse about how the class has been going

Mike comments on the slowness of the class, which to him can be good and frustrating.  Jeff is still struggling with the difference between giving an opportunity or helping them use what we know.

He does cite specific evidence that Lane used practice #1 (Students bring a wide array of misconceptions to their science classrooms.  We need to provide opportunities for them to work through these misconceptions so that they do not interfere with their understanding of science concepts.) in class the day before by providing an additional scenario.


The second segment follows the first segment directly and Mike says because we are all teachers and good at using the scientific method we have all done it before…… it is all guided by questions like “how do you want to figure it out versus how do you need to”.




In the third segment, Tanya and Cynthia join the conversation.  Tanya talks about deconstructing and reconstructing understanding. She explicitly states that Lane has been able to  listen to the students and when he heard something that had a chance to grow, he asked questions to lead them and then brought in a new object so they could have new understanding. She acknowledges that even she has to do that.   Tanya continues to articulate the value of this model.  Cynthia adds that Lane has done a number of formative assessments and that Lane was able to make critical decisions to push everyone’s thinking further. Teachers have to be aware.  Pulling aside this learning environment is critical piece.



What I found interesting in this video is that each person was able to articulate explicitly why the classroom was being run or managed in a specific manner. I also thought it was interesting that Tanya used the phrase "even me" when discussing learning new things and overcoming misconceptions.