Wednesday, August 21, 2013

I-RISE Congress - Lowering at a constant speed

Thank you again for such a great experience! I am sharing the slides of the congress presentation.


I am the first I-RISE Scholar coming from México. I show you where I am exactly from.

During High School, in a aptitudinal test they told me I had good aptitudes to go for a exact science carreer or for humanities. In my mind that didn't make sense, how can you mix them both? I decided to study a B.Sc. in Physics Engineering. A couple years after, I discovered there was a PER group in my University and decided to join them. It was in that moment that I realized that there was a way to mix both of my strengths, since then I decided PER is was I would do.

Basically, I started doing my fists steps in PER as an undergrad. Then I decided to go for a Ph.D. in PER, continuing working with Genaro Zavala, now as my adviser. Two summers ago Rachel went to my university for a summer workshop about video analysis. In that moment I decided that was what I wanted to do. I arrived to Seattle on April for a six month research visit to develop my qualitative research skills (my PER group do not use video analysis that much).




Due to time limitations, I could not analyze both days as I planned originally. I wanted to see what were the differences that made one day more productive than the other. Instead I decided to study in detail the second day (more productive than the first). As a clarification, E1 has already worked in ET in previous days, but not during afternoon. So it was the first time I observed them doing ET alive, but not their first time doing ET.

I share the video here, but for more detail please check the post: Forces vs Energy... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 2)
**Warning: There is wind noise in the audio**


I share the video here, but for more detail please check the post: Using ET as a reconciliation tool... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 3)
**Warning: there is also some noise in this one**





As conclusion, thank you for helping me developing my qualitative research skills. I really appreciate having a space where people get engage in this kind of discussions and gives you productive feedback to improve your opportunity areas.I am really wishing I have the opportunity to keep working with this two ET, because I felt I needed more time to finish the analysis.

Forces vs Energy... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 2)

This is the second video from my E1 Afternoon ET 08-09 saga. The group is making agreements on how to make the ET for a bowling ball being lowered at a constant speed. This video is tightly related to the first part of the saga Conceptual understanding vs Equations (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 1).

During E1 they have been talking about forces for more than one day. In this video we observe Cindy making an analogy to try to understand how to represent the opposition exerted by the hand while lowering the ball at a constant speed.

[00:00:00.00] Cindy: If I am pushing against her, all right?
So, I am pushing against her and, but you- you're, you are resisting to the point- You are resisting to the point that I can't move you.
[00:00:10.24] Cindy: Amm, is this kinetic energy?
{different voices from the group saying no}
Trevor: There's no movement
Rob: Weren't you saying (to Barbara), weren't you talking about-
Cindy: () is not moving.
Barbara: So, can I ask a question?
[00:00:17.28] Cindy: So, I am lowering a bowling ball gradually (gestures of the ball being hold by something)
Maggie: -at a constant
Cindy: -at a constant... Do I have an opposite kinetic energy -I am, I am just trying to throw this out there.
[00:00:31.14] Cindy: I don't know what's correct and what is incorrect but, could part of that chemical energy be converted into kinetic energy as well in -in the arm system?
[00:00:44.04] Rob: I was trying - I was having a hard time of exp- verbalizing that, you know? Exactly what you are saying with you resisting so the energy -kinetic energy is going downward and you are pushing back with a _force_ in the opposite direction. But the force is not the same as energy
[00:00:59.19] {different voices of the group agreeing}
Rob: And I... So the energy lose, I am not- So, you know? There is no kinetic (noise) slowing down the kinetic energy. (noise) in the opposite direction.
 Rob mentions he had problems trying to verbalize that, he might refer to the discussion presented on the first part of the saga. In this episode we observe how they realize forces and energy are different, they consider that when a force is applied in the scenario they should represent it somehow in terms of energy. They constantly talk that they are different, but still can't explain the energy story involved in the scenario given with certainty.
[Next episode of the saga: Using ET as a reconciliation tool... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 3)]

Saturday, August 17, 2013

Stirling engine ET representing energy density

In E2, 130815, Thursday AM, the teachers were asked to enact a Stirling engine in an energy theater. They had been shown the engine the previous morning and started sketching energy diagrams, but had not carried out an ET.

The engine consists of gas contained in a cylinder,separated into two compartments by a styrofoam wall. If you heat the gas in one of the compartments with a hot cup of coffee, it will expand, which moves the separating wall. The wall, in turn, is conncted to a balanced wheel with a rod, so that the wheel starts to rotate when the wall moves. Finally, the wheel is connected to a piston, which compresses the gas in the compartment that was not heated, so that the styrofoam wall returns to its starting position. This closes the cycle of the engine.

I attach the entire ET (25 minutes, three clips), since I think it gives much insight into how the groups gradually developed the idea of representing "energy density" in the form of participants' distance from each other within a particular object. The closer they are to each other, the higher the energy density. This can be compared to another representation, posted by Abby in 2011 (http://scherrenergyproject.blogspot.com/2011/08/shrinking-people-to-represent.html) of people "shrinking" vs. speading their arms, indicating the same amount of energy, but more or less useful to do work.

They enact the entire process in three steps: First, the cylinder starts go get heated, so that the engine starts to move. Then, there is the steady-state operation, where thermal energy goes to surrounding air, driven by a gradient in temperature and different thermal density at the heat source vs. heat sink. Finally, when the coffee has reached room temperature, the engine will stop and thermal energy will be evenly distributed.


 

The notion of "energy density" is found useful by the entire class, including the instructors, and this ET pair of groups is later asked to enact their ET in full class. Energy density contributes to understanding the difference in usefulness of a certain amount of energy in different circumstances.

Another thing to note: Gail is checked out most of the time.

Group 3's energy diagram:



A synthesised energy diagram, when the engine is driven by a temperature gradient between the atmosphere and a pack of ice, based on those of all groups:

Energy is money analogy

In E2, 130815, Thursday AM, they made extensive use of analogies between energy and money, when dealing with loss/waste vs. usefulness. It is different if there are 4 people with $100 each vs. 1 million people with one dollar each, with examples when the rich and poor get to interact.

Leslie came up with this idea: "It's not how lucky I am, it's where I live." In other words, what you can do with a certain amount and form of energy depends on the energy inthe surroundings.

Sture Nordholm has thought more of how to map thermodynamics to money in education:
http://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/ed074p273.

I like this analogy by Paul Atkins http://www.google.com/books?hl=sv&lr=&id=kJyXzvkXWBAC&oi=fnd&pg=PT2&dq=atkins+galileo%27s+finger&ots=Z_5l1WXMZZ&sig=Ukrtm9TUcfrbpde8uY7YbgGEeKo:
"The analogy I like to use to show the connection [between the interpretations of entropy in macroscopic thermodynamics and statistical mechanics] is that of sneezing in a busy street or in a quiet library. A sneeze is like a disorderly input of energy, very much like energy transferred as heat. It should be easy to accept that the bigger the sneeze, the greater the disorder introduced in the street or in the library. That is the fundamental reason why the ‘energy supplied as heat’ appears in the numerator of Clausius’s expression, for the greater the energy supplied as heat, the greater the increase in disorder and therefore the greater the increase in entropy. The presence of the temperature in the denominator fits with this analogy too, with its implication that for a given supply of heat, the entropy increases more if the temperature is low than if it is high. A cool object, in which there is little thermal motion, corresponds to a quiet library. A sudden sneeze will introduce a lot of disturbance, corresponding to a big rise in entropy. A hot object, in which there is a lot of thermal motion already present, corresponds to a busy street. Now a sneeze of the same size as in the library has relatively little effect, and the increase in entropy is small."

Friday, August 16, 2013

Trevor as a Case of Negotiating Science Identity

The E1 I-RISE crew has poked fun at Kara and me for our mild obsession with Trevor.  What fascinates me about Trevor is that, throughout E1, he stably positioned himself as a physics expert.  He rarely expressed interest in the thoughts of his peers or asks for help; he regularly asserted himself as an authority, explaining things to his peers or to the class; and he regularly spent breaks (or class time) talking one-on-one with Lane or Adam.  It would be fascinating to connect Trevor episodes to the literature on identity as a rich, extended case study.

I spent yesterday and today pulling a few episodes to illustrate some of Trevor's antics.  I'm not going to put these in order; instead, I'm going to organize them thematically.

These first three episodes illustrate Trevor explaining something to his peers or to the class.  I think this deserves a much more careful analysis, but, briefly, I see Trevor positioning himself as an expert by:
  • Using technical (sometimes quantitative) language (e.g., compression, tension) and referring to well-known figures in the scientific community (e.g., Richard Feynman)
  • Asserting his role as teacher-expert by moving to the center of the room when his talking, proposing a 'fun' experiment his peers can do at home, offering his solution without bidding to Cynthia, asking leading questions to his tablemates, etc.
I'd love to know if you see other bids that Trevor makes to be recognized as an expert in the videos below.

Trevor explaining to the class


Lane: What do folks think is happening at the micro level with the meter stick?
Trevor:
I know from engineering with bending, you have compression on the, the bent side, and you have the tension on the other side, so, so, you know, if you think about the molecules...
(Lane hands Trevor the meter stick, and Trevor rolls into middle of room.)
Trevor: ...on the bent side here, they have to be closer together (pause).  Because you're reducing the distance between them.  And the ones on this side have to be farther apart.  So you're sort of stretching both.  You're compressing this, and you're expanding this and both kind of want to go back, but I don't know why they want to go back. [Shrugs shoulders]
Cynthia (?): I think it's that they have been pushed opposite and so they have the potential to actually move.
Sara (?): [...] shared electrons, so they're, I mean, the meter stick is all made of wood so it's mostly carbon, so they've shared so many electrons with things around them that if you pull them apart from each other on the far side of the meter stick, they should want to go back to where their electrons are.
Trevor: Cause they're like magnetic, radio (wiggles fingers), you know, yeah.
In the background: Yeah.
Rob: The inter-molecular attractions.
Trevor: Attractions.
Rob: Too much electron sharing then you'll have combustion.  So we're not going to go there, but the inter-molecular attraction between the complex carbon molecules, organic molecules.
Trevor: So then why with clay, I don't know.
Sara (?): Because clay is not made up of carbon, so it's bonded differently.  So it's got less bonds [...]?
Margaret: Yeah, it's just [PZs?].
Rob: Less forces.
Trevor: Forces.
Sara (?): So it's got less inter-molecular attraction.  So.
Trevor: I don't know.
[Teachers talking in the background.]
Rob: Or it could have more.
Sara (?): It's got different.
Trevor: You know, we made bridges out of spaghetti, and spaghetti's [...] tension when it's not cooked, but under compression, it (snaps) like that.  And so when you try and bend it, you try and bend a piece of uncooked spaghetti, it snaps. (Lane takes meter stick back.) But if you pull equally on the ends, you, it'll hold up lots and lots of weight.
(Sara says something I can't hear.
Trevor rolls back to place.)
Trevor: [...] Property, it holds up under tension but not compression, so if you try and bend it, by compression, it snaps, right?
Lane: And that suggests to me is the difference, the molecular difference between something that wants to spring back and something that doesn't want to spring back, it must be pretty complex.  Because if cooking spaghetti changes it from, you know, from wanting to spring back to not wanting to spring back, then that tells me that I would at least have to understand what cooking spaghetti, what the molecular, you know, of cooking spaghetti is.
(Someone says something in background that I can't hear.)
Lane: Well, that's one way to do it, right.
Trevor: And I'll just throw out for, a fun experiment for you guys to make a mess in your kitchens.  When you break a piece of spaghetti, it almost always breaks into three pieces, never two.  Richard Feynman used to sit around and just break spaghetti with his frinds and like talk about why that is.  And it's very complicated to understand why that happened, but standard spaghetti, you know, just start snapping, always breaks into three.
Trevor explaining to Cynthia


Trevor: See, this is what I was trying to do.
Barbara: Call it 1, 2, 3, or A, B, C.
Trevor: That's what I was trying to do last [...].  Last time I was trying to put numbers on it.  Allright. (Barbara and Maggie are talking in the background.)
Cynthia: Because assigning numerical value becomes more confusing.
Trevor: It just helps me.
Cynthia: I, I agree.
Trevor: Well, like, so, like, if there is 1 J of kinetic energy and 10 J of magnetic energy on this ball, okay?
Cynthia: Right.
Trevor: Well, this one is going to have less magnetic energy cause it's almost to zero.  I'm gonna call this one zero.
Cynthia: Right.
Trevor: But it's gonna have almost the same amount because it really loses the most when it gets in here, right?
Cynthia: Mmhm.
Trevor: This is where the magnet really affects it.  So I said 9 J.  So this is the situation at the beginning.
Cynthia: Mmhm.
Trevor: So using that as a model, both, since this is touching these at zero, both of these are touching, these are both zero, right?
Cynthia: And then.
Trevor: And then this is out here at the 10 J mark.  Well then how many J do I have left?  I have 19, 20 total J here.
Cynthia: Right.
Trevor: And I only have 10 here.  So that must mean that this must have 10 J worth of kinetic energy.  Which is 10 times more kinetic energy than I had before.  So that's why it goes faster.
Cynthia: Right.
Trevor: In my head.
Cynthia: Yeah.  I mean, that does make sense.
Trevor: I think it makes sense to throw numbers in there sometimes.
Cynthia: Well, unless you throw numbers it's kind of this magical thing that's happening that you can't evaluate.
Trevor: And it's so hard to track which is increasing and by how much and all that stuff without numbers.
Cynthia: Right, and I think the key here is that zero value, and then you have to account for what was here to begin with and...
Trevor: Zero makes it a lot easier.
Cynthia: Yeah.
Trevor: But, I mean, if I added to all my magnetic energies.
Cynthia: Mmhm.
Trevor: If I added fifteen to all of them, it's not gonna change anything.
Cynthia: Right, it's not gonna change as long as it, you've added...
Trevor: ...to all of them.
Cynthia: ...it to all of them, right.

Trevor asking leading questions to his group


Barbara: Okay, we can talk about [h].
Maggie: Okay.
Barbara: I said it speeds up.
Trevor: Wait, hold on, did you say g, too?  Can we go back to g?
Maggie: Sure.  Okay, (reading) so based on your answers to e and f, would you say that the magnets and balls have more magnetic energy when they are tightly bonded or weakly bonded?
Barbara: I said it depends on they're talk-, this is the question I asked Adam. 
Maggie: Mmhm.
Barbara: If it's talking about this close from the magnet.
Trevor: That's, so, well distance from the magnet is, it determines both magnetic energy and how tightly bonded they are.  Would you agree with that.
Several: Mmhm.
Trevor: So (plays with experimental set-up).
Maggie: What if the mag-.
Trevor: Which ball is more tightly bonded?
Barbara: These two.
Maggie: [...]
Cynthia: The two that.
Trevor: Out of the two I'm pointing to.
Barbara: This one.
Trevor: This one.
Maggie: Yeah.
Trevor: Which one has more magnetic energy?
Barbara: That one.
Cynthia: This one.
Trevor: Okay, so the less tightly bonded one...
Cynthia: The more.
Trevor: The more, the more, the less tightly bonded is, the more magnetic energy it has.
Barbara: Thank you.
Trevor: Now that's sort of counter-intuitive, which is why they're asking the question.
Maggie: Okay, that was the problem.
Barbara: Yeah, that's not what I said.
Trevor: But you knew it. 
Barbara: Yeah.
Trevor: When I asked it that way, you had the answer!
Barbara: Yeah, but it's asking it that way.  That's what your teachers are doing, maybe in Baltimore.
Maggie: So even though it sounds counter, even though it sounds counter-intuitive, it makes sense.  Cause that was the problem I had, is I said, well, the further they are, the weaker they're bonded, and then the further they are, the more magnetic potential energy they have.
Trevor: I like [the way that sounds?].
Maggie: I teach logic, what do you want?
Trevor: QED!
Maggie: Therefore, but it didn't make sense, the more magnetic potential energy,...
Trevor: The weaker the bonds.
Maggie: The weaker the bonds, and that.
Trevor: Cause they have more POtential to release that magnetic energy.
Barbara: I wish they would stick in potential because it makes more sense when potential is in there.
Maggie: It still doesn't make sense, but that's okay.
Trevor: That still doesn't make sense?
Maggie: I don't like it any [...].  Logically, it foll-.  The logic is sound.  [What actually happens I'm not sure].  Like this last statement sounds wrong.
Trevor: What it, the more, the more, because the closer you are to something.
Maggie: Wait, hang on, hang on.  Let's change it to.
Cynthia: (Talking to herself, repeating Trevor's words:) The closer.
Maggie: I change the 'm' to 'g'.  That makes sense, the more gravitational potential energy...
Trevor: The weaker the gravity.
Maggie: Yeah, that actually makes sense.
Trevor: Between the two objects, right?  It's further away.
Maggie: That means it's higher. Okay.
Trevor: It has more potential to fall.
Maggie: It's just that magnets are a little unfamiliar to me.

Even Trevor's facial expressions when talking to his peers suggest to me that he is positioning himself as the authority:

(Play without sound)

This final episode (below) is so rich.  It shows Trevor's group members taking up his bid to be recognized as an authority and recognizing him as an expert.  This episode happens between the "Trevor explains to Cynthia" and "Trevor asks his group leading questions" clips above:


Barbara: I think I got it.  Now I'm gonna try to write it.
Maggie: Wait, say it one more time.
Barbara: Okay.
Maggie: Cause I think I was where you were yesterday.
Cynthia: Can I...
Maggie: ...Like I sort of have it but barely.
Barbara: Okay.
Cynthia: This is so complex, would it be possible to.  Barbara, would you mind if I kind of videoed and recorded this, just?
Trevor: What we're saying, you mean?
Barbara:  Not me talking.
Cynthia: Not you talking.  Okay, then I won't.
Barbara: Cause I'm not gonna say it right.
Trevor: You can videotape me talking.
Cynthia: Oh, thank you, Trevor!
Barbara: You get Trevor talking, get Trevor talking cause he'll say it right...
[Trevor says something to Maggie.]
Cynthia: This way I can prove I'm actually in a science class.
Barbara: Okay, so...
Maggie: ...So.
Barbara: Get it at 90.  So we'll say here, just for the sake of it, it has 10 J.
Maggie: 10 J.
Barbara: Of magnetic potential.
Maggie: Then you push it.
Barbara: If we push it, we give it a little...
Maggie:...a little bit of kinetic.
Barbara: Of one, and as it gets closer and closer. Here, it would just have like 2, the 1 from the push and this, this distance was equal to 9 J, cause it speeds up and pulls it.
Cynthia: But.
Barbara: And this was 1.
(Trevor starts talking to himself about his answer.)
Barbara: So here, this was 2 and then it hits it with 11.
Maggie: Okay.
Barbara: Okay, so then...
Maggie: It goes to zero.
Barbara: It goes to zero and so transfers all the 11...
Maggie: ...to here.
Barbara: This one's zero cause it's touching.  This one we're saying is 9.
Maggie: So now it has.
Barbara: I would say it's just a teeny less than 9.
Maggie: Eleven plus nine, right?
Barbara: Well, the thing is, is I think it's just eleven.  This is what I was asking Trevor, and Trevor, would you look?
Trevor: Yeah!
Barbara: It hits with 11.  This is 9 going gravitat-, I mean magnetic.
Maggie: Pointing that way.
Barbara: Potential.
Trevor: But don't, you can't think of.
(Barbara is saying something about 11.)
Cynthia: You can't give a direction.
Maggie: Ugh, I miss forces.
Barbara: You can't?
Maggie: Okay.
Trevor: No, but it's, there's this invisible...
All at the same time: Cynthia: But force wouldn't explain this.
Maggie: I know, I know, I know.
Barbara: [...] Is it taking the 9 or is it adding to it?
Trevor: Let me just say.  If this ball moves this way, 9 has to go up, because the position is what matters to magnetic energy.
Between C and M: Cynthia: That's kind of the beauty of this force, unless the polarities could magically reverse.
Maggie: Right, yeah.
Cynthia: Yeah, let's not go there.
Maggie: Yeah.
Between T and B: Trevor: If this ball moves this way, that nine can add to something else.
Barbara: Oh, okay.
Trevor: Right, but it's...
Barbara:...Okay, so the eleven transfers.
Maggie: So eleven plus nine.
Trevor: No.
Maggie: No.  (Throws head back.)
Trevor: The total energy, yes.  The total energy will be twenty.
Barbara: Yet it's.
Maggie: But then what?
Trevor: How much of it is magnetic energy, and how much is kinetic?
Maggie: Nine is magnetic.
Barbara: So eleven's kinetic.
Maggie: And eleven is kinetic.
Barbara: And.
Trevor: Right, and as it moves away, the kinetic actually goes down...
Cynthia: ...and the magnetic increases.
Trevor: Because it's escaping the magnet.  You use some of that energy up to escape the magnet.
Cynthia: Right.
Maggie: Okay.
Cynthia: But, but..
Trevor: ...But not that much...
Cynthia: ...But it's compensated...
Barbara:...All your numbers [are at the top here?]...
Cynthia:...It's compensated by that increase of magnetic, right?
(Maggie is talking to Barbara, but I cannot understand her.)
Cynthia: So in a sense, we've...
Trevor: I don't understand what you're saying.
Cynthia: If it moves further away, then the magnetic energy has increased.
Trevor: Increased.
In this episode, I see Trevor bidding to be recognized as a science expert when:
  • He offers to be video-recorded by Cynthia.
  • He talks to himself as he writes out his answer.  The three ladies at his table are talking to one another, and I interpret this to mean that they are still working their answers out.  I interpret Trevor's talking out loud to himself as he writes to indicate to these three that he has already finished his answer (and, in a sense, doesn't need their help).
  • He positions himself as the knower when he responds to Barbara's questions.
I see Trevor's group members recognizing him as a science expert when:
  • Cynthia says, "Oh, THANK YOU, Trevor!" when he offers to be video-recorded.  The way she says it comes across as submissive (?) to me, as though she is so gratified that someone as smart as Trevor would give her his attention.  (I'm exaggerating a bit to make my point.)  Cynthia goes on to say that she can use the video of Trevor talking as 'proof that she was in a science class.'
  • Barbara responds to Trevor's offer to be recorded by saying that "he will get it right," comparing his (anticipated correct) answer to hers (which she anticipates will be incorrect).
  • Barbara asks Trevor to check her reasoning as she explains it to Maggie (positioning Trevor as an expert and both herself and Maggie as learners).
I'm not sure yet how these videos might inform theory about science identity, but I think they have potential!

Teachers Struggle with Goals for Student Notebooks

On Wednesday of Week 2, Lezlie deWater gave a guest presentation on student science notebooks in the afternoon of E2. It kicked off with a book club discussion of two articles, one on Inquiry (Science, May 2011) and one on Drawing (Science, Aug 2011). During the small group discussion of the Inquiry article, Debra and Madonna (along with Jean and Wendy) in Group 2 talk about their mixed feelings on notebooks and student thinking. Leslie Atkins has joined their table and offers her opinion as well. 


For the first 40 seconds of the clip, Debra talks about feeling obligated to have students use science notebooks ("I feel like I am married to the idea that you have to have a journal") since she feels it is her responsibility to prepare them for college or industry. Madonna jumps in at 0:50 to counter Debra, saying that it is "not only the minimum here (points to notebook) but then are we pushing the minimum in terms of mental exploration (gestures to head)". Leslie interjects, saying that in her mind the important thing is for students to communicate scientific ideas to each other, not keep a perfect ledger.
Madonna then changes tack from her earlier point (caring about mental exploration) and speaks about very high achieving students she has worked with who have terrible notebooks, and how it is difficult to work with these sort of people in industry. At the end of the episode, though, Madonna acknowledges that there is a tension with the notebooks:

[00:02:14.19] Madonna: There is kind of a play of both. There is something to be said for actually physically writing stuff down, but maybe we focus to much on the production.

Debra, in response to Madonna, references Leslie, and says:

[00:02:29.02] Debra: But what I think I hear you saying is that if we can get them nailed down on the skill of thinking, of being able to communicate their thinking, then it doesn't matter what format."


In this episode, Debra and Madonna alternatively emphasize the importance of student thinking while they also express concerns about preparing students in the structures and formatting they perceive is needed for college and future careers.  The questions they are struggling with seem to be: Do we need to prepare students to do formal scientific documentation that will be expected of them later on? Will teaching students to think and communicate be sufficient for them to be able to tackle any type of scientific documentation in the future? By focusing on formal structure in the notebooks, are we masking our assessment of students' actual understanding of the physics? Are science journals/notebooks necessary and if so, what style is best for my classroom?


Assessments and LABELS

E1 130808 822 T7

Assessment

Prior to this conversation there was a discussion on assessment and how we evaluate students. Cynthia spoke of the European model of students having to articulate what they know in front of the teacher/class.




This clip spoke to some common components/issues of standards and assessment. Probably the most fascinating part of the video for me was that Cynthia was identifying kids in 5th grade as advanced and regular education.