Friday, August 9, 2013

Energy Theater: Where is the thermal energy?

On Thursday afternoon (8/8/13) in E1, the class enacted its second energy theater; this time for the mousetrap car.  In this pair of video episodes, I am showing a group that was formed by taking 2 members from each of the four tables (in Noah’s ark style?).  These clips focus on their attempts at determining where the thermal energy will be present.

In the first episode, Tanya (white blouse) is the lead voice.  “Yeah, let’s ignore the air,” is her big remark at 0:18, with immediate agreement from Maggie.  “Air is minimal, we don’t have to put it into the equation.”  The group seems to be in agreement without needing further clarification.  “It’s like a frictionless track,” she adds.  Again, the group seems okay with this, but Lane interjects, “hold on.”  As Lane attempts to draw out a more detailed description, Tanya adds more and says “it’s minimal and it won’t change a variable between our experiments and it would be very small compared to what we’re doing.”  At the end she brushes it aside with a sweep of the arm, “let’s eliminate one thing.”  Again, the group is happy; except for Jeff (blue shirt).  A long “eeeehhhh,” escapes his lips.  But at this point, they are moving on.


For the next three minutes, they discuss how to demonstrate elastic energy and how to show elastic transforming into kinetic and how that transfers from the “drive train” to the body of the car.  This video picks up as Tanya shows herself as changing from elastic to kinetic, moving to the body of the car, and then at 0:20 says “since I’m scraping against the floor, I’m done.  I’m heat.”  Finally, Jeff speaks up: “I’m going to disagree.  I think there’s a fundamental difference between the car and the hockey puck.  We have static friction and not…”  At that moment, Tanya gives a little gasp.  Jeff goes on to say “I think wind resistance is going to stop this car more than friction.” 

“But if we don’t have friction, how will it move forward?” Tanya asks.  She’s not convinced.  Jeff goes on to describe how he thinks its static friction with the floor that results in rolling and that no heat would be generated.  He ends his explanation with a satisfied clap of his hands at 1:12.  Other members of the group chime in and start asking questions, looking for further clarification.  At 1:34, Tanya begins looking around.  She goes and finds the spare rope not in use and sets it up as the air; she’s bought into the idea.

** Video should be here.  I'm having problems with errors.  
Go to folder 2013 E1 Episodes and watch "E1 130808 I think its the Air"**

I think this pair of episodes shows the power of Energy Theater.  If a group is willing to engage in open dialog, then members have a safe place to share their ideas.  Tanya made some great arguments, but there was room for Jeff to speak up as well and present what a more accurate representation. 

These episodes also represent an evolution in thinking as one moves from the idea of sliding friction to rolling.  Sliding friction is the easiest way to think of friction, and this naturally leads people to the conclusion that the floor receives the largest thermal energy piece.  But a more advanced representation demands looking at rolling and the physics at play between the ground and the tires.  Also, the possible friction in the axles was mentioned.  It was interesting to see these teachers navigate the ever expanding complexity of the problem, recognizing different components that might lead to thermal energy.  While a 100% “correct” answer is not possibly, an appreciation for the complexity is apparent.


Full video: E1 130808 1257 T7&outside-1 

Metaphor vs. literal language, "you are a pain in my neck", "I have a headache"

In E2 130808 Thursday PM, they were given a set of sentences, representing kinds of conceptual metaphors and asked to analyse what is fixed and what is moving. For instance, in "Harry's in trouble", Trouble is a fixed container/location, in which Harry happens to be located, whereas in "Harry has trouble" Harry is fixed and trouble a movable possession of his.

Group 2 are puzzled by the fact that these sentences do not come across as particularly figurative, focusing on "I have a headache". They all agree that "My head hurts" is more clearly literal, and Debra proposes that the expression "You are a pain in my neck" is a more typical metaphor.

They rightly point out that "you are a pain in my neck" does not fit with the moving/fixed scheme of the (event structure) metaphors in the given examples.

An important part of "conceptual metaphor" as a theoretical construct, developed by Lakoff and Johnson, is that our everyday thoughts and language are subconsciously grounded in metaphoral thought structures:
http://www.google.com/books?hl=sv&lr=&id=r6nOYYtxzUoC&oi=fnd&pg=PT6&dq=lakoff+johnson&ots=Llx99p9A0-&sig=GfaP-uIYp60YPGH1ejrrXVIuxxY
http://www.google.com/books?hl=sv&lr=&id=KbqxnX3_uc0C&oi=fnd&pg=PR9&dq=lakoff+johnson&ots=lfOeadbAfi&sig=pE4XoFO69qZCLE8iLopwu_Pvzps



They come back to this issue of what sentences are metaphorical vs. literal, using the headache and pain in the neck examples several times in their small group discussions, and express a bit of confusion and frustration.

 
 
Rachel joins in to clarify her view on the matter. The group thinks that "I have a headache" is literal, but Rachel counters that it is not an object that you can put in your pocket, it's an abstact state of mind.
 
Lakoff & Johnson claim that metaphorical vs. literal language is not a clear-cut dichotomy, but a gradual scale, which I think is shown in a nice way in the example sentences given here.
 

Put "...in bed" after everything, "write it down I-RISErs!"

In E2 130808 PM, they are introduced to the idea that language is full of metaphorical expressions, which do not come across as particularly figurative.

An example is "I'm in love". Love is actually an abstract state of mind, but here we talk about it as if it were a container in which I am located. We can apply the thought figure to many scenarios, including change ("I'm falling in love"), causation, etc.

They were given a set of sentences and asked to analyse what is moving and what is fixed. (In "I'm falling in love", I move and love is stationary.) However, in these sequences, they got caught by the idea of what it would be like if you put "...in bed" after each sentence, inspired by fortune cookies. Apart from being extremely hilarious, it shows how context dependent language is.

A set of perfectly innocent sentences that are given a completely new interpretation:

He went over the edge.
She entered a state of euphoria.
The clothes are somewhere between wet and dry.
I couldn't believe the students got to that idea on their own.
Sometimes students need us to push them harder.
I have a headache.
She received her bachelor's degree.

There are also some comments to us in I-RISE and reflections on what it would be like to listen to them.

 

Only Stamatis can bring cursing into class in a philosophical way....

Keepin' it Fun on Friday - A short clip to make you smile. 

Stamatis brings up a book in class on Thursday in E2 concerning the following key terms: Bullshit, chicken shit, and pig manure. I think it is interesting how unphased the teachers are here. One the overhead, a huge picture of the book title is being shown to the left.
The clip is from E2 130808 1255 T4.




E1 - Negotiation + Roles + Representations

E1 used Energy Cubes for the first time in Tuesday (first week). In table 6 (3 woman -Emma, Krista, and Barbara- and 1 man -Tracy-) there seems to be some roles involved in their dynamics. The three girls actively discuss a lot to figure out the energy in the scenario, while Tracy plays a role as a consultant for them. When they have a content question, they ask directly to Tracy to know the answer.

Ending the planning of the energy cubes


This team had a difficult time planning the cubic energy dynamics. Here we can see how both Emma (on the left) and Barbara (on the right) ask for Tracy's approval as they move in the decision making. They discuss the presence of potential energy in the scenario. They talk about potential energy being present, but is there other potential energy? They decide to left out gravitational potential energy (as consensus).
When Tracy considered what would happens if they consider it "although..." they both reject the idea to include it, they say "we are ready to move on (Barbara)" "I am not ready for that Tracy [...] I can't go there yet (Emma)".

Is he being considered as a reference in the group instead of an active member from it? He expressed the curiosity to discuss on the potential energy and how it goes to the floor. Yet when he observe the reaction he decides to abandon it, "I didn't go there" as saying he also thinks is difficult. I think Tracy is being responsive to his team situation. He has been attending to the group participation and reacting to that. He first say he dismissed it, but they he try to discuss it. At the end, after presenting his personal position he decides to not go there.

I decided to add the last seconds of this video to show how their dynamics, even after that tension with the energy cubes, still seem to be in a good environment of collaboration.

On the other hand, I am intrigued... what to they mean when they talk about potential energy? Emma talks about gravitational potential and then ask Tracy if he thinks there is other potential energy not due to gravity... I have observed potential energy being particularly difficult while doing ET. I don't know if Lane has established some rules on the use of the label potential energy.

Comparison with the other representations
They are talking to Adam (instructor) about the differences between using energy theater and Energy Cubes (EC).

At the beginning Tracy is saying things that could implement while doing Energy Theater (ET) (sitting down to have agreements on what will happen). [00:50] Barbara seems to notice a similarity, but she says for her it is not the same. According to Krista comment [1:13], she seems to connect easily what is done in ET into using cubes to explain it. [1:20] Emma "we want a diagram". They all agree the diagram is useful to make the decisions.
[1:32] Emma presents the concern that doing ET allows people who doesn't know stay in a passive role while the other do the thinking and tell you what to do. She consider that working with EC, since it is a smaller group, it involves a more active role from all of the participants and it adds more complication (since everyone is involved in the decisions]. Adam present his personal reaction to be told what to do [1:54] "I would say why?, I am the guy who push back". Emma still believe that if you don't want anyone to know you don't know it would be easy to not participate in ET. Barbara answer to that "But then when people started talking, everybody started talking".
Now I wonder... How were they acting during their ET? Is their comments related to what they experience... I would like to know if Emma actively participated during the decision making in the ET. What I liked about this video is that during the process of the EC everyone was into the analysis of what was happening, they questioned each other in every step they made for the representation. They were so meticulous and got frustrated more than once, they seemed to be very exhausted by the end of the planning (shown in this episode). I am amazed on the engagement they shown during this activity despite the frustration they got.

Thursday, August 8, 2013

Let's Keep It Simple

Context

Monday morning the E1 students went outside and were told to find some situation that had something to do with energy. They were then to come back in and draw a diagram of the situation they observed. Their directions were intentionally vague. This is the first step in the Algebra Project pedagogy. 

The Video

Table 3 struggled a bit to reach a consensus on what to chose for their scenario. Rob (man leaning on the railing) pushed several times for a simple situation. He especially wanted something that dealt with motion because he felt like he understood the energy related to motion. Here are the two times that he mentioned his desire to keep things simple
The rest of the group supported his decision to go with a simple scenario (with the possible exception of Margaret, the woman in the red shirt). 

Why is This Interesting?

I think this interaction is interesting because it suggests something about how this group is framing the task, the project, and physics in general. What I see them doing is activating a very common physics resource (I am apparently in the mood to channel the Maryland PER group today). In physics we usually try to stick to simple situations and to break things down, and make assumptions, and throw out irrelevant details. In physics, this is usually a good thing. But the issue is that most physics students don't do this. Our students tend to be interested in the fun, complicated, messy situations. This is what makes Energy Theater so great (okay, one of the things) - it allows us to talk about the messy, complicated situations of everyday life and analyze them from an energy perspective. So in some ways I think this group is doing a great job of doing physics, but it's actually not what we want them to be doing here.

The second interesting thing is the way this group is trying to position themselves. They appear to be attempting to position themselves as "knowers" or "physics experts" instead of as "learners". Rob admits that he doesn't feel comfortable with the basics of physics. Therefore he wants to chose a situation he feels comfortable with. I find it interesting that he wants to chose a situation that he knows rather than taking this opportunity to learn about something he finds interesting. For instance, he says he finds the waves fascinating but he is intimidated by hydro-physics.  Margaret (the woman in the red shirt, with her back to the camera) appears to be positioning herself very differently from the rest of the group (I'll probably talk more about this in a different post).

Negotiation of Color Use in Energy Diagrams

On Monday of the first week, groups in E2 did an energy theater on a scenario involving a ruler hitting a metal ring. Then the groups were asked to make a diagram representing the energy theater they just did - this was the first time in the E2 class that the teachers had done energy theater or made a diagram. After working for some time, the groups came together in a circle and each group explained their diagram. At the conclusion of the share-out, Rachel summed up some features of the diagrams that groups were in "consensus" on. Then she specifically called out the use of color in the diagrams, saying that "we are going to save color for something else". She also mentioned that the use of different colors to designate different energies in some groups' diagrams was "redundant", since the teachers already used a different letter to show the different types of energy.

Immediately after Rachel makes these statements about color, Sid shoots her hand in the air and begins a several minute-long explanation about her need to use color in the diagram. This clip starts after she has already spoken for two minutes on the same topic. I choose this clip because it shows a moment of tension in the classroom between the instructors and some of the teachers over who is in charge of the determining how energy diagrams are made, and by Sid's extension, how in control she is over her own learning.  Another reason I felt this clip was important is that references and jokes made about using/not using color in diagrams were made by members of the class several times over the next few days.

I want to focus on several sections of the clip - the first minute where 1) Sid is speaking (0:00-0:53), when 2) Wendy makes comments (0:54-1:17), and 3) the three short segments when the instructors are speaking to the whole class, but members of Sid's group are simultaneously speaking quietly to each other (at 1:38, 2:19 and 2:40).



1) For the first minute of this clip, Sid is emphasizing through strong vocal tone and large gestures that the ability for her to use color in creating her diagram is very important to her. She specifically calls out the fact that she is still in the process of understanding how to create the diagram and what her diagram means, and she is not yet ready to refine her diagram, which is why she needs to hold on to her use of color. I think her emphatic tone and her long explanation are a reaction to her perception that the use of color is being taken away from her, and thus her ability to understand the energy theater diagram on her own terms may be seriously damaged. She apologizes for being stubborn about this issue, but remains determined saying her "creativeness feels a bit stymied", while gesturing with both hands toward herself. I think she feels that she must stand up for her rights as a learner, which are being threatened by the removal of a tool on which she feels she is currently dependent. Most of Sid's explanation is directed towards Rachel, and she even points her finger at Rachel when saying she is "not at that point right now" of moving to refining her diagram. While Sid is speaking, Rachel nods slightly but also does not smile and stands with sort of rigid body posture (from field notes - not shown in video). Rachel responds to Sid by saying, "I appreciate you putting it out there..." From her response and physical stance, it seems like Rachel is listening but does not plan to concede or affirm Sid's position on color.

2) Around the minute mark, Wendy speaks up and brings up a related concern - how not knowing what the diagram should look like as a final product makes it difficult to decide on the number of pathways or types of representations to draw at the start of making the diagram. She makes a large reaching motion with her arm from behind her to in front of her in order to indicate the start and finish of the diagram process. This gesture is not in reference to her person or Rachel but is meant to indicate the diagram process. Rachel tells Wendy, "That is a great point," also that she herself has similar concerns when working on such problems, and that she "agrees" with Wendy. Rachel noticeably relaxes her facial expression and shifts her weight to a more relaxed pose when she responds to Wendy's comment (from field notes - not shown in video). Wendy responds with a "Yeah" and does not add any more concerns. The difference in the interactions between Rachel and Sid, and Rachel and Wendy may have to do with the fact that Wendy has expressed a concern that does not necessarily conflict with the style of representation that Rachel has in mind for the energy diagrams.

3) Stamatis suggests getting new white boards for the groups to refine their diagrams while being able to refer to their originals. At 1:38, Julie, Sid and Wendy have a whispered conversation, where Julie says she thinks the instructors are leading them to some point but she is not sure where. Wendy chimes in, "As usual." Rachel brings up color again, saying she had it in mind to use for another feature, but maybe color could be used in both ways - Sid nods at this comment. At 2:19, Sid and Julie have another exchange that is difficult to hear, but Julie points out that she thinks the instructors have a plan for the diagrams. At 2:40, both Julie and Wendy indicate to Sid that they now feel more comfortable with the plan of refining the diagrams based on the norms Rachel has established. Sid says that she "completely understands that as long as I can do this first" gesturing to the original color diagram. Her tone and phrasing indicate she is still defensive on her position on the issue of using color.  Rachel comes over, she and Sid have a brief exchange. Sid laughs, and the group gets back to work.

In this clip, Sid, Wendy, Julie and Rachel are negotiating not only the norms for using color in an energy diagram but also who is in charge of determining both the content (what consists of an energy diagram, what is the purpose of making them, what is the refinement process for) and pace of the class (are we ready to stop using color and refine?). I think this clip shows an example of how interactions between instructor and learners might affect the buy-in of learners to the content. Interestingly, I am reflecting on this episode from Day 1, however, and now, on Day 3 and 4, there is pretty good consensus in the class on diagram representations.