Wednesday, August 7, 2013

Research sequence for video microanalysis in physics education

StagePromptSkills developedProduct
Project documentationSet up a blog and grant access to your research partners and advisors.  Blog every day about what you do for this project.Research documentation.  Reflection.Detailed archive of research activities, reflections, and products
Identification of interestsWhat are you interested in these days?Sense of research identity.
Identification of research questions.
Research questions
Data selection(Advisor selects an hour or two of video that is likely to be of mutual interest.) Data set
Content loggingWatch the video.  Keep time-stamped notes of what’s happening so you can find things again later.Video “eyes” (professional vision for video research). Technical facility with Inqscribe.Indexed video
Episode selectionShow me an interesting part. 
Find a moment where something happens.
Professional vision for video research.Episode
Episode isolation and transcriptionCreate a short episode that includes only the events of interest.  Get it down to less than five minutes.  Transcribe and caption it.Close observation of video.  Technical facility with Inqscribe and Quicktime.Captioned episode
Methodology reflection and literatureWrite down how you selected the episode you selected.  What caught your eye?  Why does it seem important to you? 
What kinds of things are you interested in looking at within your selected episode?  (e.g., physics, gesture, social dynamics, etc.) 
Explicit awareness of methodology.Basis of methodology section
Methodology literatureRead Derry et al, then relate your episode selection process to theirs.
Read Jordan&Henderson “foci for analysis” and write about what else you might want to attend to.
(Maybe) read Ochs and reflect on your transcription choices.
Placement of methodology in a scholarly context.Basis of methodology section
Narrative analysisWrite what happens in the episode as if you were telling someone about it who hasn’t seen the episode.  Be detailed, but only write about what matters.Distinguish observation from inference.  Support inferences with observations.  Recognize that appropriate description depends on audience and claims.Basis of body of future paper
Development of claimsWhat is true and mattersabout this episode?Make a meaningful claim.Title and abstract of presentation
Theory reflection and literatureWhat theoretical assumptions are inherent in the work you have done so far?  What do your research question, claim, study design, interpretations, results, etc. say about how the world (the mind, people) work(s)?  Read papers (selected by advisors) and blog a 500-word reflection on each.Explicit awareness of theoretical premises.  Placement of theory in scholarly context.Basis of theory section
Issues-oriented literatureIdentify papers relevant to the claim you are making.  Read papers (selected by advisors) and blog a 500-word reflection on each.Situating work relative to existing scholarship.Basis of literature review
Presentation(depending on the presentation opportunities) Create a talk/poster/proceedings paper.Present work to colleagues.Presentation to research group and/or professional society
Paper developmentWrite the paper.Paper development.Publication

Snapshot! Timeframe in Energy Theater




(This definitely has subtitles in it on my computer but I can't see them when I put them here.)

This clip shows the very first Energy Theater in the E2 class. The scenario is a ruler being bent back and released to hit a ring. Some members of the group are struggling with whether they should be representing a "snapshot" (either an instant or a short time interval) or the "entire movie" (referring to the short video clip shown to the class.

Narrative of Video

Debra is the major proponent of the "snapshot" idea. She begins by saying it's impossible to portray the whole movie: "You can't do the whole thing, you just pick one piece." She claims they need to choose among individual instants or short time intervals in which energy is transferred from one object to another object:

[00:00:22.21] Debra: you can say that the energy scenario or snapshot we're gonna do when you're pulling back the stick? that's it?
[00:00:30.24]or it could be letting go of the stick--but the ring hasn't let go
[00:00:36.17] or it could be that the stick is here but the ring is moving

In a later class discussion, Debra suggests that to her, "snapshot" means a short time interval ("it's not a still shot, frozen.") However, it's not clear to me why Debra thinks that the shorter process of pulling back the stick can be represented by energy theater, but the entire process cannot. She says (in the later class discussion) that "doing step one, two, three is a slippery slope" but doesn't explain why.) It seemed like maybe she's thinking that each of these "snapshots" has a defined set of energy transformations that occur. I'm not sure if she thinks showing the whole "movie" would be too complicated, or if it actually would not be possible.

Brad and Bryan express the desire to show the "whole movie"--Bryan seems to imply that in fact the "snapshot" would be "going into it too deep" and that it would be simpler to show the entire process as shown in the video: "From stick back to ring stopped." Don arrives late to the conversation and breaks it up with a joke that seems to settle the argument in Brad and Bryan's favor, but Debra is not deterred.

[00:01:23.13] Debra: I think it would be much quicker, much shorter to do
[00:01:26.15] This is the stick with all the stored elastic energy in it
[00:01:31.19] and the snapshot starts when we let go

Bryan appears to be frustrated, holding his face in his hands; Brad seems to give in ("Right on; I agree."). However, a few moments later, it seems like Brad hadn't quite understood what Debra was saying:

[00:01:34.07] Debra: And it's pushing the ring forward and then that's where we stop.
[00:01:37.14] it's transferred energy to the ring and the ring hasn't let go yet
Brad: Oh you just want to do the first part!

Debra is still seeing the process as being broken up into segments that should be (or must be?) separated from each other. Brad seems not to have understood this; Bryan also does not seem to have fully considered it either. Later when Debra says that "most of the energy would still be in the ring, because the ring hasn't let go yet" Bryan chuckles with surprise and delight. "You're right!"

Thoughts
Energy Theater Logistics
I was surprised that the learners were sent immediately into Energy Theater without even a short discussion of what it was, how it worked, what were the conventions, etc. Of the three ETs I have observed so far, two of them were largely taken up with how to represent objects, types of energy, time (as in this clip), etc. Only by the third was most of the conversation primarily related to the physics rather than the mechanics of the energy theater.

Group Dynamics
I also noticed that of the seven people in the group, only 3 speak (not counting Don's joke as he enters the group). The three non-speakers positioned themselves at the other side of the lobby from the four speakers. (At the very beginning of the clip, you can see Gail "crossing over" to the other side.) After the end of this clip, Don does speak a few more times about physics content. Later in this session, Jean tries to ask a question several times but is ignored. Finally she refuses to participate in the theater because she doesn't "understand what's going on." The other two women (Gail and Melanie) never speak at all during the entire Energy Theater. [I showed my E2 I-RISE buddies an extended version of this clip that shows some of this conflict but didn't post it here--I felt like I had enough with the first three minutes to write about!]

Talking about Timeframe (or not)
What is most stunning to me is the way the speakers talk at each other. The "snapshot" and "movie" advocates don't seem to ask each other about why they think their method is better. Interestingly, the only reason offered by the proponents of each method is that their way is easier. Debra says the snapshot would be "much quicker, much shorter to do"; Brad wants the video because "that's what I did [in his diagram] so I want to make it easier on me"; Bryan thinks the snapshot would be "going into it too deep." My hunch is that each group also thinks their way is more accurate or more complete but this is not discussed. The other groups members are not asked their opinion, nor do they volunteer it. Don makes a joke based on a snippet of conversation he hears ("Eye on the ring") that diffuses some of the tension but does not move the conversation. My sense here is that a lot of the conversation is focused on how and not why.

Links to arxiv versions of research paradigms papers

A couple of folks have expressed interest in reading the papers we've written about qualitative PER.  Here are the links:
http://arxiv.org/abs/1307.4135
http://arxiv.org/abs/1307.4136

The difference between and/or simultaneity of energy transfer and transformation

In education, I personally feel that using transparent words and phrases is very beneficial when students learn new concepts.  As learners go deeper into topics, then they can further develop their understanding of jargon in the field.  But that jargon can be an impediment early on.  On one hand, we want to introduce students to the proper (i.e. accepted, traditional, etc.) vocabulary as early as possible.  On the other hand, if the vocabulary is an impediment to learning, then it might be best to steer clear.

The video segment below takes place during the first day (8/5/13) of Energy 1.  The task assigned to the groups was to build a list of the “features” and “values” of energy.  For instance, the example given in class was “feature” = starting form and “values” = light, chemical, gravity, magnetic, etc.  Then small groups took 15 minutes to create a list of features and values.  When the full class resumed, features suggested were transformation, transfer, ending value of energy, type of system, and matter effects. I have attached the group's whiteboard for reference at the end of the entry.


The following segment considers a 4 minute conversation at Table 7.  This conversation focuses on establishing the meaning of the words transfer and transformation.  When the video picks up, they have already been talking about this for about 5 minutes and it is clear that not everyone is on the same page.  Jeff and Tanya are the leading voices in attempting to describe the difference; Jeff is giving pretty good examples. Cynthia is the most vocal person in this video, loudly and clearly trying to make sure she gets the difference between the two.  In fact, she seems to be trying to determine if transfer and transformation can occur simultaneously. 


At one point she says, “This is just a question, that you also have transfer when you have transformation.”  Later she asks, “Is our definition of transfer broad enough to include transfer within transformation? Because I’m having trouble making the distinction and I’m not sure if the distinction is important.”

This conversation brings up a few different thoughts in me.  The initial one that I was pulled toward when listening to the conversation live was: do they even know what they are talking about?  It seemed to take some time to establish meanings for the words transfer and transformation.  The fact that this conversation continued for fifteen minutes means, to me, that there is a lack in clarity in what they are talking about.  Are the words transfer and transformation too confusing?  I see my students tripping over these words.  I see even these teachers grappling with these words, looking for the right meaning.  Should we simplify the way we speak?  Instead of saying transformation, could we say “form change?”  Instead of saying transfer, could we say “object change?”  The fact that both words contain “trans” may be adding an impediment that could be avoided.

After listening to this conversation a few more times, one gets the sense that Cynthia has a solid grasp on the difference between transfer and transformation.  What she really wants to grasp now is whether or not both can happen simultaneously.  Consider the statement: When an object is pushed, chemical energy in the body is transformed to kinetic energy in the object.  But this sentence shows both “form change” AND “object change.”  Form goes from chemical to kinetic.  Energy moves from body to object.  Is there a temporal order here?  How important is that ordering in understanding a given situation?  This video clearly shows the challenge inherent in simply vocalizing this issue, much less determining an answer to the question (if there even is a satisfactory answer).  I think later experiences with energy tracking diagrams may lead to deeper analysis of this question.

Full video title: E1 130805 1453 T7-1

Group 7's whiteboard for this activity:

Do long-term, responsive curricula constrain in-the-moment responsiveness?

Framing is everything to me.  Whether I'm participating in a conversation or a research meeting, I want to understand (and jointly negotiate) "what is going on here," and my answer to that question deeply influences how I participate.

I observed E1 yesterday morning, and there were a number of times when I struggled to understand "what was going on there."  Several times, I wrote, "It's not clear to me why Lane is asking the teachers to do this," or, "I think the meaning of this exercise is lost on the teachers."  Other times, I felt that the teachers took up Lane's framing of an activity in different ways than he intended.  For example, in the midst of negotiating features of energy that are common to any scenario (e.g., a ball rolling down a hill, a person jumping up and down, etc.), Lane suggested that they should avoid using terminology that has not been agreed-upon by the group -- that using "science words" like "radiation" can sometimes be "excluding" -- and the teachers took this up as an opportunity to define and discuss what radiation means.  This taking things up in different ways than intended suggests to me that Lane and the teachers weren't framing their participation in the same way.

Today, watching Kara and Susan's field notes, it struck me that maybe what's happening is that the EP instructional staff is introducing tools and representations that we have developed in response to former EP teachers' needs -- negotiation of energy features, Energy Theater, a forms table, etc. -- in ways that are not responsive to where the current teachers are.  Thus, our long-term curricular responsiveness is constraining our in-the-moment responsiveness, and it feels inorganic.

I went back to our field notes from yesterday, and, sure enough, most of the times that I noted that I did not understand what was going on correspond to moments in which the classroom activity shifted toward an activity or representation that we've (EP folks) developed, rather than attending and responding to what is going on in the moment. 

I've never attended to this phenomenon, so maybe it's the norm; maybe enforcing shared representations and shifting teachers' attention toward particular ways of participating supports the development of a classroom community in which teachers work together and put their thinking on display and thus promotes in-the-moment responsiveness.  (So maybe this way of doing things promotes in-the-moment responsiveness in the long term.) 

Kara has expressed interest in looking back at how ET was introduced in past years to see how this fits in...  I'll look forward to her post!

Scientists' notebook vs. research "diary" 

08/05/2013 - Episode 1 (E2, afternoon) 



Here is my first episode form the class on Monday. 
And my first (ever) blog post.

I chose this clip because it surprised me how emotionally Gail (lady in black) reacted to the idea of sharing her notebook with others. This conversation happened right after Rachel informed teachers that by the end of the workshop, they will exchange notebooks with each other. 

Gail is clearly not happy with the idea that someone else will read her notes. She claims that knowing that she is not writing for herself but for others will make her pay more attention to HOW she is writing rather than to WHAT is she putting in her notebook.

I wonder if she would be less upset if sharing notebooks was optional, i.e., if teachers were told that at the end of the workshop they can decide whether they want to share their notes with others or not. That would allow her (and others) to be as open as she wants to and only at the end of the class would decide what she feels like doing. Because she knows from the beginning that she has to share her notes, she feels that she can't be as open as she would like to and that she has to be more neat than she normally is. It found her reasoning against sharing notebooks very interesting.

Energy 1 - Episode 1 - Work?

Tuesday morning, for the four of us who observe during the afternoon, was a technical session to get our episodes ready. For me to find an episode was a matter to go back to my Monday field notes and look for the FLAG tags I used. Then I checked the video on those and decided which episode was worth to share.

Context:

The activity started in a very non traditional way. They were talking about travel agency, they were asked to imagine what features they needed to include in a travel webpage, and then what values will be included for each feature (for example, a feature was transportation, the values were airplane, train, car, etc.).
Then they were asked to do the same for energy. I copy our (Brad and I) field notes on the instructions:
2:48 Lane: "Now we want to make this type of a list for energy values and energy happenings."
They are asked to think about the different types of energy as a feature, and specify the values for each one. It can go either way, first thinking in the features, and then its values, or the other way
Cynthia: "Can we start with an example?"  "Can movement be a feature, or can we give it a scientific term?"
Table 2: combustion equals fire?
Lane: "the features should be features of ALL energy happenings" *There sees to be confusion on how to identify the features and values*

I didn't focus on the confusion around the activity because I was not familiarized with the expectations of that activity. But I got super interested in how they were proposing work as a feature of energy. The way they discuss work and also on their description on why/how potential gravitational energy is doing work (it is only a couple seconds they talk about this).


At the beginning they are pretty sure on work happens in a lot of different forms of energy, they quickly list them. They all seem to agree (or at least no one objects or question them). Will (with the khaki shorts) and John (in the back to the right) are listing the different energy where you can find work. Then Fred (next to will with the name tag) tries to introduce the formal definition of work.
In the past summer teaching seminar they worked on trying to distinguish between work and energy, while here they are trying to label energy as always involving work (at the beginning of the conversation shown).