My first blog post, ever. Obviously first for I-RISE classroom E1 as well.
I didn't do one yesterday b/c i was solving technical issues and finishing up my PERC reviews due that day.
Today E1 started energy theater. It was an interesting transition because Lane (one of the co-teachers with Adam) emphasized a lot in the morning about how the teachers could choose what to do next. Then after lots of talk about process vs. content, it seemed he just gave them the NLDS standards and said that is what the standards say. Then there was lots more discussion/negotiation/clarification about that.
They moved on to defining important "instants" in time, as distinct from what was going on in between the "instants", using the meter stick and metal ring sliding across the floor. After each group shared one instant, they drew a picture of their "instant" and then groups arranged their whiteboard pictures in the order they occurred in the physical setup.
Then Lane emphasized that he was now going to be a football coach and just tell them what the next representation would be. This was energy theater. He joked and emphasized the teachers had no choice in it. Adam gave the three (four) rules with lots of clarification back and forth with teachers.
Okay, that's what they were roughly doing. Next blog post will be what they did during energy theater of this meter-stick & metal ring physical scenario.
Thanks for reading this far.
Insights and updates from Interdisciplinary Research Institute in STEM Education (I-RISE) Scholars, directors, and collaborators
Tuesday, August 7, 2012
E1 PM I Have To Get To Know You
It was the way that the class got to know each other that got them to really talking. At first they were all just sitting there have a few side conversations and then the class started.The class was broken up into groups by each table. Each group had to learn something about another person at the table. I was surprised at how non random they made this. Not one person was picked twice to be talked about. Some people paid more attention to details than others myself included lacked a few details. I enjoyed hearing my group express their thoughts and feelings on the topics that we were to sure short dialogue about. You could see the passion at which the teachers at table three Mr and Mrs Lawrence Madonna and Michele are all perfect examples of how a teacher should view teaching. I love that they have this unique ability for others to see that they have a true passion for the passing on of knowledge.
E2 PM Video Analysis Day 1
00:09:00
Nicole is concentrated on writing in the corner of the white board. She seems very content with what she realized, drawing the attention of Brian. Bruce, seeming to have taken the leadership role of the group, asks her to share. Nicole reluctantly shares her idea which was a very simple but important relationship with transfer of energy: when some energy goes down in a system, energy in another system goes up. The gymnast begins to move turning chemical energy into motion energy, and the motion energy into something else and so on.
00:25:00
While Christine and Nicole create a story board for their energy theatre Todd, Brian, and Bruce go on to talk about how simple pole vaulting would be to represent with energy theatre. As they think about it though they realize that there is more energy transfer than they originally thought. First chemical transferring into motion and then the motion transferring into the bending of the pole creating a larger and larger elastic potential energy.
00:28:10
Another group comes and joins the group* we are viewing. Christine and Nicole just finished creating the layout for the storyboard but has yet to put anything on it. The two groups begin to share ideas when a member of the new group (name unknown) mentions that during the gymnast's routine all the energy in the system comes to one "pinpoint" in the spring board. This is the transition from the gymnast pushing down on the springboard and when the springboard snaps back launching the gymnast into the air.
The observed group* immediately agrees with the new idea even though earlier they were certain that throughout the whole routine the gymnast was in motion meaning a constant transfer of energy.
* used to clarify which group the mic and camera are concentrated on.
Nicole is concentrated on writing in the corner of the white board. She seems very content with what she realized, drawing the attention of Brian. Bruce, seeming to have taken the leadership role of the group, asks her to share. Nicole reluctantly shares her idea which was a very simple but important relationship with transfer of energy: when some energy goes down in a system, energy in another system goes up. The gymnast begins to move turning chemical energy into motion energy, and the motion energy into something else and so on.
00:25:00
While Christine and Nicole create a story board for their energy theatre Todd, Brian, and Bruce go on to talk about how simple pole vaulting would be to represent with energy theatre. As they think about it though they realize that there is more energy transfer than they originally thought. First chemical transferring into motion and then the motion transferring into the bending of the pole creating a larger and larger elastic potential energy.
00:28:10
Another group comes and joins the group* we are viewing. Christine and Nicole just finished creating the layout for the storyboard but has yet to put anything on it. The two groups begin to share ideas when a member of the new group (name unknown) mentions that during the gymnast's routine all the energy in the system comes to one "pinpoint" in the spring board. This is the transition from the gymnast pushing down on the springboard and when the springboard snaps back launching the gymnast into the air.
The observed group* immediately agrees with the new idea even though earlier they were certain that throughout the whole routine the gymnast was in motion meaning a constant transfer of energy.
* used to clarify which group the mic and camera are concentrated on.
Rance Solomon
Withdrawal from the large group
I was observing E1 Group 3 Monday afternoon. I was simultaneously impressed by the collaboration within Group 3 and surprised by their eventual withdrawal from the large class discussion at the end of the day. The general outline of activities for Monday afternoon was as follows:
- Go outside to observe “energy events”
- Group whiteboarding to create some sort of diagram/representation of one of the energy events you observed
- Walk around and view other groups’ whiteboards followed by class discussion
- Group whiteboarding to create a list of essential energy “features” that would apply to any energy “happening”
- Class discussion of essential energy features.
Within Group 3 all four members were contributing to the conversation and contributing along their different strengths (Andrew and Allison were stronger in physics, Madonna was stronger in biology and chemistry, Michelle was fairly strong in all three subjects). I noticed different people in the group taking the markers or erasers at different times to make contributions to the whiteboard. When not writing on the whiteboard, group members would point at or tap the board as they were expressing their ideas. Everyone seemed to feel equal ownership of the whiteboard and equally responsible/capable of making contributions to their group. (Abby, some talk about efficiency and loss to thermal energy here.)
During the energy representations class discussion, all the groups were attentive and involved, talking both about the activity as a whole and about features from various whiteboards that they liked or found confusing. I didn’t get a chance to see all the whiteboards but my impression was that Group 3’s board was more technical and included more equations than the other boards. During the “gallery walk” Group 3 finished viewing the other whiteboards and sat back down before the other groups but they were engaged and contributed to the class discussion.
Group 3 had more good discussions while whiteboarding their energy features and came up with a list of features that was longer than some of them were expecting. However, the group sort of broke off on their own during the large class discussion. Group 3 would contribute features from their board and listen to other groups’ features but did not engage during the group debates. There was some class discussion of the difference between “type, form, and state” that arose based on a comment made by Group 3 but somehow Group 3 ended up being the least involved in this debate. While the rest of the class tried out various ideas and terms, Group 3 would discuss what those terms did or did not mean amongst themselves. They were paying attention but not engaging with the larger class. This was very noticeable (to me, not necessarily the other teachers) due to the otherwise very productive class discussion in which participants would often ask for clarification or elaboration on someone else’s idea. At one point Group 3 commented amongst themselves that “no one else is going to want to work with us,” recognizing that they were withdrawing from engaging with the broader class.
I’m not sure why Group 3 worked so well amongst themselves (or at least appeared to in the moment) but did not integrate as well with the whole class. I’m also not sure why Group 3 was more engaged during the first class discussion (about energy representations) than they were during the second class discussion (about energy features). Possibly they saw the second discussion as having more “right answers” than the first and hence withdrew from the conversation when they felt they already had the right answers.
Monday, August 6, 2012
First Day of Class
What a day, what a day. First of all, I feel our introduction and collaboration with the students/teachers during the morning was very helpful. I spoke with Tomme, Nicole, Todd, and Christine. Todd isn't the most outgoing from what I could tell but he can be very task oriented. At one point during the "Rights/Roles and Responsibilities" exercise Nicole and Christine became side tracked from the work and began chatting of personal matter, and Todd in response semi-politely interrupted by saying, "One responsibility we could put would be staying on task," while gesturing towards the white board. Nicole is very outgoing and willing to take control of the situation right off the bat. For Tomme and Christine I was unable to get an idea of their habits.
After coming back from lunch I was in for a brutal lesson in the importance of coming back early. The student that previously had worn the mic during the morning session left the mic on the table while they went out into the lobby to practice their energy theatre. This left Ben and I recording the same group which in a way was somewhat helpful but not quite as productive.
The groups then present their Oscar winning Energy Theatre routine. They are showing the energy transfer of a gymnast on a spring board. What I really thoroughly enjoyed for some strange reason is that even though the task had rings to represent the different points of energy transfer one group thought outside the.... rings (Oy vey). For the transfer of energy into heat during the gymnast's routine one of the students would remain in the ring that that particular energy would be present in and after a minute or two would step out of the rings. Doing this represented the energy going into the rest of the universe.
I am really interested when students or people for that matter bring in more advanced ideas than was expected or when they stumble onto significant ideas during their tasks.
I wonder what impact would giving a Middle School student literature on the ideas of special relativity or quantum mechanics have on how they think or go about solving problems. This sort of learning is what drove me towards the unrelenting world of physics. I had no scientific background but I wanted to be smart like Einstein (now it's more like a combination of Einstein, Feynman, Tesla, and Chuck Jones). So I went out and read books to do with time dilation, relativity, and all these amazing ideas that not only encouraged me to keep trudging through my work but it also showed the importance of things like simple algebra.
After coming back from lunch I was in for a brutal lesson in the importance of coming back early. The student that previously had worn the mic during the morning session left the mic on the table while they went out into the lobby to practice their energy theatre. This left Ben and I recording the same group which in a way was somewhat helpful but not quite as productive.
The groups then present their Oscar winning Energy Theatre routine. They are showing the energy transfer of a gymnast on a spring board. What I really thoroughly enjoyed for some strange reason is that even though the task had rings to represent the different points of energy transfer one group thought outside the.... rings (Oy vey). For the transfer of energy into heat during the gymnast's routine one of the students would remain in the ring that that particular energy would be present in and after a minute or two would step out of the rings. Doing this represented the energy going into the rest of the universe.
I am really interested when students or people for that matter bring in more advanced ideas than was expected or when they stumble onto significant ideas during their tasks.
I wonder what impact would giving a Middle School student literature on the ideas of special relativity or quantum mechanics have on how they think or go about solving problems. This sort of learning is what drove me towards the unrelenting world of physics. I had no scientific background but I wanted to be smart like Einstein (now it's more like a combination of Einstein, Feynman, Tesla, and Chuck Jones). So I went out and read books to do with time dilation, relativity, and all these amazing ideas that not only encouraged me to keep trudging through my work but it also showed the importance of things like simple algebra.
I loved the questions that were used to introduce one to another in the class. The questions chosen were not the typical questions (i.e background, or age) so I was forced to think on another level unexpectedly. Sid, who sat at table 2, mentioned how her most enjoyable experiences were the ones that required field trips. Her trips were atypical; going to places like Belgium instead of the local zoo. Her comments about the trips moved me because it was a great reminder that learning can be done outside of the classroom. More importantly, she reminded me that learning can be done at anytime and is a 24/7 aspect to life. This made me wonder if the classroom itself can have an impact on how students may learn physics, or any conpect for that matter. Since energy is abstract and the center for all of the sciences, I believe that it can be taught anywhere and with any tool. Furthermore, I am gathering a belief that maybe educators should venture "out of the box" to present the concept of energy to students. Maybe using tools that have never been used (or are barely used) to teach energy can help the way students learn and teachers teach physics.
Another moment that stood out to me within my time of observation was also during the introuduction. Two of the four questions that were asked in the beginning of class were -Why is it important for kids to learn energy and why do people believe that science is hard. I and another lady (I can't remember her name) said that the two questions were somewhat related. We both mentioned how energy is related to all of the sciences. She said that people find science to be difficult because educators seldomly "connect the dots" to learning, or the seldomly go back to the basics of a scientific concept after learning it in an advanced fashion. She recommended that schools (especially college) should go back to the basics after learning an advanced concept to tie everything together. For colleges, she mentioned that college students should have a course at the very end that relates what they have learned in their advanced courses with their courses in the very beginning.
I think that what I will be looking for within the two weeks of observation is how teachers will use their scientific background to present energy to their students. I am also curious to understand how teachers use their scientific background to with explaining energy to help their collegues. I wonder how the teachers will use their backgrounds to "connect to dots".
Another moment that stood out to me within my time of observation was also during the introuduction. Two of the four questions that were asked in the beginning of class were -Why is it important for kids to learn energy and why do people believe that science is hard. I and another lady (I can't remember her name) said that the two questions were somewhat related. We both mentioned how energy is related to all of the sciences. She said that people find science to be difficult because educators seldomly "connect the dots" to learning, or the seldomly go back to the basics of a scientific concept after learning it in an advanced fashion. She recommended that schools (especially college) should go back to the basics after learning an advanced concept to tie everything together. For colleges, she mentioned that college students should have a course at the very end that relates what they have learned in their advanced courses with their courses in the very beginning.
I think that what I will be looking for within the two weeks of observation is how teachers will use their scientific background to present energy to their students. I am also curious to understand how teachers use their scientific background to with explaining energy to help their collegues. I wonder how the teachers will use their backgrounds to "connect to dots".
Science identity 1.1
So Sam gave me some good pushback today to really think about the difference between science identity, empowerment to do science, interest in doing science, and understanding of what science is. These are all related, but distinct ideas. As it turns out, I'm probably less interested in science identity and more interested in the empowerment and interest in doing science (within my own research). So I'll be thinking about how to apply that to my work here at I-RISE.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)