My students tend to ignore sound, or just lump it into the KE of molecules. Today during the class discussion when we were creating a consensus about our description of Thermal Energy and Sound, it was brought up that sound was not just vibrations, but had waves too. I don't know that all of the teachers as a class were really comfortable with the connection between sound and Thermal Energy, nor did they necessarily see any connection between them. Have you seen other examples of this happening in classes? It might be interesting to flush out their understanding a bit more. Table four mentions Heat loss, friction, and sound all in the same breath (Tuesday) but I don't know if this group distinguishes between them.
Insights and updates from Interdisciplinary Research Institute in STEM Education (I-RISE) Scholars, directors, and collaborators
Wednesday, August 10, 2011
Energy Cubes
My students tend to ignore sound, or just lump it into the KE of molecules. Today during the class discussion when we were creating a consensus about our description of Thermal Energy and Sound, it was brought up that sound was not just vibrations, but had waves too. I don't know that all of the teachers as a class were really comfortable with the connection between sound and Thermal Energy, nor did they necessarily see any connection between them. Have you seen other examples of this happening in classes? It might be interesting to flush out their understanding a bit more. Table four mentions Heat loss, friction, and sound all in the same breath (Tuesday) but I don't know if this group distinguishes between them.
Reflections, Day One, Energy Two: Amy (Two of Two)
Thermal energy always increases.
The second two clips focus on the idea (mostly put forth by Nina) that thermal energy always increases. Within the framework of Energy Theater, this seems to suggest that the number of ‘T’s (‘T’ representing a ‘chunk’ of thermal energy) must always be greater at the end of the scene/act than at the beginning.
Nina first brings this up in response a question that Stamatis posed during their discussion of the ball-moving-through-water scenario. The teachers were discussing three forms of energy: kinetic, (gravitational) potential, and thermal, and they were negotiating whether they needed to specifically articulate each transformation (gravitational energy of water to kinetic energy of ball to gravitational energy of ball) or whether they should just focus on the start and end states of the system. Stamatis encouraged them to think about the forms pairwise: whether it was possible to go from each kind of energy to the next, and vice versa. (E.g., Can we go from kinetic to potential? From kinetic to thermal? From potential to thermal? From potential to kinetic? Etc.)
Nina responds that intuitively, she sees thermal energy as a sort of ‘dead end’ – in that other forms of energy can turn into thermal energy, but thermal energy cannot be transformed. (E.g., kinetic energy can become thermal energy, but thermal energy cannot become kinetic energy.)
Later, John seems to ‘buy into’ this idea, or at least use it, when the group is discussing what would happen if the ball were moving through ‘more frictiony’ water in the first place. In this alternate scenario, the group has ‘G’s (in the water) turn into ‘T’s (also in the water, I think), and John says, “…these Ts can’t turn back into Gs, can they?” Nina immediately answers, “No,” and goes on to reiterate her earlier intuitions.
The content-oriented me is totally fascinated by this. When I brought this up yesterday afternoon, Sam reaffirmed what I had been thinking as I listened, which is that it certainly seems intuitive to Nina (and perhaps the other teachers) that something increases over time, and she seems to have associated thermal energy with this quantity. I was impressed by Nina's ‘articulateness’ and how this could certainly turn into a super-productive discussion about entropy.
Download QuickTime 7 for Mac OS X 10.6 & 10.7 (Snow Leopard and Lion)
There are two methods available:
1. You can just download version 7.6.6 of QuickTime here. Yes, it's not the latest version of QuickTime 7, which seems backwards, since the latest version is apparently only available for Leopard, but it turns into QuickTime Pro, which is all we need.
2. If you want Mac OS to automatically download the right version of QuickTime for your OS, there's a trick: Open up TextEdit, and hit Shift-Cmd-T to make the file a plain text file. Then save it on your Desktop as "movie.qtz" (don't use .txt file extension!). Double click the file on your Desktop, and Mac OS will inform you that it can't open the file in QuickTime X, but offers you to install QuickTime 7. Accept that offer, and you're done. Then you can delete the file movie.qtz that you had just created.
Yes, this is a little strange and counter-intuitive, and yes, QuickTime X in Lion apparently offers some of the QuickTime Pro features. I still like the handling of QuickTime 7 better...
Thoughts on Assessment and Future Research Project Idea #3
I spoke at length about this idea with Rachel and Dorothy this morning, so maybe they can add to this discussion. I was thinking about the Rogers stuff that I’m feeling totally connected to, and I remembered a paper that I read a few years ago about comparing the effectiveness of different instructional styles (in Tutorials). (I’m linking to the paper here: Koenig, Endorf, Braun teaching methods paper.) I thought it would be interesting to try to do something like this with teaching styles along a “Rogerian spectrum” – from teaching that is aligned with the Rogerian perspective to teaching that is misaligned. Then there could be qualitative and quantitative assessments of learning for each class, and we could compare…
After the conversation with Rachel, I think what I’m really saying is that I’m still fuzzy on how to assess whether learning has taken place, and I want to see that happen for teaching "along the Rogerian spectrum." (As in, this is something that has been on my mind for a week – not just in relationship to Rogerian discourse, but in general.) Is it necessary to have both quantitative and qualitative measures? Is it necessary to show that using an instructional method/theoretical framework for relating is more effective than not using the method/framework, or is it enough to show that use of the method/framework was productive? (But, then, how is productive defined?) Rachel pointed out that Rogers defined ways of assessing learning in his book, which I have not yet read (am feeling more and more excited to do so).
I suppose this has turned into a little bit of philosophical musing on my part, but I wanted to post the paper and my idea for reference in future conversations, and I want to keep thinking about this in relationship to Rogers’ framework.
Future Research Project Idea #2
Idea #2
I’m writing this on behalf of Sam and expecting that she will correct me if I have mis-spoken. She (and Rachel) articulated that Leslie described her sense that she and Stamatis were teaching two (different) classes concurrently since their instructional styles are so different. It would be interesting to watch (and compare) the interactions that happen: (1) between Leslie and groups and (2) between Stamatis and groups…and then maybe sequential interactions…
Future Research Project Idea #1
There are several ideas for research projects stewing, so I’m going to try to document them here. I’ll do this in three different posts so that people can comment separately…here’s part 1 of 3.
Idea #1
Yesterday afternoon, Stamatis and Leslie mixed up the groups in Energy 2 - so that each new group was comprised of one (or two) members of the original groups – and the teachers individually explained the energy story that their original group had come up with.
I thought it would be super interesting to follow the members of a single group as they re-explained their group’s energy story to other members of the class. We could not only compare the explanations/conversations that each individual member gave (e.g., compare Teacher 1's explanation to Teacher 2's explanation); we could also compare the individual explanations to the group explanation (i.e., Teacher 1's explanation to Group's explanation).
Tuesday, August 9, 2011
Awkward Introductions: What are you doing here?
So we started out the day yesterday by actually sitting with the teachers and being part of the introduce-your-partner-class-introductions in E1. I had a hard time explaining why I was there and did not anticipate that it would be so difficult. Sure, it’s easy to explain to other scholars, but to the teachers? The last thing I wanted to do was make them more aware of me listening in on everything they say in the next two weeks. So, I tried to say that I wanted to learn more about energy, but I felt like they didn’t really buy that (“What do you mean you don’t know about energy?” someone said). Really, though, that’s true! Heck, they’re teachers and by listening to their ideas I will learn so much about how to think about energy. . . because, shucks, sometimes I think of a herd of little capital E’s running around.
Anyway, I think in that moment, I felt like maybe these teachers wanted a more research-y answer, since, after all, my nametag says ‘scholar’ and I’m going to be the weirdo in the headphones. Of course, I don’t want to tell them, hey, I’m actually really interested in watching how you use your hands while you’re talking and thinking about energy. Yikes! So, suddenly, I felt like I was kind of not being honest. Being genuine seems key in establishing some kind of trust. I realized that, to me, this explanation was a really important moment for the person behind the camera to get right. Otherwise, I could end up feeling like I left the folks at my table feeling like bugs under a microscope. Really, I guess I’d like them to see me as just another one of their students, except, one listening in remotely, with ridiculously large headphones on.
So, what I wish I had said, more clearly and confidently, was that I’m here to learn about how people talk about energy. That seems much more consistent with my true intention. It blends my desire to learn about energy from them and my desire to learn about how they discuss energy. I wonder, though, if the real backbone of explaining where I’m coming from is to tell them I really want to think of energy as a belief. Anyway, definitely, if I could do it again, I’d put a lot more thought into how I explained the answer to this simple question: what are you doing here?