Tuesday, August 9, 2011

What other ELAs exist out there?

I have not heard of Energy Theater before this year and I wish I had! It would have been amazing to teach this last year when I had the chance! One thing that my colleagues and I at KSTF (Knowles Science Teaching Fellowship) have been working on is a sort of similar lesson plan involving the energy in circuits. Here, we combined a paper that I am attaching below called "Electron Runaround" with energy. We think that we will be using some sort of card system to show a set amount of energy instead of people but we are still working on this idea. I would love to work on this more using a more Energy Theater approach -but here we have the students as charges and the cards as energy. Do you think this representation will still be effective?

Electron Runaround paper by Vandana Singh

Tips for using wireless headphones without interference

We now have 4 sets of wireless headphones, 2 Sonys and 2 Sennheisers. Each brand has three distinct channels, and the 3 for Sony are different from the 3 for Sennheiser. We currently have both Sonys in E1 and both Sennheisers in E2. We just had some problems in E1 with not being able to pick up one of the tables. I'm not sure what was going on, but I fixed it by changing the channel on the headphone base from the middle to the right. It seems like it's a good idea to have the two headphones on the left and the right, rather than in the middle, to decrease the chance of interference. Other things we discovered today is that if a channel is staticky, it will automatically switch to a different channel, like an automatic radio tuner. If you don't know this is happening, it can be confusing why you keep picking up someone else's table no matter how many times you change the channel. We're still having problems with static that we don't know how to fix.

Reflections, Day One, Energy Two: Amy (One of Two)

After spending the morning reflecting and re-watching the portions of yesterday’s episode that I flagged, I’m realizing that this EPSRI experience is going to be as much a personal as a professional journey. Coming from a research experience that is very directed, focused on content, and quantitatively-driven, I feel somewhat overwhelmed and uncertain but also happily challenged and free. In any case, I suspect that this will be an evolutionary experience, and I invite comments on my perspective and ways that I could be more (or less) open-minded.


I reviewed a number of ‘flagged’ snippets from yesterday, and two particularly stuck to me. (I’ll have to clip and transcribe the video later, since the ‘clippable’ versions are not yet available.) Edited: This will be post one of two, per Rachel's request.


We get to define stuff because we’re physicists.


The first clip shows a statement that I’m trying to make meaning out of: Stamatis is sitting at the table, and the teachers are discussing their ‘pre-negotiation’ of Energy Theater for a ball that is released from rest underneath the surface of water (a swimming pool, I think). They have depicted the scenario in time on their whiteboard: they showed what the ‘energy of the system’ would look like at three different points in time – just before the ball is released, as the ball is moving through the water toward the surface, and after the ball has reached the surface and come to rest. Stamatis asks, “So, nothing’s moving here?” Nina replies, “Correct…we get to define that because we’re physicists.” I can’t see her face, but she sort of shakes her hand at Stamatis when she says it, and the tone of her voice changes.




This statement totally struck me for several reasons: because it seems to me to say something about what Nina thinks physicists do, because she identifies herself and her peers as physicists, and because I can’t tell if she is joking (and for a whole host of other reasons). But no one responded to her! It was almost as if no one heard her at all.



Reflections Of A Returning Scholar

Last year, the EPSRI wasn't yet a "thing." Rachel and Sam had invited a couple researchers from around the country to help with the data collection for the Energy Project and learn something about video-based research. I was the only scholar who was there for the entire three weeks of Energy 2 (which started a week early) and Energy 1 (which ran a week late). We were figuring out how to do things on the fly, the technical stuff with cameras and microphones, the field note taking in a google docs spreadsheet, how to write field notes, and so on. Things weren't made easier by scholars arriving and leaving every couple days. On the other hand, a nice apprenticeship model was established, everybody just helped out with the training of new people. We had fun hanging out in the "lounge" while not observing, talking on the chat across rooms, and having a beer at night, talking about work and other things.

One year later, things have changed quite a bit. The EPSRI is an institution now. There was an application process involved, many people were interested in participating in the summer research institute, Sam and Rachel had to turn people down because the institute was full. We have our own "classroom," not just a room where no courses happened to be scheduled. We have a tech person! No more copying files from SD cards onto our own computers and being responsible for converting the data according to the guidelines and uploading them to the server over night. No more stray or lost video files. Exciting! We are integrating ourselves with the participants in the teacher professional development courses, instead of pretending we weren't there. Just before lunch, we even switched roles with the teachers in E1, doing energy theater while having teachers be responsible for the video cameras. Everything seems strangely familiar, and yet, it's different. Bigger. Better.

I'm looking forward to working together with awesome colleagues at this year's EPSRI, observing exciting conversations about energy, and honing my skills as a "video-researcher." I can't wait to start looking at video, find interesting stuff, and share it with you all! It's good to be back!

Monday, August 8, 2011

Constructing Classroom Communities

This morning I observed the Energy 2 course, and the topic of constructing classroom communities caught my attention. Nina, who was wearing the microphone I was listening to, made the comment that she had been “teaching physics” for 4 years, but did not consider herself a “physics teacher” nor a “physicist”. She continued to comment that “physics teachers” are “intimidating”. She further explained this comment by stating that “physics teachers” have “exclusive knowledge”, such as the knowledge of “equations”. Nina added that “physics is not my major”. I found Nina's specific placement of herself as someone who “teaches physics”, as separate from a “physics teacher” as well as separate from a “physicist”, quite interesting. This highlighted the existence of many different physics related “communities” within the perceptions of teachers. (I suppose that the term “community” will be used loosely in this blog post to describe a group of people who have gained membership to co-exist in a space with agreed upon norms and values). It made me question how and why membership to these different communities exists/doesn't exists within the perceptions of certain individuals. Furthermore, I had never thought to differentiate the action of teaching from the label of “teacher”. Perhaps the seemingly subtle difference that exists in Nina's perception of “teaching physics” and being a “physics teacher” lies in her self perception of her command of the subject matter as well as her perceived command of her pedagogical content knowledge. I also wonder how the other participants view their memberships to these communities and whether they feel as though there are any “overlaps” that could exist between “teaching physics”, being a “physics teacher”, and being a “physicist”. (If this was made into a Venn Diagram, what would be included in the overlapping/non-overlapping spaces?)

Interestingly, Nina also mentioned that when people don't want to “act stupid” they “put up a wall”. Thus, she emphasized that it was important to her to have the “right to be wrong”within the community of the EPSRI classroom in order to effectively communicate with others. It makes me wonder if Nina views the EPSRI classroom as an exception to her division between the various communities involving “teaching physics”, “physics teachers”, and “physicists”.

I appreciated the terminology that Nina used to describe her personal perceptions of these various communities that perhaps actually all coexist within the EPSRI classroom. She also helped me to think more in depth about the relationship between “teaching”, “knowing”, and “doing” science.

How To Interact with Others and Badgering

On the first day of Energy One, much time was spent describing the rights and responsibilities (r&r) of all people involved in the class. It was striking to see the interaction between Group 3 and then hear what they had to say about rights. I found a clip where Tomme states, "You're badgering to get information" to Bill in the second E1 video, at about minute 10:30. It was certainly a case where the teachers each had their specific way of learning and seemed unwilling to adjust or help each other understand the different way of processing. Tomme then states, "This is not an educational process that's happening here, and I certainly hope you don't do this in your classroom."



It seemed like there may have been a communication malfunction when the teachers were thinking about the differences in their learning styles. I wanted Kristi (the silent member of the group during this interaction) to speak up and play mediator. I expect teachers to be good at facilitating and providing positive feedback to each other and I found this situation to be very typical for situations I have seen from my students in high school. Ideally (at least to me) teachers should be allowing students to challenge what they say, and allowing push back within their classrooms because this is how students will be able to get over misconceptions. Without the ability to question and discuss their confusion regarding physics, the students will have a difficult time truly internalizing what is going on around them. If the teachers don't feel comfortable working through their understandings with their peers, it might be difficult to allow students to question within the classroom.

**Mary Bridget made the comment that Bill was not present for the "getting to know you" introduction. Had he been there, this may have helped to alleviate some of the pressure in the situation.

According to Dorothy, this group worked well together after lunch and after the discussion around r&r. I feel like perhaps this conflict could have been avoided had the r&r discussion come first. But perhaps the r&r was more productive because they had already experienced this issue. This leads me to wonder as an observer, what exactly was the purpose of engaging the students in this first video (Honda Cog from Youtube showing a Rube-Goldberg machine) and analysis? Was it to start a dialogue about energy and get the teachers interested? Was it for the instructors to understand better what prior knowledge existed? Was it just a mixer activity or a sort of pretest that will be brought back later? I might have missed this too (I was challenged today with observing and typing at the same time!).

A couple of notes for me:
All video stored for EPSRI is under \\physicsdata\classes for PCs.
It is better to download the videos onto the computer before using Quick Time and Inqscribe.

Day 1 Reflections: non-verbal interactions

This is going to be more of a reflective post and no particular episode. There were a lot of technical issues both this morning (with audio) and this afternoon with software. So, in some ways, I feel like I haven't really had a chance to engage in any "thinking" or really even much "observing."

That being said, there were a few things that stuck out to me this morning with the group that I was observing (Group 6: Melanie, Ingrid, and Brian). During the discussion about the Honda Cog video, I couldn't really hear what they were saying. In some ways, I think it made me more consciously aware of all the non-verbal things happening. Each of them had their own laptop and this seemed to make it more difficult when they were trying to discuss with each other since they were not always looking at the same thing. Also, Melanie and Brian interacted much more one-on-one, whereas interactions with Ingrid involved the whole group. This may have been due in part to the fact that Melanie and Brian knew each other and also because they were sitting on one side of the table and Ingrid was on the other side. In fact, at one point, Ingrid actually got up and went around to the other side of the table to see what Melanie had drawn on the whiteboard.

On the whole, this group seemed to be working productively and engaging in interesting dialogue (what I could hear of it). It was fascinating to watch their gestures while only catching snippets of what they were saying, particularly when talking about vibrating and spinning. It reminded me a lot of Hunter's paper/talk on differentiation, especially because I seemed to see the "shaking" gesture that he talks about.

Later in the morning, I could hear better and there was something that stood out to me in both of the small group discussions: about what "unencumbered" conversation looks like and then later, about rights and responsibilities. During the first, this group spent quite a bit of time talking about disasters (9/11, snowstorms, power outages, etc.) and how people interactions between people are different in those situations than in everyday life. During the discussion of rights and responsibilities, I was fascinated by the negotiation of wording for what went on the board. One of them would propose an idea and it seemed clear that they all understood the phenomenon, but there would be discussion (sometimes lengthy) about how to succinctly sum up that phenomenon to put on the board. I may try to pull out a good example of this tomorrow (~11:40), but we'll see.