Monday, August 8, 2011

How To Interact with Others and Badgering

On the first day of Energy One, much time was spent describing the rights and responsibilities (r&r) of all people involved in the class. It was striking to see the interaction between Group 3 and then hear what they had to say about rights. I found a clip where Tomme states, "You're badgering to get information" to Bill in the second E1 video, at about minute 10:30. It was certainly a case where the teachers each had their specific way of learning and seemed unwilling to adjust or help each other understand the different way of processing. Tomme then states, "This is not an educational process that's happening here, and I certainly hope you don't do this in your classroom."



It seemed like there may have been a communication malfunction when the teachers were thinking about the differences in their learning styles. I wanted Kristi (the silent member of the group during this interaction) to speak up and play mediator. I expect teachers to be good at facilitating and providing positive feedback to each other and I found this situation to be very typical for situations I have seen from my students in high school. Ideally (at least to me) teachers should be allowing students to challenge what they say, and allowing push back within their classrooms because this is how students will be able to get over misconceptions. Without the ability to question and discuss their confusion regarding physics, the students will have a difficult time truly internalizing what is going on around them. If the teachers don't feel comfortable working through their understandings with their peers, it might be difficult to allow students to question within the classroom.

**Mary Bridget made the comment that Bill was not present for the "getting to know you" introduction. Had he been there, this may have helped to alleviate some of the pressure in the situation.

According to Dorothy, this group worked well together after lunch and after the discussion around r&r. I feel like perhaps this conflict could have been avoided had the r&r discussion come first. But perhaps the r&r was more productive because they had already experienced this issue. This leads me to wonder as an observer, what exactly was the purpose of engaging the students in this first video (Honda Cog from Youtube showing a Rube-Goldberg machine) and analysis? Was it to start a dialogue about energy and get the teachers interested? Was it for the instructors to understand better what prior knowledge existed? Was it just a mixer activity or a sort of pretest that will be brought back later? I might have missed this too (I was challenged today with observing and typing at the same time!).

A couple of notes for me:
All video stored for EPSRI is under \\physicsdata\classes for PCs.
It is better to download the videos onto the computer before using Quick Time and Inqscribe.

Day 1 Reflections: non-verbal interactions

This is going to be more of a reflective post and no particular episode. There were a lot of technical issues both this morning (with audio) and this afternoon with software. So, in some ways, I feel like I haven't really had a chance to engage in any "thinking" or really even much "observing."

That being said, there were a few things that stuck out to me this morning with the group that I was observing (Group 6: Melanie, Ingrid, and Brian). During the discussion about the Honda Cog video, I couldn't really hear what they were saying. In some ways, I think it made me more consciously aware of all the non-verbal things happening. Each of them had their own laptop and this seemed to make it more difficult when they were trying to discuss with each other since they were not always looking at the same thing. Also, Melanie and Brian interacted much more one-on-one, whereas interactions with Ingrid involved the whole group. This may have been due in part to the fact that Melanie and Brian knew each other and also because they were sitting on one side of the table and Ingrid was on the other side. In fact, at one point, Ingrid actually got up and went around to the other side of the table to see what Melanie had drawn on the whiteboard.

On the whole, this group seemed to be working productively and engaging in interesting dialogue (what I could hear of it). It was fascinating to watch their gestures while only catching snippets of what they were saying, particularly when talking about vibrating and spinning. It reminded me a lot of Hunter's paper/talk on differentiation, especially because I seemed to see the "shaking" gesture that he talks about.

Later in the morning, I could hear better and there was something that stood out to me in both of the small group discussions: about what "unencumbered" conversation looks like and then later, about rights and responsibilities. During the first, this group spent quite a bit of time talking about disasters (9/11, snowstorms, power outages, etc.) and how people interactions between people are different in those situations than in everyday life. During the discussion of rights and responsibilities, I was fascinated by the negotiation of wording for what went on the board. One of them would propose an idea and it seemed clear that they all understood the phenomenon, but there would be discussion (sometimes lengthy) about how to succinctly sum up that phenomenon to put on the board. I may try to pull out a good example of this tomorrow (~11:40), but we'll see.

Sunday, July 31, 2011

Embodied Cognition

In a recent post on the PHYSLRNR list, Doug Holton provided this link to a presentation he gave last year to the American Education Research Association's (AERA) Constructivism Special Interest Group. Here's a link to the accompanying paper.

Based on the presentation, I checked out Embodiment and Cognitive Science by Gibbs and have been slowly going over it. The Amazon reviews seem spot on - it's very dense and not for casual reading. But it makes a strong case for the importance of embodied cognition as part of the overall framework of cognitive science.

My (admittedly surface) exposure leads me to think that there's enough overlap but enough difference between Embodied Learning Activities and Embodied Cognition for this to be a productive framework for both analyzing Energy Theater and also for thinking about possible modifications to it.

Saturday, July 23, 2011

Energy Posters

I recently ran across these cool posters, which can be ordered from PhysicsCentral for what looks to be free in the US, and can be freely downloaded and printed. The posters themselves are neat, but when you click on them, you get further information. Two in particular deal with energy questions that I heard come up in UE2 and I bet came up in UE1.

This one addresses "How many cheeseburgers do you need to eat to row across the Atlantic Ocean?"

This one addresses "How long you would have to yell to heat a cup of coffee?". I was particularly struck by this one, given all the interest in UE2 about the nature of sound energy. I wonder how the participants in the room would have responded if this poster and its associated discussion had been given to them after their own deep discussion of sound.

I also like the posters: striking visuals and engaging questions. I think I'm going to order the set!

Friday, July 22, 2011

Response to Brookes & Etkina

I just read a paper that I should have read before submitting my recent PERC paper on ontologies for energy.  I hope I get the opportunity to address this paper during the review process:

Brookes, D. T., & Etkina, E. (2007). Using conceptual metaphor and functional grammar to explore how language used in physics affects student learning. Physical Review - Special Topics:  Physics Education Research, 3(010105), 1-16.  Link

The authors use conceptual metaphor to account for student difficulties in quantum mechanics.  They especially address metaphors for energy, including the conceptualization of heat as a fluid and of energy as a vertical location.  The hypothesis of the paper is that "students overextend and misapply conceptual metaphors in physicists' speech and writing."

Some things that I see as being the same about our work:  We are both applying theories of conceptual metaphor.  We are both especially interested in metaphors for energy.  We are both identifying metaphors using linguistic analysis of (1) expert physics discourse and (2) physics learner discourse.  Using similar techniques, we identify two of the same metaphors for energy: as a substance, and as a vertical location.  (I have a third one too.)  We are also in agreement that expert physicists have multiple coherent metaphors and use them all, ideally knowing the applicability and limitations of each.

Here are three things that I see as contrasting about our work, mostly in the category of theoretical premises.  (I'm attributing them to myself only not because I am solely responsible for them but because I didn't consult my coauthors before writing this post!)

Brookes & Etkina:  Many metaphors are wrong (they use "defunct" and "historical").  Certain metaphors are correct ("modern," "conventional").
Scherr:  All metaphors contribute to a valid understanding - all are good for something.  Certain metaphors are better for certain purposes (e.g., substance is good for conservation).

Brookes & Etkina:  Students acquire metaphors/language from teachers.  (This is consistent with their grounding in Chi & Slotta.)
Scherr:  Metaphors are natural to human thought.  Language is learned by Vygotskian internalization, which is not a straightforward acquisition from experts.

Brookes & Etkina:  If we experts are not careful, we may make ontologically mixed statements, and may cause novices to suffer from ontological misclassification (a cognitively serious condition; again, this is Chi.).  For example, students think particles get tired, because expert speech led them to ontologically misclassify particles.
Scherr:  People (experts and novices) have easy cognitive access to a variety of ontologies.  (See Gupta et al.)  Expertise with discipline-specific metaphors includes knowing which features to map; novices may export different features than experts, but their understanding is potentially flexible.

Thursday, July 21, 2011

2011 PERC Proceedings papers submitted

Energy Project team members have submitted five papers to the 2011 PERC Proceedings:

H. G. Close and R. E. Scherr, "Differentiation of Energy Concepts Through Speech and Gesture in Interaction," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

B. W. Harrer, R. E. Scherr, M. C. Wittmann, H. G. Close, and B. W. Frank, "Elements of Formative Assessment in Learners' Discourse about Energy,"  C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

S. B. McKagan, R. E. Scherr, E. W. Close, and H. G. Close, "Criteria for Creating and Categorizing Forms of Energy," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

R. E. Scherr, H. G. Close, and S. B. McKagan, "Intuitive Ontologies for Energy in Physics," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

R. E. Scherr, H. G. Close, and S. B. McKagan, "Promoting Proximal Formative Assessment with Relational Discourse," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

Documenting a class session with video and photos

This is not going to be a detailed instruction manual for the specific equipment we use; we'll do that part in person.  This is an overview of the procedures for video- and photo-recording a class session.  The other critical documentation for every class session is field notes (addressed in a separate post).

Videography

1.  Arrive at 8am so that you have time to get things in order before class starts at 8:30.  Our technical assistant will have charged the cameras and put fresh batteries in them and in the microphones.  The first order of business is to decide where to place your microphone for your session (and thus where to point your camera, since the camera should record the same people that the microphone is recording).  There are two normal options:
  • Have an individual person wear the microphone.  The important advantage of this option is that if and when the participants get out of their seats, which happens regularly in this class, the microphone goes with them.  Here are instructions for recruiting a microphone wearer.
  • Set the microphone in an unobtrusive spot on the table (for example, poking out from under the computer monitor).  The important advantage of this option is that the participants tend to be more comfortable with it.
Check with the instructors and fellow scholars to decide what's the best plan for your session.

2.  Position your camera so as to see the mic wearer well.  Often a shelf of windowsill works best.  Always plug in the camera when you can, to preserve the battery for when you need to be mobile. 

3.  Once you are set up, do a sound check, start recording, and find a place to settle in and take field notes.  It's tempting to have a "scholars' table" in the back of the room.  However, this can look a little intimidating (a wall of laptops staffed by people with big headphones on).  Consider integrating yourself into the classroom differently.

4.  This is the kind of class where participants are likely to get up and move around.  When they do, you will need to grab the camera and microphone receiver (these are both small) and follow them as best you can, be that out into another room or whatever.  Leave the tripod connected, but disconnect the camera's power cord as well as the wireless headphones (the "base station" for those is big and clunky).  Have other headphones handy (keep earbuds in your pocket?) so that you can still listen.  

If your group is stable in the new location, you may be able to set the camera down.  Frequently, though, when you are going handheld, you can't take field notes.  If the action is a whole-class activity, it may be effective for one scholar to hold the camera while the other takes field notes.  If not, just do your best to summarize what you saw when you get back to your laptop.

Still photography

1.  Photograph every white board the teachers produce, if possible - all the groups, not only the group you are observing.  There is often a "gallery walk" or a break during which you can take photos.  To photograph a white board, hold it upright (to avoid glare from the ceiling lights) and include the table number in the frame of the photo.  The date and time are recorded automatically by the camera.  

2.  Photograph the front board when something significant is on it.  Breaks are usually the time to do this.

3.  If you think of it, take "promotional photos" as well as data photos - pictures that show the course and/or the EPSRI in action.  We use these on brochures and posters describing the programs.