Monday, August 9, 2010

"Why are your white boards different?"

After Energy 1 had made white boards describing an energy scenario they observed on the ship canal today, Stamatis asked something like this: "Several of you observed an airplane flying by.  You observed the same phenomenon.  So why are your white boards different?"

This seems like a terrific example of a particular kind of question.  I was pretty sure I knew where Stamatis was going, because of my previous experience with the class: the participants had just done the people talk and pictorial representation (white boards of walk on the ship canal), so the next step in the Algebra Project sequence is to identify the features of energy scenarios.  They are going to brainstorm possible features, then choose the most important features, then develop (or maybe be given?) a representation that shows those features.  So the white boards are different because they have not yet agreed on a common representation, because they have not yet agreed on the important features of energy scenarios.  Stamatis's question, thus, is intended to motivate the upcoming string of activities.  I would think this is probably why he asked it - in order to give participants a kind of a puzzle, or preview; something that hints at what's ahead, and if it's a little bit mysterious, maybe that just makes it tantalizing.

On the other hand, people might just find the question bizarre; who would think that different groups' white boards would be magically the same?  That can't be the real question, so what is the real question, if any, and what is the instructor trying to accomplish by this mysteriousness?  I can easily imagine the question making people anxious.  After all, it's unanswerable within their current experience.

I think that this kind of question sends the message that the class is about to go somewhere that is known to the instructor and not known to the students.  Some people probably feel safe knowing that, like they have a knowledgeable driver in an unfamiliar city.  Others might feel like unwilling captives, not knowing where they are being taken or whether it's somewhere they want to go.  In either case I think part of what the question accomplishes is to frame participants as passengers in the vehicle.

Sunday, August 8, 2010

References?

Twice last week I was asked for references, and I've spent some time tracking some down. (I'm terrible at remembering titles and authors. I use Mekentosj Papers to help organize and categorize what I've read - and it helps - but I'm still kind of bad at this.)

(1) References having to do with teaching from the students' perspective (that is, not charting a course based on the expertise of a scientist - directing students to a known answer, but instead helping them untangle their knots and work together to figure something out).

Duckworth; Hammer (Disc. Learning and Disc. Teaching); Schauble (just about anything - there's a recent paper I love - "supporting the development of the epistemology of inquiry"); Deborah Ball (he description of Shay numbers seems like it must be an inside-out view); Mortimer and Scott (The Tension Between Authoritative and Dialogic Discourse - Kara - via Rachel - reminded me of this literature).

(2) Then the other line of research had to do with questions-that-aren't-questions, or the role and meta-messages of question. For this I think of Lakoff's "Women, Fire and Dangerous Things" where he reports on (Grice??) and what it is to "lie." Tannen and framing. And Conversation Analysis and a paper on "I dunno..." (asking kids "are you popular" and they say "oh, I don't know. I guess." - the "I dunno" has a role in the conversation that has nothing to do with knowing/not-knowing).

This is still all too vague. I'll keep working on this and updating this list as I come up with specifics.

Friday, August 6, 2010

Why I love being here

Today is Friday, day 5 of my experience as an Energy Project Videographer (EPV). I have been in Seattle for almost a week, and I really fell in love with this city, although I haven't seen a lot of it, yet. It is so green, here! That is really amazing, especially all the over-abundantly flowering front yards. And the weather is perfect, it is cool and sometimes cloudy in the morning, when I am going to work, and once we're done at the university, it's the most beautiful day outside, inviting to sit outside or go for a walk (today is probably an exception, though).

At SPU, I received a warm welcome into the "inner circle" of the energy project. I had just met everybody at AAPT/PERC, two weeks ago, but it was like meeting up with old friends. Monday was my first day on-site, and Leslie and I got introduced to the general procedures by Rachel and Sam. Then everything went very fast, and Leslie and Sam ended up sitting in the classroom, videotaping the morning session, while Rachel and I were participating in the warm-up energy theater. Right away, this experience was amazing, and I was inspired to look at the recorded data, later-on to do some analysis. And I am still working on that. In fact, I felt like I could have gone home after the Monday morning session, having gathered enough data to spend the next year analyzing it.
But no, I returned to the classroom as EPV in the afternoon, to take field notes of what was happening. It turns out that that's a lot. As an observer in a classroom, I felt totally overwhelmed by the amount of information that I was swamped with. How could I ever note everything down that was happening, right now? And then try to process some of it, at the same time, and write my own thoughts on that down? Eventually, I decided to focus on what I could see happening in "my" group, to not pay too much attention to what people were saying. After all, I would be able to listen closely while watching the video. But it might be interesting to have some kind of narrative of what people are doing, with a general sense of content, but without much detailed dialog or interpretation, in my field notes to have anchor points for watching the video later.
After the afternoon session, all the instructors and researchers ("visiting scholars") met in the "lounge" for a debriefing of the day and exchanging thoughts about the next day. Sitting there with the entire team, being able to raise questions about something that we observed during the day was such a rich opportunity to have intellectual exchange happening.

Unlike the first day, Rachel and I usually spend the mornings outside the classroom, processing video data, posting blog entries, thinking, talking, etc. Otherwise, the structure of the day is the same each day. But it does not at all get boring. There is just so much going on around us, it is really amazing. Which brings me to my conclusion and the answer to the "question" I raised in the title: Since the moment I arrived here, I have felt to be a (somewhat) important part of a very very interesting project. I am immersed in a rich and fertile environment (and I am fully aware of my metaphor), I feel like I will be able to grow a lot (intellectually) during the three weeks that I am spending here. Working on the energy project with those fantastic people that are so enthusiastic and accessible (meaning: always willing to talk about what they are doing and thinking) has already been so much fun, and will continue to be fun and a source of intellectual inspiration. I am proud to be here.

Moral/Immoral Teaching

There's this quote by Robert Irwin (an artist reflecting on teaching) that I love. - The book mentions how - while most students create art that mimics their teacher's - his students created art that looked nothing like Irwin's art and became significant artists in their own right. He says:

"It is very difficult to avoid, the student being so lost in the beginning and the school set up to emphasize short-term performance. So they tend to imitate what you do as a way of associating with what you say. But what you're trying to do is develop their sensitivities and not your own. I have strong philosophic reservations about what it is we are actually talking about when we use the word morality, but as that word is most commonly used, I would think that the most immoral thing one can do is have ambitions for someone else's mind. That's the crux of the challenge and the responsibility of having the opportunity to deal with young people at such a crucial time in their formation. One of the hardest things to do is not to give them clues -- 'Here, do it this way, it's a lot easier' -- and instead to keep them on the edge of the question."

This question of morality came up yesterday in the instructors' meeting and I'm still tossing around Stamatis's view of moral/immoral instruction. I think his view is different from Irwin's. And I think along Irwin's lines-- and that the moral/immoral question is independent of discipline-- immoral art teaching is like immoral science teaching to me. But to give someone access to a conceptual science idea or even method (say, control-of-variables) - which I think (??) was what Stamatis was saying as the moral issue - is a different kind of thing than giving someone access to an artistic style. Right? That this conceptual story of science is somehow a birthright while understanding abstract art might not be? Not sure...

I'm still convinced that science instruction should be a lack-of-imitation. And that this means a not-fix-it mentality. But I can see more of a gray around around this than I like to admit.

Thursday, August 5, 2010

E2 Day 4 afternoon summary

I believe I have not posted summaries for afternoons 2 or 3, sorry.

This afternoon started with a continuation of the magnets discussion from the morning.  One side of the room (Bellevue colleagues, led by Matt and Lisa) advocated for negative potential energy which increases to zero at infinity, and the other side of the room (primarily Lezlie, Linda, and Mary Sue) argued for the idea that as you keep adding potential energy, it gets bigger and bigger (positively).  They eventually drew two graphs of PE vs. distance, one positive and one negative but both increasing and both leveling out at the top.  In an hour-long argument, which was an absolutely killer interchange IMO, they pretty much came to understand one another's arguments, and decided that in order to choose between the two graphs, they would need to locate an experiment that depended on the value of the PE at a point rather than the difference in PE between two points.  This was all the closure they required.  The discussion was really explosively awesome on multiple levels:  the physics issues, the scientific argumentation that took place, the details of the way the instructor (Hunter) managed the discussion, the different roles taken by the teachers (like when Lisa went all "teacherly" on Lezlie).  Whose dissertation is this??

After a much-needed break, we enjoyed Eleanor's AAPT talk, and then discussed the rock cycle video in preparation for reading that paper and case study tonight.  These felt like pleasant changes of pace.

Paper ideas

Everybody please use the comment space to record ideas for papers you can envision based on what's happening so far.  At this point, it can be directions for analysis rather than actual claims, if you want.  I'll start.

Self-organizing classroom

On Leslie's notion of today being an incredible day, I would like to report a very exhausting (at least for me) 45 minute episode that happened this afternoon. Hunter was drawing a graph on the board, showing potential energy (the upper half in the picture below).


After some initial discussion about representing positive and negative potential energy, Lisa stood up, came to the front of the room and drew the same potential energy graph, but below the x-axis. Next came a very very long whole class discussion about the differences of representing the physics in negative or positive potential energy (whether it be gravitational potential energy or magnetic potential energy). Since I was taking field notes, and was trying to write down what happened in the whole classroom, as well as what happened in the group that I was observing, I couldn't really follow the detailed contents of the discussion. But I realized that the teachers took over the classroom. They really wanted to talk about that. A few people were slamming arguments around other people's heads, it was really fascinating. But the most fascinating thing that I noticed (in light of me still analyzing Monday's ET episode) was Hunter, quietly walking to the back of the room, at some point, completely holding himself back, even having his hand near his mouth (as if to actively prevent himself from speaking). It was just so amazing to see how the classroom was managing itself without an instructor having to intervene somehow. At some very late stage in the discussion, Hunter helped mediate the discussion when there was a gap, and the momentum of the discussion was gone. It was just one of those gorgeous moments where a classroom organized itself and the instructor just stepped back to let it happen. Very impressive...