Thursday, August 5, 2010

Incredible day!

I thought this morning was incredible. The field notes (I prefer "analytic field notes" to convey that they are not even attempting to be unbiased!) --- so --- The analytic field notes are peppered with "great" "awesome" "I love it" and "joyous!"

Some interesting things to note:
  • When does Hunter choose to leave the table? - I feel like it must take incredible self-control to walk away when things are so cool - but he does seem to leave at a time when his leaving is minimally awkward. Maybe he leaves when the right question has been found rather than a right conclusion?
  • Stamatis mentions that there is something that needs to be resolved before moving on (10:30-ish), and this feels like something he has decided by looking from the outside in (knowing the full energy/work story) rather than the inside out (that is, not knowing the whole story and trying to decide how to progress). The group is fine with leaving it unresolved, with the possible exception of Lezlie. What kinds of things would I think "need to be resolved" to "move on" - and what is the imagined trajectory? I think it differs greatly from Stamatis's perspective on this question, and I think it's something that I'm still learning how to navigate - how to ditch the logical path in favor of the organic one.
  • When discussing the Gaussian Gun, my group immediately talks force - it feels like what I would do, too - energy can't help me figure out what should happen (not in a away that would feel like I "get it") - and when I do think of energy I think of wells and steepness and sliding down slopes in a kind of energy space. When I look at that ball fly off I think it was pushed by something stronger than could possibly have been there, and I was to find out how that can be. It actually takes a while before they talk energy and it would be interesting to see what makes them switch. They acknowledge some ookieness with energy (more pot. energy when less force, for example) and do a little reconciling of force and energy, but really begin to tackle the question of where the energy is (field? object? system?). It's a super sophisticated conversation.
  • There are moments of just laughter and joyousness that I noted -- where the kind of fun they're having is real intellectual play, with jokes and ideas -- it would be interesting to look and see if this helps diffuse (defuse?) the tension of argumentation and signal "we're still playing"? It doesn't seem forced, though, it's really just play.
  • There's really something to this Gaussian Gun question - there are intuitive reasons to believe both answers, and figuring out which makes more sense taps into pretty big ideas. I try in my inquiry class to start with complex phenomena that need explaining -- where there's clearly an "I-don't-get-this" going on that can take a long time to unpack into simpler problems that we can figure out. I think it really matters - doing inquiry this way - and we can say that it's the "real world example" or "provides relevance" but I think ti's something else- maybe rigor? knowing that you don't know? but it's also related to the sense of play, I think. Anyway, this Gaussian Gun is great. (was there a worksheet with it? was that helpful?)
  • Joel has a really weird role at the table. He seems to usually interject to teach, asking leading questions rather than genuine questions. There was a period today when I thought he was actually playing around with an idea as he spoke (rather than having figured out the idea) -- and I was sad to see that the group didn't engage with that idea. But I wonder if his role will be shifting soon. Seemed like he might start veering towards playing with ideas aloud.
Anyway, I'm just about to scrap my entire plan for next semester (which starts in 10 days) and try this out-- maybe starting the whole year with the Gaussian Gun.

What representations are best for showing what features?


This morning my group had a discussion about which representations are best for showing which features. They had a really meaty discussion of the content with lots of examples from their classroom and how their kids relate to different representations. And they produced this amazing whiteboard! The black writing lists the features of energy scenarios that they came up with last year as part of the Algebra Project progression (did they remember this list, or look it up somewhere?), and the green writing lists the representations that would be best for each feature and how they show it. I really like that they say that theater shows the evidence because you can infer it from the type of energy.

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Energy 2 Day 3 morning summary (mostly about work and pie charts)

This morning they started out by introducing themselves, where and what they taught, whether they had used any energy theater or anything else from last year in their classes, and how it had gone. Several teachers said that they had used energy theater. Several said they had not (in many cases due to implementing new curriculum and having too much to worry about), but that they intended to this year. A few said they had implemented other aspects of the curriculum, such as the algebra project or PET diagrams. A few had adapted energy theater to other topics.

Then they discussed a series of questions about the Van Heuvelen article on work that they read last night, in small groups and large groups. The most interesting and fruitful question seemed to be one about whether you can represent work with a pie chart. My group suggested different methods, such as having work be a slice of the pie, having work be an extra slice in addition to a whole pie, having separate pie charts for work and energy, or having the pie chart change size as energy is added or taken away. In the end they decided pie charts were not a very good way to represent work. Based on Leslie's comments and the large group discussion afterwards, all the groups were having interesting discussions about this topic. Jake suggested having a plate with empty space around the pie.



Leslie thought the work pie chart discussion was really interesting because they were grappling with the limitations of a representation and when it was and was not useful. I saw this and also how it was example of how it can be really difficult to distinguish between a quantity and the change in that quantity, not just with work, but with velocity and acceleration, flux and change in flux, etc. Hunter went in a completely different direction, I think because he saw the central issue as the difficulty of visualizing/understanding work, and said that this was a perfect lead-in to a discussion of metaphor. He asked them to read a section of Lakoff and Johnson on metaphor theory, to lead into a discussion of what kind of metaphor work is. I don't think they got back to work, but they had a lot of discussion about what kind of metaphor time is, and what kind of metaphor learning is. The teachers really got into the metaphor stuff, much more than I expected.

Energy Theater Propaganda

Here Lisa talks about how she used Energy Theater in her class and it helped a failing student open up and get excited about science:


Instructor-participant hybrid

This is a companion post to Benedikt’s post describing the first-day energy theater for the group he participated in.  I was in Lane’s group, which is sort of significant to say in and of itself because Lane was definitely a central participant.  The other participants were Lezlie, Linda, Mary Sue, Joel, and Liz.  I was supposed to be an “extra” (in the theater sense) but found it very hard to keep my mouth shut – I tried, really I did, but I noticed that Stamatis was behind me and managed to not say anything the whole time, unlike myself, and it sounds like Benedikt achieved restraint also in a way that I did not.  I’ll keep trying.

Lane did a lot to draw the teachers’ attention to the rich physics issues in the scenario (cart oscillating on a spring).  For example, when the teachers had done a frictionless version (no thermal energy transfers) and then were modifying their scene to include thermal energy, Lane asked them to consider when the thermal energy is transferred – constantly all along, or more at certain points in the oscillation?  At the time, I didn’t understand why Lane would think they needed to think about that.  Having heard from Lane later at the instructor’s meeting, I now think that he was acting as neither an extra nor an instructor, but as a kind of a “special participant.”  Participants have the authority to raise physics issues for group consideration, according to their own interest.  Lane thinks that the thermal-timing question is interesting, so, in his role as a participant, he can bring it up.  It’s a little bit of a hybrid role that he’s taking on, though, because Lane knows the answer to the thermal-timing question, so in that sense he’s being an instructor rather than a participant.  This instructor-participant hybrid is something Renee Michelle and I saw a lot in TAs.   We think it originates in a desire to relate to the students and not be too formally “teacherly,” while at the same time giving the students the benefit of their greater expertise.  “Benefit,” in this case, is roughly: an increased opportunity to enjoy the satisfaction of a beautiful, coherent, rich physics model.

I think a problem with the participant-instructor hybrid role is that no matter what the instructor thinks – no matter how modest and friendly one acts – the participants see the instructor as an authority figure, and are at risk of giving over their ownership of the intellectual work to that person.

Tuesday, August 3, 2010

What I observed yesterday morning, while playing silent participant in the energy theater

I was in a group with Valentina, Matt, Lisa, Angie, Camille, Adam, Hunter. Matt immediately took on a very strong, leading role, trying to get people thinking about the physics in the scenario. Most of the teachers took part in the conversation, but Matt was a strong moderator. Hunter, Adam and I held back. On very few occasions, Hunter raised his hand to play "Instructor" and give a little cue. At all of those times, he picked up on something that was just said, asked for clarification or gave a more methodological hint how to proceed. He always emphasized that he does not want to tell the group what to do, he was merely pointing out potential ways of proceeding (Matt for example brought up the issue of simplification the physics in our group, and Hunter stepped back to be the instructor and told us that we could either try to think about everything at once, or do some simplifications, to later add on further details). In general, I was under the impression that Hunter was actively holding himself in the background, that he wanted to support whatever was going on in the group without taking too strong a lead. I remember some funky physics going on (for example, we had a lot of thermal energy going from the spring over to the environment; I think it was as much as was going from the cart to the environment/floor). We also did not talk about other details like, where is the kinetic energy, where does it come from, what does it cause, what causes thermal energy going into the floor? On several occasions, I was tempted to prompt a discussion about some physical details, but I could refrain from doing so because I just wanted to see, in what direction everything would go. At some point, Hunter started to say something, at the same time, Karen started talking, Hunter immediately stopped, and Karen asked if all of us were convinced that our enactment made sense. Hunter silently applauded and told the entire group that he was about to say the same thing (in general, he not only said that he wanted to be open and transparent about everything, he actually was). He also told us that he was very pleased that one of the participants had come up with this prompt for a consistency check. And then, we actually had a defined end of the activity, everyone was pleased, there was agreement in the room that we had accomplished the task, without Hunter having to interrupt anything.

I was only in the room with Lane's group for a small amount of time, I only saw the last couple minutes of discussion and the final practice rounds of the theater, so maybe Rachel can talk more about her impressions in this group, so that we can better compare the two approaches.

Limitations of Energy Theater

I am - as noted - a think-then-talker, so blogging this feels premature, but Sam insisted.

It seems in class we've been discussing some limitations and strengths of various metaphors and representations. So I'm curious about what strengths and limitations of the energy theater you see.

Strengths
  • everyone has to participate
  • enforces a particular ontology that we know to be useful
  • easy to make some new research claims based on this data
  • using the body forces you to take the perspective of energy. (I'm not sure that this is unique to energy theater.)
  • requires some level of consensus that makes participants resolve differences (not sure this is true - or, again, not unique to energy theater.)
Limitations
  • ephemeral - thinking of Latour and the role of inscriptions in creating science, there's a reason we use paper. I think this is the big one for me.
  • there needs to be a 'director' and this might be the person most likely to speak up, rather than the person most likely to work towards consensus and engage everyone's ideas. So while consensus and participation are mentioned above, I don't see this happening in practice. Linda raised a concern that was entertained but not addressed; Joel could easily be replaced with a Cabbage Patch Kid (or other inanimate object).
  • I tell my students that I don't write what I have learned, I write so that I can learn - writing it down helps me figure things out. I can imagine that a similar thing would happen in energy theater with moving bodies around -- it helps you figure it out -- but I would be too reserved to learn this way. I would rather play around with inanimate objects (objects that enforce an ontology but otherwise do not disagree with me or find me stupid). Then discuss those ideas - after I'd had a chance to form some ideas - with others.
  • more mundane: the number of people can be limiting, the difficulty in seeing what everyone is doing simultaneously (when it actually runs I have trouble seeing what's happening)
I'm thinking of maps (Giere) -- no one map is the best (and then I think of Borges) -- a subway map is a terrible representation in cases when a terrain map might be useful, and vice versa. So what's the problem solved by the energy theater representation? What does this access that other representations don't?

I'm not sure I see its advantages as profoundly greater than, say, using dice with energy labels. As noted above, I'm still new to this and not sure how I will feel in a day or two, but since it seems that many of you are really sold on the energy theater representation, I'm curious what advantages you see that I haven't.