Monday, August 26, 2013

Respiration is Degrading

View my Prezi here


This clip is from a whole-group conversation. It is preceded by Steve asking "Is there any other kind of degraded energy besides heat?" The clip begins with Madonna mid-sentence; her complete sentence is, "Madonna: In respiration, the energy contained in the CO2 bonds and your water at the end are not necessarily useful."

Madonna is positing the chemical energy of CO2 and water (the products of respiration) as "degraded energy".

I found support for Madonna's idea in Campbell:

The products store less free energy per mole than the reactants; that fits our colloquial definition of "degraded"=not useful.

It also fits with Rachel's idea of degraded=less of a gradient, I think--because the products store less free energy, there is less of a gradient between them and the products of any future metabolic reaction that might involve them. Glucose is non-degraded--and useful--because there is a big difference in free energy between it and the products of respiration, a metabolic reaction that the cell can carry out. The cell CANNOT carry out a reaction with a similar release of free energy from CO2. But if it could...then the chemical energy in CO2 would be useful.

I got this idea from Campbell, that debunks the biologist's shorthand that "energy is stored in bonds". "It is important to realize that the breaking of bonds does not release energy," as biology teachers, yours truly included, often tell their students. The "stored energy" we refer to, says Campbell, is actually "potential energy that can be released when new bonds are formed after the original bonds break, as long as the products are of lower free energy than the reactants."

 There are a few things I find curious about this explanation:

If the energy "can be released", then why is it not appropriate to call it stored?

With the phrase "potential energy that can be released when new bonds are formed", is Campbell reiterating the potential energy=possible energy misconception?

Can I help myself here by renaming potential energy as gradient energy or difference energy? In that case, the potential energy is not in the reactants, but between the reactants and products. This jives with something I already know about gravitational potential energy, which is that the amount you have is relative to where the "bottom" is.


[00:00:00.00](Steve: Is there any other kind of degraded energy besides heat?
Madonna: In respiration, the energy contained in the CO2 bonds...)
 and your water at the end are not necessarily useful
[00:00:05.10]they're degraded to you, they weren't utilized
[00:00:08.04]you're using your ATP to do work for your body
[00:00:12.23]but the CO2 and the water that is given off
Debra: They're lost.
[00:00:18.00]I don't know--is that degraded energy?
[00:00:21.20]There's still energy in the chemical bonds...
[00:00:28.18]And the same thing with a battery.
[00:00:30.04]In a battery you have movement of those electrons due to a difference in electrical potential or reduction potential
[00:00:41.06]but it's degraded once...
Debra: Well it's the concentration difference that drives it

[00:00:49.01]Madonna: In a copper battery, once that copper has received its electrons and becomes a solid, it's no longer...

[00:00:57.29]Steve: So those are degraded matter. I'm trying to think...
[00:01:00.21]if you've got the carbon dioxide when you're done
[00:01:04.25]it's had the transfer of energy by breaking its bonds
[00:01:12.11]no, reforming more stable, tighter bonds
[00:01:15.10]so they've given up that energy
[00:01:18.07]so now you've got a matter leftover

[00:01:21.14]Madonna: that contains energy

[00:01:24.01]Steve: But does it?
Madonna: Yeah! The carbon to oxygen bonds have energy

[00:01:30.07]Steve: But it bonds at a lower energy than it started
[00:01:33.21](Don makes a "downhill" gesture) It's been degraded.
[00:01:36.12]It's a much lower potential

[00:01:41.01]Brad: The energy density in sugar is higher
than the energy concentration in CO2 and water

[00:01:48.15]Debra: So then it IS coming down a gradient

[00:01:54.10]Madonna: it would be waste energy that you're putting off







Friday, August 23, 2013

I-RISE congress 2013 - Jesper Haglund

Below, I share some of the slides I presented at the I-RISE congress and some reflections along the way.

I am a postdoctor in Science Education at Linköping University, Sweden. Dring my stay in Seattle, I was asked about geography and climate, so I started off with some comparisons:
These overlays comparing the latitudes of Europe and North America show how far to the north Sweden (and also Poland) are located. We thank the Gulf Stream for making our countries habitable.
 
I have experience of recording and analysing video data from my previous research, but never in the organized form that has been developed within I-RISE. While I-RISE records what happens throughout entire courses, I have previously been involved in short interventions only.
There are many commonalities between the lines of research being done within the Energy Project at SPU and in our group at Linköping University. From a science content perspective, we have a shared interest in thermpdynamics, and in particular in concepts relating to its second law, i.e. efficiency and energy degradation. We have also both analysed language in science and science education from the perspective of conceptual metaphor. What I learned most about being an I-RISE scholar, however, was to get to know about the structured approach to qualitative research, involving taking and sharing field notes and making blog posts, so that episodes that had caught one person's attention quickly could be discussed within the group.
 
 
In all, I found my time as an I-RISE scholar a very rewarding experience. Apart from getting to know about the professional development at SPU and the research on its outcome, it provided good opportunities to build networks within the PER community.
 
In addition, I think that the way conceptual metaphor was introduced in E2 and how the participants came to approach the matter holds an interesting story that may be the embryo of a manuscript. In previous research, it has been shown that conceptual metaphor is prevalent in language in scientific discourse and science textbook. However, we have struggled to establish eduactional implications of such analysis. Reactions reviewers and at conferences have sometimes been of the type:
 
“OK, you have found that science language is full of metaphorical language. So what? How can I as a science education researcher or teacher use that?”
 
I think that we have gathered data in E2 which can help us respond to such reactions in two ways:
  • Science teachers find the idea of looking for metaphorical aspects in students’ language intriguing and worthwhile. It may help them analyse the students' thoughts and respond to them.
  • After a brief introduction to conceptual metaphor, some science teachers independently reach the conclusion that we cannot talk about energy without recourse to metaphor (as has been argued in general about language overall by Lakoff & Johnson).
To the best of my knowledge, these arguments have not been put forward before, and may provide a basis for research collaborations in analysing the participants' dialogue and a useful manuscript pitch.


Wednesday, August 21, 2013

Using ET as a reconciliation tool... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 3)

This is the third (and probably last) video from the Lowering ball saga.

Right before this episode, Barbara was explaining her reasoning on how is the energy story while lowering the bowling ball at a constant speed. Her story focuses on the ball having lots of potential gravitational energy at the beginning, and as it is lowered it loses potential energy, which is transformed into kinetic (since it is moving). Since they are working to define the ET they will represent for this scenario, some of the group members let her know that they can not lose energy (since it is conserved), nor can add extra kinetic energy (since it is constant speed). Since the discussion was not leading to a change, they decide to explore Barbara's idea while acting her ET.

**Warning: this video contains some noise in the audio. 
It is 3+ minutes, but I think it has a lot of things to discuss about - meaning: it is worth it!**

[00:00:01.08] Trevor: So if I am potential and somebody is kinetic and we are moving in the air, so this is the beginning right? 
[00:00:08.10] Barbara: Are you the ball or...
[00:00:09.03] Trevor: This (the rope) is the ball, and we are going to ignore everything else just focus on this. As the ball moves down more I have to do something (noise)
[00:00:21.20] Barbara: You changed to kinetic.
[00:00:22.69] Trevor: OK, now don't we have more kinetic energy than we started with?
[00:00:27.28] Krista: So we will be going faster like () it will be dropping faster?
[00:00:30.27] Trevor: We have to be going faster
[00:00:31.26] Barbara: Well you need, the guy is... No because the guy is putting resistance.
[00:00:38.16] Krista: So then we have to include the man our-
[00:00:40.24] Barbara: You use less pot- No, you use less potential and that became kinetic and, and it still can fall so-
[00:00:44.74] Trevor: But where do I (potential) go?
[00:00:49.00] Barbara: To kinetic, and you ended up staying there (the ball).
[00:00:51.26] Krista: But now we have () kinetic energy, because now we are both kinetic.
[00:00:55.11] Barbara: No, they were both potential and they both went to kinetic, that's (Trevor: No) what I am saying.
[00:00:59.20] Krista: So, I think we need more people.
[00:01:01.21] Barbara: Ok, so you have one kinetic, two potential and you all three are potential. No! You need more of your because the three of you- you need five, four.
[00:01:09.22] Krista: Hypothetically, go ahead. Walk us here.
[00:01:12.21] Barbara: Four potential, before it starts lowering. But one- When it's moving say one kinetic, three potential
Trevor: Ok
Krista: Ok, so what happens when 
[00:01:23.04] Barbara: And then one other changes to kinetic. And it still moves past the waist.
[00:01:30.03] Trevor: Are we still moving faster 'cause we have two kinetics, and we started with one?
[00:01:35.05] Barbara: Maybe one can go to thermal.
[00:01:36.19] Trevor: So you think thermal's in the ball?
[00:01:40.28] Barbara: Thermal in the- I don't know where, not in the ball. () in the air...
[00:01:43.02] Krista: Where do I (kinetic) go?
[00:01:44.06] Barbara: Maybe call it in the air. Some kinetic in here (the ball), thermal and kinetic in here. Very simplified.
[00:01:56.22] Barbara: (Maggie is transferred and transform into thermal in the arm) No! We need potential in here (the ball).
**Different voices at the same time**
[00:02:06.29] Emma: So far in the examples we've seen, this is the problem I am having. When we have some kinetic energy and some thermal energy exiting to the air from an object that's usually a really small portion of the energy. And so I am really hesitant to say that of all the potential energy in the ball- 
[00:02:25.17] Barbara: But it still moving when it is here, so you can have kinetic energy in the ball.
[00:02:29.10] Emma: But you can't have more than you started with because the ball speed is constant. So you can't gain kinetic energy, which means you have to be given energy.
[00:02:34.10] Barbara: Well, so what _you_ guys want to do. 
[00:02:39.15] Trevor: I think we need to put these people who are changing from potential to something else have to go into the arm. Because if you ima-
[00:02:46.00] Barbara: Not from the ball.
[00:02:48.22] Trevor: From the ball (Other voices: from the ball).
[00:02:51.24] Krista: Maybe is not a direct path like that kinetic- No, potential. Go ahead.
[00:02:56.07] Barbara: Would you say it again, what you-?
[00:02:57.09] Trevor: So I am saying potential, from the ball, has to go into the arm and I think it's thermal, because the arm doesn't get going faster either.
Emma: Yeah.
[00:03:07.16] Barbara: So the potential from the ball goes into the arm.
[00:03:09.27] Krista: I mean through a chemical process is heating up the arm, not directly-
[00:03:14.28] Trevor: I think it's kind of directly
[00:03:16.26] Krista: I mean, but it is a direct reaction to what is happening (Barbara: the ATP). So it's causing the arm to heat up.
[00:03:24.11] Barbara: And whenever ATP (is hydrolyzed?), it changes the shape of the molecule. That's how the body gets work done. 
[00:03:33.14] Barbara: But you know what, I want to see what- You guys play yours now.

I presented this video in the I-RISE Congress, and basically I could use this video for 10 different purposes. But what I (personally) am more interested of, is how they decide to use the ET as a tool of conciliation with Barbara. Instead of remain in a discussion trying to persuade her (we consider Barbara and the group initially were talking of different things), they decided to understand where is she coming from, and then question her in the blank spot that she has not addressed. I consider this group dynamic shows responsiveness and I can almost see how with the ET performance I can observe the accommodation and assimilation process of Barbara (magic to my eyes). And I simply love how Barbara, after all the questioning they made to her model, the modifications she decide to include, and the addition of new elements, at the end she stills recognize that ET as her own.

Some other issues that we discussed with this episode is how they see thermal energy as the answer to conserve the energy in the system, but they have problems trying to explain where should it go, or why it happens.
ATP shows up again, if it weren't because of KD explanation, I wouldn't be aware of it (long time since I had bio classes). Now I realized that it is a thing while trying to explain the scenarios during E1 and E2, but I could not say if this is a sign that the instruction of the PD should address or if they prefer to simply mention it with no further details (those two positions has been brought up in more than one occasion).
We also noticed the implication of representing kinetic energy as the people jogging. Rachel said she doesn't like it because it allows to mix the substance and level energy ontology. In my personal opinion, I liked it because I was able to see she sometimes tried to mixed both ontology, but she also notices it and go back to her regular pace.

This is the end of the Saga. I share the other links if you are interested in more details, or simply get more information of what happened before.
Conceptual understanding vs Equations (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 1)
Forces vs Energy... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 2)
I-RISE Congress - Lowering at a constant speed

I-RISE Congress - Lowering at a constant speed

Thank you again for such a great experience! I am sharing the slides of the congress presentation.


I am the first I-RISE Scholar coming from México. I show you where I am exactly from.

During High School, in a aptitudinal test they told me I had good aptitudes to go for a exact science carreer or for humanities. In my mind that didn't make sense, how can you mix them both? I decided to study a B.Sc. in Physics Engineering. A couple years after, I discovered there was a PER group in my University and decided to join them. It was in that moment that I realized that there was a way to mix both of my strengths, since then I decided PER is was I would do.

Basically, I started doing my fists steps in PER as an undergrad. Then I decided to go for a Ph.D. in PER, continuing working with Genaro Zavala, now as my adviser. Two summers ago Rachel went to my university for a summer workshop about video analysis. In that moment I decided that was what I wanted to do. I arrived to Seattle on April for a six month research visit to develop my qualitative research skills (my PER group do not use video analysis that much).




Due to time limitations, I could not analyze both days as I planned originally. I wanted to see what were the differences that made one day more productive than the other. Instead I decided to study in detail the second day (more productive than the first). As a clarification, E1 has already worked in ET in previous days, but not during afternoon. So it was the first time I observed them doing ET alive, but not their first time doing ET.

I share the video here, but for more detail please check the post: Forces vs Energy... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 2)
**Warning: There is wind noise in the audio**


I share the video here, but for more detail please check the post: Using ET as a reconciliation tool... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 3)
**Warning: there is also some noise in this one**





As conclusion, thank you for helping me developing my qualitative research skills. I really appreciate having a space where people get engage in this kind of discussions and gives you productive feedback to improve your opportunity areas.I am really wishing I have the opportunity to keep working with this two ET, because I felt I needed more time to finish the analysis.

Forces vs Energy... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 2)

This is the second video from my E1 Afternoon ET 08-09 saga. The group is making agreements on how to make the ET for a bowling ball being lowered at a constant speed. This video is tightly related to the first part of the saga Conceptual understanding vs Equations (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 1).

During E1 they have been talking about forces for more than one day. In this video we observe Cindy making an analogy to try to understand how to represent the opposition exerted by the hand while lowering the ball at a constant speed.

[00:00:00.00] Cindy: If I am pushing against her, all right?
So, I am pushing against her and, but you- you're, you are resisting to the point- You are resisting to the point that I can't move you.
[00:00:10.24] Cindy: Amm, is this kinetic energy?
{different voices from the group saying no}
Trevor: There's no movement
Rob: Weren't you saying (to Barbara), weren't you talking about-
Cindy: () is not moving.
Barbara: So, can I ask a question?
[00:00:17.28] Cindy: So, I am lowering a bowling ball gradually (gestures of the ball being hold by something)
Maggie: -at a constant
Cindy: -at a constant... Do I have an opposite kinetic energy -I am, I am just trying to throw this out there.
[00:00:31.14] Cindy: I don't know what's correct and what is incorrect but, could part of that chemical energy be converted into kinetic energy as well in -in the arm system?
[00:00:44.04] Rob: I was trying - I was having a hard time of exp- verbalizing that, you know? Exactly what you are saying with you resisting so the energy -kinetic energy is going downward and you are pushing back with a _force_ in the opposite direction. But the force is not the same as energy
[00:00:59.19] {different voices of the group agreeing}
Rob: And I... So the energy lose, I am not- So, you know? There is no kinetic (noise) slowing down the kinetic energy. (noise) in the opposite direction.
 Rob mentions he had problems trying to verbalize that, he might refer to the discussion presented on the first part of the saga. In this episode we observe how they realize forces and energy are different, they consider that when a force is applied in the scenario they should represent it somehow in terms of energy. They constantly talk that they are different, but still can't explain the energy story involved in the scenario given with certainty.
[Next episode of the saga: Using ET as a reconciliation tool... (Afternoon ET 08-09 saga - part 3)]

Saturday, August 17, 2013

Stirling engine ET representing energy density

In E2, 130815, Thursday AM, the teachers were asked to enact a Stirling engine in an energy theater. They had been shown the engine the previous morning and started sketching energy diagrams, but had not carried out an ET.

The engine consists of gas contained in a cylinder,separated into two compartments by a styrofoam wall. If you heat the gas in one of the compartments with a hot cup of coffee, it will expand, which moves the separating wall. The wall, in turn, is conncted to a balanced wheel with a rod, so that the wheel starts to rotate when the wall moves. Finally, the wheel is connected to a piston, which compresses the gas in the compartment that was not heated, so that the styrofoam wall returns to its starting position. This closes the cycle of the engine.

I attach the entire ET (25 minutes, three clips), since I think it gives much insight into how the groups gradually developed the idea of representing "energy density" in the form of participants' distance from each other within a particular object. The closer they are to each other, the higher the energy density. This can be compared to another representation, posted by Abby in 2011 (http://scherrenergyproject.blogspot.com/2011/08/shrinking-people-to-represent.html) of people "shrinking" vs. speading their arms, indicating the same amount of energy, but more or less useful to do work.

They enact the entire process in three steps: First, the cylinder starts go get heated, so that the engine starts to move. Then, there is the steady-state operation, where thermal energy goes to surrounding air, driven by a gradient in temperature and different thermal density at the heat source vs. heat sink. Finally, when the coffee has reached room temperature, the engine will stop and thermal energy will be evenly distributed.


 

The notion of "energy density" is found useful by the entire class, including the instructors, and this ET pair of groups is later asked to enact their ET in full class. Energy density contributes to understanding the difference in usefulness of a certain amount of energy in different circumstances.

Another thing to note: Gail is checked out most of the time.

Group 3's energy diagram:



A synthesised energy diagram, when the engine is driven by a temperature gradient between the atmosphere and a pack of ice, based on those of all groups:

Energy is money analogy

In E2, 130815, Thursday AM, they made extensive use of analogies between energy and money, when dealing with loss/waste vs. usefulness. It is different if there are 4 people with $100 each vs. 1 million people with one dollar each, with examples when the rich and poor get to interact.

Leslie came up with this idea: "It's not how lucky I am, it's where I live." In other words, what you can do with a certain amount and form of energy depends on the energy inthe surroundings.

Sture Nordholm has thought more of how to map thermodynamics to money in education:
http://pubs.acs.org/doi/pdf/10.1021/ed074p273.

I like this analogy by Paul Atkins http://www.google.com/books?hl=sv&lr=&id=kJyXzvkXWBAC&oi=fnd&pg=PT2&dq=atkins+galileo%27s+finger&ots=Z_5l1WXMZZ&sig=Ukrtm9TUcfrbpde8uY7YbgGEeKo:
"The analogy I like to use to show the connection [between the interpretations of entropy in macroscopic thermodynamics and statistical mechanics] is that of sneezing in a busy street or in a quiet library. A sneeze is like a disorderly input of energy, very much like energy transferred as heat. It should be easy to accept that the bigger the sneeze, the greater the disorder introduced in the street or in the library. That is the fundamental reason why the ‘energy supplied as heat’ appears in the numerator of Clausius’s expression, for the greater the energy supplied as heat, the greater the increase in disorder and therefore the greater the increase in entropy. The presence of the temperature in the denominator fits with this analogy too, with its implication that for a given supply of heat, the entropy increases more if the temperature is low than if it is high. A cool object, in which there is little thermal motion, corresponds to a quiet library. A sudden sneeze will introduce a lot of disturbance, corresponding to a big rise in entropy. A hot object, in which there is a lot of thermal motion already present, corresponds to a busy street. Now a sneeze of the same size as in the library has relatively little effect, and the increase in entropy is small."