Sunday, June 2, 2013

Group A readings

Reflection on " Representing energy. I. Representing a substance ontology for energy"

I would like to apologize in advance for my writing and ask for some patient. My name is Carolina Alvarado, and this is not my native language but I am trying my best to explain my self as clear as I can. Before starting the analysis I would like to introduce me a little more with you. I am a grad student in Tecnologico de Monterrey, Campus Monterrey (in Mexico), working with Dr. Genaro Zavala. I am currently at SPU collaborating with the Energy Project group for six months.

It was two summers ago (2011) when I met Rachel Scherr. She was invited to give a workshop in my university for physics and mathematics teachers. The workshop consisted in an introduction of how to use video recording to analyze students conceptions. The sessions were not focused on the analysis of energy, but the tapes she brought to the sessions were related with energy.

While I was reading the article I started to recognize some of the scenarios. Then I realized some (or most) of them were presented during the workshop. I worked  with Pablo (a grad student colleague  on the scenario of "Leaves blowing in the street...". During the activity we were encouraged to analyze the data in the way we thought was convenient. We were not previously introduced to the energy ontology, and neither Pablo or me were familiarized with PER literature on energy (our dissertations are not related with energy). After watching the video a couple of times, we decided on focus our analysis on how the students referred to the energy in this scenario. We made a presentation were we show the attributes students were giving to the energy involved in the movement of the leaves while blowing in the street. Now that I read the article, I noticed we were actually referring to the different energy ontology can have.In a way this helped me to build on my research confidence: It made me feel like I have that something that helps to start a research.

Getting to know the ontology of energy, after having that first encounter with its implications, helped me to understand the relevance of it. In the exemplifications given in the article we can observe how the students goes from one ontology to the other. While trying to understand energy as a substance, they use different ontology at the same time, going back and forth. How can you try to understand energy while you can not define how to talk about it?

Reading this first papers allows you to considerate the implication of using each kind of energy ontology. Also, the research considerates the facilities and complications to use different representations in a classroom environment. This first paper definitely facilitates to understand why did the Energy Project came up with a new model to represent energy transfer and transformations. It is in "Representing energy. II. Energy tracking representations" where we get to know the details of energy tracking through embodiment, creative diagrams and use of cubes. I consider that establishing the properties of energy as a substance (instead of changing ontology during the analysis) helps to eliminate certain uncertainty on how to "talk" about energy. As it has advantages (comparing to other representations) it also has limitations. For purposes of conservation of energy and tracking how energy transforms and transfers I consider the strategies proposed in this research are very convenient.

I am really excited to participate in the I-RISE and get to work with new colleagues to develop my skills as a researchers.

Friday, May 31, 2013

Group B reflection

Topic: Energy degradation and dissipation
Articles: “Conserving Energy in Physics and Society” and “Matter Scatter…”

After reading the article, “Conserving Energy…,” my first thoughts were “Do we really want to go there?” and “How in the world do we organize this learning experience?”  Let me back up a moment and fill in a few more details about my experiences with energy instruction coming into this summer.  My Group A post summarizes how I came to energy pies as the focal point of my energy instruction.  The Modeling materials I work from separate the energy unit into closed and open systems.  First we start with the closed system, where everything that is part of an interaction is included in the system.  Therefore, the conservation of energy holds true.  After about two weeks of that, we then shift to open systems.  Now, an agent that does work or has work done to it can be outside of the system.  Energy is not conserved in this case.  Instead, we say that the work done adds to or subtracts from the total energy of the system.  Simply put, in closed systems we don’t talk about work, in open we do.

I thought this was brilliant on paper.  It made perfect sense.  The energy pies were a quick, clean, and simple way to diagram situations.  However, after five semesters following this format, I don’t like parts of it.  Specifically, open systems.  I think that idea confuses students to no end.  In fact, I've slowly been phasing that idea out to focus on closed systems for describing every situation.  This is certainly what is being suggested in this article. 

On one hand, I really like the Energy Tracking Diagram (ETD) depicted here.  It really does a great job of summarizing all of the nuts and bolts.  On the other hand, do ETDs ask for too many details?  Do we really need to follow thermal energy as it spreads to the hand, environment, and spring?  Is it important to have students follow thermal energy everywhere it could possibly go (such as spreading to more and more objects or spreading spatially)?  Or is that losing precious time with “meaningless arguments” about how much thermal is here and how much is there, when there might be a final computation that is a primary outcome, or there might be five other examples I want to look at? 

These are all rhetorical questions, of course.  I've found myself wrapped in conversation with my colleagues for long stretches of time on very similar issues; for instance, a clay ball that is released and “splats” on the ground.  Where does more thermal energy end up, in the ground or in the deformed clay ball?  One of my colleagues and I still don’t agree.  But is that a question I want my students to tackle, or am I simply interested in having them draw an energy pie scenario that goes from gravitational à kinetic à thermal as the ball is released, arrives just above the floor, and hits the floor, respectively?


Finally, my second initial question was “How do we organize this learning experience?”  Rather than taking more time here to answer that, I’d like to see what is done this summer.  I’m quite intrigued by Ross’ “Matter Scatter” article and the notion of starting first thing with the 2nd Law and with a concept like “available energy” or “free energy.”  I’m curious if the directors have found a good sequence.  I’m also interested in experimenting with possible sequences myself.  It may be one of my research interests this summer.  

Thursday, May 30, 2013

Group A reflection

Reflection on “Representing energy. II. Energy tracking representations”

One of the joys of teaching at the University of New England (in southern Maine) is its proximity to the ocean.  With the semester over, I’ve had the luxury of reading these I-RISE articles on the beach.  With the sun now setting, I’ve returned home to write up some thoughts.

First, a brief background on my experience with energy.  Throughout my undergraduate and graduate studies I received traditional energy instruction, i.e. NO diagrammatic representations whatsoever!  Upon my hire at UNE, I participated in a two-week workshop on Modeling Instruction, since all physics instructors at my university work in studio classrooms and utilize the Modeling method.  During week 2 of that workshop, I was exposed to energy pies.  This way of diagrammatically representing energy opened my eyes forever.  For three years I’ve been joyfully using pie charts. 

Therefore, I was taken aback when the article “Representing Energy I” suggested that pie charts are nice but really don’t get the job done.  That was yesterday.  Today, after having a good night’s sleep and reading “Representing Energy II,” I feel open to the Energy Theater, Energy Cubes, and a whole host of new possibilities.  I’ve been asking my students to answer the same questions that are posed over and over again in these articles: where is the energy at the beginning, what is the energy doing, and how does the energy change?  This is a slow process and we take our time.  The discussion takes place in words and then the energy pies are drawn as a conclusion.  All seems well.  However, when exam time arrives, students consistently show that they struggle with any situation that has more than three forms of energy present.  Most students can only handle simple conservation of energy calculations.  Anything more abstract vexes them greatly.  So much for bringing in sociopolitical issues or crosscutting multiple sciences!

I see the Energy Theater (ET) as a way to bring the previously only-in-words discussions about identification and tracking to life.  My only foray into embodied representations has been asking groups of students to “act out” position vs. time and velocity vs. time graphs.  This has always been an activity that students favor.  The possibility of doing the same thing with energy is exciting.  However, I am not yet willing to abandon energy pies.

As I was completing the article and considering Energy Tracking Diagrams (ETD) and energy animations, an activity sequence came to mind.  My classroom has four tables that seat six students each.  I can ask each group of six to choreograph an ET for their given example.  Once they have successfully acted out their ET performance, I would have them design and submit a “write-up,” in this case an ETD (like that shown in Figure 4).  Finally, if there is a numerically solvable variable, I would ask students to simplify the ETD to an appropriate series of energy pies that would enable them to solve the problem.  I feel that the great strength of pie charts is in simplifying a situation to only the most relevant parts.

Frankly, I am just as excited about the possibility of using Energy Cubes, which I felt received short thrift in this article.  I see cubes as a means of creating an energy animation.  Given that at least one student in any group has an iPhone (which I know is true since I ask them to utilize these for video analysis), cubes offer a perfect opportunity for “stop animation” movies.  Using the cubes, they can track energy transforms and transfers on their whiteboard playing field, taking a snapshot of each change.  They can then send 5-10 images to their email, download and enter into Powerpoint (each table has two iMacs), and make a slideshow flipbook.  This eliminates the need for programming skills and puts the students back in control.  I’m wondering if the Energy Project team has seen this approach/activity in the past.

Posted by Brad (for some reason, I do not see my name posted with this entry on google groups)

Monday, May 6, 2013

Existing research themes (2013 edition)


Below are some of the ongoing research interests of the Energy Project. We encourage you to pursue whatever research interests grab you, whether those originate with you or with us. You do not need to pursue any of these during your I-RISE session. However, to prepare for your I-RISE experience, please choose at least one of the following topics, read at least one of the related articles (or another article on that topic that you want to bring to our attention), and post a 500-word reflection on it to this blog.

We are also still interested in the things we were interested in in 2011 and 2012.


Energy degradation and dissipation
Energy conservation is central both in a sociopolitical sense and in the formal study of physics, but the term has a different meaning in each context. In physics, energy conservation refers to the idea that the same total quantity of energy is always present in any closed system; energy is neither created nor destroyed. In the pubic consciousness, however, energy conservation refers to the idea that we have to guard against energy being wasted or used up; the energy available to serve human purposes is both created (in power plants) and destroyed (in processes that render it unavailable to us). We are creating a conceptual model for what happens to energy during physical processes, expecting to eventually include entropy and the second law of thermodynamics.

Content knowledge for teaching energy / Responsive teaching
“Content knowledge for teaching” is the specialized content knowledge that teachers use in practice – the content knowledge that serves them for tasks of teaching such as making sense of students’ ideas, anticipating conceptual challenges students will face, selecting instructional tasks, and assessing student work. "Responsive teaching" is when teachers respond to the disciplinary substance of student ideas as they arise during classroom instruction. We hope to better understand teacher’s practices along these related lines, and also to develop criteria for observational assessment of both of these constructs.



    Relational discourse
    Normal classroom conditions, characterized by evaluation and attention to learning targets, may present threats to students’ sense of their own competence and value, causing them to conceal their ideas and reducing the potential for proximal formative assessment. In contrast, discourse patterns characterized by positive anticipation and attention to learner ideas increase the potential for proximal formative assessment and promote self-directed learning. Excerpts and reflections on this blog: General approach. Carl Rogers on education parts I, II, and III. Example of relational discourse among learners. Application of theory to classroom observation.

    Forms of energy Our primary learning goal is for learners to conserve energy as they track its transfers and transformations among objects. Another learning goal is to coordinate our theoretical model of energy with observable properties of objects. One way we do this is by categorizing energy into forms that correspond to types of observable evidence of energy.

    Sunday, October 28, 2012

    Tales from a Secondary Implementation of ET: Part II

    Hi again,

    In a previous post, I discussed some of the principle benefites and possible limitations that might be associated with using ET as an instructional tool within the context of a mathematical college physics course (specifically an algebra-based course). I also detailed my experiences in leading my students through the first four steps of Moses' algebra project (Field Trip, Pictorial Representation, People Talk, Feature Talk). In this post I will discuss my experiences over the next two classes during which I formally introduced my students to Energy Theatre.

    The Five Questions:

    As I mentioned, I opened up Friday's class by readdressing the 5 questions developed during "feature talk." After reviewing these questions while writing my previous blog post, I realized that many of them (e.g. "what forms of energy are there?", "is energy being transferred?", and "where is the energy located?") were not a far cry from the questions that we might expect an expert or "good student" to ask during a formal energy-based problem solving session. Thus I decided to use these questions as the basis in which to anchor a mathematical analysis the way to bridge ET to the mathematical representation.

    As part of their homework, my students had to come up with a complete description of a mousetrap cart using their 5 questions as a guide. By framing the previous night's homework as a test for their questions, I was able to lead a fairly meaningful discussion on what might need to be altered. Section C, for example, decided that "what does energy do?" wasn't terribly helpfull. Meanwhile, section B decided that "is energy being transferred?" should be spun off into "is enery being transformed?" By keeping track of the alterations that each section made, I hoped to instill a sense of ownership in my students.

    I opened thenext full day of ET by again readdressing my students' 5 questions. Now that my students had had some experience in ET, I asked them to begin brainstorming, for each question, what types of answers they might expect. All three of my sections had previously generated a question along the lines of "what types of energy are there?" and I had them use this as a starting point. The result of this brainstorm was a list of different types of energy (e.g. kinetic, potential, spring, thermal, chemical, etc.). My sections also all had questions along the lines of "how would we measure the energy?" this question was used to generate a list of possible evidence for the different types of energy (e.g. is there movement? temperature? stretching or compressing springs? etc.).

    With these lists in hand, I pointed out that they could also be used to address some of the students' other questions (e.g. "how much energy is there?", "is energy being transformed?", etc.). Again, by having my students continually refine their questions, I was bringing them to a point where they would be able to conduct a mathematical analysis with real teeth.

    The Theatah, The Theatah

    After our initial reassesment of the 5 questions, I introduced ET and we spent the rest of the day performing ET for the mousetrap cart. The students in my classes had been working in groups of 3-4 up until this point, but I merged the groups in each section into two super groups of roughly 12 students each (my smaller section had 9 each). Some groups were able to finish by the end of class while others needed a few minutes at the beginning of the next to finish.

    On the second day of using ET, I gave my students three new situations: My pushing a 2 kg weight across a rough, horizontal surface at constant speed; An activated heat pack; and an activated cold pack. This final situation turned into a homework assignment for the students to practice using Energy Tracking Diagrams. Having spent the first day working out what exactly this ET thing was, my students took to these new situations rather easily.

    The bigest difficulty that I encountered was getting my students to figure out exactly what I was asking of them. One group, for example, tried to create a sequence of "pictures" where the ropes represented an initial state and a final state. They kept the number of students constant, but each student was only featured in on "instant."  I also had to push many of the groups to come up with ways of distinguishing different types of students (kinetic, thermal, etc.). While many groups figured out different types of movement (my favorites were miming a chemist pouring chemicals for chemical energy, and jumping up and down for kinetic energy), some simply called out "I'm kinetic energy." One group tried to use different regeons within their rope loop to indicate that they were different typed of energy.

    A further difficulty which I am beginning to notice now that we are fully involved with mathematical representations is the fact that ET (and ETD's) track the full "trajectory" of energy, while standard mathematical approaches only look at the initial and final states. I'll readress this point as I discuss bringing ET into math. I'm not sure how this will present itself on a mathematical analysis level, but many of my students have expressed some confusion about relating energy tracking to the mathematical statements, dispite being largely able to handle the math.

    One logistical difficulty that I encountered was that there were too few of me. Since I had devided my class sections into two groups each, one had to perform out in the hall while the other used the class space (there were too many desks for both to be in the class). While I was able to wander back and forth and ask probing questions about the energy flow and about the ET representation, I got the distinct sence that the group whom I was not immediately attending to were busy in off-topic discussions. This seemed not to be a large issue during the I-RISE since there were three instructors, as well as many observers who functioned as authority figures. The in-service teachers also had a more developed sense of focus and responsibility.

    Once my students got the hang of ET, they were able to easily act out the additional situations of the heat pack and pushing the weights. Many of them also told me that they enjoyed the activity and one asked from where I got the idea!

    Energy Tracking Diagrams

    On the second full day of ET, after my students had acted out the first two ET situations, I introduced them to Energy Tracking Diagrams. Since this was yet a further abstraction of energy flow (an abstraction of an abstraction, really) I demonstrated ETDs for the first ET situation which my students had just enacted: my pushing the weights. I then had my students create ETDs for the heat pack. For homework, I had them create ETDs for the cold pack.

    Two immediate benefites I found with ETDs was the ability to "homework-ize" energy theatre and the ability to have students work in smaller groups while still doing an ET-like activity.

    Beyond these benefites, however, I found that my students actually had more difficulty with ETDs than they did with ET. Specifically, they were confused about how to represent the object, how to break a complex process into a few descrete stages, how to synchronize energy transformations with energy transfers in their diagrams, and which pieces of energy turn into other pieces of energy ("does K turn to T or is it the C that turns to T during this step?"). Many of these issues did not present themselves during ET. Another difficulty which I observed was that, while conservation is a built in consrtaint in ET, my students were very casual with the number of energy letters in their energy tracking diagrams.

    In the end, while ETDs bring many benefites, I felt that spending time coaching their proper use would detract too much from the time I wanted to spend building up a mathematical formalizm. While ET provided a great kinesthetic introduction to energy and energy flow, ETDs seemed to add too much complexity. Perhaps there is a way to succesfully and meaningfully integrate these into a math-based-physics curriculum, however at the moment am not able to.

    Bridging ET to Math

    I closed out the second day of using ET by formally introducing the law of conservation of energy (Del_E = W + Q + Other energy inputs). I built up to this by generating a law for the conservation of students (Del_N = #Students who cross over a piece of rope). With this equation in hand, it was only a small jump to energy conservation.

    The next difficulty was to introduce definitions of Work and Heat and to introduce the mathematical formulations of the varyous energy forms. This was one of the major points of departure from ET; while the theatre could only represent kinetic energy, say, as a group of students making running motions, in a mathematical representation we have to use a particular formula.

    Over the next few days, I continued to draw upon the list of questions which the students developed and refined over the course of the week as a basis for mathematical analyses. When I and other expert problem-solvers approach problems from an energy standpoint, we generally have a list of questions we  try to address: "what is the system?", "what elements of the system are associated with energy?", "are any of these changeing?", "Is energy being transferred to or from the surroundings?", "if so, how?", "Are there convenient initial and final states to choose?", etc. Each of these questions addresses an aspect of setting up a mathematical solution and many of them were questions which the students needed to address when performing ET. Thus, while the conservation of students inherrant in ET makes an excellent conceptual bridge to a mathematical representation, the act of addressing these questions makes an excellent bridge of practice to using math.

    Finally, I mentioned before that one other point of departure from the ET and ETD representations of enery and the mathematical representation is that ET and ETDs attempt to track the full "trajectories" of energy while the cannonical mathematical approach only looks at initial and final states. Again, my students haven't displayed any problem-solving difficulties apart from the standard abilities of this particular population, however some have expressed confsion about this point on a recent "quiz" question "list one thing that you're still confused about."

    Some final thoughts:

    Overall, I thought my students liked doing energy theatre. Two things that I feel that they have very clearly gotten out of it is a more tangible sense of conservation, and the idea that energy can change forms. Once I begin to discuss energy dissipation and efficiency, I hope to use the fact that students in ET tended to spread out and become thermal. This was an effect that some of my students explicitly pointed out to me and, I suspect, others noticed as well.

    Friday, October 19, 2012

    My experiences at I-RISE and what I observed

    My final presentation, at long last:

    I examined when the teachers acted as expert knowers and expert learners.

    My patronus is a lynx and I'm awesome at saving scared people with it.

    A bit about little old me.

    These are my assumptions about I-RISE.

    Why I think all of these good things happen in I-RISE. It's all about letting teacher engage in the creation of knowledge.


    There are a variety of mechanisms that lead to the creation of these positive experiences.

    So what do I really mean by expert knowers and learners? This is my operationalization of the terms.

    My analysis of I-RISE is based in the concept of communities of practice.

    Additionally, distributed cognition helps to inform my analysis of the cognition that occurs in I-RISE.

    How tools can transform cognitive tasks.


    My analysis specifically examined interactions between Akbar, Sarah, Nicole, and Jessica.

    The idealized version of what I felt I had observed.

    The relationship I hoped to find between teacher roles and the progress of their model building.

    What I actually saw all four teachers doing.

    A look at just the two teachers that I believed to be the most influential or telling of the group activities.

    The three segments in time which I decided to focus. I felt that when one person deferred to authority that the others in the group stopped co-creating knowledge and primarily became passive listeners.

    First I wanted to share an early time clip in which the primary deferrer to authority leaves the group and we see the group engage in productive co-creation of knowledge.









    Summary: I-RISE Rocks


    Thursday, October 18, 2012

    Gina's Congress Presentation

    Here are the slides and video from my I-RISE Congress Presentation.  My apologies for taking two months to get these up.


     During my two weeks at I-RISE, I explored how the rules of Energy Theater affected teachers' representations of energy.

    To start off my presentation, this is my spirit animal- a baby panda!

    I attended I-RISE in the transitional summer between undergraduate and graduate studies.  I came in with some experience in interaction analysis and discourse but I still had a lot to learn.  

    I am generally interested in the studying the many facets of how students experience their physics classes.  In particular, I enjoy studying open-ended, constructive learning environments like I-RISE.

    I looked at the rules of Energy Theater and how they mediated the teachers' discussions about designing energy representations.

    In this first clip, teachers are negotiating about their energy theater for a mousetrap car.  We see that rules play an important role here.  They first acknowledge that they are breaking representational rules.  Later we see that they realize they are not one unit of energy, which violates conservation of energy.  


    In the next clip, the teachers are drawing out the energy story for the Gaussian Gun.  They are attempting to reconcile their knowledge that a small amount of energy is dissipated with the rule that energy can only exist in equal sized chunks.



    Rules and norms came up in other areas as well.  With more time, I would have explored how Todd got the class on board with the MFer representation for the Gaussian Gun.  It would have also been interesting to study rules and rule-breaking of the social responsibilities outlined on the first day of class.  

    In conclusion, I-RISE was awesome!