Thursday, August 16, 2012

Transformation as shape shifting

Leslie mentioned that yesterday morning (8/15/12) in E2, Christine brought up different analogies for transforming and transferring energy and talked a lot about shape-shifting. This is extremely relevant to my work with forms, where we've been talking about which analogy to use for forms. We prefer to think of energy changing forms as changing its shape, but others (e.g. Eric Brewe) like to this of it as changing its carrier, as in moving from being in a cup to being in a bowl. I don't have time to go back and find the video right now, but I did find the relevant section of the field notes, and am copying it here for future reference. It sounds like a great discussion, and I am excited to watch the video. One thing I notice from the field notes is that it sounds like they are differentiating transformation from transfer by thinking of the former as changing shape and the latter a moving from one place to another. It seems like using a carriers model would make this differentiation more difficult.

These notes were taken by Abby, Ben, and Gina. If any of you have comments on what was happening here, let me know.

Also, this clip is from a whole group discussion following small group discussions. Christine's group didn't have a microphone, but Leslie was talking to them and is pretty sure that they didn't discuss this in their small group. Christine is bringing it up for the first time here.

Field notes:

10:05am
Christine: I am wondering if there is contorted energy - energy is contorted and its based on how much resistive force is in the environment. Contorted energy is continual and cyclic.  For example, the ball and magnet - MPE is the contorted energy. {I like the idea of contorting energy} (I don't get it) {transformation and force, kind of mushed together, I think}
....
Akbar: would that contortion be a transformation then?
Christine: When you put soemting in a mold and it takes that shape over time. It's an analogy. I don't think energy is linear.
MA: do you think energy has shape then? 
Christine: no, maybe Leslie can help with an analogy. 
Dean: ...
Jessica: How is that different than elastic energy? 
C: Maybe you can help me find a different word.
MA: They did something more crazy then just transfering energy.
Christine: energy can change its shape somehow - 
Chris: type? 
SV: Shape shifters?
Christine: Yes!
...
10:11 A: I like what you're saying. I'm just trying to figure out how that would be different in meaning. Like we're trying to put on transformed. When I think of transformed I'm thining of energy and I'm thinking of... I see it in that same way. I'm just trying to equate, why was there a need to use a different term out side of transformed.
Christine: when I think of transfer I think of being from one object to another and transform being in one object.
Leanna: We could have a steel bb above the earth and the environment coudl give it it's energy.
Christine: it's like the contorted energy is what starts it.

Building a group idea

This episode comes from Table 2 on the morning of Day 7, just before the 45 minute mark in E1 120814 1202 T2.  The group has been working on the Gaussian Gun for a few minutes and is trying to figure out if the magnetic energy of the magnet decreases as the ball moves towards the magnet.


Transcript

Mary: Well if it’s giving, if it’s transferring some of it’s (or this?) energy into the ball wouldn’t you have
           to say it’s lost the energy?  Otherwise it would be like a source of endless energy.
Julie: Right.  Right.
Mary: Cause some of it is going into the ball so it has to lose some.
Julie: Unless there’s some sort of energy created by the joining of two charges. [Sid about to speak]
          So [Sid stops] if this one needs this one and the create something “bigger” [Sid nods] than
          what they are individually.
Lane: Are you saying energy that wasn’t there before?
Julie: Energy...
Mary: The only way it could do that is if it got cold right there [gesturing where marble and 
          magnet collide]
Julie: Right...
Lane: It must be thermal!
Julie: It’s always heat!
Mary: It’s always...
Julie: I don’t know...
Sid: But this this magnet right, if this is here [touches magnet and ball together] and then I take this
        away [pulls ball away]
Julie: It still has energy [pointing at magnet]
Sid: It still has magne---tism [Julie nods, ‘yeah’]... right?
Julie: Right.  It hasn’t lost anything in the transfer.
Sid: It hasn’t lost it’s power of magnetism [Julie nods, ‘right’]... right?
Julie: Maybe maybe it’s like you’re saying [pointing at Mary] that it’s it’s not like a battery or
         something that loses energy.  It always has a certain amount it just gives.. something to the steel
         ball.
Mary: Shares it.
Julie: Shares it... I don’t know.

Discussion
The thing that strikes me about this episode is the productivity of the discussion and the way the group arrives at the idea of the energy being shared.  At no point in the discussion do I feel like any one member contributes the key idea.  Rather, the idea of energy sharing emerges naturally from the group as a whole.  In the video I see two sorts of moves happening that support the building of a group idea: Mary, Julie, and Sid support each other sharing ideas and they build on these ideas in a way that always moves the discussion forward.

There is a lot of thinking out loud and tentative language in this discussion.  All of the words and gestures in blue show support and engagement with each other's ideas.  Whether it's verbally saying 'right' or a small nod during a pause, these moves indicate that the listener is valuing the speaker's contribution and encourages the speaker to continue when she might otherwise abandon her idea or feel like she isn't able to communicate her idea to the group.

The words in red are all moves to build on each other's ideas and to keep the discussion moving forward.  Rather than rejecting Julie's idea about a new energy coming out of the magnet meeting Mary offers a condition (not currently met) in which Julie's idea would work.  In response Julie simply says "Right", she does not say "never mind" or "forget it".  Both Mary and Julie's responses keep the conversation moving forward as opposed to throwing an idea away and starting over again.  I interpret the "But" at the start of Sid's comment to be partially validating Julie's idea.  Sid is sort of saying 'But- here's an observation that seems to support Julie's idea that the magnet does not lose magnetic energy.'  This brings Julie right back into the conversation and Julie offers a new idea, explicitly attributing some of it to Mary.  Julie starts to trail off as she is unable to identify the "something" that gets transferred.  Rather than rephrasing any of Julie's statement Mary simply completes it by introducing the idea of sharing energy.  Mary also says shares "it" rather than shares "energy".  Saying "it" attributes the it (energy) to Julie (in the discussion that follows it's clear that the group is talking about energy being the thing that is being shared).


Wednesday, August 15, 2012

Those are some attractive MFers

Best put by Stamatis, "We did not expect to see this." Todd's idea of the MFers is very interesting. Especially seeing that it evolved from a simple task like energy theatre, and that Todd is a geology and space teacher with no background in physics.
MFers Energy Theatre
[Todd gets the attention of the classroom.]
Todd: So these ropes represent places in space. This rope (bottom left) is next to the magnet with nothing in it except for these MFers. Uhh... This (middle rope with Leslie) is the magnet and ball B together. That's what Leslie is, she's the magnet and ball B.
MA: Then what's the rope?
Todd: That's where she is.
MA: Okay.
Bruce: (off screen) So wait. Leslie represents the magnet and ball B?
Todd: Yes.
Bruce: Okay.
Leslie: We now represent objects.
Todd: Yes, and Stamatis (top right circle) is ball C and this is the space he is in. Okay, and I'm going to be the ball A, and all of these people are also things. They are magnetic forces, MFers. And they're very, very small, tiny MFers-
Akbar: Okay.
Todd: -that you can't even see and that we don't know exist for sure.
[MA says something to Akbar--not audible.]
Todd: And their movement causes a magnetic force. So their energy is the magnetic force.
[Todd gets the MFers to begin moving in an elliptical motion.]
MA: Is this the field that we're seeing happening?
Todd: Yes.
MA: Ahhh, okay.
Todd: I'm ball A and they're just going to keep moving.
MA: So are they like gravitons?
Todd: Yeah. And they never stop moving, and as far as we know they don't ever slow down... or speed up.
MA: They just go the amount they go.
Leslie: And the reason you say that is because the magnet doesn't get any weaker or stronger because you came by, the ball.
Todd: Right. So somebody placed me here and I start to get pulled in.
Akbar: Like a vortex.
Todd: And I get faster and faster and __[not audible]___ till I slam into this magnet.
Akbar: Sling-shot.
Todd: And kinetic wave energy is then vibrating through and passed over as.... kinetic energy to ball C and then goes out.
MA: And what happened to you Leslie? What are your roles -on your paper-?
Leslie: This one is thermal and sound.


As the teachers talk about these MFers, gravitons are brought up. The teachers do not fully understand gravitons. They do not know what they look like, how they act, or how they are made, but the teachers know that when dealing with gravity they are the things that grab onto objects and pull them into a center point. And the teachers use this knowledge to better understand Todd's ideas of the MFers. They are things that grab onto magnetic objects and pull them towards a magnet.
And a very good analogy that Sam used was, "It's like a scholarship that is set for only a certain race and gender. When non magnetic things come by they just don't get the scholarship money." If nothing else, Sam contributing to class is note worthy.

Rance

Rule Breaking Pt 2- Thoughts about the Rule Enforcer

Brian F. and I had some great discussion today unpacking a lot of thoughts about rules in ET.  I'll preview another instance of rules playing a role in the discussion of how to represent energy tracking diagrams.  This occurred yesterday afternoon.

Background and Summary:
Jessica, Bruce, Melanie and Leanna have just drawn the force diagram for ball A of the Gaussian gun.  Leslie asks them to diagram energy transfers for the ball and check this against their claims.  The group decides that A interacts with magnet and environment.  Jessica asks about the energy in the magnet of the gun. The group agrees that there is nothing (they change their mind on this later, which is super interesting but I won’t talk about it here).  Then they start talking about the impact of the ball on the environment and decide that the interaction is negligible, though they do understand that sound and heat are converted from MPE.  They try to resolve this knowledge that there is some energy transferred without breaking the rules of ET but then they ultimately decide not to include this in the diagram.  Fun fact- Jessica is the one who brings up the “rule-breaking” and she was the one who prompted the “rule-breaking” discussion from before. 
  



Transcript- starts at the discussion of the environment around 0:30
Melanie: We said before impact on environment is negligible...
|Leanna: Mmhmm
|Bruce: Yeah
Melanie:...but that would be the only thing that maybe has something because there's some small amount of sound and some small amount of...
Bruce: You could right that in tiny letters... A fraction of MPE's going over as- as thermal and sound.
Jessica: You broke the rules of energy theater
Bruce: Then screw it, (hands hit table) forget it, it's so insignificant then it's not worth a full MPE
Jessica: Maybe nobody will notice if you make it small enough
Bruce: (laughs)  We would write it if this weren't breaking the rules. Therefore we're only kind of writing it..
Leanna: Can we agree this is in space or in a vacuum?
Jessica: Yeah, get rid of that, we're in space.
Leanna: In one case we can also get rid of this though.
Bruce: Yeah, I don't think we should just move to space but at the same time, we should just say, negligible- just forget it.
Melanie: We haven't put it in anywhere else
Bruce: Yeah we haven't put it in anywhere else we decided... yeah
|Jessica: We should not move to space because life gets very difficult down here when we move to space
|Bruce: Yeah...Oh god.

Discussion
It is interesting here how the rules mediate the discussion about the representation in several ways.  "Maybe nobody will notice if you make it small enough." I found this super interesting- for what purpose would we want to write it so small then?  Is it that the teachers want to still be accountable to their own knowledge that this small energy transfer exists but do not want to be called out by the audience?  Here, they are recognizing how ET rules can be limiting.
Another fun instance is when they start playing with the idea that the gun is in a vacuum or in space. This would allow them to erase the "environment" bubble and frictional energy lost.  This was an instance of the rules having a ton of influence- it led the teachers to go so far as to modify the situation to be consistent with the rules.  I thought this was interesting because the situation comes from the real-life experiment, yet they were willing to follow the rules at the expense of the situation.
Finally they decide to drop the heat transfer completely.  It is important that they are understanding and making explicit the assumptions and simplifications that go into the representation.  They are aware that their representation is incomplete, but the incompleteness is sanctioned by the rules.

Brian and I discussed the authoritativeness of the rules and how the rules can be enforced through people and the audience.  I plan on exploring further the power relationship between rules and the teachers.  Specifically, how rules influence the discussion, as well as how rule-breaking can be an act of transgression.

Attending to Student Ideas in order to Assist

In a previous post, I brought up an episode in which Stamatis observes a group of teachers discussing "electron repulsion" as a mechanism for Normal Force. Others in the group had suggested that perhaps normal force is something we just "made up" to balance gravity. In that post, I claimed that the teachers' conversation is what leads Stamatis to begin pursuing an instructional sequence consistent with many aspects of "Clement's Bridging Analogy".

Clement's Bridging Analogy

In Clement's Bridging Analogy paper, the instructional sequence for the Normal Force is outlined in the following way:

#1 The target question of whether the table exerts a force on book is introduced
#2 The anchoring situation of a hand pushing on a spring is introduced 
#3 Similarities and differences between the two situations are discussed
#4 Several bridging cases are introduced (book on foam, book on a flexible board)
#5 Discussion of similarities and differences continue
#6 The teacher introduces microscopic model of table as made up of atoms connected by spring
#7 Teacher demonstrates the bending of table using a laser and mirror.

In my mind, the bridging analogy provides two important things:

(1) It provides a plausible mechanism for how a table can possibly exert a force. Making sense of this mechanism involves reconceptualizing the table as being comprised of tiny stiff springs.
(2) That sense of mechanism has empirical consequences–we should be able to detect compression in the table. This provides support for the idea that the table exerts a force without relying on notions of balanced force.

Background for Episode

Nicole is the teacher who kept bringing up with her group the question of why there is a normal force on the book. In this case, the teachers already were in agreement that there is a normal force, and Sarah had even introduced an argument for why, which centered around an intuitive notion of balance:
"Just going back to the basic idea that the cup isn’t falling through the table. So we know there’s a force on the cup. So it’s almost like this is made up as like there has to be something countering it, so we’re gonna make it up."
Stamatis revoices Sarah's argument in the following way (although he doesn't attribute it to her):
"It seems to me that somebody says. So. One kind of reasoning, a logical reasoning, that says, Look I’m committed to the idea–for what reasons is a different story–that something that isn’t moving must have a balanced force. And so, if I have this force [pointing to gravitationally downward force drawn], and I believe that the force is there– the downward pulling of the earth–then I must invent a force that point upwards."
After revoicing the argument, Stamatis asks the teachers to set this reasoning aside for the moment, and asks if there might be any other lines of reasoning/evidence that would suggest there is should be a force exerted on the marker from the table.

I think to make sense of Stamatis' role in this group up until this point, we might think about Stamatis as an identifier of learners' needs. He has closely attended to their ideas and question concerning the normal force, and has identified within those ideas a need for a mechanistic account of normal force. He has been quietly attentive this whole time. When he joins in, he re-voices some of the ideas and question that they do have, and because he has identified specific needs, he begins pursuing a line of reasoning with them that will help them address that need. In that sense Stamatis is also in the role of being a provider. I suppose another way of conceptualizing Stamatis' role in this group is as diagnostician/prescriber. He has diagnosed that the teachers lack a mechanism or evidence for normal force; and he has prescribed the normal force bridging analogy.

A claim might be something like: Stamatis at first attends to student contributions in order to identify needs and/or diagnose issues. Some evidence that he attended to student thinking is that he re-voices Sarah's argument, and that asks teachers to set aside this reasoning and consider another line of reasoning. In the episode below, however, I want to claim that when Stamatis begins pursuing the Bridging Analogy, he shifts to a new way of attending to the teachers' contributions. Rather than listening in order to identify needs or diagnose, Stamatis attends to teachers contributions for the purpose of helping them through that sequence. This changes drastically both his role in the group and the way he responds to their contributions.

The Episode

So, here is about a 2 minute clip from a part of the larger episode. In this clip, I want to focus on the ways in which Stamatis responds to teacher contributions. There are three contributions that I'll draw our attention to:
  • Dean suggesting they could try to create a scenario in which normal force exists without gravity
  • Nicole and Dean suggesting you know your finger exerts a force when holding the marker because you (i) have to keep pushing and (ii) you are feeling the pressure
  • Nicole suggesting that you know that the spring exerts a force because the marker has observable motion in response to force (rebounding)
In each of these cases, Stamatis doesn't seem to take up the their ideas; however, I think there is evidence that Stamatis is attending closely to their thinking. My claim is that he does not take up their ideas as contributions because he does not see their ideas as helping with the instructional sequence he is pursuing. The bridging analogy replaces the table with a spring; it does not get rid of gravity. The bridging analogy focuses on evidence of compression, not evidence of feeling. The bridging analogy focuses on evidence of displacement downward, not evidence of rebounding upward. Each time, Stamatis' response to their contributions is to redirect the teachers' attention to a new scenario, one that I think he hopes will get the instructional sequence moving forward in the way he understands its function.


Here is the Transcript

SV:     What I’m saying is that this is based on the idea that I must invent a second force–
N:        Right
D:        Right
M:        Mm-hmm
SV:      And what I’m saying is, can I have an independent line of reasoning that does not depend on the, “There has to be a second force.”
N:        Yeah, I don’t know.
SV:      So… let’s think about this… from another perspective
D:        Create a scenario where you don’t have this [gravity], but this [normal] somehow shows up.  [Laughs]
S:        Yeah.
SV:      So that could be the case, OR, I could actually start from a scenario where I know that there is a force.
D:        Which one? This one here?
SV:      No, no.
D:        I’m sorry. I’m sorry. I’m sorry. [Hands up, “my bad” gesture]
SV:      I start with a scenario with a marker that I know there is a force exerted on the marker, and then I can actually make modification [gesturing] of that scenario until I get to the table,
D:        Mmmmmmm
SV:      And if I believe that so… [pointing to Nicole who is holding a marker] Do you, in that situation, do you believe that you, your skin, is exerting a force?
N:        Yes.
SV:      OK. What evidence do you have for that?
N:        Cause I have to–I have to push to keep [gesture] the marker from moving.
D:        Also, there’s a sense in which you can feel [gesture] the pressure
M:        Yeah, that’s what I was going to say
N:        Well wouldn’t that be evidence that it’s pushing on me?
[silence]
N:        or No?
D:        [unintelligible]
SV:       [Takes marker from Nicole] So here is a situation. Suppose that I do not start from that scenario, but I start from a scenario where I take the marker and I put it on a spring.
N:        Oh.
SV:      So I put it on the spring [pantomime], and it goes… “boing!”, right?
Many:  Right
SV:      So do I have any evidence that the spring is exerting a force on the marker, in that case?
N:        When it comes back up, it pushes on it and makes it move.
D:        Right.
SV:      If I substitute the marker with my finger, will I have any evidence that the spring is pushing on my finger?

Digesting the Episode

A few things stand out:

First, Dean suggests that they might look for a scenario in which normal force exists and gravity does not. This seems reasonable in the sense that Stamatis has told them to pursue a line of reasoning that won't involve the balanced forces argument. The bridging analogy doesn't have this as the next step, so if Stamatis is pursuing the bridging analogy script, he is unlikely to take up this contribution. Stamatis responds by saying, "So that could be the case, OR, we could start from a scenario..."

Second, Stamatis asks the group what evidence they have they their skin is exerting a force. Dean and Nicole offer different contributions–both about how they know there is a force based on *feeling*. Nicole seems to suggest you having to exert yourself, and Dean says you can feel the pressure. The bridging analogy I think involves pursuing evidence from visible compression, not feeling. In response to these contributions, Stamatis takes the marker from Nicole in order to introduce another situation.

Third, now with the scenario of the marker on the spring, Stamatis asks about evidence. Nicole doesn't offer up the evidence based on compression. Instead, she offers up the idea that the spring will cause visible motion (rebounding). In response, Stamatis again changes the situation. Stamatis replaces the marker (which might rebound), with your finger, which you can hold still while having the spring compressed. Stamatis now asks the question again, "what evidence?"

In that sense, Stamatis has moved the group from Step#1 in the bridging analogy to Step #2.

Attending to Student Ideas–For what Purpose?

I think there is pretty good evidence here that Stamatis is attending to student contributions and using those contributions in order to make improvised instructional moves. Let me be clear: one kind of way that teachers might attend to student contributions is to evaluate those ideas in terms of correctness. That is not what Stamatis I think is doing here. I think Stamatis is attending to student contributions in terms of their propensity to keep them moving along a particular instructional sequence–the Normal Force Bridging Analogy. This instructional sequence requires that certains ideas and argument come into being, and certain kind of scenarios be considered. Within that instructional sequence, Stamatis is monitoring and adjusting in order to keep the conversation "on track." This kind of attending to student thinking was preceded by a period of time in which Stamatis was attending to student ideas for the purposes of "identify needs and then providing for those needs" or "diagnosing issues and prescribing." (Neither of these metaphors feels quite right to me; the first one doesn't convey my sense of Stamatis's expertise, and the second one doesn't convey his caring. Maybe together they give you some sense of how I see it.)

Why do we say energy is in the field?

Leslie asked me a physics question a couple days ago that I didn't know how to answer, and I am still thinking about it, so I'm posting it here for others to ponder.

Why do we say that electric/magnetic/gravitational energy is in the field, when the energy is actually in the interaction between two objects, and the field is the thing we define to eliminate the second object and therefore does not include the interaction? In other words, the electric energy term has a q^2 in it, to include the electric interaction between two charges, but the electric field term only has a q in it because it only includes one charge. You can have an electric field even if you have only one charge that is not interacting with anything. But do you have electric energy is you have only one charge that is not interacting with anything? I don't think so. If this were true, the energy would be in the individual charges (or spread around them, but still belonging to them), rather than in the interaction between charges.

Tuesday, August 14, 2012

How do we transform energy?

The past week the teachers have painstakingly dedicated their time to mapping out energy and force transfers in different systems. And in doing so they have used the idea of potential energy. The teachers have become fairly comfortable with potential energy. They toss it around like play-do using it to put in any gaps they have in their energy stories. But today Leanna asked a particular question that the other teachers either neglected to think of or wanted to imagine wasn't there--What's responsible for converting potential energy to kinetic energy?
Now I am familiar with some of general relativity enough to know that for some things all we can say is, "Ce l'univers," but I feel like there is definitely more to it than that. This was a very interesting idea that I never thought of, and it showed to me the power of these group conversations where you look at a simple idea and you take it apart until every single thing is laid out in front of you. Then you have all the pieces and you know and understand how it works, and you can put it back together. Or you can make something new that no one has ever seen before.

Rance