This meeting discussed two episodes about teacher's perceptions
of what it means to have useful energy. It was pretty incredible to
have all of these talented people show up to watch my episodes and share
their responses. First, we looked at Jessica's Useful Energy video from
E1, where she discusses Shrinking People to represent the usefulness of
the energy. I am going to write down a random assortment of people's
reactions to this episode.
1. Rachel suggested Jessica's
suggestion might be a secret form of being "less" energy and whether
Jessica really understood it to mean not as much usefulness as opposed
to not as much energy. Lezlie/others thought that even if Jessica knew
this - students might not. Lezlie said that we have seen students
interpret less energy with stature in the past already. Here, Jessica
was worried that the opposite might be true.
2. Stamatis was
concerned with what "usefulness" actually means for the teachers (and
for us). We talked at length about what the ultimate reason was for the
energy and perhaps that teachers might think that the order of energy
use matters. For example, if the energy appears in a certain form at
the end of a process, that form might be the most useful...? Teachers
might think that the energy that doesn't "do" the thing you were setting
out to do is not as useful - even if it is used in the process.
Other ideas mentioned were:
- that's not why you were doing it - (so it must be less useful)
- the turbine moving in the coal burning example is more observable, - Lane
- things that are moving and electricity are viewed as useful - Sam
- anything that you have a use for is useful! -Rachel
3. Amy asked how much of this is an association of entropy? Lane
said if you don't use thermal energy, it will disperse and "go away."
At this point we started making a list of:
What makes energy less useful?
a. Less useful by changing form - Jessica
b. less useful by spreading out
c. by using it
d. increase in energy ?
e. can't be stored
f. can't be controlled
g. becomes less available
Care should be taken not to make it sound like it is always a one
way street - as in it always becomes less useful - unless we are
intentionally planning to state that.
4. Both the way usefulness is talked about and Azzam's control comments bring up a human
element of use. We talked about quality vs. usefulness next. Quality -
not requiring humans - Usefulness - what is supposed to be done with
it. Sam and Stamatis brought up the idea that the teachers and ET need
constraints. Jessica thinks that you can't run the movie backwards -
she needs/wants the constraint in place. Two constraints that are not
there that Stamatis wants are: 1. Can't have Gs--> Ts and 2. How do
we show the irreversibility of ET?
5. We watched the second episode - Derrick's talk of the quality
of energy from E2, briefly before closing. Line 40 was discussed
(Derrick uses "liberate") - Lane says, 'Run free, little ball, run
free!'
Line 38 Tim says the thermal is gone which is a dead end comment!
Line 51 Derrick says, "less that's available to you" and we ended with the big question,
"What is it that makes energy more or less useful?"
Talk about a great question! Thanks everyone for the rich discussion!
Insights and updates from Interdisciplinary Research Institute in STEM Education (I-RISE) Scholars, directors, and collaborators
Friday, September 23, 2011
Thursday, September 22, 2011
PRST-PER Paper on Substance Metaphor for Energy
Eric Brewe just published a PRST-PER paper on "Energy as a substancelike quantity that flows: Theoretical considerations and pedagogical consequences." I haven't read it yet, but it sounds like something that is particularly relevant to this project.
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
The Cabin in the Woods (part 2 of EPSRI Congress presentation)
The other part of my EPSRI Congress presentation was to present my thinking on an analogy that Hunter and Rachel came up with for instruction, and how it applies to different instructional knowledge.
Here's the analogy:
Here is my characterization of different teach methods' relationship to the cabin in the woods:
Here's the analogy:
- Cabin in the woods = Content knowledge
- Path to cabin = Instructional method
- Wilderness skills = Scientific thinking skills
- Navigation skills = Problem-solving skills
Here is my characterization of different teach methods' relationship to the cabin in the woods:
- Leslie’s Teaching Method (SGSI / Responsive Teaching) – Ask questions to get them started on path towards woods, let them find their own path, redirect them if they’re on a path that is clearly not going towards the cabin.
- Guided Inquiry – Guiding along a specific path
- Pure Discovery – Exploring the woods (who cares if you ever get to the cabin?)
- Direct Instruction – Helicopter air drop
Energy Theater Force Diagrams and the Five Laws (from my EPSRI Congress Presentation)
The recent posts about energy theater diagrams have inspired me to finally post about my EPSRI congress presentation.
In E2 this year, they tried to answer the following challenge:
Why does energy transfer or transform? (Wealth analogy)
Must have something to do with forces…
What is relationship between energy & force?
(Physicist answer: W=F.d)
As an answer, they came up with the following five laws of forces and energy:


The idea is that you draw all the forces in the scenario, and each force must correspond to a transfer or transformation of energy, or you have to use the laws to explain why it doesn't. For example, Fbh, the force of the ball on the hand, corresponds to 2KEh -> 2KEb, or the transfer of 2 units of kinetic energy from the hand to the ball. This is a transfer of kinetic energy, consistent with laws 1 and 2, it is in the direction of motion and giving kinetic energy to the ball, consistent with law 3, it is a contact force transferring energy, consistent with law 4, and the number of energy units, 2, is determined in relationship to the number of energy units involved in other transfers and transformations by the relative magnitudes of the forces, consistent with law 5.
This was a very disciplined use of diagrams, and led to lots of questions (and answers) about the scenario that would not have come up otherwise. Leslie and I are still talking about exactly how to analyze this, but one idea would be to look at the questions it produces and how commitment to the laws and the representation leads to these questions.
In E2 this year, they tried to answer the following challenge:
Give a causal or mechanistic description of energy transfers and transformations.
Why does energy transfer or transform? (Wealth analogy)
Must have something to do with forces…
What is relationship between energy & force?
(Physicist answer: W=F.d)
As an answer, they came up with the following five laws of forces and energy:
- When forces transfer energy, they transfer kinetic energy.
- Kinetic energy is present in all transfers and transformations (potential energy always transforms into or from kinetic energy).
- (a) A force on an object in the direction of motion increases kinetic energy. (b) A force on an object opposite the direction of motion decreases kinetic energy. (c) A force on an object that is not in motion neither increases nor decreases kinetic energy. (d) Forces within objects transmit energy.
- Transfers of energy are due to contact forces. Transformations of energy are due to non-contact forces.
- Forces transfer or transform energy proportional to their magnitude.
To check these laws, they invented another kind of "Energy Theater Diagram" which they used to determine the relationship between forces and energy transfers and transformations in a particular scenario. Below are a couple frames from a movie of a hand pushing a ball under water, and a picture of a diagram on the front board picture representing the analysis of a single time step in this movie:

The idea is that you draw all the forces in the scenario, and each force must correspond to a transfer or transformation of energy, or you have to use the laws to explain why it doesn't. For example, Fbh, the force of the ball on the hand, corresponds to 2KEh -> 2KEb, or the transfer of 2 units of kinetic energy from the hand to the ball. This is a transfer of kinetic energy, consistent with laws 1 and 2, it is in the direction of motion and giving kinetic energy to the ball, consistent with law 3, it is a contact force transferring energy, consistent with law 4, and the number of energy units, 2, is determined in relationship to the number of energy units involved in other transfers and transformations by the relative magnitudes of the forces, consistent with law 5.
This was a very disciplined use of diagrams, and led to lots of questions (and answers) about the scenario that would not have come up otherwise. Leslie and I are still talking about exactly how to analyze this, but one idea would be to look at the questions it produces and how commitment to the laws and the representation leads to these questions.
Monday, September 19, 2011
Energy Theater Diagrams E1 Examples
Here are some examples of the Energy Theater Diagrams that E1 used
this summer (2011). I thought it might be interesting to look at these
and compare them to your ideas.
1. This first one is interesting because it circles the final energy form and uses arrows to show us the progression of an energy chunk.
2. This next one is really different than our version - it uses different moments in time to show the progression of the energy. Does this work for your rules? How would the arrows work here or could they work?
3. Here is a third example of the energy involved in a light bulb. They use arrows as well. It might be interesting to do "our version" of energy theater diagrams for these and compare the situations.
1. This first one is interesting because it circles the final energy form and uses arrows to show us the progression of an energy chunk.
2. This next one is really different than our version - it uses different moments in time to show the progression of the energy. Does this work for your rules? How would the arrows work here or could they work?
3. Here is a third example of the energy involved in a light bulb. They use arrows as well. It might be interesting to do "our version" of energy theater diagrams for these and compare the situations.
Friday, September 16, 2011
ET for Raising and Lowering a Ball at Const. Vel. Part 2
Rachel and I have again reconstructed our ideas about raising a ball
at constant velocity and also worked on lowering the ball at constant
velocity. Below show our pictures of these ideas. We have made changes we *hope* will reflect a better snapshot of what is happening.
- Kinetic Energy Issue: We took out steps 3 and 4 (not just 3 as Lane mentioned in the previous post's comments) because we agreed that the ball would then be gaining kinetic energy. We did not put in an extra K in the ball and the hand because we believe that it is evident that the ball is moving because of the gain in gravitational energy.
- Friction btwn Ball and Air: We also felt better about our ideas surrounding the friction of the air with the ball/hand because we added in a K for the air. This K is the bulk movement of the air as it gets pushed out of the way by the ball/hand. We called this "macro" movement. As a secondary process, this "macro" movement dissipates into smaller "micro" movements, which we represented by transforming the K to a T in the air.
- We drew new BLUE arrows to represent this change and I thought perhaps this might be related to entropy??
- Overall Effort from the Human: We erased some of the C-->T transformations in the hand during the lowering process based upon our observations that the body gets warmer when "walking up stairs" as opposed to "walking down stairs" at the same rate. We are still unsure about this and how it relates (or if it relates) to the fact that the force exerted by the arm/body on the hand is the the same for both situations!
- How can it be that you are exerting the same force (doing the same work) but using more energy?
Lowering the Ball at constant speed:
Tuesday, September 13, 2011
Therapy?
Leslie Atkins relayed the following conversation she had with a student:
Me too!
A student stayed after class yesterday and said to me: "you talk just like my dad does -- and he's a psychotherapist. Have you been a therapist in the past?"
Me: "what do you mean?"
Her: "You say things like -- 'what I hear you saying is... did I get that right?" and "Can you say more, I'm not sure what you mean?"
I think it's a good sign.
Me too!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

