This morning in E1, the teachers were doing calculations, and Abby and Virginia got bored watching them. They asked Rachel about what to do about it on the chat, and a fascinating discussion ensued (copied here with irrelevant parts edited out):
10:53 Virginia Flood: Is it just me or is watching people interact with calculators kinda lame?
10:54 Abby Daane: I feel like they should just use one as an example now and be done with this but I know this is just me being greedy as a researcher
10:55 Virginia Flood: I guess they seem to like doing this.
10:55 Abby Daane: Is Rachel around?
10:55 Abby Daane: I was just wondering what she thought about this
10:55 Abby Daane: Is there something we can look for or listen for?
10:56 Abby Daane: I really don't have any interest
10:56 Virginia Flood: I think just type up interesting action stuff.
10:57 Virginia Flood: Like every now and then my guys show each other something.
10:59 Rachel Scherr: Hi, I just tuned in. What's up?
10:59 Abby Daane: well - my group is calculating....
10:59 Rachel Scherr: You're bored?
11:00 Abby Daane: well
11:00 Abby Daane: kinda
11:00 Virginia Flood: My group is calculating.
11:00 Abby Daane: just wondering if there is something I should be looking at that would help during calculations
11:01 Rachel Scherr: The first year that I observed this class, there was so much that was so exciting, and then there were parts that were utterly dull to observe. Since during the dull parts I had a lot of time to think, I really did some introspection about WHY it was so dull to watch, and what I thought that meant about teaching and learning.
11:01 Abby Daane: ooooooo I like it!
11:02 Rachel Scherr: For me it was actually huge. Because the dull parts were... how I had been teaching for ten years.
11:03 Abby Daane: I feel like this part is sort of important though - the math part of physics is important right?
11:04 Abby Daane: I mean - not for understanding the conceptual part - but for problem solving
11:04 Abby Daane: but that is not conceptual at all - more like just math
11:05 Rachel Scherr: Right, and maybe there's stuff going on inside people's heads that would be really great if only we could know about it. because the problem is, you're not really getting access to what they're doing, correct? since they are working kind of privately?
11:05 Abby Daane: yes.
11:05 Abby Daane: or at least they are doing a lot of math that doesn't translate well
11:05 Abby Daane: (on head phones at least)
11:07 Rachel Scherr: and here we are at a learning theory question. or at least i am. because if there is nothing for you to observe, there is nothing for them to observe about each other, and there isn't any (or not much) social construction of knowledge.
11:07 Abby Daane: true so they probably aren't learning new stuff - they are back to practicing
11:08 Abby Daane: (but at the same time - this skill can be important - but it is more skill-building and not knowledge gaining
11:08 Rachel Scherr: so if you have a social-construction theory of learning, then there can't be much learning happening right now.
11:09 Rachel Scherr: but if you have a private-cognition model of learning, you can think of this as being time well spent.
11:09 Abby Daane: can you have both?
11:10 Rachel Scherr: This is a hot area in learning sciences. The two theories have very different research questions, standards of evidence, etc
11:10 Rachel Scherr: so it is hard to "have both"
11:10 Rachel Scherr: and very interesting to try to find data and research questions that explore the shared areas
11:10 Abby Daane: hm. I mean - do both within a classroom at different times
11:12 Rachel Scherr: Can you alternate talking with private work time? i mean, of course you can, so i must not be understanding your question yet. say more?
11:13 Abby Daane: I mean to ask if the two theories exclude the other theory or do they both think you can learn in different ways?
11:14 Abby Daane: can you have different models for different times in the class?
11:14 Abby Daane: and do each "side" think that their way is the only way?
11:14 Rachel Scherr: the social-construction people (which by now includes me) say that since there is no way to get *evidence* of private cognition, there's not really anything to talk about.
11:15 Abby Daane: but there still could be learning going on
11:15 Rachel Scherr: The private-cognition people say that obviously there IS private cognition, since we all feel ourselves doing it, so let's attempt to model it.
11:15 Abby Daane: it's just boring because you can't do anything with it
11:15 Abby Daane: I see
11:15 Abby Daane: so neither are "against" the other, just not interested in it
11:17 Rachel Scherr: Right. I would say it's a little antagonistic sometimes, because one side's data is the other side's noise. It's hard for each to get their minds around the other way of thinking.
11:17 Abby Daane: hm
11:17 Abby Daane: this is fascinating
11:18 Rachel Scherr: More fascinating than calculations
Rachel told me about it at lunch, and we reminisced about 2009 when we first found ourselves in Abby and Virginia's position. We've talked a lot about what it means about instruction and our values when we're bored watching instruction, and I think we have a lot of similar values around this.
So I was surprised when I read the chat and found myself strongly disagreeing with something Rachel said. I was excited to discuss it with her, and figured hey, why not do so semi-publicly?
When Abby said, "Can you have both?" Rachel said not really, and identified herself with the social-construction side of the debate. My answer to this question would be very different: "You have to do both! Either one by itself is inadequate and only tells part of the story." I agree that it would be difficult for any individual researcher to try to do both at the same time, and that it makes sense to focus on one or the other, but I feel strongly that for our community (or any community) to tell a complete story about learning, that story ultimately has to include both.