Monday, September 5, 2011

Confusing Energies in Quantum Theory

Virginia is taking a class on inorganic chemistry, this semester. The textbook for the course is Miessler and Tarr, "Inorganic Chemistry."



Chapter 2 is titled "The Schrödinger Equation" and provides a short review of the basic principles of quantum mechanics, especially the Schrödinger equation and it's implications for the theory and things that are interesting to chemistry. The second page of the treatment of the Schrödinger equation looks as follows:




Note what is written in the red box:

The potential energy V is a result of electrostatic attraction between the electron and the nucleus. Attractive forces, like those between a positive nucleus and a negative electron, are defined by convention to have a negative potential energy. An electron near the nucleus (small r) is strongly attracted to the nucleus and has a large negative potential energy. Electrons farther from the nucleus have potential energies that are small and negative. For an electron at infinite distance from the nucleus (r = ∞), the attraction between the nucleus and the electron is zero, and the potential energy is zero.


The notation here is rather confusing, in my opinion. First, potential energy is attributed to an attractive interaction between the electron and the nucleus. OK, I can get behind that. In the next sentence, however, "attractive forces [...] have a negative potential energy." How can a force have energy? But, as if this isn't confusing enough, in the next sentence, the electron "has a large negative potential energy." Metaphorically speaking, first the force "owns" the potential energy, then the electron does. Which one is it? And then, in the last sentence, the potential energy is again attributed to the interaction. How confusing is that???

Yes, this is not a physics textbook, but I'm sure we could find these kinds of inconsistencies in physics quantum textbooks, too. How are students supposed to understand energy, when even textbooks use inconsistent descriptions and notations?

Tuesday, August 30, 2011

Amy's EPSRI Congress Presentation

My EPSRI Congress presentation was broken into two parts, based loosely on the prompts that Rachel and Sam provided.

I started by talking about what I felt that I learned, both instruction- and research-wise, and how this was connected to where I come from.

In a 'techn
ical sense,' I was 'raised' in an instructional environment that is mostly worksheet-driven and in which the direction that the instruction takes is largely predetermined (and dictated by the worksheets). In E2, I observed instruction that was more open-ended, and the direction that the class takes changed dynamically. Although I got the impression that Leslie and Stamatis always had a (sometimes detailed) plan, the plan changed as the teachers chose the questions that they wanted to pursue.

My previous instructional experiences, alongside my observations of E2 instruction, allowed me to better characterize some of the differences between 'guided' and '(more) open' inquiry:

On of the joys of the EPSRI for me was seeing how what is done at SPU is 'the same kind of different as me.' Although the quantitative research that I've done for the past five years is very different than the qualitative research that is done in the Energy Project, the two kinds of research intersect in more ways than I had anticipated. Both explore and synthesize multitudes of data (albeit different kinds), and although research questions are defined differently (and at different times), the research questions are semi-dynamic beings that evolve over time. (Perhaps that the research is so similar shouldn't surprise me, since we are all scientists, but it did!)

As I wrote in my EPSRI reflection, significant for me throughout this process is the continued refinement of a number of questions about assessment -- what it means, what it looks like, etc. Although not articulated very well, I included a slide attempting to hint at this:

The latter half of my presentation focused on what I thought about for most of the EPSRI, which was an interaction between Stamatis and a group of E2 teachers. I wrote several blog posts about this (five, in fact: one, two, three, four, and five). In short, Stamatis and this group of teachers had an interaction that just didn't work (by self report of both Stamatis and the teachers), and I wanted to figure out why. The clip that alerted me to this gem is here:



Context for the video can be found in this blog post.

I shared what struck me about the video:


And then my own impressions of the 70-minute interaction that took place. My first impression of the interaction was that the group just didn't get the question that had been asked of them. But then I noticed that they repeated (or appropriately reinterpreted) the question a number of times throughout the interaction, so maybe they did get the question, and something else went wrong. I started to look for other potential mismatches (and blogged about them here and here).


Ultimately, though, I began to wonder whether there was some other (perhaps deeper) 'mismatch' that took place during the 70-minute interaction, which generated a number of open questions:
...and ultimately led me to start paying attention to (a) things that the E2 participants said about the instructors or (b) things they said about their own classrooms (i.e., about themselves as instructors). I shared this clip of Don talking about his classroom:



(Context for this video can be found here.) This video itself led to a flurry of questions for me:


Finally, I ended with a series of possible directions for this 'project seed:'


As an afternote, Costas and I had coffee on Wednesday (immediately following the EPSRI Congress), and he suggested that anyone who might pursue this further should look into the 'learning styles' literature (in particular, search for papers by Sternberg).

Saturday, August 27, 2011

Benedikt's EPSRI Congress Presentation

At the end of this year's EPSRI, all the scholars and directors gave presentations on what they had done/learned/experienced during the research institute. Rachel had posted some prompts for our presentations, and I let them loosely guide my own preparation for the congress. In the end, I decided to show some cool pictures that I had taken during "EPSRI Camp" and talk a little bit about the research themes that I had been working on since the last EPSRI in 2010, and how they influenced my experience at this year's EPSRI.



On the first day last year, I had participated as an extra person in an energy theater activity in E2. Thinking about how the spatial arrangement of instructor and participants influences or is influenced by the instructional style / instructional intentions, I spent several months analyzing this episode after the EPSRI. Rachel had pointed me in the direction of literature on "Participation Framework Theory," and at the AAPT winter meeting 2011 in Jacksonville, FL, I presented my take on participation framework theory, using the episode from the very first day of last year's EPSRI.



This year, Rachel opened up this topic for me again with her blog post about Positioning in Small-Group Interaction. I picked it up for my presentation and had a couple of slides with preliminary thoughts for possible analyses in terms of participation framework theory.




A more recent research theme is multimodal analysis. Inspired by Eleanor's PERC paper from last year, I tried to create rich and detailed pictures of learners' ideas by looking not only at what they say but also take into account how they say it (prosody) and the gestures that accompany speech. In particular, I analyzed the video episode "Hot to Cold or Cold to Hot," in which three participating teachers in last year's E2 are trying to figure out how a refrigerator works. I presented results from this analysis at FFPER 2011 in Bar Harbor, and also at the AAPT summer meeting and PERC 2011 in Omaha. Since Virginia's research area is gestures (she knows much more about it than I do), and she had already talked about them in her presentation on Monday, I decided to focus on prosody analysis. Here is a slide with some results from my analysis from last year's data:



I had compared the pitch contour of a teacher's utterance of "know" to the typical intonation of "duh" (according to Merriam Webster online dictionary) to ascribe meaning to the prosody of her utterance in terms of commitment. However, since there are many ways to say "know" and "duh," I am tempted to do some more research on this topic. The opportunity presented itself when I observed Stamatis use the word "know" five times within one minute of dialog with "my" group in this year's E2, and Leslie led a discussion about "duh" statements in the same class, a week later. When I was putting together my presentation, I only had the video of the first episode handy, so I decided to go with "know" instead of "duh."





All these analyses were preliminary, I did not want to ascribe any meaning to any of my observations or come up with inferences and interpretations. After I had already put together my slides, I realized that I had only written up observations, without even having to restrain myself not to make inferences at the same time. I realized that apparently, my training with Rachel over the past year had resulted in me automatically keeping observations and inferences apart.

After all these more methodological aspects, I briefly summarized my big research theme, proximal formative assessment. Virginia had pointed me in the direction of a similar interaction to the "Hot to Cold, Cold to Hot" episode in her blog post, so I used some of her pictures for my slide. I did not perform any analysis on this, but I definitely want to keep it on the back burner in case I need it for further study.



Unfortunately, I had to cut off the discussion about my "EAR model" of proximal formative assessment, because the time was running out. At some point, I definitely want to continue talking to Stamatis about the points he raised (step missing between Assessment and Reaction).

Toward the end of my presentation, I briefly tipped my hat to recurring content themes
that I have been thinking and blogging about. Telling stories about energy, thinking about energy in electrical circuits, and thinking about forms and categories of energy had all been things that I had been thinking (and blogging) about before, and that had come up again in this year's EPSRI.

After showing some pictures of products of the EPSRI pastry kitchen, I concluded my presentation with a slide about "Souvenirs" that I could take home from the EPSRI, this year:



The biggest take-away from this year's EPSRI for me was to realize how much I was able to learn since last year's EPSRI, and how much I seem to have grown as a researcher. Thanks so much to Rachel and Sam for organizing EPSRI 2011 and making it an awesome experience- again!

Thursday, August 25, 2011

Abby's E1 Reflection for the 2011 EPSRI Congress (Thermal Energy)


I really enjoyed both presenting and hearing other presentations this week. I was struck by the huge variety of observations and the impressive amount of information gleaned in just two weeks. I began my presentation with a couple of ideas that I had been mulling over during my two weeks of observation. I first talked about Teacher Analysis vs. Research Analysis. I learned that when doing research, there is a tendency for me to look at the teaching itself and analyze its effectiveness. I found out from Rachel that this seems to be a tendency that is common among teachers, and that it is not all bad. However, I noticed that here, the research tries to refrain from judging and opinion. It is encouraged to take the teacher out of the system and take judgments out. I have to retrain my brain a bit to not judge immediately and make claims about how I would do things differently if I was in control of all classrooms everywhere. Here is the slide that I used:




Next I talked about Research for Teaching and Learning vs. Research for Understanding. While I recognize that there IS value to doing research just for the sake of understanding and learning, my motivation at the moment lies with doing research to find understanding that WILL help students and teachers in their classrooms in a more immediate fashion. I want to help make a change in the education system as well as learn how students learn physics. I am still working on this idea and I really appreciate the help I have had from Amy (and others) in understanding the differences and similarities between these two motivators. It was also interesting to hear that many of those in the room have shifted back and forth between them.


Finally - I got to the "meat" of my talk - looking at the value the teachers place on thermal energy. I interpreted the word value in two ways. First, that some of the teachers tended to reject the idea that thermal energy could account for an equivalent loss in kinetic or potential energy. Their impression was that 5.0 Joules of kinetic energy seemed to be much more energy than 5.0 Joules of thermal energy. Second, they saw that thermal energy was worth less to humans than other forms of energy and at times deemed it a "useless" form of energy.
I think that the above statement is far clearer than my slide I used in my talk - and I realized during the talk that I could have been clearer than the below:




From here, I showed two videos about the discomfort surrounding the first kind of value of thermal energy. I previously blogged about the first video here, but then I showed a shorter clip of this video where Tim talks about using thermal energy as a Hail Mary Pass. (A Hail Mary Pass being used here as a long shot, last ditch effort when there are no other options left!) I find it intriguing that Tim and others don't like the idea of so much GPE going away into heat. Thermal energy (or “heat” as it is used in our class) seems to be this energy that is worth less to people. Below I think it is important to see that Ingrid, and the group in general, find the body heating up as acceptable rather than before when the energy was suggested to just go away as heat. It seems to be easier to accept when the body (something we can relate to and sense more easily) is suggested.




Then, when talking about Thermal Energy being a lesser energy, not worth as much in terms of its usefulness, I used the video from my blog about Shrinking People here, and Amy's example from E2 about thermal energy being a dead end here.

Finally I ended the talk (over my time) with this slide:
I feel like it was an incredibly good thing for me to put together a presentation for this Congress. It really helped me to organize my thoughts and see how much had happened in two short weeks for me. My learning curve was steep and I felt like this was a great experience for me to understand how video can enhance research.

In hindsight, I believe I definitely should have used more transcriptions in my videos and I should have done an introduction about my background (Where I Have Come From) - I completely left that out! I wasn't sure what to put into the talk or how official to make it and knowing what I know now, I would have put more pictures into the talk as well. I also worry that I repeated too many things from the blog that had already been stated, but I felt like for me, it was the first time I worked to tie together more than one video into one coherent idea...or two!

Virginia's Reflection on Presenting for the EPSRI Congress


A few days ago, I gave my presentation to summarize my experience at EPSRI over the last two weeks. I tried to present a mixture of my background and research interests, methods and content I learned, as well as some gesture analysis I did while I was there. I was grateful that we were required to give a presentation because it helped me organize my thoughts and forced me to try and explain past, present, and future research that I’m interested in. It also was an outstanding learning experience for me because it was my first presentation to a research group!

My slides:



One thing I learned from my presentation was just how carefully you have to pick your words. Since it’ so condensed, you’ve really got to make sure every line reflects exactly what you mean. One of my slides (slide 16) used the word “help” twice, which unfortunately made it sound like I was saying gesturing is a separate auxiliary entity that assists with cognition (instead of being a part of cognition). Not exactly the message I was going for while trying to support embodied cognition! Also unfortunate is the way this wording made it sound like Kerry intentionally gestured to “help” her visualize or feel. Oops.



Another thing I was thinking about was whether I should have captioned the video I showed. I struggle with whether or not to caption videos when I want people to be paying attention to gesture. I think it can make a huge difference in comprehension, but I find that when something is captioned, I’m always reading and not really watching. If I were showing a clip longer than a minute in the future, I will probably caption it and then show a non-captioned version for the second viewing. The other solution, of course, is to provide a written transcript and hand it out.

Finally, I am still working on how to not panic in public speaking situations. I don’t think I’m shy and I usually don’t have too much trouble sharing my opinion in a group discussion, but the second I’m at the front of the room at the helm of a Powerpoint, everything changes. Even in a group of people I have comfortably spoken in front of, I still am totally and utterly terrified of presenting. And unfortunately, I don’t have a good answer yet for how to work on this in the future. Take a course? Ick. People always tell me with practice it won’t be an issue, but I have my doubts. Guess I’ll have to keep thinking about that one.

Overall, presenting was a very positive experience and I was really pleased to get the opportunity to share my ideas with the research team. I also think it was great practice for giving future talks and I learned a lot about what I want to do in the future. Plus, I’m really thankful that I’ve come home with a presentation to show my advisor and anyone from home that wants to know what I was up to for two weeks (I already showed my mom)!

Monday, August 22, 2011

Vortex of intellectual intensity

This morning we had the beginning of the EPSRI Congress.  Abby's presentation was hugely stimulating and had several of us talking through lunch (at PCC) about the special status, if any, of thermal energy - whether energy transformations always involve some, whether and when thermal energy can transform into other forms of energy, etc.  The discussion included stretching springs, falling comets, quantum field oscillations, the sufficiency of various types of explanations, learners' interest/disinterest in being told answers, what happens in a conversation when people show interest/disinterest in what someone else is saying, potential tradeoffs between (Rogerian) genuineness and acceptance -- it was one of those conversations.  As we got up to walk back to SPU, a guy sitting across from us pulled at my sleeve and said, "Excuse me, before you go -- could you tell me what caused this vortex of intellectual intensity that you all seem to be experiencing over there?  Because I'm pretty sure I heard you talking about physics at first, and just now you were talking about interpersonal psychology, and I'm just trying to imagine what would make you have such an amazing conversation for such a long time."

I don't remember exactly what I said - I think I explained that we study the teaching and learning of physics and that we were having a sort of a conference, sharing findings from a common data set of video of people learning physics together.  I do know that I grinned hugely, because I am so grateful to have such a great field and such awesome colleagues, with whom these kinds of conversations happen all the time!

Friday, August 19, 2011

Why are some activities boring to watch? social-construction vs. private-cognitive

This morning in E1, the teachers were doing calculations, and Abby and Virginia got bored watching them. They asked Rachel about what to do about it on the chat, and a fascinating discussion ensued (copied here with irrelevant parts edited out):

10:53 Virginia Flood: Is it just me or is watching people interact with calculators kinda lame?
10:54 Abby Daane: I feel like they should just use one as an example now and be done with this but I know this is just me being greedy as a researcher
10:55 Virginia Flood: I guess they seem to like doing this.
10:55 Abby Daane: Is Rachel around?
10:55 Abby Daane: I was just wondering what she thought about this
10:55 Abby Daane: Is there something we can look for or listen for?
10:56 Abby Daane: I really don't have any interest
10:56 Virginia Flood: I think just type up interesting action stuff.
10:57 Virginia Flood: Like every now and then my guys show each other something.
10:59 Rachel Scherr: Hi, I just tuned in. What's up?
10:59 Abby Daane: well - my group is calculating....
10:59 Rachel Scherr: You're bored?
11:00 Abby Daane: well
11:00 Abby Daane: kinda
11:00 Virginia Flood: My group is calculating.
11:00 Abby Daane: just wondering if there is something I should be looking at that would help during calculations
11:01 Rachel Scherr: The first year that I observed this class, there was so much that was so exciting, and then there were parts that were utterly dull to observe. Since during the dull parts I had a lot of time to think, I really did some introspection about WHY it was so dull to watch, and what I thought that meant about teaching and learning.
11:01 Abby Daane: ooooooo I like it!
11:02 Rachel Scherr: For me it was actually huge. Because the dull parts were... how I had been teaching for ten years.
11:03 Abby Daane: I feel like this part is sort of important though - the math part of physics is important right?
11:04 Abby Daane: I mean - not for understanding the conceptual part - but for problem solving
11:04 Abby Daane: but that is not conceptual at all - more like just math
11:05 Rachel Scherr: Right, and maybe there's stuff going on inside people's heads that would be really great if only we could know about it. because the problem is, you're not really getting access to what they're doing, correct? since they are working kind of privately?
11:05 Abby Daane: yes.
11:05 Abby Daane: or at least they are doing a lot of math that doesn't translate well
11:05 Abby Daane: (on head phones at least)
11:07 Rachel Scherr: and here we are at a learning theory question. or at least i am. because if there is nothing for you to observe, there is nothing for them to observe about each other, and there isn't any (or not much) social construction of knowledge.
11:07 Abby Daane: true so they probably aren't learning new stuff - they are back to practicing
11:08 Abby Daane: (but at the same time - this skill can be important - but it is more skill-building and not knowledge gaining
11:08 Rachel Scherr: so if you have a social-construction theory of learning, then there can't be much learning happening right now.
11:09 Rachel Scherr: but if you have a private-cognition model of learning, you can think of this as being time well spent.
11:09 Abby Daane: can you have both?
11:10 Rachel Scherr: This is a hot area in learning sciences. The two theories have very different research questions, standards of evidence, etc
11:10 Rachel Scherr: so it is hard to "have both"
11:10 Rachel Scherr: and very interesting to try to find data and research questions that explore the shared areas
11:10 Abby Daane: hm. I mean - do both within a classroom at different times
11:12 Rachel Scherr: Can you alternate talking with private work time? i mean, of course you can, so i must not be understanding your question yet. say more?
11:13 Abby Daane: I mean to ask if the two theories exclude the other theory or do they both think you can learn in different ways?
11:14 Abby Daane: can you have different models for different times in the class?
11:14 Abby Daane: and do each "side" think that their way is the only way?
11:14 Rachel Scherr: the social-construction people (which by now includes me) say that since there is no way to get *evidence* of private cognition, there's not really anything to talk about.
11:15 Abby Daane: but there still could be learning going on
11:15 Rachel Scherr: The private-cognition people say that obviously there IS private cognition, since we all feel ourselves doing it, so let's attempt to model it.
11:15 Abby Daane: it's just boring because you can't do anything with it
11:15 Abby Daane: I see
11:15 Abby Daane: so neither are "against" the other, just not interested in it
11:17 Rachel Scherr: Right. I would say it's a little antagonistic sometimes, because one side's data is the other side's noise. It's hard for each to get their minds around the other way of thinking.
11:17 Abby Daane: hm
11:17 Abby Daane: this is fascinating
11:18 Rachel Scherr: More fascinating than calculations

Rachel told me about it at lunch, and we reminisced about 2009 when we first found ourselves in Abby and Virginia's position. We've talked a lot about what it means about instruction and our values when we're bored watching instruction, and I think we have a lot of similar values around this.

So I was surprised when I read the chat and found myself strongly disagreeing with something Rachel said. I was excited to discuss it with her, and figured hey, why not do so semi-publicly?

When Abby said, "Can you have both?" Rachel said not really, and identified herself with the social-construction side of the debate. My answer to this question would be very different: "You have to do both! Either one by itself is inadequate and only tells part of the story." I agree that it would be difficult for any individual researcher to try to do both at the same time, and that it makes sense to focus on one or the other, but I feel strongly that for our community (or any community) to tell a complete story about learning, that story ultimately has to include both.