Thursday, June 30, 2011

Stop the world...

This morning when I was recording field notes in UE1 I found myself hitting the tab key in order to pause the flow of visual and auditory information that I was perceiving so that I could figure out what I wanted to say about it before moving on. It didn't work. The scene around me continued to unfold as I sat and struggled for words and I had to make the choice between missing what was happening now or giving up on writing down what I had just seen.

The kind of real-time collaborative note-taking that we are doing is new to me. Usually when I take field notes they are very minimal--noting who is present, the nature of the activity in very broad terms (e.g., lunch, gardening, book-reading), times, and anything I notice that I think I will want to remember later--especially if I am not sure it is well captured by the camera. But I am specifically not counting on my field notes to capture what is going to be interesting to me in the video data--rather, I know I (or someone) will watch the video later, log the content, and tag moments of interest for close transcription and analysis. This is time-consuming, though, and there's a lot to be said for generating something like a content log--the kind of documentation that will be useful for identifying segments--while the video is being recorded. It is clearly valuable for this kind of event, in which we are trying to do as much as we can together in the short time that we have. So I think that I have been trying to do something like I do when I am taking field notes during this workshop. This is not quite possible in real-time, which leads to futile efforts to stop time with my left pinky finger.

I haven't done an exhaustive comparison, but there seem to be some interesting differences in the ways that videographers on the team are doing field notes. These differences may be lessening over time, which I guess is what you would expect. I come from a tradition in which a basic assumption is that anything that human beings do is potentially worthy of analysis. I also know that it is virtually impossible for an observer to detect everything that is possibly significant by viewing an event once, in real-time. Those two premises motivate me to try to document everything I can in the field notes. On the other hand, even though all human activity is potentially researchable, the particular researchers here (including myself) have interests that will lead them to seek certain kinds of episodes instead of others. Given the limitations of what one can actually possible notice and record in real-time, it would seem that the best use of field notes is to try to focus in on phenomena that seem relevant to the research goals of the investigators and tag them in ways that will be findable later on. Strangely, though, while limiting oneself in that way would seem to make writing field notes easier, I find it difficult. Though I know I do not catch (anywhere close to) everything, once I have noticed something it is hard to disregard and not record it--deciding whether or not to record it is a cognitive step that takes more time than I have in this situation.

More later on field notes, content logs, and transcription.

My favorite quote of the day

Barb: "I almost didn't take this class because I went, '8:30 to 3:30 listening to a lecture on physics? That sounds terrible!'"

EPSRI Congress preparation

This is the first year that the EPSRI will include an EPSRI Congress after the session of observation/reflection/research. The reason we added the Congress to the session is that the Energy Project team wanted more opportunity to learn from the Scholars, and we thought the Scholars might find it valuable to synthesize the experience.

Our plan is that each scholar will have one hour of dedicated time - the "Benedikt hour," for example. During your time, your job is to respond to these two prompts:

1. What was significant for you this session?
1a. Show video if possible.
1b. Make sure we know what we should know about YOU to understand why it was significant - your background, your expertise, your interests, your learning curve, etc.

2. Where do you want to go from here, if anywhere?
This could be just a mindset, or perhaps there are specific actions you have in mind such as beginning new research or collaborating with us.

We are really looking forward to it!

What am I learning from teachers?

Some of the teachers in UE2 seem to think of us physics PhDs as repositories of knowledge and of themselves as ignorant.  I think it's safe to say that typical professional development reinforces this conceptualization:  the attitude from university people toward teachers is, "We know what you need to know."  (That's what I had experienced before coming here, and I've heard teachers say that is their experience.)  Our hope is that the professional development offered here does not take that attitude.  I am trying to cultivate the attitude in myself that they know what we need to know.

I want to confess that this is nontrivial for me - it's an attitude I aspire to, but it's not how I was raised.  In order to help make this mindset deeper and more automatic for myself I am trying to articulate specifically what physics I have learned from the teachers so far this week.

First of all, they are right about something, which is that they do not give me physics answers that I didn't already have.  They do, however, give me questions I didn't have.  And if you believe that questions indicate learning, which I do, then I have learned physics from them.  Then, sometimes I get the fun of answering those questions; so I wind up with more answers than before, even though the teachers didn't give me the answers. Here are some of the questions the teachers have pushed for me this week.

1. What is energy?  Okay, this is not this week, and I learned it with the whole SPU team, but still:  Only because I personally was pressed on this over and over by teachers, and only because I was challenged to stop being evasive, I articulated for myself that:  Energy is stuff that makes things happen.  It is invisible, massless, and can permeate objects.  It moves from one place/object to another, without any of it going away or appearing out of nowhere.  That's what energy is to me.  I didn't know that before.

2. What is force?  Many teachers are calling repeatedly for better distinctions between energy and force.  Much as I have thought in terms of forces and even studied the teaching and learning of forces, I do not have a succinct conceptual statement of what force is that feels as satisfying to me as my energy statement.  Here's what I've got for now:  Forces are pushes or pulls.  They are interactions between two objects that can (sometimes) cause those objects' motion to change.  Forces are different from energy in that forces are not stuff; they are more like arrows.  They can appear and disappear, they do not travel from one place to another but rather are associated with specific objects the whole time they are in existence.  This still feels too long and messy; I'm working on it.  I would not have been working on it had I not been pressured by teachers to do so.

3. What does it mean to say that energy comes in different forms?  This is a question that is very much still active for me.  Forms seem to me to be categories of evidence for the presence of (or changes in) energy.  In this sense they seem conceptually highly useful, since they are the kinds of things we see that tell us that energy is present (or changing).  What could be more pedagogically or scientifically significant than the nature of the visible evidence of the invisible stuff?  On the other hand, I have not yet met a categorization of energy forms that I like (any normal-length list has forms missing that I care about); I don't know what would constitute a valid basis for categorization or for making up forms that aren't on whatever list you've been handed; and the "kinds of things we see" are tied in with our perceptual and technological capacities, which isn't what I had originally meant to be talking about.  K-12 teaching about energy seems to me to be very forms-oriented, so I want to have a clear understanding of forms, and I don't.

4.  Might it be possible to have a different, coherent, explanatory model, in which energy is created out of nothing?  Today Lisa (UE2) wanted to explore the possibility that when you lift something away from the earth (in her case an elevator), gravitational energy is created in the object.  She also had a complete and correct energy story in which energy was conserved, so it wasn't that she lacked understanding, it was that she wanted to explore a possible alternative model.  (And I found that I have some sympathy for her intuition, that there is something energy-like created by pulling attracting things apart.  can anyone help me with that?  does that come from somewhere?)  I don't see Lisa as having been merely creative or rebellious; devising and testing alternative models of a phenomenon is critical to science.  This really has me thinking.  What might that model look like, fleshed out?  Would there be anything wrong with it?  Would it be equivalent to some other model - would it make energy more like some other physics quantity?  I think that my own model for energy is only as strong as the alternative models that it's better than, if you follow the grammar of that.

Maybe I will get a chance to share some of this with them.  Unfortunately I think it might be surprising for them to learn that I am learning anything from them (other than how ignorant they supposedly are), and maybe having examples would help.

Benefit of struggling through a question

Just a short note to follow up on yesterday's long discussion about heat movement I posted about this morning:

At the beginning of class today Lezlie asked the group about strategies they were finding in the class that support learning. After group discussion the teachers came back to discuss all together. Adria comments on the advantages of working through a question to get to the answer. It was a long process yesterday to finally come to an understanding about why heat goes from hot to cold, but now she says that she will never forget it after the very long and involved discussion yesterday.

(Don't have video yet, but the episode will be on the video of Table 4 towards the start of class)

Most of the teachers in the class seem always to want to just be told the answer (which makes sense because they are curious and want to know!) but maybe after a few of these experiences of working through to the answer the hard way without simply being told they will start to see --like Adria-- the benefits to the struggle.

Do we need different forms of energy?

Today UE1 had a long discussion about chemical energy. The discussion became very general so Eleanor suggested they take a more specific example to work with: gasoline on fire. After discussing in small groups how they would represent this scenario in energy theatre the groups compared answers. Everyone seemed to be on the same page that the gasoline had chemical energy to start with and that when it came in contact with the heat energy of a lit match that a reaction took place which transformed chemical energy into light and thermal energy.

Although everyone seemed to agree on this representation, it didn't seem that everyone thought of chemical energy as energy that is stored. Heather kept going back to the idea of WHEN and WHERE the chemical energy was and kept mentioning the idea of the interaction of substances as the cause(?) of chemical energy. (I need to get video from this morning and I will make an episode... If I'm allowed to make an episode of Heather?). At one point she specifically asked if we could just have two kind of chemical energy: active chemical energy and potential chemical energy. (Sam talks about this idea in her post about yesterday). Almost immediately someone pointed out that by definition chemical energy is always potential and that once it's "active" it has transformed into another form of energy.

At this point Heather seemed to have a very interesting idea. She wanted to know why we had different forms of energy in the first place.
"We are just classifying. But what is the overall? What is the pure thing? What is energy?"
This idea stood out to me because I went through the same thought process yesterday! It will be interesting now to see where Heather's thinking goes next (it will be interesting to see where my thinking goes next). Will she see the utility in having different forms of energy so we can more easily talk about energy? Will she begin to think energy isn't even a real thing? Will she continue on this line of what is the "pure" thing behind it all?

Forms of energy Part 5 - Types of Chemical Energy

Another cool thing that happened in the discussion of the germinating plant: They decided they needed two different types of chemical energy. Chemical energy that is being stored - indicated by putting your hand to your mouth and holding it still, and chemical energy that is being used - indicated by putting your hand to your mouth and moving it back and forth like you're eating. I don't understand exactly why they needed these two to be separate. But I think it had something to do with their concern about how things can use chemical energy when they're not receiving any energy: e.g. a runner running while not eating, or a plant growing while still underground.