Monday, June 27, 2011

S.C.R.E.A.M.

In UE2 this morning, Meg said she has something specific she wants to learn this week.  She was given this acronym for different forms of energy, SCREAM, for Sound-Chemical-Radiant-Electrical-Atomic-Motion.  Her question is:  Where is solar energy?  Is light and heat energy, which she had been told belong under "radiant"?  Is solar energy something other than light and heat together?  What about other forms of energy that don't seem to be on this list -- are they secretly on there somewhere?  How?  We were in a small group discussion together at that point, and she asked me directly.  "Where is solar energy on this list?"

I had the pleasure of responding completely honestly (and I think in sort of a gush) that we, the Energy Project team with our physics PhDs and so on, were actually obsessing on this very issue ourselves, and that watching the video of them (or people like them) discussing forms of energy had really challenged us to figure out our own answers to these questions.  And that we did not have answers for ourselves yet.  And how great that we have this shared obsession, because we really want to keep talking about it.  I rephrased the issue as being how we categorize forms of energy, on what basis make lists of forms, whether and when it's legitimate to invent a new name ever.  She (and the others at the table) seemed friendly to my identifying the larger issue in her specific question.  Our conversation was interrupted by a change of activity, which was fine with me, it felt like an opener.

First day technicalities

The first day of qualitative data collection in any context is glitchy, I'm afraid, and today is no exception.  I think anytime you get brand new equipment and/or new systems there is an adjustment period.  Today so far one of the wireless headphones is not working at all; iEtherpad (our system for taking collaborative field notes) has gone offline; several (all?) of the microphone/headset combinations are hard to listen to, either because they are buzzing or they are too loud; the new cameras generate a file type we have never heard of before and don't know how to convert; and we only have one still camera.  Sheesh.  However, the classes are going well, the data is being collected (knock wood) even if the real-time access is messy, and it seems like things are getting worked out.

Friday, June 3, 2011

Forms Paper - in progress

I've been thinking for a few months about writing a paper about forms of energy expanding on some of my earlier blog posts:

http://scherrenergyproject.blogspot.com/2010/06/swackhamer-and-form.html
http://scherrenergyproject.blogspot.com/2010/07/maybe-swackhamer-was-right-after-all.html

Here's the abstract we submitted for an AAPT poster that I thought I could turn into a paper:

Understanding forms of energy through testing novel cases
National and state standards often list forms of energy that students should know, including gravitational, kinetic, potential, etc. Form can be a useful shorthand for describing the state of the system, or it can be a meaningless label to be memorized. Most physics instruction does not emphasize a deep understanding of the physical meaning of form. Are there ways that our instruction could more effectively help students gain an understanding of form? One way to develop and test understanding of forms of energy is to ask the question, “What must be considered when deciding whether a new form is legitimate?” We present case studies of students struggling with the legitimacy of forms of energy not listed in the standards, some of which they deem to be legitimate and some of which they do not. Finally, we suggest instructional methods to take advantage of this struggle.
Warren Christensen (who was a scholar-in-residence with us last fall) has been analyzing data where teachers invent the term "phase energy" to describe the energy that goes into changing phase. We've got some examples somewhere of teachers trying out various other kinds of energy, such as "cold energy", "buoyant energy", and "box energy". So the plan was that we would discuss several examples, and Warren would write up the phase energy example as a PERC paper that would be part of a larger paper on form in general.

But as we started working on it this week, the whole idea started falling apart. Hunter and Rachel questioned whether people really use form as a meaningless label, and I realized that I don't actually have a lot of evidence for them doing so. Swackhamer claims they do, but I don't really need to write a paper just to argue with an unpublished manuscript. My original evidence was the video of the guy struggling with the term "electromagnetic energy" in the video in the second blog post above, but when I went back and watched it again, I had a different interpretation: he's got a whole lot of ideas about what electromagnetic energy might be, but they don't quite fit together for him in a coherent way, and he's trying to make sense of them. He's trying to assign more meaning to the label. A lot of teachers in that clip were very concerned that that forms of energy might be used as meaningless labels, but in fact they were demonstrating a strong commitment to using these labels in a meaningful way.

Here's a new version of the abstract:

National and state standards often list forms of energy that students should know, including gravitational, kinetic, potential, etc. Form is a useful shorthand label for describing the state of a system. This type of label is useful to enable efficient communication, but it can obscure meaning. When a student uses a label for a form of energy, we do not know what meaning is packed inside that label. By watching students grapple with novel forms of energy that are not included on standard lists of forms, we can better understand how they think about form in general. We present video analysis of teachers studying energy in a summer professional development program. As these teachers come to understand a new form of energy, they invent language to describe what they are learning.
I'm still not quite satisfied because I can't articulate what it is that we better understand how they think about forms in general and why we care, but it's getting there.

Energy as cause and effect

I just read the following article, which attempts to address all the whining about energy not making any sense (e.g. Feynman) or being mysterious (e.g. National Standards) by looking at how energy was defined historically:

Coelho, Ricardo Lopes. 2009. On the concept of energy: History and philosophy for science teaching. World Conference on Educational Sciences, Elsevier.

Robert Mayer defined energy in terms of cause and effect. He considered that the weight and height of a falling body cause it to fall and gain velocity, and that these two are related by mh~mv^2. He considered that motion causes heat and vice versa, and calculated an equivalence between them:
Forces are causes, is its basic statement. This is used to apply to forces the classical saying 'causa aequat effectum', c=e. If the effect e becomes a cause of an effect f, then e=f. Mayer writes c=e=f...=c. The quantity of force holds therefore constant. Mayer expresses this in the form: force is indestructible. As c=e, Mayer says that c is transformed into e because at the end, no part of c can exist, and at the beginning no part of e exists. He pointed out, however, that, for instance, 'transformation of heat into mechanical effect’ expresses a fact and does not explain the physical process. We also say, he exemplifies, that ice is transformed into water and this is not dependent on how and why it happens. He adds that these kinds of questions are useless and typical of poets and philosophers of nature (Mayer 1978, p. 52). ‘Transformation’ does not explain therefore what is going on in a physical process. The concept was instead used to connect observable data.
From this, and some other stuff about Joule which I found not as fun to read, Coelho concludes:
Energy is usually presented in the following way: ‘energy can neither be created nor destroyed but only transformed’. If energy cannot be destroyed, it must be a real existing thing. If its form changes, it must be something real as well. Thus, that statement can easily lead to the concept of energy as something material. The German physician Robert Mayer did not find, however, anything like a substance but rather a methodology for dealing with phenomena. Using observable or measurable elements, he established equivalences between different domains, such as those which concern heat, motion, position or electricity. Let us suppose that we use Mayer's methodology for dealing with phenomena. In this case, we know in advance that an equivalence is established by us between certain quantities. Hence, we do not need the ‘indestructibility’ of an entity to express that the quantity does not change. As we also know that we establish equivalences between mechanical, thermal, electrical quantities, we do not need to suppose the ‘transformability’ of the same entity. Thus, we understand energy conservation and transformation as a consequence of our dealing with the phenomena. Some difficulties with the concept of energy as something material can be overcome.
Since I don't see a problem with energy as a substance, I don't find the need for such an explanation quite as compelling as Coelho does, but I do find it intriguing. It might be useful as an additional way to think about energy, alongside the substance metaphor we like so much.

Friday, May 13, 2011

Existing research themes

Below are some of the ongoing research interests of the Energy Project. We encourage you to pursue whatever research interests grab you, whether those originate with you or with us. You do not need to pursue any of these. However, to help prepare for your EPSRI experience, we encourage you to pick at least ONE of the following topics and read the related articles and blog posts.

Embodied learning activities. In ELAs, instructors deliberately arrange for human bodies or parts of the body to stand for entities in the description or explanation of a phenomenon. ELAs are intended to promote and externalize conceptual understanding in physics for the benefit of the learner, the instructor and the researcher. An ELA we call "Energy Theater" plays a central role in Energy Project instruction.
R. E. Scherr, H. G. Close, S. B. McKagan, and E. W. Close, “‘Energy Theater’: Using the body symbolically to understand energy,” C. Singh, M. Sabella, and S. Rebello (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2010 Physics Education Research Conference)
E. W. Close, H. G. Close, S. B. McKagan, and R. E. Scherr, “Energy in action: The construction of ideas in multiple modes," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and S. Rebello (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2010 Physics Education Research Conference)
E. C. Kahle, R. E. Scherr, and H. G. Close, “An evolving model for seeing colored objects; A case study progression,” C. Singh, M. Sabella, and S. Rebello (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2010 Physics Education Research Conference)
H. G. Close and R. E. Scherr, "Differentiation of Energy Concepts Through Speech and Gesture in Interaction," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

Other groups doing embodied learning activities:
Kinesthetic Astronomy
Paradigms in Physics kinesthetic activities

Conceptual metaphors for energy.
We find it very useful to use a substance metaphor for energy, in which objects are containers, and energy is in the containers. This metaphor supports ideas of conservation, flow, transfer, storage, etc, which are among our primary learning goals.
R. E. Scherr, H. G. Close, and S. B. McKagan, "Intuitive Ontologies for Energy in Physics," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

R. Duit, Should energy be illustrated as something quasi-material?, International Journal of Science Education 9 (1987), pp. 139–145.
Swackhamer, G. (2005). Cogntive resources for understanding energy. [unpublished draft].

Amin, T. G. (2009). Conceptual metaphor meets conceptual change. Human Development(52), 165-197.

Teacher and learner empowerment. A primary goal of the Energy Project is to help participating teachers value beginners as legitimate participants in the scientific process – to value themselves and their students as intelligent agents who can figure out scientific ideas from scratch. We have adapted the Algebra Project instructional framework described by R. Moses for teacher professional development.
Close, H. G., DeWater, L. S., Close, E. W., Scherr, R. E., & McKagan, S. B. (2010). "Using The Algebra Project method to regiment discourse in an energy course for teachers," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and S. Rebello (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2010 Physics Education Research Conference)
S. B. McKagan, R. E. Scherr, E. W. Close, and H. G. Close, "Criteria for Creating and Categorizing Forms of Energy," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

Rogerian relational discourse. Rogers structures our thinking for how teachers and learners may interact with one another authentically, warmly, and empathetically.

Rogers, C. (1961). Significant learning: In therapy and in education. On becoming a person: A therapist's view of psychotherapy (pp. 279-296). New York: Houghton Mifflin.
R. E. Scherr, H. G. Close, and S. B. McKagan, "Promoting Proximal Formative Assessment with Relational Discourse," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)
Excerpts and reflections on the blog: General approach. Carl Rogers on education parts I, II, and III. Application of theory to classroom observation.

Proximal formative assessment. The practice of teachers' paying continual, moment-to-moment attention to specific aspects of individual students' developing understanding.
Erickson, F. (2007). Some Thoughts on “Proximal” Formative Assessment of Student Learning. Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of Education, 106
(pp. 186-216).
R. E. Scherr, H. G. Close, and S. B. McKagan, "Promoting Proximal Formative Assessment with Relational Discourse," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

B. W. Harrer, R. E. Scherr, M. C. Wittmann, H. G. Close, and B. W. Frank, "Elements of Formative Assessment in Learners' Discourse about Energy," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)

Video Analysis. Research focused on understanding the complex detail of human interaction through careful analysis of video.
R. E. Scherr, "Video analysis for insight and coding: Examples from tutorials in introductory physics," Phys. Rev. – Spec. Topics: Phys. Educ. Res. 5(020106), 1-10 (2009)
B. Jordan and A. Henderson, "Interaction Analysis: Foundations and Practice," The Journal of the Learning Sciences 4(1) , 39-103 (1995)


Derry et al, Guidelines for Video Research

Forms of Energy
. Research on how physicists and learners think about forms of energy.
S. B. McKagan, R. E. Scherr, E. W. Close, and H. G. Close, "Criteria for Creating and Categorizing Forms of Energy," C. Singh, M. Sabella, and P. Englehardt (Eds.), AIP Conf. Proc. (2011 Physics Education Research Conference) (Submitted)
And references therein.

2011 EPSRI Scholars

We excited to announce the 2011 EPSRI Scholars!

EPSRI I (course for elementary teachers, June 27-July 1 and Congress, July 5-6)
Krishna Chowdary, The Evergreen State University
Emma Kahle, Columbia University
Siri Mehus, University of Washington
Lane Seeley, Seattle Pacific University
MacKenzie Stetzer, University of Maine
Enrique Suarez, Tufts University


EPSRI II (course for secondary teachers, August 8-19 and Congress, August 22-23)
Jessica Bartley, Tara High School
Kristy Chun, University of California - Santa Barbara
Abigail Daane, Seattle Pacific University
Dorothy Echodu, Teso University
Virginia Flood, University of Maine
Benedikt Harrer, University of Maine
Mary Bridget Kustusch, North Carolina State University
Amy Robertson, University of Washington

Daily schedule

8am: Arrive at Otto Miller Hall and get everything ready for class.

8:30am: Class begins. You spend the morning either observing class, or doing research development related to the data that you collected earlier.

There are two courses going on at the same time: Course 1, for teachers who are new to the Energy Project, and Course 2, for teachers who took Course 1 last summer. You will be assigned to one of the two courses and will stay with that course the whole time.

In each course, two Scholars will observe class at the same time, and two other Scholars will develop research on that class at the same time. In this way of operating, you have two different kinds of partners: one who is in the room with you, and one who is observing the same group as you but for the other half of the day. Meanwhile, another foursome is conducting research on the course that runs in parallel with yours, so another pair of scholars will be doing research development at the same time as you. This arrangement provides a strong framework for collaboration.

Lunch: Take lunch at the same time as the teachers do, unless you have a better idea. You may bring your lunch or you may walk to Fremont and buy lunch. There is usually a big group that walks to Fremont and back for lunch. There is barely time to do this during the lunch period - you may wind up walking while you eat - but it's a really nice walk.

Afternoon, until 3:30pm: Spend the afternoon either observing class or doing research development related to the data that you collected earlier, whichever one you didn't do in the morning.

3:30-4:30pm: Scholars and instructors meet to discuss the events of the day. We meet in the same room, but at different tables (Course 1 Instructors, Course 1 Scholars, Course 2 Instructors, and Course 2 Scholars), so that people can either have focused discussions amongst themselves or get information or insight from other groups.


Weekends are all yours.