Some of you might have wondered if you can somehow print or save the PERC proceedings papers that are hosted by googleDocs on the Energy Project Hub web page. It turns out that there is a relatively easy way to do this:
1. Click on the title of the paper you want to print/save.
2. Once the document is loaded, click in the URL line of your browser and bring the cursor to the end of the URL by hitting the right arrow key of your keyboard.
3. Then add the string "&chrome=true" to the URL (without the quotation marks, and without any blanks!) an hit Enter.
4. The page reloads with Download and Print buttons at the top.
Insights and updates from Interdisciplinary Research Institute in STEM Education (I-RISE) Scholars, directors, and collaborators
Thursday, August 26, 2010
Friday, August 20, 2010
Dedra's thoughts and episodes from Friday
Ok - so this will be my last post for a while. I would have liked to have finished the transcripts for the episodes I found interesting, but as I clipped 6 today, including 20 mins of last night's instructor meeting, that's not going to happen.
I found the discussion that Rachel, Hunter, Sam, Benedikt and I had after lunch to be very fruitful. As we talked about this mechanism issue, Rachel and Hunter keyed in on an important point - this is an emotional issue - when a person is satisfied that they have found 'causation' that is really an issues of personal view. For example, do you think evaporation is a cause, or is that not a word you'd accept as a cause? I think that depends highly on whether or not you trust the person using it thoroughly understands the word (and implied agrees with your understanding). A second example: If a person says the reason this charge moved is because of that one over there, the implication of cause is coulomb's law - that may be fine unless A) you don't think the person understands electric interactions, or B) you're needing an explanation that goes deeper, like QED. But in either case - there is no 'correct' - back to the nature of science. A mechanism, cause, explanation... is only as good as it is to make the person FEEL satisfied with it...
Please add to comments on this one...
So my feelings that there is something interesting going on here with negotiation of meaning about cause and mechanism is quite tied to the fact that they feel compelled to throw out the word force in order to discuss energy. So I see a few angles here: what is mechanism, how does their meaning negotiation relate to the depth of their need for understanding/comfort/emotional state..., and what constraints is ET putting on the idea space if it is limiting them from drawing on force resources? (And it really isn't - they use force all the time... but seem to think their final 'answer' can't have force in it)
So I will mull over these things. Here's a brief synopsis of the episodes I captured today since I won't transcribe them or give them their own posts:
E1 100819 1502 Instructor meet mechanism modeling consensus.mov
This is a 24 minute clip of the instructor meeting where SV talks about being unclear with the use of the word mechanism, but I expanded it to also include the topic of consensus building. I would have to look at this fresh - but it seems very related, and at minimum starts to give the instructor side of this story. There's discussion in here about whether or not the broader physics community even has consensus about the word mechanism - an idea Hunter echoed this afternoon in an even stronger way - that it may not even be a 'scientific' term (my wording, not his).
E1 100820 0931 Tim_value_of_social_learning.mov
This was one of the first discussions of Friday morning. This is only a 3 min clip. There is a discussion going on briefly about whether to discuss things in forces vs. energy, and also the benefit of ah-ha moments, and how that solidifies ideas. (the mic quality isn't good) social learning is explicitly mentioned - but not taken up by the group as being off topic, but they discuss there being value in having the participants figure things out. they mention early frustration about the class - and whether everyone gets it now - they seem to think it's been a huge benefit. there's discussion about the instructors being aware of where things were going. I'm not sure how useful this clip is... comments of interest are brief and sound quality isn't great.
E1 100820 0931 Tim_workshop_purpose.mov
a bit later they again start talking about purpose. This clip is 8 mins long. Here they were explicitly prompted to discuss what's useful. "the instructor avoids defining any damn thing" you can't do that - need to put structure to it.. but need to give kids genuine opportunities to put ideas together on their own and be the guide on the side, and (compare formulations around the room). they're talking explicitly about the content and activities in the workshop really helped promote the kind of conversations they needed - brought out their ideas - gained fundamental insights about how energy works... consensus making process is great - they talk here about the need for MORE consensus... they also talk about tricking the students into thinking some meta-discussion is a 'fun side discussion' (my words) so the students are engaged thinking they're stealing time away from boring stuff, but it's actually the discussion the teacher wants them to have. I find this really ironic because IT IS EXACTLY WHAT IS HAPPENING in the moment for them! they're no longer answering the given prompts in their group, but they're having the meta-discussion about teaching that the workshop is 'really' about... This is a nice clip for thinking overall about the purpose of the workshop and their buy-in....
E1 100820 0931 Tim_reflecting_on_teaching.mov
Here again they're asked explicitly to reflect on the teaching in the workshop. This is a 7 min clip. They say they had to 'invent the objective' - Two participants say something explicit about knowing SV and trusting his teaching methods, and wondering if he did these things on purpose. They like the tools but found their use a bit vague at times "that huge highway could have been made a bit narrower" They express some frustration about concrete things they came to consensus on but never got back to. ('a disconnect') They also say they would have rather known the objective up front. They also think that the participants are homogeneous - want similar goals, but in their own classrooms they have to deal with different interest levels. 6 mins or so in, there is brief mention of why energy is a good topic for the course - that there are several different formats for discussing it. I wish this point had gone further. An interesting point they make is how without a standard for representations (on whiteboards) they were able to interpret other people's work. I'm not sure how directly useful this clip is to me, but probably useful to thinking about ET goals.
The last two clips interest me most (each about 3-4 mins long)
E1 100820 1031 Tim_force_energy_causation.mov
In this one the F=ma is explicitly stated - and ironically Tim who says they should keep it in context of energy (he's the one that used the word force and bruce argued he shouldn't the day before!!) Arny goes back to this energy/force confusion - he asks pointedly what role the force plays - doesn't the rubber band just stand for elastic potential energy? Arny uses the word 'cause' in a way that seems really provocative (is that REALLY what causes it?) - Tim seems to agree but one group member answers with the same force argument they just made. Then someone says that the removal of the string creates an unbalanced force that then allows the energy to be released. Arny wants more clarification... and he gets a simple physics answer - i don't think that's what he wanted...
E1 100820 1031 Tim_cause_mechanism_discussion.mov
Here they have an analogy of the rubber band in space. Tim uses the word push a lot, it's the mechanism for transferring that energy. Very briefly someone says 'do we have to have an object?' - unfortunately this line is dropped... There seem to be two levels of discourse (at least) within the group, and a lot of interesting statements are dropped for re-stated force explanations. Arny says the rubber band in outer space is like the car upside-down, which is really nice. Then they go back to 'what is the cause' - they seem to find that point difficult - but settle on it being the push "F=ma".
These last two clips are from about 15 mins of discussion they had about the rubber band launch. They were asked: 'what is the funder, what object is exerting the force, what causes the launch" There seems to be Tim and Arny trying to have a deeper discussion about cause and mechanism, where Tim and Janel keep repeating F=ma based reasoning. I'm not sure where Mary's ideas are here...
Anyway - food for later thought - time to return to Oregon!!
Thursday, August 19, 2010
feedback on being a videographer
I think it would be really useful to know the activities and the goals, and the instructional strategies ahead of time. While this might bias the way I look at things, I think I already come in with a bias, I have my own ideas of where I might go with certain prompts or how i might address certain things - so knowing what the instructional team has in mind would help me focus. For me, the instructional meeting at the end of the day isn't really doing that.
I also think that having more focused time to talk with the other videographers about what we find interesting and why would be good. I liked the idea of this afternoon's looking at video together (sorry I slept through half of it!!) but I have not been looking at things on that level - and as a part time visitor I don't think that level of detail is where I'd want to focus. Maybe not.. I'm not sure about that. But I would have rather watched a 5 min clip silently, thought about it, discussed, then honed in on details. Maybe that's just because i'm a think before talker...???
Or maybe I'd just want to be given something specific to think about that would be useful - because maybe I'm thinking about things that have already been exhausted in conversations, or are not of interest to the general SPU group. Or maybe you want an outside perspective? I'm thinking a lot about modeling, community building, and buy-in because these are issues relevant to me in my teaching - but maybe that's not where everyone else is? Perhaps it's this worry about miss-match that's causing me to want the above two things...???
Anyway - 2 cents from me. I hope I've made a contribution. I'm still not sure if I have...
AARGH! but still some useful comments
So today I did the stupid mistake of not turning the video camera on - and that with spending lots of time fixing the mic, re-adjusting the position, and all!! I feel like such a dope! But lesson learned... I hear kayla got good recordings though. And I do have a few things I'd like to point out from my notes...
The first question they were asked to reflect on in groups was about how the potential energy discussion from the previous day would relate to 6th grade teaching. I posted previously about this - about how consensus is being formed, and whether or not there is a need to be more explicit about it. However, even in a fairly off-task group (which the group I watched today was), the main points seem to be coming up (if i'm even right on what the 'main points' are - see my post on being a videographer). Here are some snippets (not exact quotes but close):
- when you learn a new method... when you need to attack new material use a known method - then relates it to ET - all the sudden yesterday was using ET that [we] now know well to tackle hard stuff - yesterday put [the participants] in the position of what is it like to ... put me in [6th graders] shoes
what interested me about this statement is that she is echoing Eleanor's statement from last week (about new techniques best being explored through known situations while new situations are best explored through known techniques), that was said during a wrap-up discussion but never really made concrete. I thought it was a beautiful point then and wanted it really driven home, so was happy to see it creeping up again. How does this happen? What do they absorb? As teachers, how do we know how effective we are in getting this kind of idea across without feeling the need to harp on it? I still have that feeling that saying something repeatedly is necessary - it's reassuring to me as a teacher, but is not done here AT ALL... but rather giving someone repeated need to work things out themselves is the technique used here - but when doing that, without having a bunch of people observing, how would we ever catch such a gem of a statement where we hear them buying-in??
- all represented something in different ways - have to know what arrows... mean
This statement relates back to the consensus idea - it came up the previous day that one of the whiteboards had arrows used two different ways (I have that in my recording - and they were referencing this in specific) - here they were talking about different representations being good, and strengths and weaknesses of different models, but explicitly stating that you have to know what the things mean - have to be explicit about definitions. This was a point of frustration for me yesterday - why wasn't that point 'driven home' by the instructors - but yet it was there today... how? this was the example I used in my previous post - that I would have asked a wrap up activity to get them to state this explicitly yesterday - but it was still there today - they remembered that flaw and realized the need for consistency. (later at another table during wrap-up discussion someone says "a model is a representation - what are the good things about it and what doesn't work so well" - that should be on Kayla's video)
- 6th graders... if kid didn't have any real world reference points, what might PE look like... experiences to hang the concepts on i think they'd be lost - gotta introduce those first concepts - can make that JUST AS EXPERIENTIAL - hesitate to call what SV does as inquiry-based, it's MYSTERY-BASED
This was the quote of the day - absolutely brilliant - Arny again!! but mystery-based - that's how i feel... this whole process is a mystery. how is it working? i feel in the dark - they feel in the dark, yet somehow it's all working out. But beyond that - it's beautiful that they realized that even when introducing new concepts they think they CAN find an experiental way of doing it - even if this activity isn't exactly what they want to replicate.
There was also this cute moment:
- ball 1 and ball 4 will be same... elastic collision (lots of agreement with him) multiple chiming in here 'that's how i labeled mine too!!'
they were all excited about consensus not just in the idea but in the representation
- every single one of these balls was stuck, no recoil - completely inelastic - what happens is not only conservation of momentum but also a pulse of force
this was after the demo when they were asked to work it out in their group - i didn't get it at all ... 'also a pulse of force' ... what? and why are force and momentum not being related here? What about impulse??? This echos the idea i brought up at the instructor meeting this evening - that they seem hesitant to use the word force because this is "energy theater" (or energy workshop... or whatever) but force is an important role - it is the mechanism (in one way of defining that term) - why not encourage them to see what role force plays rather than to have them feel like they shouldn't use the word? What explicitly makes them feel like force is a bad word in here?
Here's another moment that emphasizes this:
- they're deliberately trying to confuse us by separating out magnetic force and magnetic potential
this seems counter-productive to me. but there's something deeper about this whole issue. I brought this point up in the instructor meeting (Benedikt got the video) and SV said something about Costos (spelling??) suggesting a different use of the word mechanism, and that we could have the full ET without getting into terminology trappings, and thus enable consensus building within the community without a need to match terminology to the broader physics community (he said something like 'we don't run into any trouble there')... because this is a big concern, right? we want THEM to build meaning, community, consensus - but AT SOME POINT they need to relate to the broader world of physicists which usually (though SV pointed out a lot of the things addressed here aren't so clear) already has their own consensus (terminology definitions). And SV may be doing something great in finding a workshop that bypasses this - but at some point doesn't it have to happen in our classrooms? I think during the meeting SV was arguing no, but I don't agree. I agree it doesn't have to be our focus - but if training people to go into the workforce, grad school, whatever - it has to happen at some point. HOW DO I RECONCILE THIS???
At one point I thought I heard the group use the word 'capability' instead of energy - that seems to me to be quite analogous to 'potential' and perhaps how it came up - I think it would be interesting to explore their term use more - in terms of sense-making (not conceptual understanding) - like the quote i posted from several days back where they decide to use the word process instead of mechanism, because for that group process held more meaning - it was more clear.
Otherwise there was a lot of background noise today and my group spent a lot of time off topic - so while I'm frustrated I don't have exact quotes for these snippets - that's the best I could type in real time and it captures most of what I found interesting...
Dedra's thurs morning notes
I don't know how to actually delete this post :( all the info has been put elsewhere now
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
reflection on (during :P) instructor meeting
This whole idea is coming up about being explicit about a zero-point for potential energy - and I'm glad Hunter is saying that we need BOTH to realize there is a choice, AND to make that choice (explicit) - and Lane is now talking about doing a consensus forum again tomorrow. I am glad to hear this conversation.
I think the one thing that's been bothering me is that I want to see more concreteness - and I don't want to be thinking on a shallow level 'give me an answer' - but on this level of understanding that system choices, models, levels of detail, origins... are all choices - but we still need to be explicit about them in order to have productive scientific discourse.
I think I've seen a lot of groups go around and around because they are talking across each other. They sometimes reach the idea that the reasons they're not saying the same things is because of system choices (or one of these other things) - which is terrific - they're building this idea of needing to be explicit, they're understanding that there are multiple explanations/models... they're thinking about strengths and weaknesses of representations...
THIS IS TERRIFIC - but I feel there's no resolution...
So how do we get them to have resolution (more concreteness) without dictating it? In my classroom, I dictate it - 'ok, so we've run into a dilemma - we can't interpret that without making the origin explicit' - then i demonstrate the use of multiple conventional choices, and discuss their strengths/weaknesses.
Better yet - can we get them to do more consensus? If, for example, after they looked at other table's whiteboard representations of the scenarios this morning, they made an explicit list about what choices were made, what was represented, what they found confusing (a conversation at my table about using arrows in two different ways - both to show more and to show up - probably not being a good idea) and so forth? Having something that they are generating rather than a summary discussion or just moving onto a new puzzle?
I fear they're in the middle of a tough spot - on the one hand, we don't want to promote 'giving answers' but on the other hand, we don't want them spinning their wheels (or not reflecting on the beautiful nuggets they do come up with).
There is the model of thinking that goes initially people think right/wrong, then they think everything is relative, then eventually they come to realize that there are answers they can stand behind based on argumentation, even though other answers could also be reasonable. (Perry scale)
We don't want to leave the participants in this middle place...
Thoughts???
transcript showing concern about using word force, and force relating to mechanism
This post relates directly to my other posts - and probably doesn't make much sense as a stand-alone, but the idea is basically these two points:
- how are they using the word mechanism, and do we need to be more clear about it
- do they feel inhibited to use the word force, and is this problematic?
here's the transcript (video is joe buoyancy mechanism) - my main points of interest are in color. The purple bit is the real gem - the red bits are also interesting. I'm concerned that Tim is referring to an outside authority - not a negotiated meaning of mechanism. No one else seems to see it that way - he's the only one clear about it, but it isn't his construct. It's also interesting how Bruce keeps wanting to only talk energy but uses force terms like push. Bruce is basically pushing this whole reconciliation of their two explanations because of Tim's use of the word buoyancy in the whiteboard diagram - Tim says it is problematic because they should only talk energy. I think bringing up COM is interesting here, Bruce says 'that's one spot that's gravity' - I think Bruce is seeing bringing up COM as requiring a force explanation, where only energy is needed. He has a good point there and it's dropped completely. Energy explanations don't require the particle model, but Tim is relying on one. Mostly I'm still wowed by their negotiation of mechanism... I hope this is clear below:
J = joe, mic wearer
M = mary lady in pink shirt
L = lady in blue jacket
B = bruce in green jacket and grey t-shirt
T = tim in blue t-shirt
C = Chris
[B] Tim can you show me your explanation (points to the whiteboard)
[T] um the water is going to push down on the ball right?
(the females are having a side conversation here i'm ignoring until they join tim and bruce - joe is silent through this)
[B] the water is going to push down the ball?
[T] well the water is pushing down so it's going to displace the ball
[B] no it's going to displace the water
[T] it's going to displace the ball - why does the ball float
[B] are you going back to buoyancy? I'm going back to energy
[T] buoyancy is the - gives the ball kinetic energy
[B] i'm going back to KE - i'm going back to this. Here's my original level of the water, right? you know i should say this is my original level of the water right? (he's pointing/drawing on the whiteboard?) i have this ball, i push it down, it says hey water get out of the way because i'm coming down here so the water can not go any other way except up
[T] uh huh
[B] so the water continues up
[00:01:14.29]
[B] the water is being displaced - i'm doing this in terms of energy so what i have now is
[T] so what have you done...
[B] i have this block here of water, this is my displaced water
[T] what if you take it sort of that the ball is already under water level and you don't have to worry about the higher..
[B] you still got all this i have to push it down
[T] that doesn't matter but what have you done to the PE of the water
[B] what i've done is i've raised the water level, ok, i've and the water wants to come back down again so i have increased the the height of the water ...
[C] the gravitational potential energy
[B] right i've increased GPE of the water so you showed it that way and then i'm saying that the water wants to come back down so now i'm holding this down here when i let go the water says um
[C] but it
[B] the water wants to come back down and take the place of the ball
[00:02:16.07]
[B] and so the ball moves up say a little bit but when it moves up from here to up there it pushes some of the water
[C] out
[B] yea it helps push it away so actually what i think is going on is that the water is going like that as well as the ball is moving straight up
[M] when you let go
[B] yea and and then it ... (drops the whiteboard marker on the diagram)
[T] that's when it reaches the top
[B] it never reaches the top totally right?
[T] it doesn't need to
[M] if it stops it might
[B] but that's my interpretation but to draw it is to here (can't quite hear but he's again dropping the marker on the drawing)
[T] ok, that's fine but the way tod (some discussion about the name of the guy with others chiming in) he talked he simplified he said you only have to consider the center of mass of the water
[B] ok
[T] so to push the ball down you raise the center of mass of the water
[B] ok
[00:03:26.23]
[T] so when that goes down you've lost Gravitational potential and its transferred that to KE of the ball
[C] can you say that again louder ...
[T] so you have the center of mass of my cup of coffee (he lifts it up) is is right there and
[B] there's all different ways to model this
[T] uh if i push something in there i raise the level somewhat but it doesn't matter it's i've raised the COM of that cup of coffee and that's really what you can consider ... active in COM instead of worrying about all the... details of the system (I can't quite get this)
[B] so
[T] the point was that the ball at the bottom has buoyancy it's because the the water has GPE and .. the COM can fall so the COM of the water goes down it loses PE transfers that to KE of the ball, ball increases in KE and i've also got like a bit of feedback where because you have drag with resistance in the water it's transferring KE back to the water
[B] oh that's interesting
[C] so you're thinking it's GPE of the water that it's falling.. pulled down so it's pushing
[T] yea... (can't hear) i mean it doesn't matter to overanalyze that part it's just that water the COM of the water goes down the ball goes up the ball goes into motion so you don't have to worry about forces necessairly but but the object's got buoyancy usually (?) here and it's drag here (pointing to the diagram) usually so, it's simple enough
[B] the only reason i'm just sharing this scenario is because i wanted to keep it all with energy
[00:05:21.23]
[B] rather than COM and buoyancy
[T] well COM just tells you how you can look at position of the water
[B] that's one spot - that's gravity...
[T] well you're talking about GPE so it acts on you can take that COM of the water as as the point where it acts on
[B] right..... ok i just thought it should be all because this is all about energy i thought he wanted us to keep it more to energy
[T] this is in terms of energy
[B] yea although you had the word buoyancy in there
[T] i don't see a problem - that's the mechanism
[B] you're going to call that the mechanism
[T] that's how it transfers it's you know like the interaction that causes that to action (?) this KE transfers because of buoyancy this KE transfers because of drag
[C] so those are the forces
[T] umm.. yea they generalize them as interactions not necessairly forces... because friction..
[B] ok
[C] who generalizes who genera i said they generalize it so i'm going to ask who
[T] the smart people with hats um i did a pilot there's this interactions.. they used that format and i've seen it somewhat in biology...
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)