Tuesday, August 10, 2010

Energy is not matter; it's woo-woo.

Today in E1 small groups discussed the question of whether there is really energy flow in physical systems (as Energy Theater suggests), or whether energy is more the kind of thing that disappears from one location and appears in another, without necessarily following a physical trajectory from A to B. Arny said that he definitely thinks we are pretty limited by the human-bodies representation of energy, but he also thinks that a biochemist could tell us "remarkable details" about the bodily processes by which chemical energy is transformed into bodily motion, and that those processes constitute an energy flow. Here is what Chris says to that (transcript below):



Chris: But that is an ideal that energy is a something.  And it’s that something can move from here to there.  Where energy is not a something, it's the ability to make something or do something, but it's not the something that can actually go from here to here and transform and change from here to here.  It's not, the way you, you can go through the, we know that there is, chemicals that move as a result of this, and we speak of, due to respiration and blah blah blah, but the thing energy itself is not a thing at all.
Sara: So then are you saying that energy itself is formless?
Chris: Yes.  That is what I'm saying.  Energy itself is formless.  It makes - it does make things move, but what is it?  It is, in itself, [???].  Woo oo!  This is,  I mean, it is what makes things do what it does, but there's nothing, we cannot represent and say, oh here's this little bit of energy going to this little bit of energy, because that's saying it is actually a bit, and it's actually, [mouth motions].

It seems like Chris is trying to say that energy is ineffable - almost inexpressible.

There is an intervening few minutes in which they talk about the energy in glucose, and the photoelectric effect.  Chris continues to strongly defend the distinction between energy and "particles."  Arny says, "It's not matter, but does that mean it's nothing?" and Chris says "It's woowoo."  (Big prize to LESLIE for helping me understand that she was saying "woowoo," not "mubu," though we both liked mubu.)  Tell me what you think.

We had such an interesting lunchtime conversation that Rachel told us that we should post about it on this blog

Reflecting on observations from last Monday's energy theater in E2 (see here and here), Leslie, Sandy and I were talking about different approaches to teaching/facilitating energy theater, over lunch today. I felt like I could see a difference between emphasizing the (physical) content in one case and the (energy theater) representation in the other case. From there, we engaged in a vivid and lengthy conversation about the specifics of content and representation. We were exploring if there is something like content without representation or representation without content. Or even and idea without representation.

Representation and Social Interaction in Energy Theater

Rachel just walked into the videographers' room and asked me if I had seen anything interesting today. Of course I've seen many interesting things, but there was only one that made me jump up to find a piece of paper to write on it.

I was observing students in E1 working through their first implementation of Energy Theater, where they were trying to work out the energy transfers and transformations during the process of drawing a bow. They decided on their objects of interest fairly quickly, and then spent a long time discussing how much energy should go where. While they were negotiating this there were clearly some students who felt confident about what was happening, and others who felt less confident. While they were negotiating, I noticed the group shift their attention back and forth between gesturing with their representation (the regions laid out on the floor) and discussing with each other several times.

I think that because the representation and the social interaction are located in the same space, Energy Theater makes this type of switch much easier than when students are working on another representation such as a blackboard. When working on a blackboard, the confident students standing closest to the board can plow ahead with their plan without the consent of their colleagues. However in Energy Theater attention directed towards the shared representation is also directed towards the shared social space, which makes it more apparent when anybody is confused or uncomfortable. I think it is easier for groups to form consensus when working with a representation that happens to be their colleagues.

I've read a bit about the design behind Energy Theater... is this something that people had in mind when they came up with it?

Discovery learning and discovery teaching

I forgot how fantastic and teacher-appropriate this article is.  Energy 2, especially, is grappling with the tension this paper negotiates, in the course of reflecting on the Algebra Project method and whether they might use something like it themselves.

D. Hammer, "Discovery learning and discovery teaching,"Cognition and Instruction,15(4), 485-529. (1997)

Abstract: Teachers interested in promoting student inquiry often feel a tension between that agenda and the more traditional agenda of "covering the content." Efforts in education reform devote substantial time to addressing this tension, primarily through curriculum reform, paring the traditional content and adopting inquiry-oriented methods. Discovery learning approaches, in particular, are designed to engage students in inquiry through which, guided by the teacher and materials, they "discover" the intended content. Still, the tension remains, in moments, for example, when students make discoveries other than as intended.
How teachers experience and negotiate these moments depends largely on their expectations of curriculum and instruction. For some, successful instruction entails progress through a planned set of observations and ideas, and such moments of divergence may represent impediments. Others see the classroom as an arena not only for student exploration but also for teacher exploration, of the students' understanding and reasoning, of the subject matter, of what constitutes progress toward expertise and how to facilitate that progress. For them, successful instruction depends on teachers' often unanticipated perceptions and insights. One might call this discovery teaching.
This article presents a detailed account of a week of learning and instruction from the author's high school physics course, to provide a context for discussion of the role and demands of teacher inquiry. On the view supported here, the coordination of student inquiry and traditional content is not simply a matter of reducing the latter and welcoming the former. It is a matter of discerning and responding to students' particular strengths and needs.

Monday, August 9, 2010

"Why are your white boards different?"

After Energy 1 had made white boards describing an energy scenario they observed on the ship canal today, Stamatis asked something like this: "Several of you observed an airplane flying by.  You observed the same phenomenon.  So why are your white boards different?"

This seems like a terrific example of a particular kind of question.  I was pretty sure I knew where Stamatis was going, because of my previous experience with the class: the participants had just done the people talk and pictorial representation (white boards of walk on the ship canal), so the next step in the Algebra Project sequence is to identify the features of energy scenarios.  They are going to brainstorm possible features, then choose the most important features, then develop (or maybe be given?) a representation that shows those features.  So the white boards are different because they have not yet agreed on a common representation, because they have not yet agreed on the important features of energy scenarios.  Stamatis's question, thus, is intended to motivate the upcoming string of activities.  I would think this is probably why he asked it - in order to give participants a kind of a puzzle, or preview; something that hints at what's ahead, and if it's a little bit mysterious, maybe that just makes it tantalizing.

On the other hand, people might just find the question bizarre; who would think that different groups' white boards would be magically the same?  That can't be the real question, so what is the real question, if any, and what is the instructor trying to accomplish by this mysteriousness?  I can easily imagine the question making people anxious.  After all, it's unanswerable within their current experience.

I think that this kind of question sends the message that the class is about to go somewhere that is known to the instructor and not known to the students.  Some people probably feel safe knowing that, like they have a knowledgeable driver in an unfamiliar city.  Others might feel like unwilling captives, not knowing where they are being taken or whether it's somewhere they want to go.  In either case I think part of what the question accomplishes is to frame participants as passengers in the vehicle.

Sunday, August 8, 2010

References?

Twice last week I was asked for references, and I've spent some time tracking some down. (I'm terrible at remembering titles and authors. I use Mekentosj Papers to help organize and categorize what I've read - and it helps - but I'm still kind of bad at this.)

(1) References having to do with teaching from the students' perspective (that is, not charting a course based on the expertise of a scientist - directing students to a known answer, but instead helping them untangle their knots and work together to figure something out).

Duckworth; Hammer (Disc. Learning and Disc. Teaching); Schauble (just about anything - there's a recent paper I love - "supporting the development of the epistemology of inquiry"); Deborah Ball (he description of Shay numbers seems like it must be an inside-out view); Mortimer and Scott (The Tension Between Authoritative and Dialogic Discourse - Kara - via Rachel - reminded me of this literature).

(2) Then the other line of research had to do with questions-that-aren't-questions, or the role and meta-messages of question. For this I think of Lakoff's "Women, Fire and Dangerous Things" where he reports on (Grice??) and what it is to "lie." Tannen and framing. And Conversation Analysis and a paper on "I dunno..." (asking kids "are you popular" and they say "oh, I don't know. I guess." - the "I dunno" has a role in the conversation that has nothing to do with knowing/not-knowing).

This is still all too vague. I'll keep working on this and updating this list as I come up with specifics.

Friday, August 6, 2010

Why I love being here

Today is Friday, day 5 of my experience as an Energy Project Videographer (EPV). I have been in Seattle for almost a week, and I really fell in love with this city, although I haven't seen a lot of it, yet. It is so green, here! That is really amazing, especially all the over-abundantly flowering front yards. And the weather is perfect, it is cool and sometimes cloudy in the morning, when I am going to work, and once we're done at the university, it's the most beautiful day outside, inviting to sit outside or go for a walk (today is probably an exception, though).

At SPU, I received a warm welcome into the "inner circle" of the energy project. I had just met everybody at AAPT/PERC, two weeks ago, but it was like meeting up with old friends. Monday was my first day on-site, and Leslie and I got introduced to the general procedures by Rachel and Sam. Then everything went very fast, and Leslie and Sam ended up sitting in the classroom, videotaping the morning session, while Rachel and I were participating in the warm-up energy theater. Right away, this experience was amazing, and I was inspired to look at the recorded data, later-on to do some analysis. And I am still working on that. In fact, I felt like I could have gone home after the Monday morning session, having gathered enough data to spend the next year analyzing it.
But no, I returned to the classroom as EPV in the afternoon, to take field notes of what was happening. It turns out that that's a lot. As an observer in a classroom, I felt totally overwhelmed by the amount of information that I was swamped with. How could I ever note everything down that was happening, right now? And then try to process some of it, at the same time, and write my own thoughts on that down? Eventually, I decided to focus on what I could see happening in "my" group, to not pay too much attention to what people were saying. After all, I would be able to listen closely while watching the video. But it might be interesting to have some kind of narrative of what people are doing, with a general sense of content, but without much detailed dialog or interpretation, in my field notes to have anchor points for watching the video later.
After the afternoon session, all the instructors and researchers ("visiting scholars") met in the "lounge" for a debriefing of the day and exchanging thoughts about the next day. Sitting there with the entire team, being able to raise questions about something that we observed during the day was such a rich opportunity to have intellectual exchange happening.

Unlike the first day, Rachel and I usually spend the mornings outside the classroom, processing video data, posting blog entries, thinking, talking, etc. Otherwise, the structure of the day is the same each day. But it does not at all get boring. There is just so much going on around us, it is really amazing. Which brings me to my conclusion and the answer to the "question" I raised in the title: Since the moment I arrived here, I have felt to be a (somewhat) important part of a very very interesting project. I am immersed in a rich and fertile environment (and I am fully aware of my metaphor), I feel like I will be able to grow a lot (intellectually) during the three weeks that I am spending here. Working on the energy project with those fantastic people that are so enthusiastic and accessible (meaning: always willing to talk about what they are doing and thinking) has already been so much fun, and will continue to be fun and a source of intellectual inspiration. I am proud to be here.