Wednesday, June 30, 2010

that's what keeps us lively

final episode and my favorite from today

happy medium

Here's a clip from Wednesday with a different view of energy theater. Eric and Jamie are in conversation; transcript follows the clip.


[00:00:05.03]
eric: you know one thing that I've been kind of arguing with myself about here, a lot of the stuff that we did, it's all, the inquiry based, you know how we have this big emphasis on inquiry based learning. That's great. But I think we're pushing it to the point where we're kind of skipping the facts part, you know what I mean? I've got, I've met so many kids--high school kids--that have no concept of fifth grade principles, you know what I mean? Hard learning stuff, they should know. And you're not going to be able to do your inquiry based learning as a sophomore if you don't already have this background knowledge. And we're kind of not..., I mean, when I went to school, they focused on that. Man, they went bing, bing, bing [repeated hand chopping gesture], they beat all the hard knowledge, you know, all the book work, right? And you did some experiments. So, there wasn't a lot of inquiry based learning, but [looks away, shrugs with lower arms] later on, when I got into a situation where there was inquiry based learning, at least I had an idea of what to expect, or knew what was happening because I had the...[puts hands in pockets], I don't know. You've got to have a happy medium! I think we're, you know, but it's just like it swings back and forth [motions hand back and forth] Do it this way, no do it this way.

[akbar leaves conversation].

jamie: It's actually, lends itself more to, at least the way we've been learning, more to learning theory about how, actually, people learn.

eric: yeah

jamie: you know, taking our prior knowledge and either using that, or expanding on that, so, um, how do you..., some of that can be done through experimentation. some of it has to do with, you know, there is some of that 'sage on stage,' we have to explain it [motions with both hands in front of him]. We know [hands motion forward, as if handing something], we have to explain it. So, totally, I agree with you. It's like, finding the happy medium, the happy medium between the two.

this is awesome

This post is intended as a comment on Sam's "Sick of Energy Theater" post. This clip is from Friday's energy theater, and is just one tiny data point, but is still some positive feedback. Watch it and see [interesting comment occurs ~0:30]...

Jamie's end comment, "I wish our kids could do this..." is enigmatic. Watching him directly, and looking at his gestures now, I think he means that the kids would be puzzled and unable to physically work through energy problems like the teachers were doing right there. However, it could be that he simply wants to use energy theater in the class. Other interpretations?

Speeding up processing

We have enough cards that if you're sitting near the camera, it's pretty easy to just swap the cards out during a break and start processing video in the background while you're still in class recording and taking notes. Then when you're off you can focus on making episodes and doing intellectual work rather than grunt work.

Tuesday, June 29, 2010

Cropping video

I am actually making an episode. Hooray! The group I'm watching takes up a tiny portion of the screen, and there's lots of distracting stuff happening all around them, so I wanted to crop the image to show just the group I'm watching. A little googling found the following video explaining how to do this with Quicktime Pro:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NeZDjX3o9mQ

It's boring to watch, but the directions work.

cycling on the water cycle

The water cycle keeps coming up in teacher discussions. I'm assuming it's an important part of grade 4-5 curriculum in the state. Also, it seems to be where teachers have a concrete understanding of something "not being created or destroyed."

Today, I listened to two teachers, Sara and Charlene, working to create energy theater scenarios for their classrooms. Sara wanted to apply energy theater to earth science:

"What if we were to do some sort of energy theater with land and water? We could do faster water, which does erosion, and slower water, which does deposition. But how do you demonstrate a bigger object [like a river, vs. a chair or a plate of spaghetti]? "

Sara and Matt discussed kinetic energy, how there is more in the faster moving water, how the kinetic energy transfers from the water to the soil. "But how does it transfer in deposition?" Sara struggled with both how to understand the energy concepts and with how to create an exercise for her students. At this point, she dropped her questions and focused on on teaching the process of energy theater to kids.

While the water cycle seems a really huge thing to tackle with energy theater, I wonder if there's some way to capture the connection teachers have with the concept. I also find myself wondering how Sara might have worked through her question about how energy transfers in deposition if she had been doing this as energy theater in a group, rather than discussing it sitting at a table.

Energy Theater for 3rd graders : What's too hard?

The one piece of interesting data I got today was a group of teachers planning an activity of Energy Theater on global warming to do with 3rd graders, or maybe 4th graders (there was a lot of discussion about whether the activity was too advanced for 3rd graders). They decided that the objects would be the sun and the earth, and the kids would be the heat energy and the greenhouse gasses in the atmosphere. One teacher asked, "So some people are energy and some people are gasses?" The first teacher said yes, and the other teacher went with it. She corrected her once, when the first teacher lapsed into referring to the thermal energy kids as "the sun", saying, "They're the energy, not the objects!" Otherwise, everybody seemed fine with this odd mix of people playing both energy and objects. Aside from the one lapse, I don't think they were actually confusing matter and energy, just confusing the rules of energy theater. But I could be wrong.

The basic plan was that the heat energy kids would travel from the sun to the earth, and then the greenhouse gas kids would try to leave the earth, and the heat energy kids would stop them. The activity definitely illustrates something, but not really what's going on with energy in global warming.

The really depressing part of this discussion was the part about how much the kids should be allowed to figure out on their own and how much they should be told. The teachers debated all aspects of this issue for a long time, but it seemed like every time they concluded that the kids would not be able to figure anything out on their own and should just be told what to do. At one point, a teacher asked if you should let them come up with their own representations and present them and come up with a consensus representation a la the Algebra Project, or if that was too hard. They all decided it was too hard, and they should just give the kids a representation. After all, it was hard for them, so it would be extra hard for their students.

This brings up an interesting general question: If something is challenging for teachers, does that automatically mean it's too hard for students? For these teachers, the answer was yes. My answer is probably yes for content, but no for process. If instructors are struggling with the content of a quantum mechanics course, it's probably too hard for students (and everyone in Maine will know what I'm talking about). But students are capable of a lot more complex processing than we give them credit for, and you don't need to be an expert at process to teach it.