Wednesday, August 7, 2013

The difference between and/or simultaneity of energy transfer and transformation

In education, I personally feel that using transparent words and phrases is very beneficial when students learn new concepts.  As learners go deeper into topics, then they can further develop their understanding of jargon in the field.  But that jargon can be an impediment early on.  On one hand, we want to introduce students to the proper (i.e. accepted, traditional, etc.) vocabulary as early as possible.  On the other hand, if the vocabulary is an impediment to learning, then it might be best to steer clear.

The video segment below takes place during the first day (8/5/13) of Energy 1.  The task assigned to the groups was to build a list of the “features” and “values” of energy.  For instance, the example given in class was “feature” = starting form and “values” = light, chemical, gravity, magnetic, etc.  Then small groups took 15 minutes to create a list of features and values.  When the full class resumed, features suggested were transformation, transfer, ending value of energy, type of system, and matter effects. I have attached the group's whiteboard for reference at the end of the entry.


The following segment considers a 4 minute conversation at Table 7.  This conversation focuses on establishing the meaning of the words transfer and transformation.  When the video picks up, they have already been talking about this for about 5 minutes and it is clear that not everyone is on the same page.  Jeff and Tanya are the leading voices in attempting to describe the difference; Jeff is giving pretty good examples. Cynthia is the most vocal person in this video, loudly and clearly trying to make sure she gets the difference between the two.  In fact, she seems to be trying to determine if transfer and transformation can occur simultaneously. 


At one point she says, “This is just a question, that you also have transfer when you have transformation.”  Later she asks, “Is our definition of transfer broad enough to include transfer within transformation? Because I’m having trouble making the distinction and I’m not sure if the distinction is important.”

This conversation brings up a few different thoughts in me.  The initial one that I was pulled toward when listening to the conversation live was: do they even know what they are talking about?  It seemed to take some time to establish meanings for the words transfer and transformation.  The fact that this conversation continued for fifteen minutes means, to me, that there is a lack in clarity in what they are talking about.  Are the words transfer and transformation too confusing?  I see my students tripping over these words.  I see even these teachers grappling with these words, looking for the right meaning.  Should we simplify the way we speak?  Instead of saying transformation, could we say “form change?”  Instead of saying transfer, could we say “object change?”  The fact that both words contain “trans” may be adding an impediment that could be avoided.

After listening to this conversation a few more times, one gets the sense that Cynthia has a solid grasp on the difference between transfer and transformation.  What she really wants to grasp now is whether or not both can happen simultaneously.  Consider the statement: When an object is pushed, chemical energy in the body is transformed to kinetic energy in the object.  But this sentence shows both “form change” AND “object change.”  Form goes from chemical to kinetic.  Energy moves from body to object.  Is there a temporal order here?  How important is that ordering in understanding a given situation?  This video clearly shows the challenge inherent in simply vocalizing this issue, much less determining an answer to the question (if there even is a satisfactory answer).  I think later experiences with energy tracking diagrams may lead to deeper analysis of this question.

Full video title: E1 130805 1453 T7-1

Group 7's whiteboard for this activity:

Do long-term, responsive curricula constrain in-the-moment responsiveness?

Framing is everything to me.  Whether I'm participating in a conversation or a research meeting, I want to understand (and jointly negotiate) "what is going on here," and my answer to that question deeply influences how I participate.

I observed E1 yesterday morning, and there were a number of times when I struggled to understand "what was going on there."  Several times, I wrote, "It's not clear to me why Lane is asking the teachers to do this," or, "I think the meaning of this exercise is lost on the teachers."  Other times, I felt that the teachers took up Lane's framing of an activity in different ways than he intended.  For example, in the midst of negotiating features of energy that are common to any scenario (e.g., a ball rolling down a hill, a person jumping up and down, etc.), Lane suggested that they should avoid using terminology that has not been agreed-upon by the group -- that using "science words" like "radiation" can sometimes be "excluding" -- and the teachers took this up as an opportunity to define and discuss what radiation means.  This taking things up in different ways than intended suggests to me that Lane and the teachers weren't framing their participation in the same way.

Today, watching Kara and Susan's field notes, it struck me that maybe what's happening is that the EP instructional staff is introducing tools and representations that we have developed in response to former EP teachers' needs -- negotiation of energy features, Energy Theater, a forms table, etc. -- in ways that are not responsive to where the current teachers are.  Thus, our long-term curricular responsiveness is constraining our in-the-moment responsiveness, and it feels inorganic.

I went back to our field notes from yesterday, and, sure enough, most of the times that I noted that I did not understand what was going on correspond to moments in which the classroom activity shifted toward an activity or representation that we've (EP folks) developed, rather than attending and responding to what is going on in the moment. 

I've never attended to this phenomenon, so maybe it's the norm; maybe enforcing shared representations and shifting teachers' attention toward particular ways of participating supports the development of a classroom community in which teachers work together and put their thinking on display and thus promotes in-the-moment responsiveness.  (So maybe this way of doing things promotes in-the-moment responsiveness in the long term.) 

Kara has expressed interest in looking back at how ET was introduced in past years to see how this fits in...  I'll look forward to her post!

Scientists' notebook vs. research "diary" 

08/05/2013 - Episode 1 (E2, afternoon) 



Here is my first episode form the class on Monday. 
And my first (ever) blog post.

I chose this clip because it surprised me how emotionally Gail (lady in black) reacted to the idea of sharing her notebook with others. This conversation happened right after Rachel informed teachers that by the end of the workshop, they will exchange notebooks with each other. 

Gail is clearly not happy with the idea that someone else will read her notes. She claims that knowing that she is not writing for herself but for others will make her pay more attention to HOW she is writing rather than to WHAT is she putting in her notebook.

I wonder if she would be less upset if sharing notebooks was optional, i.e., if teachers were told that at the end of the workshop they can decide whether they want to share their notes with others or not. That would allow her (and others) to be as open as she wants to and only at the end of the class would decide what she feels like doing. Because she knows from the beginning that she has to share her notes, she feels that she can't be as open as she would like to and that she has to be more neat than she normally is. It found her reasoning against sharing notebooks very interesting.

Energy 1 - Episode 1 - Work?

Tuesday morning, for the four of us who observe during the afternoon, was a technical session to get our episodes ready. For me to find an episode was a matter to go back to my Monday field notes and look for the FLAG tags I used. Then I checked the video on those and decided which episode was worth to share.

Context:

The activity started in a very non traditional way. They were talking about travel agency, they were asked to imagine what features they needed to include in a travel webpage, and then what values will be included for each feature (for example, a feature was transportation, the values were airplane, train, car, etc.).
Then they were asked to do the same for energy. I copy our (Brad and I) field notes on the instructions:
2:48 Lane: "Now we want to make this type of a list for energy values and energy happenings."
They are asked to think about the different types of energy as a feature, and specify the values for each one. It can go either way, first thinking in the features, and then its values, or the other way
Cynthia: "Can we start with an example?"  "Can movement be a feature, or can we give it a scientific term?"
Table 2: combustion equals fire?
Lane: "the features should be features of ALL energy happenings" *There sees to be confusion on how to identify the features and values*

I didn't focus on the confusion around the activity because I was not familiarized with the expectations of that activity. But I got super interested in how they were proposing work as a feature of energy. The way they discuss work and also on their description on why/how potential gravitational energy is doing work (it is only a couple seconds they talk about this).


At the beginning they are pretty sure on work happens in a lot of different forms of energy, they quickly list them. They all seem to agree (or at least no one objects or question them). Will (with the khaki shorts) and John (in the back to the right) are listing the different energy where you can find work. Then Fred (next to will with the name tag) tries to introduce the formal definition of work.
In the past summer teaching seminar they worked on trying to distinguish between work and energy, while here they are trying to label energy as always involving work (at the beginning of the conversation shown).

Scientists' notebooks are personal in style, reminds of ET and work with students' notebooks

In E2 Mon 130805 PM, the groups had been introduced to the idea that they would be sharing their notebooks with each other. Next they were given example excerpts from scientists notebooks (Einstein, two by Pauling, one sketchy and one neat, Jane Goodall, etc.). It was clear that they were very different in style.
 
In the selected group work episode, I was intrigued by how the group relates to the way their own energy theater sessions turn out different and not "universal". Next they turn to discussing how they introduce their students to the task of writing notebooks. On the one hand, there should be room for expressing their personal styles of writing, but then again, if they do not have any examples of what could be done, they will not be able to get starting. In addition, eventually students will have to synthesise their disperse notes into a more standardised lab report.
 

Some of the scientists' notebooks were sketchy and meant to be used for his or her own use, while others were neater and meant to be shared with others. This reminded me of Shaaron Ainsworth’s research on learning by drawing to oneself vs. for others.

http://product.design.umn.edu/courses/pdes3701/documents/drawingtolearn.pdf
http://dl.acm.org/ft_gateway.cfm?id=1854587&type=pdf&CFID=238158373&CFTOKEN=14383620


Monday, July 15, 2013

Group A Reflection: Davenport

I am lucky enough to have participated in Energy Theater myself, and reading the careful analysis of group's discussion in the third paper ("Negotiating Energy Dynamics...") was especially interesting for me as I remembered my own experience with my group, trying to represent our ideas about the energy in a light bulb. In particular, I remember encountering the problem of whether we were representing electrons or electrical energy. At the time I felt that my confusion represented a specific knowledge gap on my part, so it is comforting to see that some other teachers had the same issue.

I think this confusion is the result of an interesting aspect of Energy Theater: Energy is hard to understand primarily because it is nonmaterial. By representing energy as a material substance (specifically by having people "embody" certain amounts of energy), things that actually are material substances (in this case, electrons) are not represented physically! Since we were walking around the circuit, gesturing with our hands to signify "electrical energy", it was easier for us to begin to think that we were electrons that possessed electrical energy, rather than that we were energy in a particular form.

I really liked the idea of the student called "Leah" (do you all typically use their real first names?) who suggests that the group stand within a loop of string that would represent the electron; when people/energy packets left the loop, that would represent that electron losing energy. To me that does (as the student says) solve the matter/energy problem--it becomes easier to see that the electron has its own existence outside of the electrical energy associated with it, and that the electrons don't disappear when the energy is transferred to the filament. I think if my group had thought of that, it would have made a lot more sense to me.

The authors of the article remind us that in Energy Theater, "Motion of objects is supposed to be indicated by including kinetic energy in the area designated for that object, not by displacing the rope that bounds the object-area within the representation space." I am having a hard time picturing what this would look like though. This instruction asks us to make the invisible visible (people represent energy) and the visible invisible (objects are shown to be moving only indirectly, by the expression of kinetic energy.) I am curious about how different learners represent and understand kinetic energy associated with moving objects, and how well different solutions in Energy Theater allow learners to understand their models. 

The authors say that "Energy Theater – a material representation  that uses the metaphor of energy as a substance – contributed to the disambiguation of matter and  energy for these participants...The activity of developing an Energy Theater enactment for this scenario caused the group to grapple with the distinctions between matter and energy, and to invent enactments  that illustrated these distinction". In my own experience, it was reflecting on the "rules" of the theater, particularly that each person represents energy, that reminded us to make a distinction between electrons and electrical energy. 

Still, I admit that I'm not sure I understand Toni's comment at the end of the exchange: "And because you still have energy maintained in the matter, we’re getting hung  up on the matter representation, and what we did was pure energy. Not all the potential is realized." Is Toni saying, Don't worry about the matter, we're supposed to be doing energy? But they are representing some pieces of matter--the bulb, the filament, the socket. Is there a good reason why these parts are represented, while others are not? I suppose that if you are representing electrons along with electrical energy, why not represent air molecules along with thermal energy? Since we don't know energy is there aside from its effects on matter, it does seem natural that we want to include, indeed focus, on matter rather than energy in our representations.

I was discussing my upcoming trip to Seattle with a friend, and she said, you know, energy can be a hard concept to grasp. Aha! Even our metaphors for UNDERSTANDING have to do with interacting with a material substance! The matter/energy problem is one I struggle with in my own biology classroom, and I am looking forward to learning more about how learners may come to understand and resolve it!

Friday, July 12, 2013

Group B readings: Responsiveness

During the last couple months I have been reading and learning about responsiveness. Even though I was not familiarized with this literature, the content of it really aligns with my research perspective.

Ball (1993) talks about the meaning of being a responsive teacher and the impact it can have in the students' learning. She presents a reflection on her own practice while trying to create an intellectually honest learning environment. I think it is important to understand the implications being responsive implies. In order to listen to the student thinking the teacher need to be sensitive to the students ideas. 
I consider the promotion of responsiveness in the classroom responds to a constructivist learning model. By identifying the conceptual models the students articulates during the instruction can allow the teacher to promote further exploration in these to develop a better understanding. While writing this I can not relate this with the extensive studies developed on misconceptions, not referring at them as an obstacle but as an starting point (Smith, DiSessa & Roschelle, 1993). I think responsive teaching is a good reflect on how the identification of the students' cognitive models on the scientific phenomena can be addressed in real time to improve their learning process. For example, Ball while working with elementary students in a responsive learning environment got to understand how their students understand negative numbers operations. The students felt free to give further information on their reasoning and question each other. The identification of the students' thinking allow the teacher to modify the activity to address emerging concerns. 
This in-the-moment response takes me to the concern: How can a teacher become a responsive teacher? How can you develop that sensibility that can help you notice the students' ideas? Reading vanEs (2011) helped me to address some of those concerns. I consider learning how to be a responsive teacher can be more difficult than implement a structured activity. VanEs shows that teachers can develop the sensibility to identify or listen carefully to students' ideas. The study shows elementary teachers having regular meetings to examine students' mathematical thinking. All of the teachers involved bring video clips from their own classroom and were asked to find remarkable issues to discuss in the group and to analyze students' thinking. At the beginning the teachers' analysis was more centered in their own practices, focusing their reflection in a general behavior of the class. While they move from a general observation to focus on particular discussions they started to notice more the students' thinking and also relating it to the teacher behavior. This research shows teachers can develop the skills to identify students' thinking, even when it does not address how to react to it in the moment-to-moment interaction. It also reveals the relevance of having a group support during the teachers development in responsiveness. The collaborative discussions allow teachers to learn from each other perspectives.
I would like to finish this blog entry with some reflections on what means to create an responsive classroom. According to Maskiewicz and Winters (2011) a responsive environment requires every participant to be responsive to others' ideas and contribution, it needs to engage the entire classroom community in considering the value in the ideas presented. I had the opportunity to read in a responsiveness conference the following phrase "It is not a diet, it is a lifestyle". I consider being responsive shouldn't be consider the goal for the teacher, but a way to better understand the students' current cognitive state to react to their necessities in real time interventions.
 
  • A.C. Maskiewicz and V. a. Winters, Journal of Research in Science Teaching 49, 429 (2012).
  • E. van Es, "A framework for learning to notice student thinking," in Mathematics teacher noticing: Seeing through teachers' eyes, edited by M. G. Sherin, V. R. Jacobs, and R. A. Philipp (Routledge, New York, 2011), pp. 134-151.