Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Models of Potential Energy

I want to present some examples of some of the models of potential energy (or gravitational energy) which the teachers discussed as they gathered in the lobby to compare Energy Cube diagrams.

In particular, three separate models of potential energy emerged: potential energy as stored energy, potential energy as always present, and the standard model of potential energy is something that kinetic can turn into. I want to simply post some examples of these three models to spark discussion. The teachers spent roughly half an hour negotiating these different models, trying to either select one over another or create a hybrid of multiple models and these clips are taken from different portions of the conversation.

I should add that a fourth model, that an object has the potential to have energy, did arise, however Lezlie was quick to directly address this issue.

To add some context for this discussion as a whole, the groups had observed Lane fire a whirlybird earlier in the afternoon. The students were tasked with picking two (roughly) consecutive moments (e.g. beginning to pull the elastic band back and having pulled it all the way back) and using the energy cubes to track the energy flow.

Let me begin with the model of potential energy as stored energy. Here is a clip of Michelle*. [UE1 120628 1550 Front&Lobby Stored Energy]. This statement occured shortly after Lezlie explicitly distinguished potential energy from the "potential to have energy." (the original video is "UE1 120628 1537 Front&Lobby." the time stamps are for this video.)

[00:13:54] Michelle: I like the word "stored" 'cause the rubber band is stretcehd. To me it's storing energy that it's going to be able to use. The potential, it's like you're saying anything can have potential, you know, but if it's stored energy, like in a battery or in a stretched rubber band, that means you can use that storage, like in a hibernating bear or your pantry, or your- you can use that.

I think one of the most interesting parts of this clip is that Michelle explicitly distances her model from the word "potential" preferring the word "storage." I think that Michelle chosing a more suitable word for her idea as the teachers negotiate the meaning of potential energy conveys a depth to her understanding. It is notable, also, that her model is not limited to elastic energy, but contains a wide range of objects in which energy can be stored.

Let me move on to the second model of potential energy: It is always present and only take over once enough kinetic energy has been transfered elsewhere. I should note that this seems to recal the "impetus" model of forces, though I don't mean to imply any particular stance towards misconceptions (I suspect many of you can guess, though). Here is Theron explaining this model [UE1 120628 1601 Front&Lobby Potential Always there]:

[00:24:45] Theron: What I think was the- the- kinetic energy of the whirly bird rocket thing was transfered through friction to air molecuels around it, is what I had in my head. And then the gravitational energy was constantly there. And then eventually, it's- the potential is gonna pull it back down.

Although this model, at first listen, seems to conflate energy with force (or impetus), an important thing to notice is that Theron maintains conservation: the kinetic energy all transforms into thermal energy. The question, however, becomes how does potential energy relate to other forms of energy in this model.

Finally, let me present a brief clip of Doug presenting his model of potential energy as somethign that kinetic energy can transform into. This model is closest to our standard conceptual model of potential energy [UE1 120628 1600 Front&Lobby Standard Model]

[00:24:10] Doug: after the rubber band has stopped transfering energy, at that point it would have had its maximum kinetic energy. But as it's ascending, that kinetic energy is transforming into potential energy. Because you're- you're going higher but you're slowing down. The higher you go, the slower you're going, but hte more potential energy you have.

As a teacher, this particular clip makes me want to jump up and dance. From the researcher perspective, I think it's interesting that Doug incorporates two particular elements into this model: a height dependance and a gradual transformation from kinetic to potential.

So, these are the three basic models of potential energy that I observed durign this discussion. The teachers spend a good deal of time negotiating these models. I plan on examining this process in more depth over the next few days. Lane and Lezlie, for their part, largely let the teachers debate among themselves, generally only clarifying points that teachers were making. I recommend watching the whole episode, especially after the third group presents their diagram.
*please correct me if I used the wrong names.

Monday, July 2, 2012

UE2: How we teach science is constrained by the MSP.


Episode #1 title: UE2 120628 1038 T2 Reflecting on NoS Metacognition Prompts

(Loose) transcript: [00:00:00.00] Michelle: What did you reflect on yesterday?
Joan: I reflected on the B questions, the nature of science.
Michelle: Oh!  So did I.  Okay.  I only got, I didn't do 'em in order.
Joan: I just went down the list on.  So I said science is grappling with ideas and understanding in our natural world and we're constructing how energy moves from our cup experiment, what is happening, and how to represent it.

[00:00:26.15] Michelle: I like grappling.  Beautiful word.  Um, let's see, (reading question:) do you ever feel you're being led to a specific answer?  No, absolutely not.  We have plenty of time to mull things over, and we revise and doubt and, you know, it's kind of refreshing this year to actually at the end get an answer...
Joan: Yeah.

[00:00:54.27] Michelle:...as opposed to last year.
Joan: Yeah.
Michelle: Um, number one (reading:), how does the work we've done (?)?  I said some of the times we're replicating what scientists do.  Like yesterday when we did the three probe thing, I thought that that was, you know, we collected data and analyzed and what not.  Um, most of the time I feel like it's more of an 'aha' moment.  I guess that's scientific, too.  More of what, we're focused a little more on the inquiry, discovery-type methods.  And then for number two,...

[00:01:37.15] Michelle: (reading:) What role does building the, you know, I said, man, I think that's kind of pivotal.
Joan: I said building a conceptual model helps us understand, step by step, what we are trying to understand.  Just thinking through something, oh I said, makes me feel like a scientist.

[00:01:53.27] Michelle: Oh, that's a good one.
Joan: You know, I was thinking, my daughter works, uh, in uh, for Harvard in part of the medical research, and she's on the administrative end of things, but it's, I was thinking it's interesting how much of research is grappling with problems and then just, you know, brainstorming and coming up with ways that they think might help something...

[00:02:20.01] Joan: And then, you know, and, so it's kinda interesting.  Because when you said you'd be surprised, you know, like, we're teaching the scientific method, you do this, you do this, you say.  They don't really follow that so much, because, especially with, she was, um, uh, part of surgical research, and so a lot of it is discovery while you're, and then they...

[00:02:47.13] Joan:...and trying it out and seeing it, and I know some of it's on rats, but it's a lot of, I have this idea and going and just trying it out and things like that.  So it's kind of interesting how the.
Michelle: See I would think at that level if you're medicine and you're Harvard, I would think it would be like, come up with the idea, write a grant to get your funding, and then totally pursue that, and if you get a little offshoot, then I guess that's the next grant.

[00:03:26.12] Joan: Right.  Yeah, it's all about grants.  That's huge.  Yeah.  Yeah, and those have been drying up.
Michelle: Oh, I'm sure.  I'm sure.
Joan: But it is kinda interesting that I think sometimes what our idea of scientists and what happens is kind of two different things.

[00:03:52.03] Michelle: The stereotype.
Wendy: We want kids to understand the basics of how to ride a horse, and then once they know how to ride the horse, they can go out in the discipline and explore and do things the way they want.

[00:04:00.09]  Joan: Well you know now.
Wendy: (inaudible)
Joan: Well but even with the way the MSP is set up, for a while we were just stuck on the scientific method, and now we're going into field studies, we're going into observations, and that's more what the science community would say.  That it's all those things, not just that one way of doing things.

Commentary: As with the other episodes I've blogged about today, the episodes in this post were clipped from a longer discussion about the metacognition prompts that the teachers had answered the previous afternoon.  Michelle (closest to camera on right), Joan (in middle on right), and Wendy (closest to window on right) do most of the talking, and Adria (on left) joins the table toward the end of the episode but doesn't say anything.

A number of things stuck out to me about this clip:
  • Michelle seems to be one of the louder, more persistent voices in the "give-us-answers" camp.  We see her referring to getting answers again here.
  • She says she feels like a scientist when she is doing and analyzing experiments.  And maybe when she has 'aha' moments, although she connects this to scientific practice in what feels like an afterthought to me.  [In other words, I think if she were asked, "When (in UE2 on Wednesday) did you feel most like a scientist?," she would answer, "When we were doing an experiment."]
  • Joan says that she feels like a scientist when she's thinking through something, or when she's grappling with an idea.
  • Joan connects her own sense of when she feels like a scientist to what 'real scientists' do, saying it's not actually about the scientific method, it's about a lot more than that.  I get the sense that in the statement, "But it is kinda interesting that I think sometimes what our idea of scientists and what happens is kind of two different things," "our idea of scientists" ~ "the scientific method" and "what happens" ~ "more than that."
  • When Wendy says, "We want kids to understand the basics of how to ride a horse...," I think she's advocating for teaching the scientific method -- it's the 'simple' version of what scientists do, and it's digestible for kids.  All that other complicated stuff is for those who have mastered the simple stuff.  
The teachers then transition into a conversation about the MSP (the Washington State tests):


Episode #2 title: UE2 120628 1038 T2 Constrained by tests

(Loose) transcript: [00:00:00.00] Joan: Well but even with the way the MSP is set up, for a while we were just stuck on the scientific method, and now we're going into field studies, we're going into observations, and that's more what the science community would say.  That it's all those things, not just that one way of doing things.

[00:00:21.07] Wendy: I think it's because of the testing, I think.
Joan: Yeah.  Yeah.
Wendy: The WASL (?) has been around, what, eight years maybe, ten?  Collect that kind of data from students...are we really heavy on inquiry, are we really heavy on content?  I think they're learning that wow, we're treating scientists or thinking science is just this.

[00:00:50.00] Joan: Yeah.
Wendy: Because of these tests.
Joan: But that's one thing...the test really has (inaudible).
Wendy: Yeah, because the teachers are saying, No we're going to be doing scientific inquiry because this is what they're going to be testing.  This is what science is and we're going to do all of these...

[00:01:06.26] Wendy: ...and in doing the professional development class I was doing, I had a lot of teachers coming up to me and saying, "How can we turn our curriculum materials into a controlled experiment?"  And I'm like, you can't.  Why would you want to?

[00:01:20.16] Joan: Yeah.
Wendy: Because that's what they test on the MSP (inaudible).  But I'm like, That's not what science is about, it's about exploring and investigating and observations and field studies and, you know, all of that.

[00:01:34.18] Joan: Yeah.
Wendy: But that's not what they're testing, so how can you teach it?
Michelle: Yeah.
Wendy: Let it go.

[00:01:41.00] Joan: But it's good now that they have included field studies and all that.  So now it isn't such a narrow vision.
Wendy: Yeah.  They're easier (?).
Joan: Yeah.

[00:01:49.03] Michelle: It is still kinda frustrating that I'm thinking back to last year.  I teach sixth graders, but last year I did a leadership class.  And it was all seventh and eighth graders.  And of course the eighth graders had taken the science WASL, and I was like, okay, so like, how was it?

[00:02:14.13] Michelle: And a bunch of 'em went, What was the answer to the car question?  And I went, Explain to me what the car question was.  And basically what the scenario is is a kid walks over.  A car has been driven and it's parked, and you lean against it.

[00:02:35.12] Michelle: And the question was, when you feel the heat, was it convection, conduction, radiation, or whatever?  You know, and I'm like.
Joan: Wow.
Michelle: That is so unfair.  I mean, if you're gonna go back to that, then give us the nice little set curriculum so we make sure there's a heat unit in there so that these kiddos are ready.  But.

[00:02:57.25] Joan: It's already in their standard, so that's, yeah.
Wendy: I bet you if you went (inaudible) to the standards, it is verbatim.
Joan: Yeah, it would be addressed in there.
Michelle: Really?

[00:03:05.26] Wendy: The questions on the sixth grade science WASL, MSP, whatever, how many stars are in the solar system?
Michelle: How many what?
Joan: Stars.
Wendy: Stars are in our solar system?

[00:03:16.07] Wendy: One, millions, or billions?
Adria: (inaudible)
Wendy: One, millions, or billions?
Joan: Those are the choices.

[00:03:24.13] Wendy: One, millions, or billions?  Kids go, this is a trick question.  I said, go have fun with it.  And it is, if you go to the standards, it's verbatim.
Joan: It's right there.
Wendy: Verbatim.  Right out of the standards.

[00:03:43.01] Joan: Yeah.
Wendy: Students should know that the sun is our only star in the solar system.
Michelle: Really?
Joan: The other thing that I think a lot of people forget is that OSPI puts out a tests and items specification.  It tells you what's gonna be on this year's test...

[00:03:58.08] Joan: ...so you know, when you look at that tests and items specification, you, you pretty well know, you know, what's going to be on that test.
Michelle: That's from the OSPI website?
Joan: Yeah.

[00:04:10.06] Michelle: And what's it under?
Joan: Test and items specifications.
Wendy: It tells you what kind of items.
Joan: Well it tells you what standards, you know, it's on there like the standards...

[00:04:19.10] Joan: ...so it lets you know, like, what they are going to be hitting.  So like, it had on there something about plants, which is part of the standards, too, but it's, some of those standards are like in the first and second grade standard band.
Wendy: It's not just fifth grade.

[00:04:41.27] Joan: Not just fifth, so it helps you, gives you (inaudible) knowing what.  So in the library, I make sure that I create lessons around what I see in the tests and items specifications.  They may not be asked verbatim, but.
Michelle: What the, what concepts will be.

[00:05:06.15] Joan: Yeah, what's gonna be tested.
Wendy: Just in order to make sure you cover all the content, and making sure the kids have heard it, right?  Not experience it, not learn it, not drill it, not whatever.  But even just heard it.  One of our teachers went down and made flashcards of questions of all the fifth grade standards...

[00:05:22.07] Wendy: Like the one (inaudible).
Joan: Yeah.
Wendy: Just did some multiple choice, just did some fill in short answer, you know, what (inaudible) you could ask.  And they were just flash cards that we did, you know, two or three questions and we talked about them in the morning real quick.

[00:05:35.09] Wendy: And just discussed em, just so kids, even if one kid remembered them, at least we'd gone through all of (inaudible).  It's certainly not the way we should teach science, but.
Michelle: You gotta cover your bases, too!
Wendy: Yeah, and then a question like that one doesn't come up and then...


Commentary:  This episode (#2) immediately follows Episode #1, in which the teachers (or perhaps just Joan) expressed what I consider to be relatively sophisticated views of the nature of science: she articulates that science is more than the scientific method.  She goes on to say that she's empowered to teach this way of thinking about science to her kids, now that the MSP 'allows' for it.

Even though I'm encouraged by Joan's sophisticated ideas and by the MSP broadening its view of the nature of science, I'm discouraged by the test-driven constraints that I sense (in particular) are felt deeply by Wendy and Michelle.  I'm struck by Wendy's statement: "Not experience it, not learn it, not drill it, not whatever...It's certainly not the way we should teach science, but..."  All this talk about the MSP, closely following the teachers talking about their views on the nature of science, reinforces my conviction that state standards and tests and all kinds of other systemic things disempower teachers.  And I wonder whether these systemic things constrain the kinds of learning that can happen in PD courses -- or at least the kinds of learning that teachers think is relevant to their classroom practice.  If it's not in the standards -- or if it's not what's tested -- does it have no meaning, pragmatically?

UE2: It's empowering to disagree.


Episode title: UE2 120628 1037 T7 Empowering process of disagreeing

(Loose) transcript: [00:00:00.00] Sherry: So I have nature of science.  I'm doing this A, B, C.  (Laughter)
Tim: You know, I was going to until I read B yesterday, and I was like, I think I'm going to skip that.
(Lots of talking about how they decided which prompt to answer.)
Tim: Maybe I'll do that Monday.

[00:00:13.28] Sherry: I kind of jumped around.  I jumped.
Tim: So what did you, what did you?
Sherry: Did you ever feel that you were being led to come to a specific, that was the hard one.  I thought, should I be honest or should I not?  And so, I don't mind being a little controversial.

[00:00:27.19] Eleanor: You should be honest!
Sherry: Yeah, right, but should I tackle it?  I mean.  Yeah, so, I thought some tried to lead coming to a specific answer, just because we all, like we're all 13 people right people, and so we wanted to, but if that's.  What happened is I found the strength in myself, and I said we, to think for ourself.  And to push back when we didn't agree, or we just wanted more clarification, and it worked.

[00:00:55.16] Sherry: I mean, I'm not a shy person.  It's not like I'm afraid to do that.  But I noticed that when I did, it was met with respect.  And then it was considered.  You know.  That's empowering to me.
Tim: Yeah.
Sherry: To be somewhere where, "I don't quite agree with you," and then they listen, and then they'll either push back, but not.  There are sometimes when, you know, when you, they gotta be right at all costs.

[00:01:22.03] Tim: Right.
Sherry: Whether they are even considering whether they're wrong, they just won't back.  And I didn't feel that.  That was so important to me.
Tim: Yeah, in a lot of the Seattle science units, it's safe and perfectly acceptable to say, "We have inconclusive results.  We do not have an answer."

[00:01:37.19] Sherry: But I mean even as us as teacher adults, I got that back.  I got that respect back.
Tim: Very cool.
Sherry: It was!  It was.  So I'm glad I answered that question.
Eleanor: It feels really good to be heard, doesn't it?

[00:01:52.28] Sherry: It was, and it must be a thing with me because I say it a lot, and I'll go right away.  I'll just turn around and walk away if I'm with a group that I don't feel that.  (Laughter)  And if somebody in the group doesn't give it or tromps on someone, I'll say, "Wait, wait, wait.  Let 'em speak."  It's huge with me and it's just now I'm realizing it, you know.
Tim: Let me test this theory.
Sherry: Oh, shut up.  You would!  Okay, now I'm leaving.
Eleanor: New table!

[00:02:23.24] Sherry: I just, you know, how people treat each other is so important to me.

Commentary: Thursday morning in UE2, the teachers began by discussing their answers to the metacognition prompts, as I described in an earlier post.  Tim (green checked shirt), Sherry (peach shirt), and Gayle (hoodie) are featured on camera.  Gayle and Tim have just shared their answers to the "instruction" prompts, and the episode begins when Sherry offers her answer to the "nature of science" prompts.

I feel like what Sherry is saying is that she can't learn when she doesn't feel respected or when she doesn't feel she can disagree.  I empathize with this, and I'm excited that she feels that UE2 is a place that she can learn.

I've been surprised and impressed by Sherry's regular, in-the-moment assessment of her growth -- she often says things like, "I've never thought of this before, but right now I'm thinking...and it's so cool!"  Because I don't know her in other contexts, I can't tell if this course is particularly empowering to her or if she's just the kind of gal that seeks out and appreciates learning activities no matter where she's at.  Regardless, it sounds like UE2 feels like a safe space to her.  Pleased to hear it.

And take a look at this screen shot of Tim and Sherry toward the end of the episode.  Doesn't it just make you smile?


Creating mental models

Mental models are our personal explanations of how, when, why things work with images whether it’s a picture diagram, calculation, etc. It is our perceptions, interpretations, opinions and ideas that connects to our logic.
I have many mental models of the ice ages for instance, the big bang theory, creationism, biological, chemical and physiological processes and so much more. As an instructor, we use mental models to transfer knowledge and understanding to students to learn a concept and/or to connect their prior knowledge to the new material.

In the following episode, Eleanor provides a scenario in which I visualized friction. I realized that I have many mental images of friction and could relate my experiences on a slide at a playground at various ages and weights to relate to her example. This is an excellent example to connect the class to something that they are familiar to create a mental image.
Tuesday afternoon, 6-26-12 UE2

As a pre-service Chemistry educator, I am interested in finding ways to connect students to the material in such a way that relates to their existences.  Since science is all around us just waiting for us to discover it, it should not be difficult. The difficult part, I believe, is not knowing their mental models of how and why things behave as they do.  This part takes time and energy to listen and assess their knowledge to better understand their conceptions and/or misconceptions. Here’s where assessments are used however, the instructor must invest in the students and have a deeper understanding of the materials themselves to get the students to point N to point X.
Eleanor is a great example of teaching and tapping into the class as a whole by using mental imagery to transfer information and get the class collectively to a better understanding. This has been drilled in pre-service teachers in my education program that we connect a model that is relevant to each individual class or circumstance-permitting on an individual basis, that period 1 class will be much different than 4th period class though it may even be the same subject and level.
On Friday, Sherry explained her frustrations to have to “see it” before she can transfer the material to her knowledge base instead of different learners who can believe without seeing. Eleanor gives her an example of believing though she cannot actually “see” it, she is giving Sherry a mental model of gravity.
            Eleanor: Do you believe in gravity?
Sherry: Yes, and I can't see it. 
Eleanor: Why do you believe it?
Sherry: Because there's an experience and we could call it XYZ if we wanted to.
Sherry: I want to know if it really jiggles. It's irritating to me that I can't get where other people are without this "show-me" attitude. (flag = IDENT)
Eleanor: gravity - sending a satellite, etc. - it's a powerful model.
Sherry: I tell my students that things are jiggling in place, but I don't really know.

               

UE2: Physics is the study of the invisible.


Episode name: UE2 120628 1037 T7 Study of the invisible

(Loose) transcript: [00:00:00.00] Gayle: The thing that when she was talking about conceptual models, because of my background I went to conceptual art in my head.  You know, cause it's like.
Sherry: Right, right, right.
Gayle: Conceptual art, it's just ideas.
Sherry: Uh huh.

[00:00:11.26] Gayle: And they don't, all those ideas don't have to be executed because some of them aren't good.
Sherry: Worth it, no.
Gayle: Yeah.

[00:00:18.22] Tim: And even some of the ones that are executed aren't worth it.
Gayle: Exactly.
(Sherry laughing.)
Gayle: I was working on my MFA, and I was like, well...

[00:00:24.10] Sherry: And then how many of them are trash-canned cause you don't think they're good and they really would have been, you know!
Tim: Oh, an artist never throws away anything.
Gayle: Their mother does.
(Laughing.)

[00:00:35.15] Tim says something inaudible, raises eyebrows, so I think it's a joke.
Sherry: I meant the mental image.  I meant the mental image that didn't get down.  Hmmhmm.
Gayle: That's why you have a sketch book.
Tim: But you know, artists take years and years and years playing with their concepts.  Why not do the same in the classroom, the science classroom?

[00:00:52.16] Gayle: Clearly they do (inaudible).  My ex-father-in-law is a physicist.  (Inaudible) brutal.
Tim: That's interesting.
Gayle: Well, a physicist and a misogynist.  (Looks around, laughs.)
Sherry: How do you talk to a physicist?

[00:01:09.21] Gayle: At lunch, (he said?) would you like to look at this book while we talk?  It's like, okay David, that's not nice.
Eleanor: One minute, wrap up whatever you're talking about.
Gayle: So this is going to be my Facebook post for tonight: Physics, the study of the invisible.  (Laughs)
Tim: Uhhhh...

[00:01:32.14] Gayle (mimicking Tim): Uhhhhh.
Tim: I bet there's a lot of study of the invisible.
Gayle: There is.  Study of the invisible.


My commentary: In the twenty minutes or so preceding this episode, Gayle (on right), Sherry (on left), and Tim (on left) have been discussing (off and on) the metacognition questions that they answered the prior afternoon.  Tim and Gayle responded to the questions about instructional strategies, and Sherry answered the questions about nature of science.  During their discussion, they discuss the value of going beyond experimentation to develop mental models for what they observed.  They say that it promotes sense-making and meaning-making, but it takes a lot of time, and time is something they don't have much of in their classrooms.

A few minutes later, Gayle compares mental models in art and in science.

I clipped this because I liked the sound byte at the end: "Physics, the study of the invisible."  At the time, it felt like Gayle's "model for what a mental model is" was matching what I think Eleanor was trying to get at all day on Wednesday.  But then, watching it again, it feels all awkward, especially when Tim responds with "Uhhhhh..."  And watching it again, I caught all of the half-inaudible references to Gayle's father-in-law.  (Maybe that's what made the end so awkward.)  Now I'm not really sure what to do with this clip. 

Energy dissipation - Ah ha moment

Abby, I was looking at video from day 1 for a different reason, but came across this clip and had to post it for you.  Table 2 was discussing where the kinetic energy of a wave goes when the wave hits the shore, or a wall.  By the time of this clip, they've clearly identified what their question is, and then Lezlie helps guide them towards thinking about what forms of energy the KE could change into.  But, before she does that, they have an amazing discussion of the possibilities, trying to disentangle what the energy is doing from the "physical evidence".  There is so much here!  Also, I love that Lezlie chooses the precise moment when the group has their "ah-ha" moment to walk away and let them hash it out.  What a great teacher move!






Sunday, July 1, 2012

"Well, what do you want them to get out of it?" : Energy Theater Learning Goals

On Friday there were several events that made me stop and think more deeply about the various learning goals of Energy Tracking Representations.  In my experience, teachers often have one idea of what they want students to get from their lessons, but students may have a different idea of what the important "take-aways" are.   This can cause tension between the two parties if students feel like they aren't being "given" what they need for success.  While it is important for an instructor to have a clear idea of what their learning goals are, being able to communicate their goals to the class can help avoid these kinds of conflicts.

In the morning, there was some confusion about what the UE2 participants were supposed to do with the scenario that they had chosen to analyze from their curriculum.  Eleanor made the helpful comment that their goal was to try to  "understand deeply" the topic they'd chosen.  She said that of course, teaching involves more than understanding deeply, but that this should be everyone's "goal number 1".  I think she meant that this is what you need to do first before thinking about activities, assessments, etc. and I agree!  In the afternoon in UE1, I saw several teachers try to begin lesson planning before they understood their scenario thoroughly and this strategy didn't get them anywhere.

In addition to helping teachers understand their energy-related content more deeply, it seems to me that another learning goal (for teachers & students) of the Energy Project is to 1) create accurate* and consistent representations of what they currently know about the energy processes in different scenarios and then 2) refine their models when new pieces of information are added.  This goal - using a representation to both talk about and develop one's conceptual understanding - can be difficult for learners to attend to if they think they should be seeking the "right answer", the "truth", or "the way things really are" (which is what most learners are in the habit of doing).  But how can an instructor communicate this objective to their class?  Of course, stating the learning goals explicitly throughout the course is a good idea, but most students will not take you seriously unless your assessments align with your goals.  

In the Energy Project workshops, assessments come in the form of presentations that the teachers make to each other and the feedback that they get from the instructors and other participants.  I think it would be interesting to look at video segments that show instructors giving feedback on Energy Theater or Energy Tracking diagrams.  Do they emphasize the importance of being consistent with big ideas about energy (conservation, distinction from matter, etc.) or do they spend more time discussing the forms of energy that are present, and "what really happens" to the energy at each point, etc.?  The latter is not in itself a bad thing and there is certainly ample interest on the part of the teachers to get "answers" (see Amy's post).  However,  I think the teachers are very perceptive in picking up what the instructors choose to emphasize.  If "answers" get more attention than the representation or the development of a good model, then that is what they will think is the learning goal of the workshop.

*I mean accurate in the sense of mental model that match external representations, not necessarily mental models that match "reality".  We are interested in getting students to align what they know to what they show.