Thursday, June 28, 2012

Direct Evidence vs. Prior Knowledge: A Nature of Science Question


What directly preceded this conversation: This episode is preceded by Lane posing a thought experiment. The class had considered the situation of placing an ice pack in a water bath. Now Lane asked them to considered what it would be like if the ice pack was placed in the canal outside. If they had a thermometer in the canal and recorded no change in temperature, would they have evidence that heat energy had been transferred to it?

UE1 120628 1202 T5 NOS 1045
Valerie: On one hand, you are arguing that we should base what we’re doing on knowledge that we’re constructing. And to argue that there was a transfer of thermal energy, which we all know there was, even if there’s no evidence for it, to use our prior knowledge, to affect, to interpret what we’re seeing. So, we have to think about that. I mean, which one are we trying to do?
Lane: Do we, in that case, do have evidence?
Valerie: We don’t have any evidence.
[Several learners jump in.]
Valerie: But we could come up with a completely other scenario for it, for why the ice melts. There’s like no evidence that there’s thermal energy coming from it. Only prior knowledge that there’s thermal energy coming from it.
Kristy: Well, I think the ice pack melting is evidence that  [Several people overlap speech.]           
Jeannie: Canal water isn’t room-
Sean?: [inaudible] controlled experiment, because here you have a limited amount of stuff and there you have a huge amount of stuff. So you can’t say that one thing affected the other, without using a smaller scale. The bath water actually got colder so you could see the energy changing. [Inaudible].
Lane: But I think Kristy’s saying, what I hear Kristy saying is that there’s evidence of a transfer of energy into the ice pack, even out there, because its temperature changed in a [inaudible] way. That is evidence of transfer into the ice pack, but it’s not evidence of where it came from.
Valerie: Yeah, but there’s a lot of inferring there and basing it on prior knowledge. Because just imagine someone who know nothing about thermal energy, what would they think of the ice pack melting? I mean, if you say there’s a transfer of energy because [inaudible]. You’re just using what you know to answer a question.

I have two unrelated thoughts about this episode. First, Valerie seems to be struggling with what kind of information you can use what making a scientific argument. It's relatively straightforward to tell learners we need to base our claims on evidence, but here it looks like that is hard to put into practice. While we base our claims on things we can observe, we have to use deductions and reasoning to make the connection between evidence and claims. When you've also adding reasoning to the process, then it seems kind of silly (from Valerie's point of view) to ignore previous knowledge gained from the recent experiment: the temperature of the water in the bath goes down, so our model tells us it's losing heat energy to the ice pack. I sympathize with Valerie, because she's taking a conclusion based on evidence and extending it to the new thought experiment: if we conclude the ice pack is gaining thermal energy and it's in the canal, it seems like we're using reasoning to say the likely place the thermal energy comes from is the canal. 

My second, shorter, thought is about the researcher characterization of this conversation. Ben and I both heard this conversation and labeled it "about the nature of science." But it occurs to me that it's really about what rules they're following in this discussion and in this class. It would only be about the nature of science if the learners see what they're doing in this discussion and in this class as science. (And I'm sure many NOS researchers have already had that thought, but it's new to me.)

UE2: We leave with more questions than answers

Last year, I-RISE scholars observing UE2 were struck by the number of seemingly 'aha' moments related to the nature of science and the teachers' identities as participants in the scientific community.  One thing that was flagged -- described in this post -- was the sophistication of the idea that science learning often concludes with more questions than answers.

This year, my ears perk up every time I hear something like that, and it's come up twice with not much additional attention.  Two instances come to mind in particular:
  1. During the "Rights and Responsibilities" discussion, there was a lot of talk about teachers having a "right" to leave with correct answers.  Tim responded with something like, "My sense is that these kinds of classes leave us with more questions than answers."  And I got the feeling that this is okay -- even welcome -- to him, as though he wouldn't want to interfere with that by making a rule that they have to leave with all of the answers.
  2. Yesterday (06/27) afternoon, the teachers were discussing an experiment that Eleanor did using three temperature probes: one that was placed in a cup of hot water and two that were placed in the air outside, one three inches away and the other six inches away.  She graphed the temperature over time, and there were lots of bumps in the graphs if you zoomed in close enough.  The teachers were asking lots of questions about what might have made the bumps happen, and one teacher suggested that maybe the bumps were because of air currents.  Sherry piped up to say that the bumps in the graph for the temperature probe in the water could not have been because of air currents, because the probe was in the water.  They are wondering about this, and Sherry points out that one question always leads to many more.  Eleanor agrees that "that's the way it always is."
These are sort of isolated moments in time -- no sustained discussion around them -- but I wanted to make note.

UE1 Seating Chart.

This is a seating chart for UE1 this year. We tried to put the names in the place at the table where they've sat most of the time.



Misconceptions talk


Episode title (on server): UE2 120626 1542 T2 Misconceptions talk

(Loose) transcript:
[00:00:00.00] Michelle: Wendy?
Wendy: Mmhmm?
Michelle: Um, that My Private Universe, is that the video they made where I think it was these kids graduating from like Harvard?

[00:00:12.22] Wendy: MIT.
Michelle: Oh, was it MIT?
Wendy: Mmhm.

[00:00:13.15] Michelle: And they have these WILD misconceptions?
Wendy: Mmhm.
Michelle: Okay, I have seen that.

[00:00:18.04] Wendy: And I can't remember where it was, it might have been here, that the word.  It was probably here.  The word misconception.
Michelle: Mmhm.

[00:00:31.00] Wendy: It tends to be a negative term.  Saying that what you believe is wrong.  And you shouldn't use that, in a sense, because what you believe is what you believe based on your experiences and your knowledge and your understanding.  So it's not necessarily wrong, it...
Michelle: It's yours.

[00:00:48.19] Wendy: Yeah, we need to mature it, we need to build upon it, we need to tweak it.  And so I always, now when I hear the word or think of the word or use the word, I'm really careful about how.  Because that really hit home with me, as far as, you know, what I believe is what I believe...

[00:01:06.03] Wendy:...because of who I am and what I've experienced.  You know what I mean?  So when we were answering those questions on that survey, um, and we were answering one on do scientific theories change or are they build on cultural, I think it was the one on are they built on social and cultural things...

[00:01:24.20] Wendy:...you know, my husband was saying one thing, and I was saying, you know, well, what about those people in Nambia who can only understand why the earth, why the sun comes up and goes down based on their experiences.

[00:01:37.14] Wendy: They don't have the technology.  Their experience is that the sun rises and the sun sets, and there's probably a cultural reason as to why.

Commentary: Eleanor has just given Michelle (closest to camera), Barb (in the middle), and Wendy (closest to the window) the 'forms' table from last year to revisit.  A few minutes earlier, Eleanor gave the class her 'answer' to the mousetrap car question that the participants completed on their own and then discussed, and they all expressed their relief that Eleanor was "giving them answers."  Michelle, et al., said they had "worked hard" for it, and Sherry (at a different table) said how much more she learned by thinking about the question first; because of this, Eleanor's answer made a lot more sense.  Wendy brought up the Private Universe videos -- particularly the piece where a young girl is interviewed before and after a lesson on planetary orbits, and she "holds on" to her ideas, even though the teacher explicitly addressed them.  Then the episode starts.

This moment stuck out to me because I care a lot about teachers valuing student ideas, and I tend to think that instruction whose primary goal is to 'fix' the stuff that's 'wrong' with student ideas often devalues the ideas that students bring with them.  (Disclaimer: I don't think this is always true, I think it's often or maybe even only sometimes true.)  So I appreciated Wendy's picking up on Michelle's use of the word misconceptions and sharing her attention to her own use of it.

I'm still trying to figure out if she's really valuing student ideas or just changing her language.  She's still very concerned about changing their ideas, or at least moving them forward.  But she's also acknowledging that those ideas come from somewhere, that they're based on real experiences.  Still processing.


Diagramming Energy Theater

Yesterday UE1 did Energy Theater for the first time, and after that, they were invited to diagram what their group had done. I wasn't there at the time so I don't know exactly how the exercise was introduced; Lindsay said it was pretty open-ended. I think the diagrams that they produced were fantastic. Because I am interpreting their diagrams in light of my own diagramming conventions and convictions, I am going to talk about my own way of diagramming Energy Theater first.

I have become attached to a form of diagram that I call an Energy Tracking Diagram. (UE1 calls any kind of diagram that records an Energy Theater performance an Energy Tracking Diagram, but I'm going to stick to my special label.)
  • Individual units of energy are represented as individual letters, with the specific letter representing the form of energy.
  • Energy transfers and transformations are represented with arrows. All arrows have a letter at the head and the tail. Arrows that have different letters at the head and the tails indicate transformations. Arrows that cross the boundaries of object-areas indicate transfers.
  • The process by which a transfer or transformation occurs (e.g., mechanical work, conduction) is indicated by the color or pattern of the arrow.
  • Time order of energy processes is represented by sequences of arrows. (The time order of processes that occur along separate tracks is not represented.)
  • Relative amounts of energy may be represented by duplicating letters or tracks, or by adding coefficients to the letters representing energy.
Here is an Energy Tracking Diagram (ETD) that I drew for a basketball being pushed down underwater at constant speed. (If you are concerned about my having put the G's inside the objects, feel free to ask me about that.)


Abby has other examples on her blog; here is a PowerPoint version of an ETD for a compressing spring.

Now to the teachers' diagrams! In this post I am going to focus more on the representational features and less on the substance of the physics ideas that is represented. To examine a diagram more closely, click on it, and you'll see it full size.


(Bummer about the glare on this one.) At first, looking at those converging arrows on the left side, I thought they were not conserving energy (four units of energy going into one). But then I saw that the four units of energy are all there in the cart - just not at the end of that particular arrow. Instead of prioritizing that each energy unit follows a "track," this diagram prioritizes the physical location at which the transfer occurred: the contact point between the finger and the cart. Renee Michelle says that in their ET, they all pointedly (ha) walked through the finger. Thus it makes perfect sense that they drew the objects instead of drawing schematic areas the way I usually do. Another thing I notice about this diagram is the use of color in the arrows. For them, color indicates form. In the letters, this is redundant (because which letter it is already tells you the form), but in the arrows, the color shows that the energy starts out as one form and transforms at a certain spot (the black "transformation point") into the other form. So the arrows, for them, represent the energy, whereas for me, the arrows represent the kind of process by which energy transfers or transforms.


This one doesn't show the path each energy unit takes; instead, each energy unit gets an identifying number, which has a corresponding number in other objects. So there is a C1 in the hand, a K1 in the car, and a T1 in the air. It seems that K1 goes to S1 and K6 goes to T6, so the energy units are treated as though they were traceable individually. The big block arrows seem to represent forces (one is marked R, maybe for resistance?), and the thin black arrows seem to show energy transfer. As in the first diagram, letter-color is used redundantly with the letter itself to indicate the form of energy. (It's less apparent in this diagram because two of the forms are black, and one is dark blue.)


This one uses schematic areas instead of pictures of objects, and shows energy tracks. I find it hard to follow visually - the criscrossing lines and the fact that they are dotted makes them look like a maze of snail trails to me. But I believe they are used consistently. What interests me about this diagram is the fact that the car appears twice. What's with that?


This diagram helps me make sense of the other one, because the air and the car are shown twice, so now I understand that I am being shown a kind of a time sequence. First there is the hand; then there is the car moving on the floor through the air; then there is the stopped car sitting on the floor in the air. This suggests to me that in this diagram the swirly arrows are time arrows; the energy in the car goes to the future car. 


This diagram seems to have a similar form: a sort of time sequence, but with not all of the objects present at each time - only the "spotlighted" object. This representation reminds me of energy discussions I've seen in the context of Rube Goldberg machines, in which people think of the energy as almost being passed like a baton from one "active" object to the next.


This one is a more explicit time sequence. This group uses coefficients to indicate quantity, rather than repeating the letters as the other groups do. They use a delta symbol to indicate a transformation (maybe  because it means "change"?) and an arrow to indicate a transfer. Again, both letter and color indicate form; coefficients are written in a distinctive color.

Every single diagram shows the energy being conserved, supporting my conviction that once you start using the substance metaphor you pretty much can't help conserving energy. I'm curious what's going on with thinking in terms of partial time sequences, since it seems to be popular this year.

"Inquiry-based teaching and Discovery learning"




Inquiry-based teaching methods are student-centered instead of the teacher force feeding information that the students haven’t processed, digested or not yet proved to themselves if the information fits into their framework of knowledge. In my opinion, the key to inquiry-based is allowing the pupils to design the instructor’s guided lesson. Teachers do not like this aforementioned because of time constraints and the pupil’s natural curiosity may not align to standards. Additionally, many teachers are not supported by the schools’ administrative system, by their colleagues or by resources.
So in Eleanor’s class, the question was raised, “What is a model?” The class seemed very confused as to what a model is exactly and like “energy”, there is a barrage of definitions, from Christie Brinkley to a paper airplane. Should this be a teachable moment about models?  Should the instructor continue with the objectives of the course and maintain the time schedule and great well-designed lessons?
I have not taught my content as of yet and do not know the pressures that teachers feel from students, staff and administration. Conveying information is already a challenging feat and could be more challenging when other questions are raised that the teacher may or may not be equipped to answer.
The National Science Teacher Association (NSTA) has been pushing teachers towards inquiry-based teaching using demonstrations, hands-on activities like Energy Theater and using the whiteboards and allows the pupils to walk away from the lesson with conceptual knowledge instead of superficial truths.
Sherry said today, “A conceptual model helps make meaning”.  Another teacher participant, Tim   said that he will use Energy Theater in his classroom as much as possible next year.
This seems as though they both learned a tool that will be inherently used to have their students to discover the objective of the lesson instead of an information transfer. This is a goal of mine as an educator and I feel great that Eleanor’s lesson as lasting effects on her current students and their students. 

Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Field Note FLAG Requests UE 2012

Watch for These (FLAG AND PUT TIME STAMP): 
  • Identity in relation to science/science teaching -  Amy
    • FLAG: IDENT
  • Criteria for Creating and Distinguishing forms of energy; also is energy distinguishable? - Sam
    • FLAG: Forms
  • Energy Degradation/Entropy/Energy Spreading/Dissipate/Thermal Energy is Useless/a dead end - Abby and Ben
    • FLAG: Abby (or a descriptive word of the above - like Dissipate)
  • Changing the meaning of space/multiply-occupied space/nesting esp. in gesture - Hunter
    • FLAG: Space/Gesture
  • Proximity of students' representations to previously seen/instructor's - Josh
    • FLAG: Repres
  • Meaning of the word "Potential" - Brandon
    • FLAG: Potential
  • Disambiguating Energy and Objects/Matter - Lindsay and Rachel
    • FLAG: Distinguish or Disambiguate
  • Energy transfers in a simple circuit (battery, bulb, wires)
    • FLAG: Circuits
    • Lindsay
  • Inquiry (teachers talking about it)
    • FLAG: Inquiry
    • Michele