What directly preceded this conversation: This episode is preceded by Lane posing a thought experiment. The class had considered the situation of placing an ice pack in a water bath. Now Lane asked them to considered what it would be like if the ice pack was placed in the canal outside. If they had a thermometer in the canal and recorded no change in temperature, would they have evidence that heat energy had been transferred to it?
UE1 120628 1202 T5 NOS 1045
Valerie: On one hand, you are arguing that we should base
what we’re doing on knowledge that we’re constructing. And to argue that there
was a transfer of thermal energy, which we all know there was, even if there’s
no evidence for it, to use our prior knowledge, to affect, to interpret what
we’re seeing. So, we have to think about that. I mean, which one are we trying
to do?
Lane: Do we, in that case, do have evidence?
Valerie: We don’t have any evidence.
[Several learners jump in.]
Valerie: But we could come up with a completely other
scenario for it, for why the ice melts. There’s like no evidence that there’s
thermal energy coming from it. Only prior knowledge that there’s thermal energy
coming from it.
Kristy: Well, I think the ice pack melting is evidence that [Several people overlap speech.]
Jeannie: Canal water isn’t room-
Sean?: [inaudible] controlled
experiment, because here you have a limited amount of stuff and there you have
a huge amount of stuff. So you can’t say that one thing affected the other,
without using a smaller scale. The bath water actually got colder so you could
see the energy changing. [Inaudible].
Lane: But I think Kristy’s saying,
what I hear Kristy saying is that there’s evidence of a transfer of energy into
the ice pack, even out there, because its temperature changed in a [inaudible]
way. That is evidence of transfer into the ice pack, but it’s not evidence of
where it came from.
Valerie: Yeah, but there’s a lot of
inferring there and basing it on prior knowledge. Because just imagine someone
who know nothing about thermal energy, what would they think of the ice pack
melting? I mean, if you say there’s a transfer of energy because [inaudible].
You’re just using what you know to answer a question.
I have two unrelated thoughts about this episode. First, Valerie seems to be struggling with what kind of information you can use what making a scientific argument. It's relatively straightforward to tell learners we need to base our claims on evidence, but here it looks like that is hard to put into practice. While we base our claims on things we can observe, we have to use deductions and reasoning to make the connection between evidence and claims. When you've also adding reasoning to the process, then it seems kind of silly (from Valerie's point of view) to ignore previous knowledge gained from the recent experiment: the temperature of the water in the bath goes down, so our model tells us it's losing heat energy to the ice pack. I sympathize with Valerie, because she's taking a conclusion based on evidence and extending it to the new thought experiment: if we conclude the ice pack is gaining thermal energy and it's in the canal, it seems like we're using reasoning to say the likely place the thermal energy comes from is the canal.
My second, shorter, thought is about the researcher characterization of this conversation. Ben and I both heard this conversation and labeled it "about the nature of science." But it occurs to me that it's really about what rules they're following in this discussion and in this class. It would only be about the nature of science if the learners see what they're doing in this discussion and in this class as science. (And I'm sure many NOS researchers have already had that thought, but it's new to me.)

