Wednesday, June 27, 2012

Objects vs. Energy

On Tuesday afternoon in the UE1 class, there was an interesting thread in the class discussion that centered on how physical objects should be involved in talking about energy processes.  I was struck by how their dramatically their language shifted throughout the day.  Right after lunch when they were discussing the energy processes they'd observed outside, Table 2 was having a hard time distinguishing between the movement of energy from one place to another and the movement of physical objects from one place to another. Energy cycles were being conflated with the water cycle, and the cycling of gasses in the atmosphere.



Note in this clip when Roxanne points out that the "cycle" that Jon is describing isn't about energy.  Below is the diagram they created, which has labels of energy, but is clearly representing the physical objects / processes involved in their scenario.   


Later, when negotiating features, Table 2 came up with the category of "Physical Manifestation" and had a discussion about the difference between things that can be observed in the physical world and the "causes" of these things (which I think was their idea of energy at that point?).  Miranda especially did not want to stop talking about this feature, which for her included both "matter" and "evidence".  At the end, Heather suggested that heat and sound and light are physical manifestations and Miranda said, "Yes!"

During the whole-class discussion, Miranda proposed Physical Manifestation as a feature and defined it as "anything physical you can observe" such as a light bulb lighting up, a change in temperature, and sound.  Heather also interjects that it could be heat, which suggests that they're still a little unsure about the matter / energy distinction.  (See clip below.)

After this, the class got sidetracked by a conversation about potential energy, but circled back to the distinction between physical objects, observable phenomena, and forms of energy.  Someone else proposed "Pathway" as a feature and gave examples of the objects that the energy travels through.  At that point, Miranda, Heather, and Roxanne had a side conversation where they discussed the idea that energy is "not a thing," although it does travel through matter (see next clip).


 At the end of the day, the class came to a consensus (led by Lane) that several of the proposed features involved physical objects, and should therefore be in the same category, separate from energy transformations that have their own "starting" and "ending" points.  

Despite this clarification, on day 2, the theme came back again.  In the afternoon, Lane pointed out (starting around 1:55) that most of the energy tracking diagrams show both physical objects and forms of energy very prominently.  Only one group (Table 1) had decided to minimize the salience of physical objects (by representing them with boxes) and emphasize the energy transfers.  He noted that there isn't a "right or wrong" way to do this, but that there may be some use in separating representations of physical processes from a "force story" or an "energy story".  As the day progressed, the distinction between forms of energy (and what energy is doing) and physical evidence of energy's presence seemed to become clearer for the teachers. The Energy Tracking diagrams that Table 2 drew throughout the week are good evidence of this, but I won't include them here b/c this post is already too long! 

Pedagogical considerations for classifying energy


At the end of the first UE2 session, the class discussed a list of different kinds of energy.  Several teachers said that their practices for understanding energy would be dependent on pedagogical concerns, including students' needs and state standards.  In this passage, the teachers are discussing Pedagogical Content Knowledge (PCK) -- knowledge about how to teach physics to a particular student demographic -- as opposed to simply content knowledge.  My suggestion is that in this context, content knowledge cannot be separated from PCK, since in-service elementary school teachers are always thinking about their teaching.  Thus, the teachers will filter everything they learn by asking "how am I going to teach this?"  (This is just a hypothesis at this point.)

One pedagogical issue centered on what I would call "provisional" instruction (targeted at the needs of a particular audience) vs. "definitive" instruction (scientifically correct.)  In the quote below, Joan contrasts the terms "food energy" and "chemical energy":

Joan: "I can see it both ways, I think kids can handle a change in definitions, it's just like in math, first they learn, you know, what, "flip", and as they get older, it's a "reflection" or something.  [...] So you feel like if you start with food energy, you could -- if they get a little older you could say  - another, more fancier word for that is -- I can see both ways."

In other words, students first learn a concept using ordinary language and examples ("flip" or "food energy".)  This instruction is only provisional; the definitive terms would be "reflection" or "chemical energy."  According to Joan, the instructor's terminology should be guided by what the students "can handle."  Joan is saying that students can handle a change from the provisional to the definitive terminology, in contrast with Alia's opinion:

Alia:  I think if it's chemical energy, we should refer to it as such, so even when they get older there's no misconceptions, and when they're like "what about food energy"?  Well, food energy, that's chemical energy -- well I thought it's food energy -- and then there's -- might be some confusion.

Alia feels that students need consistency, and that changing terminology would cause confusion.  A common property of provisional instruction is its simplicity; Tim points out that food energy is not on the class's list, but perhaps it should be:

Tim: It's a very big list.  In Seattle anyway, we talk a lot about food energy, because it's simple.  For kids to understand.

Another pedagogical consideration would be state standards.  Tim argues that the term "food energy" is desirable because it is required by the standards:

Tim: But the science standards specifically require them to be able to, kids to be able to draw a food chain showing the transfer of energy.  (Eleanor: Okay.)  And it's called the food chain -- so, you see where (Eleanor: And do they (have to?) label that) for them to meet standards they have to understand that food has energy (Eleanor: Right), and it's being, and it goes from organism to organism (EC: Right.)  So that's, that's the standard.  So that's why I wonder -- ha ha ha.  About that language.

"Model" as pedagogical prop

After all this discussion this morning in UE2 about what is a model, when it came time for the teachers to write in the "model" column of the forms table, both observed tables (2 and 3) were using "model" in a way that I thought was different from what had been worked out in discussion. This time, "model" meant a pedagogical prop. Something you would use to show... what, exactly? Show something having that form of energy? Or just something to point to while you talked about a form of energy, whether it was perceptually apparent that it had that form of energy or not. The systematicity of the things they chose were strange to me - I mean, I don't see the pattern or logic to it. For example, the model for thermal energy could be rubbing hands together, rubbing sticks together, bending a paperclip back and forth, etc. The emphasis seemed to be on ways of producing thermal energy where there was previously "none." While the model for elastic energy was snapping a rubber band. Why snap it? If you wanted to keep the elastic energy, then you would stretch the rubber band and hold it stretched. In any case, this new usage of "model," which the teachers seemed to settle in on fairly quickly and without any explicit negotiation that I noticed, did not seem to fit with or stem from the previous usage of model in the context of the probe. During that discussion, I thought that the focus had been on whether a constructed thing was used for thinking, and whether the thing actually had to be constructed.

UE1 built my confidence.


Episode label (on server): UE2 120626 1021 T7 UE1 builds confidence

(Loose-ish) Transcript:
[00:00:00.00] Tim: Oh well.
Jeff: But did you find that the course helped in your teaching?
Gayle: Yes.  It actually helped mostly in my confidence when I go.  Because when I come to a classroom, I don't know what that lesson plan is going to look like, and it [Energy Theater] wasn't specific to a lesson.  So if they're struggling, it's like, well, try this.  And you know, that whole acting out thing doesn't have to be just science.

[00:00:26.09] Gayle: As a methodology, it was great to employ just to get the wiggles out and to get kids engaged.  Yeah, it was really helpful.  For science, it was really a confidence builder.  For me, my background is in art.  So, well, art and math.  So the middle school science I've been doing this year a lot, and it's pretty entertaining just for me, because I learn along with them.  But also I can do this.  If I can do that, I can do this.

[00:01:01.24] Jeff: Did you find that there's a lot of very good quality science being taught?
Gayle: I think it varies a lot.
Jeff: Does it vary a lot? 
Gayle: Yeah.  It varies a lot.

[00:01:08.08] Jeff: How so?
Gayle: Well, you know, I don't want to be disparaging in a way.  Before the highly-qualified standards were put in place, a lot of people were put in science classrooms in the (?) level that don't have science backgrounds.  And so they're teaching the curriculum and not science.  But I experience both sides in classrooms.  You know, science majors, who are like (gesture).

Commentary: I can't actually find the prompt for the writing activity that the teachers are discussing in the clip, but I think it was something like, "Talk about what you learned last summer and what you hope to learn this summer."  The teachers on camera are Jeff (back left), Gayle (front left), and Tim (front right).  Tim is trying to find a video of a Rube Goldberg machine on his iPad, and Jeff and Gayle are discussing what was helpful to her about UE1.  Gayle is a substitute teacher for Seattle Public Schools; she does not have her own classroom.

What I found significant about this clip is that:
  1. Gayle indicates that the most significant contribution of the UE1 course was helping her confidence, and the reason she gives for this is that it's content-independent, and she can pair it with whatever lesson she's given.  I think this (the confidence thing) is significant because one of our goals in the summer courses is to empower teachers.
  2. Gayle identifies the wiggles-ness and the engaged-ness of Energy Theater.  This feels relevant to thinking about the affordances of ELAs -- she identifies some, but not all (and maybe not the most important ones).
  3. Gayle identifies herself as an art or math teacher AND as a science learner along with her students.  I love this, because it speaks to the kind of generative teaching that we want to see in responsive classrooms.
  4. Gayle differentiates science and the curriculum, and associates the former with quality and the latter with lack of quality.  (AND associates the former with science majors and the latter with teachers who have little or no science background.)

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

Is Potential Energy the Potential to Rise?

I want to talk about a question that was brought up a few times at Table 6, largely by Visala, namely: does something sitting still have potential energy if it has the potential to be lifted (or moved, risen, etc.)? I think that this question has its roots both in how we define particular forms of energy and in how we, as scientists, label those forms. Let me first rewind back to an interaction I had with some in-service middle school teachers last summer.

I've mentioned that part of my interest in the Energy Project emerged while I developed and taught a physics workshop for in-service teachers (Mary Bridget Kustusch was a con-conspirator with me on that). During our discussions on the different forms of energy, I realized that the teachers were using the same words to talk about different things from the other instructors and I. specifically the word "potential." When discussing a bouncing ball, we realized that the teachers considered the ball to have potential energy even when it was sitting stationary on the floor, simply because it had the potential to be kicked. This was the same issue that Visala brought up today concerning waster on the ground. It is also the same issue that that came up in the Scherr et al. 2012 article when the students were discussing leaves blowing in the wind.

I suspect that this is related to the (awful) nomenclature that we use for that particular form of energy. indeed it makes perfect sense to say that a soccer ball has the potential to be kicked. I am reminded of a particular metaphor that Rachel used in a talk she gave at the 2010 PERC in which she described "potential energy" as the maximum capacity that an object could be filled with the energy substance. An object has the potential to be filled with energy.

It is too bad that we impose this word on students. Dan, today, asked if potential was real energy. It is curious, though, that while the teachers discussed many types of energy (sound, chemical, motion, light, thermal), I don't recall once hearing a teacher come up with "configurational energy," (I haven't seen the pictures of the whiteboards, so I could be wrong...). It seems that an object's position is a far less salient attribute with which to associate energy than motion or temperature, say. it will be interesting to follow this thread through the week.

All energy is dinosaur energy



A thread running through the morning and afternoon UE1 sessions today is the question of how to temporally bound energy transfer processes.  In describing a series of energetic phenomena (as in the Wallace and Grommit video),  several teachers have wondered aloud about how far back in time one ought to go in order to satisfactorily describe the origin of the process that they are observing.  Wallace obtains energy from the cheese he eats, which in turn sets off a cascade of energetic transfer events that results in sound energy, light energy, and the energy that Grommit himself expends.  But the teachers are quick to ask where that cheese energy itself comes from.  The potential for an infinite regress emerges (turtles all the way down), until one teacher ends puts an end to the regress with the comment that "all energy traces back to the dinosours, from fossil fuels". 

In the afternoon, Sean's group is discussing where the energy to melt ice comes from, and there is a suggestion that the energy originates in the sun.  But this seems to be unsatisfying to Sean, who notes that "most of the energy we have ultimately comes from the sun. But there are other suns. Where did that energy come from? The big bang?"  In Roxanne's group discussing the water cycle, she asks: "If we think of it as a cycle, what is our starting point?  What's the bottom?"

This issue of how to temporally bound an energetic process story seems to me to be analogous to (although not exactly the same as) the issue of how to spatially bound an energetic process, i.e., how to define a system.  The question of how to use the concept of energy in a useful way is intricately tied to the definition of a system, since it is only by knowing where the system boundaries exist that one can talk about energy conservation or energy degradation (where is it conserved?  from where is it degrading?).  Likewise, defining a temporal system involves making an arbitrary decision about what will be relevant or significant for the purpose at hand.  If one does not make that decision, any energetic process is virtually unlimited in scope.  There is nothing absolute about either decision - the temporal bounding decision or the spatial bounding decision - and I suspect that discomfort in making either decision is only overcome with a lot of practice (and perhaps substantial exposure to physics).  Recognizing that the temporal and spatial assignments are arbitrary and chosen based on the particular problem being explored seems like a pretty important step toward developing a working facility with the energy toolbox.

A means by which things happen

One of the activities this morning in UE1 was a pre-course assessment, in which they were asked to describe what is happening with the energy while a bowling ball is being lowered at constant speed. Lane didn't want to have the class try to work out the answer to this question (he said, "We're not quite ready for that" and I couldn't agree more). He did invite the teachers to share what questions the task raised for them. My question about this scenario is: Where does the gravitational energy of the ball go as you lower it? (I know the answer to that question, but I still consider that "the question.") The questions they asked were nowhere near that. Some of their questions were, approximately:

  • "Is gravity energy?"
  • "Does the joint act as mechanical energy?"
  • "What is meant by the term potential energy?"
  • "Is resistance of motion an energy?"
  • "When we talk about transfers and transformations I don't even know where to begin. I don't even know what my questions are."

These questions suggest to me that the teachers are not using a substance metaphor for energy. These questions don't have a background premise that energy is a kind of a thing, a thing whose essential act is to go from one place to another. I'm not saying they should (yet); I'm observing that they aren't. It seems like the gravity, joint, and resistance questions pose energy as possibly being a means by which things happen, or are prevented from happening. This seems totally reasonable. 

Here is what Lane wrote of their questions: