Last night was our third teaching seminar. Attendance was dismal. At 5:30 there was only one teacher. At 6:00 we had six teachers. As Abby pointed out, it’s a pretty ridiculous use of resources to have four of us (Lane, Abby, me, Amy) there for six teachers. It seems like we need to rethink the structure with the informal discussion over dinner first because it just encourages people to show up late.
Zhomes Debrief:
We started with a debrief of the tour of Zhomes, guided by the question “What did you learn that you could use in your classroom?” There was an interesting range of responses about possible student activities, ranging from asking students to follow the energy in very specific aspects of the house (e.g. the super-insulated walls or the geothermal heat pump) to asking students to design a house (or a high school) that balances many complex and competing factors (energy savings, cost, water use, esthetics, community, etc.). A lot of the discussion focused on teachers’ own ideas about weighing complex factors in design. I was impressed to hear that after the tour Jeff had gone home and looked up the statistics behind some of their claims. He found several sources that gave values for the “average” energy use of a home, which had a lot of variation, but all were much lower than the value of 22K kWh to which our tour guide had favorably compared the Zhome energy use.
Reflecting on Journals:
Then Lane led the group in sharing their reflections from their journals. The exercise Abby had given them in the first teaching seminar was to jot down in their journal things they had learned about student thinking. Tonight they were supposed to share one thing they had learned. When we planned the first teaching seminar, we knew that this exercise would be difficult for them and that they would probably misinterpret it. We knew that really hearing student ideas is difficult, that this is our goal for what we hope they will be able to do at the end of teaching seminar, and that we don’t really expect them to get it the first time. So why were we so surprised and unprepared when it went exactly as we expected?
Perhaps because it started off so fantastic that we weren’t expecting the sudden dive off the cliff…
Lisa went first with a discussion of an activity in which she asked students to try to define forces. She noticed that they were initially defining forces as energy. I will need to go back to the video to remember exactly what she said, but I was really impressed with her respectful curiosity about her students’ thinking. She never said or implied that anything about this student idea as wrong or bad, but got really curious about where it was coming from and how they could use it productively when they got around to discussing energy. I was particularly impressed to hear this from Lisa given her previous history. She took E1 in 2009, E2 in 2010, and has been to nearly every teaching seminar we’ve ever had. During the first year of teaching seminar, she was part of a group of Bellevue teachers that I loathed listening to, because all they ever did was bitch about how dumb their students were and all the things they didn’t get. I don’t know how much Lisa herself participated in those discussions, because I tried to avoid listening to them and she didn’t stand out to me. But if she had been engaging with student ideas in 2009 the way she was last night, I think she would have stood out to me. So I suspect that what I observed last night was some pretty amazing progress.
Then Lane shared a student idea of how a cfl bulb works, which launched the teachers into all sorts of tangents about light bulbs, electricity, and energy conservation, but not about student ideas. This went on for way too long before we cut it off.
Then Laura shared about giving her students a pretest and posttest on electric circuits and being shocked by how poorly they did on the posttest, even though she had just given them a totally clear lesson and it seemed like they were getting it. (She also brought in copies of her students’ pretests and posttests for Keeley probes). Her discussion was totally focused on how they didn’t get it, and not really on what the students were actually thinking, but I felt like this was a fantastic starting point. Recognizing that your students aren’t learning what you think they’re learning is a critical first step to really hearing what they are thinking. This feels to me like something we can work with. (Never mind that we didn’t.) Laura took UE1 in 2009, and hasn’t been back to any Energy Project classes until Teaching Seminar this year, so it seemed like a nice confirmation that maybe we’re having some effect that she wasn’t as far along in her thinking as Lisa.
Then Jeff talked about a lesson on energy transfers and transformations, and he talked for quite a while, but I didn’t hear anything at all about student thinking, even wrong student thinking, just stuff about his lesson. I asked him what specific student ideas he learned, and he continued to talk about his lesson. Neither Abby nor Lane remember me asking him about student ideas, so maybe I wasn’t clear. I definitely wasn’t forceful enough, because I didn’t ask a second time or point out that he still wasn’t talking about student ideas.
Then Ingrid talked about an activity she did where her students looked at energy used in different sports. Like Jeff, she focused on the lesson and not on student ideas. I also asked her to tell us a specific student idea. She said one group had a hypothesis about the energy of running on Astroturf vs. cement, but then did an experiment to test it and discovered that their hypothesis was wrong. I think there was something like a student idea in here, the thing the students initially thought, but her focus was on how they tested it, not on what the students were thinking. I think we could have worked with this productively to tease out the student idea, but we didn’t.
Then Jean told a really inspiring story about a student she was working with who had been really difficult and rebellious and was suddenly turning around and getting really excited about science. This story wasn’t really about student ideas either, but it was so inspiring that nobody really had the heart to interrupt her.
Then Kim told a story about a lesson about burning almonds, which I think she hasn’t even actually given to her students yet because she’s still trying to figure out the chemistry of it herself. There was nothing about student ideas, but I didn’t have the heart to ask because everyone seemed anxious to move on.
By the time everyone was done sharing we only had a half hour left for a lot of other stuff we had planned. The instructors had a little pow-wow while the teachers were reading the big ideas article for the next section, and we decided Lane would give a little speech at the end explaining again what it means to write down a student idea.
Big Ideas:
The last section was looking at the Thompson article about big ideas and trying to figure out how to form groups to look at big ideas over the rest of the year. There was a lot of confusion about how to form groups. It’s going to be a difficult task because there is so much diversity about levels, topics, and how frequently people show up. Lane is going to set up google doc to help people figure it out.
Wrap-up:
We ended with Lane’s little speech in which he emphasized that what we want teachers to do is to “Focus on a single student idea that surprised you.” Kim asked, “Regardless of whether it’s right or wrong?” and we said yes, whether it’s right or wrong is not the point at all. This seemed like a good question, that indicated that she might be understanding the assignment. Lisa asked, “Is it OK if it's not surprising?” pointing out that she’s been teaching for a long time so she’s not surprised by much anymore. We said that’s OK.
Insights and updates from Interdisciplinary Research Institute in STEM Education (I-RISE) Scholars, directors, and collaborators
Wednesday, November 9, 2011
"Press release"
As we come into the last year-ish of the Energy Project, we are trying to get a sense of our accomplishments, especially since what we have done in the past few years is not at all what was planned. Our hired evaluators are pushing us on this partly because their job is to evaluate us relative to our own goals for ourselves. They routinely ask their clients to do what they call a "history of the future" exercise, for which the task is: Imagine the project is over. Write a press release describing what it accomplished.
To help us with this reflection we solicited thoughts from some savvy collaborators who we thought would give us helpful perspective on our project, and had a big ol' brainstorming meeting in which we filled the board with things that we either (1) feel we have accomplished (even if not necessarily documented) or (2) expect ourselves to have accomplished by the end of the project. That night I was inspired to write the press release. I had a little fun with it. Suggestions welcome.
=============================
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Multimillion Dollar Project Championed the Teaching and Learning of Energy in Physics
The Energy Project, the five-year, $3.7-million project that put physics education research and professional development at SPU on the map, has concluded. Among the prime contributions of the Energy Project was to improve the energy content knowledge of everyone involved – from teachers to faculty researchers. Some of this development leveraged the energy-as-a-substance metaphor into powerful new representations of energy, including Energy Theater, Energy Blocks, and Energy Diagrams. Armed with these organizing representational tools, learners tackled more complex energy scenarios than are normally attempted in physics courses. No roller-coasters for this crowd: instead learners took on refrigerators, cold packs, the Gaussian Gun, and electric circuits, among others. These rich tasks have given the Project unprecedented opportunity to identify K-12 teachers’ ideas about energy, including valid alternative ontologies for energy (e.g., as a fuel or a stimulus). Teacher interests drove researchers to take seriously topics not normally addressed in introductory physics, including the idea that what matters about energy is not only its conservation (as physicists normally emphasize) but also its usefulness, and how the quality of energy may deteriorate as a result of certain processes. This line of research led to a model for teaching about entropy, a concept that has been misused to bolster nonscientific arguments about evolution. Teacher interests also pushed faculty researchers into new intellectual territory in articulating the meaning and value of forms of energy, and in disambiguating energy concepts from force concepts – then subsequently weaving together these two causal factors in an integrated mechanistic account of physical processes. This energy content development not only served K-12 teaching interests, but also advanced the field of physics.
The Project’s groundbreaking research about the teaching and learning of energy took place primarily in the context of innovative professional development courses. Unlike courses that simplistically tell teachers what to do, these courses were taught responsively; instructors attended to the disciplinary substance of teachers’ thinking, took intellectual concerns seriously, and used the observations they made to guide the course content. “The participants (and their interests) are driving the questions that the class explores, within limits,” said visiting faculty researcher MacKenzie Stetzer. “They are really taking ownership of the experience in a way that leads to a more explicit partnership between the instructor and the participants.” Collaborator Siri Mehus, faculty researcher specializing in interaction analysis, said, “In its design, the course seemed to find an ideal balance between openness (participants chart their own course of exploring and understanding energy concepts) and structure (exercises and activities are well-organized, logically sequenced, and clear in their purpose). As the parent of a school-age child, it makes me very happy to know that the people who are teaching our children (at least a few of them) are thinking about students’ learning in the way that this course promotes.” Goals of the summer institute included not only energy content but also the development of teacher agency in science, enhancement of teacher understanding of the nature of science as a flexible and constructed body of knowledge, and teacher recognition that they themselves could contribute to that body of knowledge. Goals of the academic-year professional development program included fostering teacher attention to the disciplinary substance of student thinking in a “video club” model, in which teachers collaboratively analyzed video of one another’s classrooms. In a capstone effort, the Project in its last year developed the means to support teachers in putting their professional development experiences to use in their own classrooms, the ultimate goal of any professional development effort.
In addition to the pragmatic effort to improve the teaching and learning of energy, the Project made extraordinary contributions to the development of cognitive theory, well beyond what had been originally envisioned. In making use of the energy-as-a-substance metaphor the Project aligned itself with cognitive linguistics, in which metaphor is a primary organizer of thinking and a significant factor in conceptual change. In using the body as a symbolic system for learning abstract concepts (in Energy Theater), the Project found itself contributing to the most current theories of embodied cognition. These contributions took the Project beyond the teaching and learning of energy specifically into the territory of how thinking and learning take place in general, and extended the reach of the resulting research into the learning sciences.
Had these efforts been merely local, they would still have been tremendously admirable. Fortunately, during the Energy Project years, the team at SPU launched itself into the national community of physics education researchers, sharing findings and recruiting collaborators at an unprecedented scale. Dozens of talks and multiple papers, both short and long, contributed to the PER community’s recognition of the extraordinary potential of energy as a research topic. The Energy Project Summer Research Institute (EPSRI), founded to help the Energy Project create and manage its hundreds of hours of video documentation, provided a diverse community of researchers with an arena for inter-theoretical research on a common data set and made SPU a hub for scholarly community, mentorship, and leadership development. “The EPSRI is a huge community-building exercise that provides the whole PER community with deeper connections and new skills. It aligns a community around common tools and questions,” offered Michael Wittmann, lead faculty in the Maine Physical Sciences Project. By the end of the Project, SPU team members had established a new Physics Education Research Group at SPU, grounded in the Department of Physics and the School of Education. With two new full-time research faculty, three new graduate students, and multiple faculty collaborators in addition to the permanent faculty at SPU, the team is eagerly anticipating its next multi-million-dollar research program.
To help us with this reflection we solicited thoughts from some savvy collaborators who we thought would give us helpful perspective on our project, and had a big ol' brainstorming meeting in which we filled the board with things that we either (1) feel we have accomplished (even if not necessarily documented) or (2) expect ourselves to have accomplished by the end of the project. That night I was inspired to write the press release. I had a little fun with it. Suggestions welcome.
=============================
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Multimillion Dollar Project Championed the Teaching and Learning of Energy in Physics
The Energy Project, the five-year, $3.7-million project that put physics education research and professional development at SPU on the map, has concluded. Among the prime contributions of the Energy Project was to improve the energy content knowledge of everyone involved – from teachers to faculty researchers. Some of this development leveraged the energy-as-a-substance metaphor into powerful new representations of energy, including Energy Theater, Energy Blocks, and Energy Diagrams. Armed with these organizing representational tools, learners tackled more complex energy scenarios than are normally attempted in physics courses. No roller-coasters for this crowd: instead learners took on refrigerators, cold packs, the Gaussian Gun, and electric circuits, among others. These rich tasks have given the Project unprecedented opportunity to identify K-12 teachers’ ideas about energy, including valid alternative ontologies for energy (e.g., as a fuel or a stimulus). Teacher interests drove researchers to take seriously topics not normally addressed in introductory physics, including the idea that what matters about energy is not only its conservation (as physicists normally emphasize) but also its usefulness, and how the quality of energy may deteriorate as a result of certain processes. This line of research led to a model for teaching about entropy, a concept that has been misused to bolster nonscientific arguments about evolution. Teacher interests also pushed faculty researchers into new intellectual territory in articulating the meaning and value of forms of energy, and in disambiguating energy concepts from force concepts – then subsequently weaving together these two causal factors in an integrated mechanistic account of physical processes. This energy content development not only served K-12 teaching interests, but also advanced the field of physics.
The Project’s groundbreaking research about the teaching and learning of energy took place primarily in the context of innovative professional development courses. Unlike courses that simplistically tell teachers what to do, these courses were taught responsively; instructors attended to the disciplinary substance of teachers’ thinking, took intellectual concerns seriously, and used the observations they made to guide the course content. “The participants (and their interests) are driving the questions that the class explores, within limits,” said visiting faculty researcher MacKenzie Stetzer. “They are really taking ownership of the experience in a way that leads to a more explicit partnership between the instructor and the participants.” Collaborator Siri Mehus, faculty researcher specializing in interaction analysis, said, “In its design, the course seemed to find an ideal balance between openness (participants chart their own course of exploring and understanding energy concepts) and structure (exercises and activities are well-organized, logically sequenced, and clear in their purpose). As the parent of a school-age child, it makes me very happy to know that the people who are teaching our children (at least a few of them) are thinking about students’ learning in the way that this course promotes.” Goals of the summer institute included not only energy content but also the development of teacher agency in science, enhancement of teacher understanding of the nature of science as a flexible and constructed body of knowledge, and teacher recognition that they themselves could contribute to that body of knowledge. Goals of the academic-year professional development program included fostering teacher attention to the disciplinary substance of student thinking in a “video club” model, in which teachers collaboratively analyzed video of one another’s classrooms. In a capstone effort, the Project in its last year developed the means to support teachers in putting their professional development experiences to use in their own classrooms, the ultimate goal of any professional development effort.
In addition to the pragmatic effort to improve the teaching and learning of energy, the Project made extraordinary contributions to the development of cognitive theory, well beyond what had been originally envisioned. In making use of the energy-as-a-substance metaphor the Project aligned itself with cognitive linguistics, in which metaphor is a primary organizer of thinking and a significant factor in conceptual change. In using the body as a symbolic system for learning abstract concepts (in Energy Theater), the Project found itself contributing to the most current theories of embodied cognition. These contributions took the Project beyond the teaching and learning of energy specifically into the territory of how thinking and learning take place in general, and extended the reach of the resulting research into the learning sciences.
Had these efforts been merely local, they would still have been tremendously admirable. Fortunately, during the Energy Project years, the team at SPU launched itself into the national community of physics education researchers, sharing findings and recruiting collaborators at an unprecedented scale. Dozens of talks and multiple papers, both short and long, contributed to the PER community’s recognition of the extraordinary potential of energy as a research topic. The Energy Project Summer Research Institute (EPSRI), founded to help the Energy Project create and manage its hundreds of hours of video documentation, provided a diverse community of researchers with an arena for inter-theoretical research on a common data set and made SPU a hub for scholarly community, mentorship, and leadership development. “The EPSRI is a huge community-building exercise that provides the whole PER community with deeper connections and new skills. It aligns a community around common tools and questions,” offered Michael Wittmann, lead faculty in the Maine Physical Sciences Project. By the end of the Project, SPU team members had established a new Physics Education Research Group at SPU, grounded in the Department of Physics and the School of Education. With two new full-time research faculty, three new graduate students, and multiple faculty collaborators in addition to the permanent faculty at SPU, the team is eagerly anticipating its next multi-million-dollar research program.
Wednesday, October 26, 2011
Teaching Seminar visit to zhomes
Last night for Teaching Seminar Lane arranged for us to have a tour of zhomes, a new zero-energy development of town homes in Issaquah. I videotaped, but I'm not sure if there's really anything worth seeing on the video.
We had a good crowd, about 15 teachers, some of whom I hadn't seen for a while, and everyone seemed very enthusiastic about the tour. The tour was led by a woman named Elly, who is the education and outreach coordinator, and a man named Brad who is the project manager. Both of them were extremely knowledgeable about the project and were able to answer every question we asked except for the question about whether any of them had sold yet. Our fears that the tour would just be a sales pitch by a real estate agent were totally unfounded.
Having recently been through a green house remodel (from hell) myself and learned all the ins and outs of what's really green and what's greenwashing, I can say that they pulled out all the stops on this one, and really made it green in every way: reducing energy (and water) consumption, producing renewable energy (and water), reducing waste, using sustainably produced materials, and using non-toxic materials. They have super-insulated walls and a geothermal heat pump, which keeps the energy needed for heating the house and water low. They produce all the energy they need with pv solar panels. They *don't* have two things people commonly think of as being "green" features, solar hot water panels and an on-demand hot water heater, because they don't really need them with the geo-thermal heat pump. Also, there's no gas in the house, and one thing I learned in my own house remodel is that an on-demand water heater uses so much energy at once (although not much averaged over time), that it puts a huge load on your electrical system, so it's usually not worth it if you have to power it with electricity. They also harvest rainwater for flushing toilets and washing clothes. And they do lots of other cool things that I won't go into.
A couple new things I learned last night:
1. The term "watergy" means the combined water and energy used, taking into account the energy that went into producing your water and the water that went into producing your energy. I'm not sure if this is a quantitative concept, as in there's a formula to actually calculate a number for your watergy, or a qualitative concept, as in, wow, a lot of energy is used to get water to your house and a lot of water is used to make energy.
2. The price of pv solar panels has recently dropped dramatically due to flooding of the market from China, and Washington state is offering so many incentives (we pay 6 cents per kilowatt-hour for electricity, but Washington state will pay you up to 55 cents per kilowatt-hour to produce electricity), that the payback time for solar panels in Washington is now estimated to be only 7-9 years. Wow.
The two things I was not impressed with about zhomes were the design and liveability of the homes, and the price. The lighting was terrible, and that combined with super dark finishes made them really depressing to be inside. And the most of them, even a 1500-square-foot "two bedroom" had no private rooms at all, just giant rooms and lofts that are all interconnected. I like less privacy than most people I know, but even I couldn't live in a house like that. Even if I could afford it, which I definitely couldn't!
So what did this tour add up to for the Energy Project? What did we or the teachers learn that we could use in our teaching? I think using a zero energy house design could be a great starting point for a unit on energy. Students be given the task of designing a house, and then make arguments for the trade-offs of various choices. After grappling with the problem for themselves, they could be presented with the real choices made in various design projects, including zhomes (I have lots of contacts for people who could provide other case studies, and could even offer my own house to study), and asked to evaluate those choices. Bringing in things besides energy, like water, cost, and liveability, makes all those decisions even more complex. I think a project like this could really help students learn about energy conservation in both senses of the phrase (and compare the two senses) and learn some great critical thinking skills. But if neither we nor the teachers are going to take on this project, I'm not exactly sure how this tour fits into what we're doing.
It might be interesting to ask the teachers who went to reflect on how they could use what they learned in their teaching of energy.
We had a good crowd, about 15 teachers, some of whom I hadn't seen for a while, and everyone seemed very enthusiastic about the tour. The tour was led by a woman named Elly, who is the education and outreach coordinator, and a man named Brad who is the project manager. Both of them were extremely knowledgeable about the project and were able to answer every question we asked except for the question about whether any of them had sold yet. Our fears that the tour would just be a sales pitch by a real estate agent were totally unfounded.
Having recently been through a green house remodel (from hell) myself and learned all the ins and outs of what's really green and what's greenwashing, I can say that they pulled out all the stops on this one, and really made it green in every way: reducing energy (and water) consumption, producing renewable energy (and water), reducing waste, using sustainably produced materials, and using non-toxic materials. They have super-insulated walls and a geothermal heat pump, which keeps the energy needed for heating the house and water low. They produce all the energy they need with pv solar panels. They *don't* have two things people commonly think of as being "green" features, solar hot water panels and an on-demand hot water heater, because they don't really need them with the geo-thermal heat pump. Also, there's no gas in the house, and one thing I learned in my own house remodel is that an on-demand water heater uses so much energy at once (although not much averaged over time), that it puts a huge load on your electrical system, so it's usually not worth it if you have to power it with electricity. They also harvest rainwater for flushing toilets and washing clothes. And they do lots of other cool things that I won't go into.
A couple new things I learned last night:
1. The term "watergy" means the combined water and energy used, taking into account the energy that went into producing your water and the water that went into producing your energy. I'm not sure if this is a quantitative concept, as in there's a formula to actually calculate a number for your watergy, or a qualitative concept, as in, wow, a lot of energy is used to get water to your house and a lot of water is used to make energy.
2. The price of pv solar panels has recently dropped dramatically due to flooding of the market from China, and Washington state is offering so many incentives (we pay 6 cents per kilowatt-hour for electricity, but Washington state will pay you up to 55 cents per kilowatt-hour to produce electricity), that the payback time for solar panels in Washington is now estimated to be only 7-9 years. Wow.
The two things I was not impressed with about zhomes were the design and liveability of the homes, and the price. The lighting was terrible, and that combined with super dark finishes made them really depressing to be inside. And the most of them, even a 1500-square-foot "two bedroom" had no private rooms at all, just giant rooms and lofts that are all interconnected. I like less privacy than most people I know, but even I couldn't live in a house like that. Even if I could afford it, which I definitely couldn't!
So what did this tour add up to for the Energy Project? What did we or the teachers learn that we could use in our teaching? I think using a zero energy house design could be a great starting point for a unit on energy. Students be given the task of designing a house, and then make arguments for the trade-offs of various choices. After grappling with the problem for themselves, they could be presented with the real choices made in various design projects, including zhomes (I have lots of contacts for people who could provide other case studies, and could even offer my own house to study), and asked to evaluate those choices. Bringing in things besides energy, like water, cost, and liveability, makes all those decisions even more complex. I think a project like this could really help students learn about energy conservation in both senses of the phrase (and compare the two senses) and learn some great critical thinking skills. But if neither we nor the teachers are going to take on this project, I'm not exactly sure how this tour fits into what we're doing.
It might be interesting to ask the teachers who went to reflect on how they could use what they learned in their teaching of energy.
Monday, October 17, 2011
Islands of identification
Abby and I are reading P. W. Bridgman's The Nature of Thermodynamics, with the goal of understanding entropy, degradation, usefulness, etc. in disciplinary terms. We picked this book because it is a pleasant little paperback, with next to no equations, written in a chatty, accessible style, and because Stamatis said it was good.
Bridgman won the Nobel prize in physics in 1946 for investigations of the properties of matter under high pressure. He also is credited with coining the term "operational definition"; so I feel in his debt. This book, published in 1941, starts out with an extended explanation of why his book is not going to be a rigorously logical or mathematical treatise. The explanation is in terms of personal taste:
His experience is that what feels to him most like "understanding" is found when physics concepts are expressed verbally, as opposed to in the language of logic or mathematics. He goes on to suggest that this is not merely his own preference, but is likely something significant about human cognition: he suggests that if we were to study which concepts and operations have survived in physics, out of all the possible conceivable concepts,
I have the idea that Bridgman would be pleased by embodied cognition. I also think he would be a fan of Ochs, based on something he said about the development of atomic theory (long before it had any justification in experiment):
I am never going to get to the second law at this rate; but I'm really enjoying myself.
Bridgman won the Nobel prize in physics in 1946 for investigations of the properties of matter under high pressure. He also is credited with coining the term "operational definition"; so I feel in his debt. This book, published in 1941, starts out with an extended explanation of why his book is not going to be a rigorously logical or mathematical treatise. The explanation is in terms of personal taste:
[A precise logical] analysis serves certain definite purposes; in particular one may feel a security in the conclusions of such an analysis which is impossible in a less formal structure. But this I suspect is not the whole reason why those whose analysis runs to this form actually do it; it must be that they enjoy such rigorously precise activities for their own sake. Personally, my tastes place me in that other group which does not take an intrinsic pleasure in the elaboration of a logically flawless and complete structure. I would undergo the labor of constructing such a structure only as it might be necessary for some more compelling purpose. (p. vii)
His experience is that what feels to him most like "understanding" is found when physics concepts are expressed verbally, as opposed to in the language of logic or mathematics. He goes on to suggest that this is not merely his own preference, but is likely something significant about human cognition: he suggests that if we were to study which concepts and operations have survived in physics, out of all the possible conceivable concepts,
...I am convinced that the verbal factor wold be found to be one of the most important factors determining selection and survival. The concepts of physics which we inherited ready-made were such that they fit the same verbal pattern as the more familiar objects of daily life; we demand of any new concepts which we are forced to invent to meet new previously unknown situations that they permit the familiar verbal handling. ...For our verbal habits have evolved from millions of years of searching for adequate methods of dealing verbally with external situations, eliminating methods that were not a close enough fit. (p. x-xi)
I have the idea that Bridgman would be pleased by embodied cognition. I also think he would be a fan of Ochs, based on something he said about the development of atomic theory (long before it had any justification in experiment):
It just seems to be a fact about our thinking machinery that we must have our atoms; we cannot think of the velocity of a uniform fluid without imaging the "particles" of which the fluid is composed... Perhaps the human necessity for its particles is connected with the necessity for "identification" in thinking; the very words we use are little islands of identification in the amorphous sea of our cerebration, and the particle of a fluid is a little materialized piece of identifiability. (p. 9-10)
I am never going to get to the second law at this rate; but I'm really enjoying myself.
Motorcycle current
I'm going back and watching video we've collected from teachers' classrooms for evidence of PCK and attending to the disciplinary substance of student ideas. Thought this video was awfully cute:
This comes from a class that has been using an adapted version of the Physics by Inquiry electric circuits model. The groups are in the process of devising rules for what happens to the current through the battery when a bulb is added in series and (separately) when a bulb is added in parallel.
Not sure what all of the sound effects that Frank is using mean, but I think the circuit that he's 'tracing' with his 'motorcycle sounds' is a parallel one. I think the crash at the end might be when the 'current' returns to the battery.
This comes from a class that has been using an adapted version of the Physics by Inquiry electric circuits model. The groups are in the process of devising rules for what happens to the current through the battery when a bulb is added in series and (separately) when a bulb is added in parallel.
Not sure what all of the sound effects that Frank is using mean, but I think the circuit that he's 'tracing' with his 'motorcycle sounds' is a parallel one. I think the crash at the end might be when the 'current' returns to the battery.
Thursday, October 13, 2011
Light bulb energetics according to Brian Frank
The thing that makes Brian's model greatly superior to mine is that his has a mechanism for current flowing.
Teaching seminar: Goals for the year
The beginning of the academic year means the beginning of a new year of Teaching Seminars, which is a tough subject for me. There have been good times and bad times, in my opinion, but overall I would not call our Teaching Seminar a big success. Attendance is low, participation is ordinary, the video of the teachers' discussions is mostly not rich, and there's not a sense on our part (the leadership) that we have really helped people get anywhere. I hope I'm not being too negative in my characterization of our group opinion.... this is how it feels to me.
"What content area would you like to see growth in for your students this fall?
"What instructional practice would you like to focus on developing this fall?"
We are trying something different this year. The plan is to support teachers in creating more high-quality discourse in their classrooms using an established discourse tool. We have chosen a family of tools used by a team in the School of Ed at UW, called Tools for Ambitious Science Teaching; the developers are local and will hopefully collaborate with us. Our hope is that once teachers get invested in producing exciting discourse using this tool, they will be excited to see how it works in their own classroom, and will eagerly invite us to videotape. (Or, at least, they will feel less vulnerable about our videotaping, because we will be videotaping their enactment of someone else's thing, rather than just them.) And the resulting video will be better than what we've usually gotten in the past, which will both support the Teaching Seminar itself, and will serve as evidence that we're helping teachers improve their classroom practice. This is our vision.
For the first session, though, we wanted to make sure and hear from the teachers about their own goals for themselves, and how we might support them during the academic year. About a dozen people showed up and there was a convivial feeling. As teachers came in, we had these beautiful little books waiting for them (thank you, Julie!):
Abby explained that their task, with these little books, is to jot down interesting things that students say, or that they see happen in their classes. If you can write one little thing a day, or even not every day but just some days, then by the time the next Teaching Seminar comes around, there will be quite a bit of material. The books are wonderfully attractive; they have a soft vinyl cover, they come in these beautiful colors, and they fit in a shirt pocket or back pants pocket. I took one and put it in the camera bag.
After a pleasant dinner, the first task was to respond to the following prompt (I'm paraphrasing):
"It is the summer of 2012! As you relax and hike through the Cascades, you reflect on one wonderful new thing that happened this year. What is it?"
I sat with Jean, Laura, Linda, Jim, Lane, and Stamatis, with a visitor named Ragini sitting in with us for a bit. We had a wonderful conversation in which I learned a lot about each person's particular circumstances, and their wishes for their classrooms, which in some cases were in rather heartbreaking contrast. There was a lot of consensus on the kind of statements people imagined making on this envisioned future hike: here is what we agreed on:
(Click to make it bigger if it's hard to read.) The rest of our conversation was centered on two other prompts, and since we were invited to share individual answers to the questions, that's what wound up on the white boards:
"What content area would you like to focus on this fall?"
"What content area would you like to see growth in for your students this fall?
"What instructional practice would you like to focus on developing this fall?"
The handwriting is all mine. I wrote what people were saying partly because we had been asked to (and no one else picked up the pen before I did), partly to keep our discussion focused, and partly to acknowledge the very cool things that people were saying.
Here is the white board from the other table, which has responses to all three of the above prompts. I hear that their discussion included a lot about Socractic seminars (described here).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









