Thursday, October 13, 2011

Clement on embodied examples that don't work

For my other project, I'm reading Clement's paper on "anchoring conceptions" and "bridging analogies":

J. Clement, D.E. Brown, and A. Zietsman, “Not all preconceptions are misconceptions: finding ‘anchoring conceptions’ for grounding instruction on students’ intuitions,” International Journal of Science Education 11, no. 5 (1989): 554–565.

In this paper, they look for "anchoring examples," which are physical scenarios for which at least 70% of students give a correct explanation with high confidence before instruction. The idea is that these scenarios have the potential to be used in instruction to help students transfer their correct intuition to more difficult examples.

I was particularly struck by his discussion of physical scenarios that he expected to be intuitive students because they can easily put themselves into the scenario, but that turned out not to be so intuitive:
There were also some cases for which we mistakenly expected certain anchors to be stronger than others. For example, given the situation of a hand pushing down on a spring in question 4, students were asked whether the spring exerts a force on the hand. This was considered to be a good candidate for an anchor, but we had some reservations about how strong an anchoring example it would be. We expected that the upward force would be recognized more intuitively in the case of holding up a 30 pound dictionary on an outstretched hand (question 2). In both cases the subject can imagine feeling the upward force, but the dictionary situation involves a person exerting the force and allows for direct use of kinesthetic intuition. However, the results indicated that the hand-on-spring situation was in fact an anchoring example for more students (belief score of 80%) than the dictionary-on-hand situation (belief score of 65%). One possible reason for the spring being a stronger anchor is that the spring moves up when the hand is removed, whereas this is not so obvious for the hand when the book is removed.

Perhaps the most surprising result from this study was the low belief score for the log exerting a force on Mr T’s chest in question 1. We predicted this situation would be a solid anchor for students because of the opportunity to identify with the person in the problem. However, this situation was an anchor for only 53% of the students. A full 30% answered, although some with low confidence, that the log would not exert a force. We are interested in using deeper probes and analysis techniques to determine the origins of these anomalous responses in the future.
His description of what he expected seems very much in line with the way we describe how embodied learning activities build on the theory of Ochs. He does not offer any speculation about why these anchors didn't work as well as he expected. Surely this has some kind of implications for our work...

Wednesday, October 12, 2011

Light bulb energetics

In watching those light bulb energy theater episodes, I realized I needed to do some thinking about energy transfers and transformations in a light bulb that is burning steadily.  Here's what I feel clear on:  Energy, which I will call electrical energy, enters the bulb.  Electrical energy is transformed into thermal and light energy in the filament.  Thermal and light energy leave the bulb.  Check.

How does the electrical energy enter the bulb?  By means of the current, right?  Energy is carried by objects, and electrons are the objects that are going into the bulb.  That's why I called it "electrical" energy in the first place.  But, here is the issue that Russell brings up in the first episode of my earlier post:  The electrons leave the bulb, too.  And the current is exactly the same when it goes out as when it came in.  How can a current lose energy (as it must, if thermal and light energy are going to be produced at the filament) and yet be the same afterwards?

Over lunch, Amy and I did our darndest to think of what could be different that we might not be thinking of.  Could the electrons have less kinetic energy after the filament, and perhaps be differently dispersed in the wire to make up for it?  We think the answer is no.  We think that anything we could measure about the charges in the wire would be the same before the filament as after it.

My physics brain, meanwhile, was reminding me that there is something different about the electrons before the filament than after it, which is that they are at a "higher voltage."  That's just dead knowledge when I say it that way, a vocabulary word rather than an explanation; but it got me thinking.  I thought about the electrons as blocks sliding downhill.  Or actually, sliding frictionlessly on a horizontal surface (the wire), then sliding down a carpeted hill (the filament) so that the speed on the hill is constant, then sliding horizontally again (the other wire), and then being lifted back to their starting point by an elevator (the battery).  The blocks are the same before and after the hill – anything I cared to measure about any one block is the same, and a movie of the set of blocks on the lower level looks the same as a movie of the set of blocks on the higher level.  Yet they "generated" thermal energy on the way, when they rubbed on the carpet.  So the upper blocks must have had some energy not associated with an observable property of each block itself.  The only thing that changed is the height.  On that basis, I hereby invent "height energy" in the context of electric circuits.  Except it's not height; it's position relative to the battery.  So let's call it "position energy," or "arrangement energy," or "configuration energy."

Position energy is tricky, because you can't see anything about the object itself, in isolation, that tells you that it has more energy.  You know that the object has more energy because it can make more of something happen - it can warm the carpet more, or light the filament more.  But you can't see that (ahem) potential directly.

I'm also ready to define a "field" now, and my definition is:  A set of different positions associated with different energies.

Light bulb energy theater

I needed more video of Energy Theater for the paper I'm writing, and also Michael Wittmann needed some for a class he's teaching that is discussing our work - his deadline helped me get on the stick.  Abby remembered what she thought would be a good one from E1 this summer, and she is so right!  It's full of great stuff.  Here are three episodes in which E1 teachers negotiate and then enact energy theater for an incandescent light bulb. The episodes take place back-to-back, so the below is in some sense a single 22-minute "episode," but the conversation naturally divided itself into three topics, so I broke it up.

In the first episode, they discuss whether the fact that the electrons go in a loop means that they, the energy, should also go in a loop.  Their discussion is initially about disambiguating matter and energy; eventually, the issue is refined to be about the fact that the electrons are carriers of electrical energy, some of which is transferred to the filament but some of which stays with the electrons.


In the second episode, they discuss whether the thermal energy and light energy are made simultaneously in the filament or whether light energy is made from thermal energy (or vice versa).  Lane makes what I think is a terrific move, which is that he tells them the answer straight out, but not in terms of the ET representation:  he says something like, "The filament glows because it is hot," leaving them to translate that into ET.  There is also a juicy bit in which Tomme states that it is "physically impossible" for thermal energy to transform into light energy, because "light is a higher energy state than heat."


In the third episode they act out the energy theater.  Something to note is that all their planning is represented in the above episodes -- they don't really "rehearse" their energy theater, or learn from the model that they enact, because they don't have time.  Christine takes the lead and they all follow her directing.


I look forward to discussing these in a future group meeting.

Tuesday, October 11, 2011

Classroom Observation of ET

My observation of Mrs. B's 7th/8th Gr. ET - 10/10/2011

So much to talk about!  I had such a blast going observing with Rachel.  I felt like the response we got from Mrs. B was super positive and I hope that I get to do more of these observations.

We observed two classes and the differences between the two classes were absolutely striking!  Each class that she has was a small number of students compared to her regular class because 1/2 the students were out for a field trip.  The first class - Period 4 - was 16 students 10 boys, 6 girls and the second class - 5th period - was only 9 students 4 boys, 5 girls.  These students were asked to do ET for a bouncing tennis ball, from the point it just starts touching the ground, to the point it just leaves the ground.  I thought this was uber hard for the students to start with, but maybe it was just me!

The main difference between the classrooms was the students willingness to participate.  I feel like the group I watched in 4th period was paranoid about saying anything.  They were simply listening to the one student Jacob make his statement, and then followed along without considering it to be correct.  The "discussion" only lasted a little while and then they all stood around awkwardly for some time.  Finally, because I am not a good observer yet, I asked them to do it again so that I could see what was going on....then Mrs. B came over and asked them some questions that got them started again.  They couldn't move on without her really.
The 5th period class however, because it was smaller, had the full attention of Mrs. B because there was only one ET group.  I thought this class did an amazing job of working together at the time - but now I realize that although there were only 9 students, three of them were really the ones that were doing most of the talking.  Three others were called out to talk by Mrs. B, and four of them basically didn't say anything.  Were the numbers so skewed for the teachers?  It might be interesting to compare the participation of the members of the groups of adults to students.

When I came out of this class, I was so pumped up about trying to figure out ways to help out our teachers who were in the EP Workshop and wanted to use ET in the classroom.  I felt like the bridge between what happens during the summer and the classroom during the year was really not there.  Although Mrs. B did a great job on the first go-around, I felt like even between the 4th and 5th classes, things improved that could have been scaffolded a bit better for her coming out of the workshop.  A few changes/additions that I thought were really valuable that could happen were:
   1. Parent volunteers - In this case, Mrs. B was brilliant to introduce ET with the prior knowledge that her classes were going to be smaller.  However, in most classes, this opportunity is NOT possible, so how do you deal with 30ish students all learning ET at once and in different groups?   Perhaps you ask parent volunteers or other teachers to help out for this one day/training period.  That kind of support would have helped tremendously and could be something that we helped support by allowing teachers in the Seattle area a chance to help each other and providing money for a sub.  But I don't know if this is possible! :)
   2. Emphasis on conversation - I feel that although the teachers had great models for the style of open-ended classrooms during the summer, perhaps this could have been pointed out more explicitly for the teachers so that they could apply it.  I felt like Mrs. B was trying to let the students do their own thinking but that she didn't know how to "train" them to steer the conversation themselves.  I know it was only middle school, but I still feel like listening and critically thinking about what others are saying could be something that students do!  For the second class, Mrs. B emphasized that she wanted to hear everyone's conversation and ideas and that the important piece was the talking and discussing that the did.   This helped I think for 5th period.
   3. Suggestions for ET newbies in their classrooms - Now that we have some teachers who have tried ET in their classrooms, I think it would be awesome to have some of those veteran teachers of ET coming in to talk to the E1 teachers during the summer workshop, or at least if we asked them what they would say to teachers (as kind of a list of advice for them when they try it).
   4.  Allow total screw ups and start with an easy example - I think that the whole point of ET that is so awesome is that the finished product doesn't have to be wonderful (the first time) and that is is okay if they are not absolutely accurate.  I feel like the teachers in the EP workshop did excellent ET and I hope that they don't expect that of their kids the first time.  That said, Mrs. B said that just dropping a ball was too easy an example for her students to start with and I wonder if that is really true.  She started with an example that I thought was really hard.  It was tough to bring in Elastic energy, kinetic, and heat (as she called it) from friction.  Her introduction example the second class was much better. (4th period she talked about a roller coaster, and 5th period she referred to the first part of the ball's journey as it fell the second time.)
I am sure I will add more ....there is so much more!

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Cosmopolitan and Embodied Cognition

I forgot to post these pictures! So, very fittingly (because it was on the way home from EPSRI), at 4 am in a midwestern airport I decided to buy a glossy magazine to pass the time. There was no way I was going to be productive and actually read something useful, like the stack of papers I decided to lug with me. And what did I find inside? Embodied cognition!

Here's the infamous clipboard study (reinterpreted a bit):



And this one I'd never heard of. Interesting. Wonder how they measure creative thoughts.



And my mom always told me not to read trash!

Friday, September 23, 2011

EP Meeting 9/21/2011 - Useful Energy Episodes

This meeting discussed two episodes about teacher's perceptions of what it means to have useful energy.  It was pretty incredible to have all of these talented people show up to watch my episodes and share their responses. First, we looked at Jessica's Useful Energy video from E1, where she discusses Shrinking People to represent the usefulness of the energy.  I am going to write down a random assortment of people's reactions to this episode.
1. Rachel suggested Jessica's suggestion might be a secret form of being "less" energy and whether Jessica really understood it to mean not as much usefulness as opposed to not as much energy.  Lezlie/others thought that even if Jessica knew this - students might not.  Lezlie said that we have seen students interpret less energy with stature in the past already.  Here, Jessica was worried that the opposite might be true.
2. Stamatis was concerned with what "usefulness" actually means for the teachers (and for us).  We talked at length about what the ultimate reason was for the energy and perhaps that teachers might think that the order of energy use matters.  For example, if the energy appears in a certain form at the end of a process, that form might be the most useful...?  Teachers might think that the energy that doesn't "do" the thing you were setting out to do is not as useful - even if it is used in the process.
Other ideas mentioned were:
-  that's not why you were doing it - (so it must be less useful)
- the turbine moving in the coal burning example is more observable, - Lane

- things that are moving and electricity are viewed as useful - Sam

- anything that you have a use for is useful! -Rachel

3. Amy asked how much of this is an association of entropy? Lane said if you don't use thermal energy, it will disperse and "go away."  At this point we started making a list of:

What makes energy less useful?

a. Less useful by changing form - Jessica
b. less useful by spreading out
c. by using it
d. increase in energy ?
e. can't be stored
f. can't be controlled
g. becomes less available


Care should be taken not to make it sound like it is always a one way street - as in it always becomes less useful - unless we are intentionally planning to state that.

4. Both the way usefulness is talked about and Azzam's control comments bring up a human element of use.  We talked about quality vs. usefulness next.  Quality - not requiring humans - Usefulness - what is supposed to be done with it.  Sam and Stamatis brought up the idea that the teachers and ET need constraints.  Jessica thinks that you can't run the movie backwards - she needs/wants the constraint in place. Two constraints that are not there that Stamatis wants are: 1. Can't have Gs--> Ts and 2. How do we show the irreversibility of ET?


5. We watched the second episode - Derrick's talk of the quality of energy from E2, briefly before closing.  Line 40 was discussed (Derrick uses "liberate") - Lane says, 'Run free, little ball, run free!'
Line 38 Tim says the thermal is gone which is a dead end comment!
Line 51 Derrick says, "less that's available to you" and we ended with the big question,
"What is it that makes energy more or less useful?"
 

Talk about a great question!  Thanks everyone for the rich discussion!

Thursday, September 22, 2011

PRST-PER Paper on Substance Metaphor for Energy

Eric Brewe just published a PRST-PER paper on "Energy as a substancelike quantity that flows: Theoretical considerations and pedagogical consequences." I haven't read it yet, but it sounds like something that is particularly relevant to this project.