Friday, August 12, 2011

Understanding and Identifying Energy Ontologies - Have you seen them this week?

I just listened to Rachel give her talk and I have so much running through my mind about the ontologies of energy! Wow! I found the metaphors for energy to be all different ideas that have surfaced in my classroom in the past. I feel like the most common idea is that energy is a substance, but perhaps I think this way because I use this for my metaphor! A couple of different moments over the last couple of days have stuck out to me as times when people were grappling with their understanding of energy through Energy Theatre. I was thinking of a moment when the teachers were doing ET in the E1 afternoon session (110809 1238 T6 & ET video at time 08:32), Rich talks about the higher potential energy, which I *think* is getting at the idea that energy is a vertical location. (Rachel - can you please fix this if I am wrong?!) In the same video, (110809 1238 T6 & ET video at time 10:12ish) David said, "And can we represent, like, the amount of energy by the size of the person?" His idea that they should use the smallest people for the thermal energy that is always in the objects vs. the larger people for kinetic. Lane then told them that each person represented the same amount of energy. I feel like David was thinking of mass as the "Substance" in this case, instead of number of people representing the relative energy.

Have you seen other examples this week?

Badgering

There have been a couple posts (here and here) about the fight in E1 on Monday. I decided to start a new post because I've captioned the video. It's sometimes hard to hear the conversation over Lane talking, and I think some of the small nuances of word choice are important, so hopefully this will help with the analysis:



NOTE: Rachel just pointed out to me that the video embedded here does not have captions. They are definitely in the file on my computer, but for some reason they disappear when I embed the video into blogger. Rather than spending a bunch of time figuring that out, I'm just going to include the transcript here (I'm putting the captioned video on the server so you can watch it there if you want to):

[00:00:01.02]Bill: And where is the electricity coming from? I mean...
[00:00:06.01]Melanie: It's... it's potential energy stored inside the battery.
[00:00:09.27]Bill: Oop! I'm sorry. Say that again.
[00:00:12.06]Melanie: Potential energy stored inside the battery?
[00:00:14.00]Bill: What does that mean?
[00:00:14.28][Bill takes a drink]
[00:00:19.00]Bill: You don't have a thought about that?
[00:00:21.02]Melanie: No, I don't.
[00:00:23.29]Bill: You got a guess?
[00:00:25.14]Melanie: Coils.
[00:00:27.00]Bill: OK. Could be coils. Depending on the type of battery, yes...
[00:00:31.11]Bill: Enhancers? Coils enhancers?
[00:00:35.24]Lane: Blah, blah, blah.
[00:01:01.15][Bill picks up pen and starts writing]
[00:01:05.00]Bill: So... Inside the battery, there might be...
[00:01:09.00]Bill: Coils? and...
[00:01:15.00]Bill: Hamsters?
[00:01:16.09]Melanie: No. [Shrugs shoulders]
[00:01:18.00]Melanie: No. [shakes head] I don't know.
[00:01:20.11]Melanie: I think that this part isn't really working for me right now. [00:01:23.24]Melanie: Umm...
[00:01:24.16]Melanie: And so, if we're gonna...
[00:01:30.00]Tomme: I'm getting a little frustrated too, because you're rather...
[00:01:32.28]Tomme: you're badgering...
[00:01:34.18]Bill: OK
[00:01:35.00]Tomme: To get information.
[00:01:36.08]Bill: OK
[00:01:36.28]Tomme: And it's not working for me.
[00:01:38.04]Melanie: Yeah. It's not working for me either.
[00:01:39.16]Bill: OK, I can try to hold back on that.
[00:01:43.17]Bill: But I am interested in find out what's really going on.
[00:01:47.04]Tomme: Yeah. OK.
[00:01:48.08]Tomme: This is not an educational process that's happening right here.
[00:01:53.03]Tomme: And I certainly hope you don't do this in the classroom.
[00:01:55.16]Bill: Um... I'm wondering what you mean by this is not an educational process.
[00:02:00.05]Tomme: This is badgering on your part.
[00:02:01.09]Bill: OK, I understand, so my... the style that I'm leading in.
[00:02:03.29]Tomme: Yes. Yes.
[00:02:05.01]Bill: Alright. I just want to make sure... what you mean by process.
[00:02:07.15]Bill: And I apologize. I'm sorry.
[00:02:10.23]Tomme: In the battery, there are two different kinds of metal things.
[00:02:14.18]Tomme: Some metals have a high...

I was not part of the group hovering around the the video on Monday afternoon, so I had heard a lot of other people's impressions of it before I finally watched it after Abby posted it on Tuesday. I had heard a lot of people saying that Tomme's reaction seemed to come out of nowhere and that they weren't sure why she reacted this way. But as soon as I started watching Bill questioning Melanie, I had an immediate visceral reaction, and I thought I knew exactly why she was upset. I thought her choice of words was poor, and I wished she hadn't said some of these things out loud, but I definitely understood where she was coming from. I knew Bill from UE1 in June, and I was pretty sure he didn't actually mean any harm, but if I had been at that table listening to him, I would have flipped out (maybe only on the inside).

My interpretation is that he jumps into a stream of very pointed questions with no lead-in or consensus from the rest of the group that this is what they want to do, and as Melanie withdraws, his questions become increasingly sharp. When he asks her whether there are hamsters in the circuit, I feel insulted on her behalf. I want him to stop and I can't believe he doesn't see what's happening and cut it off. This feels like the kind of interaction that happens too often in tutorials, where instructors are trying to lead the students somewhere by asking them a stream of questions, and the students feel put on the spot. I don't know whether this is actually what he's doing, but what it feels like from the outside is that he's trying to be a teacher in a situation where he should really be taking a more humble role as a participant.

Rachel pointed out having a reaction to the way he takes a drink right after asking "What does that mean?" Something about this action feels... arrogant?

I also notice the way he shakes his foot and find myself wanting to grab it and hold it still. I'm sure one could do a whole analysis on how the vigor with which he shakes his foot changes as his questioning gets more intense. I'm not sure what it means. And Tomme and Melanie probably couldn't see his foot from where they were sitting.

I also notice that Roger walks over to them right as Tomme says "You're badgering", observes the most heated part of the interaction, and then walks away. Was he afraid to say anything? What message did this send to the group that someone observed this interaction and didn't respond? Did this legitimize Tomme's reaction in their eyes?

Not sure what to make of it all, but I figured I'd throw out some of my reactions for comments...

Free body diagrams with actual bodies . . .



Yesterday, in E1, Table Six was whiteboarding a story about forces. Lane and Adam act out the scenario for the classroom: Lane's sitting in a chair. Adam comes up and pushes the chair, but Lane and the chair do not move. Melanie draws not one, but two pictures with her group to illustrate the forces in this scenario.


We get a little slice of her rationale in this video clip. Adam comes over to check in with Melanie, who's alone at the table. Here's their conversation:




Adam: What you got? So this is. . .
Melanie: This is you pushing on the chair and friction pushing back and everything else staying the same.
Adam: So what don't you like about that one?
Melanie: I can't see it. That's a dot and some arrows. This is a chair, these are people.
Adam: So, can't you say that they're taking this chair and just drawing it as a dot so it's simple. Well it's look [incomprehensible]
Melanie: Yeah, I know, I did this, for those minded people, this one I need the chair. I can see the chair.
Adam: Yeah, well what's nice though, if you look-
Melanie: -it's exactly the same-
Adam: -it's the same. . .
Melanie: It's because it's not moving
Adam: So the fact that it's not moving is like a force
Melanie: If you're pushing harder, it will move
Adam: You have to overcome like this . . .
Melanie: . . . force . . . that's with you?
Melanie: They made me add it. . .

So, I'm interested in this clip because of how Melanie tells Adam that she can't "see" the dot and arrows. Instead, she says she needs the chair. She's made sense of this scenario by drawing the actual objects. To me, this seems like it could be an example of needing to work through the abstract by drawing on experiences with concrete interactions with actual things. Is this why she needs the chair and the people? Because, well, what can we know about how forces act on a dot from our real life experiences? I've never applied force to a dot. I've never sat in one or dragged it across a floor. We make use of our sensorimotor experiences with real life objects in order to work out abstract things like the forces acting on an object.

Also, I noticed that the arrows are drawn in both pictures so that they all point at the chair. The "Lane push on chair" is drawn with the arrow head on the chair and the "push of chair on floor" arrow is drawn with the arrow head on the chair. The other two forces have arrowheads on the chair, too.

It seems like maybe the orientation of the arrow heads indicates something about perspective, here: of the stuff doing stuff to the chair. Could this be an artifact of embodied thinking? If you were thinking about what's happening by "doing" the forces (embodying them) you might think of yourself doing the push and you'd orient the arrow in the direction you'd act in as the forcer. So, if I'm the ground I push up (arrow head points up to the chair) and if I'm the mass in the chair I push down (arrow head faces down to the chair) and if I'm the friction I push against the opposing motion of the chair, and if I'm the pusher I push against the friction (arrow heads meet on the chair). A closer look at Melanie's gestures in her explanation might support this.

After I got all excited about this, I realized that I have no idea how to draw a free body diagram and so I solicited help from Benedikt. Turns out, having the arrowheads facing the object is not how a typical free body diagram is drawn. After that, I had some other questions that I talked to Rachel and Benedikt about. They were:

Why are students asked to draw free body diagrams in the first place?
What is force? (How do you talk about force without making it a thing?)

I'm not sure I can really think about forces as not being things. Maybe it's because there aren't forces without things. In Melanie's pictures and free body diagrams forces are arrows. Arrows are things. Rachel talked about how force is the doing and that maybe force should be called force-ing. The "ing" makes it verbier.

I've also been noticing this week that there's a lot of gesturing that happens when people are talking about forces. You don't have the arrows when you're speaking. It seems like people do a lot of squeezing, pushing, and pulling in the air, maybe to makeup for that. Are they tracing paths? Feeling forces? Embodying the forces?

Going back to the episode, in the very beginning (13:26), Melanie seems to be using her hands to represent all the different forces in her picture. For example, in this picture she says "and friction pushing back." She's using both hands to poke the invisible chair from both directions, showing, but not saying equal opposing forces.

I'm going to keep exploring the role of gestures when people are using their hands while they're talking about forces in a future post.

In the mean time, maybe I can blame Yoda for why I think of force as a thing: The force is. . . with you. Like, in your pocket?




Coffee Break

After deciding that I'd wrestled enough with trying to get "Leaves in the Street" to load, and posting my previous entry without it, I went downstairs to get tea. In the breakroom, I ran into Sam, one of the E! teachers. He asked me how the EPSRI gig was going for me and I said I was enjoying it a lot. I asked him in turn how "the process" was going for him? He said that he was honestly finding the discussion somewhat tedious. I asked if he meant today in particular (I haven't been observing this morning, so was wondering if something tough has happened) or just kind of a cumulative effect? He said both, actually. I asked for more detail. 'Well, there's a lot of discussion in which it seems to me that a lot of people are enjoying head-to-head and debate. I'm the kind of person that if you and I disagree, I don't need you to see it from my point of view. But there are a lot of folks-- well, from a third-party perspective, it seems that two people will be talking about something and they're just using different terms, but they don't see that. They're not actually disagreeing."
Just thought that comment was interesting.

Content logging

I am starting an investigation for which I need to watch a long stretch of video - an hour and a half, which if you know me, is a lot.  When watching a long session of interaction unfold it's very useful to keep what's called a "content log," which is just a set of running notes documenting what's happening when so that you can find it again later.  I also find that content logging helps me stay engaged.

Inqscribe is ideal for this:  instead of transcribing, you just write whatever it is you want to write, and insert time stamps for every note you make.  When you go back to your log later, you click on the time stamp and it takes you to that moment in the movie.  If you create a content log in your own work, save it in the Episodes folder for your class.

think-then-talkers vs. think-by-talkers

This post from last year (which has 17 comments!) opened a big can of worms about people who need to think on their before they can talk (e.g. Leslie), vs. people who need to talk in order to think (e.g. me and Rachel). We have had ongoing conversations about this over the last year, both in writing and in person, and have been surprised by what an emotionally charged and moral issue it is. We find that we are naturally incredibly judgmental about the other type of person (Leslie thought people like us had no self-control and were just barfing our thoughts all over other people, and we thought people like her were just stupid and uncommunicative), because we assume that others function like we do but are just behaving strangely due to some personality defect. Even after a year of discussions, we still find ourselves shocked and mystified by the way the other type of person operates. Leslie sent me this article a few moths ago, which definitely helped me understand this weird alien species a little more, but it still didn't prepare me for what happened in the car this morning.

Leslie is staying with me, and every morning in the car we talk about what she's going to do in class that day. Today she said, "I think I'm going to start by giving them a prompt and asking them to write quietly about it for 20 minutes, to give them some time to collect their thoughts." I replied, "As a think-by-talker, that sounds terrible. I would feel like I couldn't figure out what I thought until I had a chance to talk about it. I would just be frustrated for 20 minutes." Leslie said, "Come on, isn't writing almost as good as talking? Isn't it practically the same thing?" I said it's better than just being told to think quietly, but not anywhere near as good as talking. (Later when I told Rachel about Leslie's original plan, she gasped in horror.) I suggested that instead she give people the option of writing or going out to the hall and talking, so that both types of people would have the opportunity to think, and Leslie said she would do this.

Looking at the field notes from this morning, it doesn't look like my brilliant plan really worked the way I thought it would. Kristy said, "Class seems ambivalent about either talking or writing; no one has an immediate response to the question Leslie poses about either talking or writing. Leslie instructs everyone to take 5 minutes to think and write and then gives them the option to either keep writing or begin talking." Then after 5 minutes people just stared into space, so Leslie put them in groups and got them talking. Maybe Leslie, Rachel, and I are just particularly extreme examples on this spectrum from think-then-talking to think-by-talking, and most people don't have such a strong preference, or aren't as aware of their preferences.

Leaves in the Street (redux)


Leaves in the Street movie
(*I'm having trouble uploading the video, but will continue to try*)


full transcript follows:

Do leaves in the street have energy?

S1 = girl in black hoody
S2 = girl in purple hoody
S3 = boy in dark green military jacket
S4 = girl in green hoody
S5 = girl in blue shirt under black sweater, with headband
T = Teacher


1 S1: You're such a rebel.
2 ((students murmuring while writing))
3 S3: No- she wrote yes no.
4 S4: What? I'm just writing yes. All right. Leaves in street. I don't think so. Cuz it's
5 just the wind.
6 S2: Yeah. I don't think I don't think the leaves in the street have energy.
7 ((S1 sits up))
8 They have a type of energy but (.) ( )
9 S5: But is wind energy?
10 (.)
11 S2: Wind is energy.
12 S4: OH:: Should we write [it down?
13 S5: [Well they’re
14 S5: [ They're getting wind energy.
15 S3: [But it's not talking about the wind.
16 S2: It's just talking about the leaves in the street. The leaves- the leaves
17 in the street do they have energy.
18 (S4:) (No.)
19 S3: They are pushed by energy.=
20 S2: =They have ↑energy. But they do not have energy (.) like to move.
21 (1.2) ((S2 moves hand on table and taps))
22 S2: (Like) perpetual motion. You'd have to have wind to do that.
23 S5: True but are we (.) I mean (.) uh a: bus doesn't have perpetual motion.
24 S2: True. ((turns to S4))
25 (I’m just thinking like)
26 S5: None of these do.
27 S2: I'm just thinking like (.) they each
28 S4: =It’s just a yes no answer.
29 S2: (like like) The bus has some type of you know (that) and then you know
30 a bike (.) has its whee:ls. ((turns to S1))
31 ((S1 slight nod))
32 S2: you you move. (I’m thinking a leaf (.) you normally [don't
33 S1: [( ) a machine
34 S2: Yeah. yeah. Uh uh a leaf you don't really u::se it that much. You don't really
35 [(.) do::: much
36 S1: [(it doesn't like) do::::
37 S2: You know? It kinda si:::ts there until something mo:::ves it. But wind- well I
38 don't think wind (.) ha:::s energy. Well it has [( )
39 S5: [You can use wind
40 [to like po:wer stuff
41 S2: [It creates energy.
42 S5: It can be a source of energy. ((points with pencil))
43 S2: Yeah. Your wind (.) is like your foot (.) on a pedal.
44 S4: [( ) ((laughs))
45 S5: [Yeah. It's a source of energy. S:: [huh I mean the leaves have a=
46 S2: [So I don't know
47 S5: =source of energy.
48 S2: The leaves have a source of energy but they don't have like (.) energy to move
49 what they're talking about is motion. Is motion energy. And I don't think the
50 leaves have motion energy? [( )
51 S1: [But does it invo:::lve energy.=
52 S4: =You guys I think we should say yes no [because the leaves=
53 S1: [(It involves energy)
54 S4: =themselves don't have energy but the wind (is moving them). So it's a
55 (.) ((gesture))
56 ((S2 raises hand))
57 S1: ((turns to S5)) It invo:lves energy cuz of the wi:nd.
58 S2: But the leaves in the street- If it said (.) leaves moving I would say yes. It says
59 leaves in the street. You could have [leaves in the street without wind.
60 S5: [But the leaves we::re mov[ing.
61 S4: [moving.
62 S2: But they were moving because of the w[ind.
63 S4: [wind.
64 S2: I'm saying if you [ha:d (.) you're like
65 S5: [Cuz that was their source of energy
66 S2: But if you had=
67 S3: =Wind.
68 S1: [But it says does it invo::lve energy
69 S2: [Leaves on the street without without ((looks at S1))
70 But what if you had leaves on the street without the w[ind ( )=
71 S4: [wind
72 S2: =moving. I just think you need both pie:ces=
73 S5: =True. But I mean what like a bus without gasoline wouldn't move either.
74 S2: [Oh true
75 S5: [And like a bicycle without peda[ls (.) uh a pedaler wouldn't move either. So
76 S4: [pedals ((laughs)). I'm trying to like uh say
77 things at the same time ((laughs))
78 S2: I don't know I don't- I just don't know (I just think that) a [lea::f wouldn't (.)=
79 S1: [It's (.) it's like it is
80 but it ( )
81 S2: but I feel but I feel like in my mind I feel like if its (.) it's ↑energy (.) it's it’s
82 involved in (the) type of energy
83 (1.0) ((S5 delayed nod))
84 S2: It's involved in a type of energy [(jus like)
85 S5: [(is that) meaning
86 S2: Well I'd say okay I'm gonna put yes slash no:? (Yes) it's involved in a type
87 of energy=
88 S4: =That's what I was saying the whole time but no one was listening

Yesterday I had the chance to sit in E2 and hear an extended version of Rachel's AAPT talk on "intuitive ontologies" for understanding energy. I hadn't read Rachel, Hunter and Sam's paper (R. E. Scherr, H. G. Close, and S. B. McKagan, "Intuitive Ontologies for Energy in Physics," ) but I HAD watched this video many times while preparing my EPSRI application. Rachel said very little before showing the movie, but she did present the concept of "intuitive ontologies" and she also mentioned her belief in students' ease with flexible use of different metaphors for energy. Then she showed the movie.

The first time(s) I watched Leaves, I focused on the social construction of knowledge. I was interested in S2's interactions with other students at the table; her thinking process was getting a lot of attention, both positively from her and from S5 and S1, and negatively from S4, and I was curious to see how all the engagements were involved in the creation of a group understanding energy descriptions. But this time, with Rachel's prompts, I focused instead on the ontologies S2, S5 and the other students were employing in order to better understand the energy scenario. I found this line of focus MUCH richer--both more explanatory and more supportive of the actual cognitive process the students were undergoing.

One thing that puzzled me on first viewings was the way in which S2 moves from saying (very definitely) "wind is energy"(L 11) to saying seconds later "I don't think wind haaas energy. Well it has [you can use wind.." (L 38). Then in L45 S5 says "Yeah. It's a source of energy". This shift from wind is energy, doesn't have energy, is a source of energy really confused me. I noted the shifts but couldn't track what had produced them, and my impression of S2's cognitive process was inchoate. What thrilled me about the ontological/intuitive metaphor approach Rachel introduced is that it instantly made sense of this progression.

As I watched this episode again after Rachel's intro, I noticed a distinct shift from the use of the substance metaphor "the leaves have energy" (L2) to the stimulus metaphor, in which energy is a stimulus to motion "the leaves in the street...are pushed by energy" (L16-19) to a metaphor of energy as fuel wind is "a source of energy"(L2).

The notion of fuel as energy metaphor is immediately interesting because of the way it supports the 2nd law of thermodynamics. Some energy is 'usable', 'consumable' like fuel, and other energy is thermalized, diffused, essentially spent. It also supports our sociopolitical discussions around energy. The kind of energy we are concerned to conserve, the kind that doesn't automatically conserve itself, is of this 'usable' fuel-like variety. Physicists traditionally operate on ideal systems in which second law realities can be separated conceptually from energy accounting, but it makes sense that students, embedded in the real world, are drawn to form concepts of energy that account for the relevant features of energy systems in the real, non-ideal world.

It's intriguing (from this 2nd law perspective) that perpetual motion crops up as the group negotiates a switch from energy-as-stimulus-to-motion to energy-as-fuel. Here's an excerpt:

16 S2: It's just talking about the leaves in the street. The leaves- the leaves
17 in the street do they have energy.
18 (S4:) (No.)
19 S3: They are pushed by energy.=
20 S2: =They have ↑energy. But they do not have energy (.) like to move.
21 (1.2) ((S2 moves hand on table and taps))
22 S2: (Like) perpetual motion. You'd have to have wind to do that.
23 S5: True but are we (.) I mean (.) uh a: bus doesn't have perpetual motion.

at L 22, S2 is searching for an energy ontology that will allow her to express second law realities. When S5 protests that a bus doesn't have a perpetual motion either, S2 agrees and then tries to formulate the new metaphor more clearly:

24 S2: True. ((turns to S4))
25 (I’m just thinking like)
..
29 S2: (like like) The bus has some type of you know (that) and then you know
30 a bike (.) has its whee:ls. ((turns to S1))
31 ((S1 slight nod))
32 S2: you you move. (I’m thinking a leaf (.) you normally [don't
33 S1: [( ) a machine
34 S2: Yeah. yeah. Uh uh a leaf you don't really u::se it that much. You don't really
35 [(.) do::: much
36 S1: [(it doesn't like) do::::

The metaphor she's searching for (energy as fuel analog) incorporates a notion of usability. S2 emphasizes the consumption of this usability with the long-drawn out "u::se" and "do:::"--the duration of the vowel suggests a 'burn phase' as something (something like fuel) is u:::::sed up, consumed. Having now shifted (through a noticeable cognitive reach for metaphor--"I'm just thinking like...like like..the bus has some type of you know..") to the metaphor of energy as fuel, it now makes perfect sense for S2 to declare that wind is NOT energy in this sense:

37 S2: You know? It kinda si:::ts there until something mo:::ves it. But wind- well I
38 don't think wind (.) ha:::s energy.

Wind doesn't seem initially burnable, usable. Perhaps because it does not feel organized for use, the way that fuel does? But then she remembers and is reminded by S5 that you can use wind to power stuff, to "create energy" so she agrees in L45 that wind is, in fact, "a source of energy".

Again, what I find nothing less than thrilling about detailed tracking of the way these metaphorical shifts are negotiated is that the process reveals that students are already employing their intuitive ontologies in an extremely logical and consistent manner. The fluid shifting can make the logic difficult to follow unless video recording is employed, and the entire negotiation wouldn't happen audibly unless a small group were employed in the cognitive exercise. But once those two things are in place, it's easy to see the way in which students are engaged in sophisticated virtual testing and refinement of competing ontologies.