Thursday, August 11, 2011

Have you done this before?

The episode below comes from the second day of Energy Two in the afternoon. The groups have ‘mingled’ in order to exchange ‘energy stories.’ (Each ‘new’ group was made up of one person from the ‘original’ groups.) The group in the video has already discussed energy stories about a cold pack and a ball released from under water, and they have been discussing the Gaussian gun energy story for quite some time.


The scenario presented to them is shown in the photo below:



(The participants drew the starting and ending states. Focus on the starting state for the following description.) A steel ball is released (from the right), and there is a magnet-steel_ball-steel_ball trio at the base of the track. From the conversation that happens surrounding this scenario, it sounds like the teachers thought about a similar scenario last year. They recall watching the outermost steel ball on the left ‘shoot out’ really fast.


The group in the video (split into two videos below) has been trying to account for the ‘faster’ speed of the ball on the left for a while. Leslie has been listening in, and she encourages them to use the ‘block energy theater’ as a tool to “help them know” what will happen in the situation.


There is a ton of interesting stuff going on here, from the group’s switching back and forth from force to energy to momentum; to the way that Nina draws out and emphasizes certain words; to the dialogue about the scenario itself; to Derricks’ saying ‘eeeerrrrrrrwwww’ when he’s describing what the ball on the left will do. But what particularly stuck out to me was when Derrick asks Leslie (at 2:20), “Have you muddled around with this at this level?” She seems confused about what he’s asking, he clarifies, she pauses (or processes out loud), and he says, “You don’t have to tell me…I mean, you don’t have to tell me what you came up with, I was just wondering if you’ve fiddled with it yourself.” She answers, “No,” and he proceeds to say, “Cause I’m having a difficult time…”








I haven’t watched Derrick closely enough to see what his posture and behavior ‘normally’ looks like, but he seems discouraged, and his request for access to Leslie’s experience and expertise seemed like a call for help. (As a side note, I sat with Derrick on the first day of class when we were discussing rights and responsibilities, and he shared with me that he had participated in professional development experiences during which he felt that he was “supposed to guess what the instructor was thinking). His response, “I mean, you don’t have to tell me what you came up with…” felt defensive to me, and I wonder whether he misinterpreted Leslie’s clarifying questions as restricting his access to her experiences.


It seemed like there was a transition in Leslie’s participation in the group’s conversation following Derrick’s question. Although she didn’t ‘tell him the right answer,’ she acknowledged that she had not ‘worked the problem out before’ and began to ask more directed questions of the group about the scenario itself. Derrick seemed to re-engage as the conversation proceeded.


The Discovery Channel is my biggest enemy

Ah, the woes of technical difficulties! I am bursting with ideas here and, after facing computer obstacles and idea obstacles, I'm finally getting to posting on this blog. I wanted to start out by marking down some impressions I had from the very first day. One this first day the participants discussed teaching methods use in their classrooms and the kinds of interactions supported therein. Sam, who was participating in the discussion, shared her experience teaching modern physics at the University of Colorado (this was part of a very rich discussion I plan to talk about in another post). With Sam's mention of modern physics, the teachers meandered down a tangent that has proved to be a recurring theme this week: physics content knowledge insecurity.

In this episode the teachers talk about parents and students asking questions about topics in abstract and modern physics. The teachers seem uncomfortable being asked questions that they do no necessarily have answers to. They identify as teachers not physicists, and as a result take on a very negative view towards interacting with pop-science topics.


Jim - Was it, um, Richard Feynman... he was giving a lecture series that year. And this is a really loose memory out of it

Don - You say Feynman?

Jim - Feynman yeah. And some woman in the audiance asked him well, Feynman, how can you, I know this is all great stuff for scientists but how would you, how could you, explain this to, um, quantum physics to the general public so that we can understand it. And he said "ma'am no one understands quantum mechanics."

Tim - I'm not going to explain quantum mechanics to... At parent night I've always got some parent that is an engineer saying "what do you think about this?" I really don't, you know? Dark energy? I don't think about that, I've read about it, its interesting. And string theory. I don't teach that. And I'm not a physicists, I'm a teacher. Planetary geology and I'm a very good carpenter.

Jim - Teach the student the tools so they can go out and investigate it.

Don - Yeah the Discovery Channel is one of my biggest enemys. Because, well, there's always some student coming in talking about some type of... oh guess what I saw on the... they come to me as if I know the answer for it. And I look at... I say I've no idea what, translational, you know, synergy is... Um ok?

Jim - People on the Discover Channel have a lot more training and have studied this a lot deeper than I ever had...

Don - And then they look at me like "you don't know this?" I don't watch television.

Many things stick out of this clip for me. The largest of which is how I've experienced similar student / parent questions in my own physics classes over the past two years. All the time - before class during class or after school - my students ask questions about string theory, about black holes, about some NOVA special they saw the past weekend, the best way to build an electric go kart, or how write a Python script to calculate pi to a million digits. Once I had a parent (an out of work mechanical engineer) keep me after school seeking conversation on the usefulness of some Bessle function and how to take a fourier transform. Sometimes I have insight on these questions and sometimes I have no idea.

In this episode, Jim Tim and Don agreed that technical questions on modern physics topics were a great source of anxiety. Their negative self-efficacy was not only in teaching modern concepts but also in responding to student interests in modern concepts. I almost get the feeling from this clip that interested students were probably discouraged from pursuing such ideas.

As a teacher, these moments of student interest and excitement are the reason I love teaching. To me this is a very personal way for students to engage with physics, and thereby take ownership of their knowledge both inside and outside the classroom.

Some other aspects that suck out for me, which might be work pursuing, are the perceived role between "teacher" and "physicist." This idea of how non-scientists view scientists and the scientific process seems compelling. Especially when then non-scientists are science teachers.
Pursuing ideas of teacher self-efficacy is also a topic that begs for attention. Its a theme I've seen a bunch this past week - how ESPRI participants engage (or do not engage) with the course material based on how confident they feel about the physics topic. (For example, Leslie's start of day lecture on the number i.)



Looking where you haven't looked before....Metaphors and U-shapes

Yesterday the Energy 2 class began with discussing how metaphors can be used towards facilitating understanding. The discussion evolved into how different metaphors about the same concept (time) can present differing or even seemingly contradictory conventions about that concept. For example, Leslie brought up the idea of a tribe in South America thinking about the future as being “behind” you. This was certainly a refreshing idea for the entire classroom to engage with; it really brought to light the action of “putting yourself in someone else's shoes”, as the entire class attempted to consider how/why this tribe's conception of time and “future” seemingly differed from our culture's conventions. (Looking where you haven't looked before!) The class even went so far as to discuss how this tribe could explain to us that the “future” was behind us in terms that we would understand, using our culture's conventions. This scenario of exploring multiple representations of a single concept helped everyone to de-construct what they thought they perceived “time” to mean and then re-construct a more tentative, yet expansive definition for “time”. By attempting to understand the why's and how's of someone else's understanding, you are able to make more explicit to yourself and to others what your previous conceptions were/are. This process of de-construction and then re-construction may be a way of describing how metaphors are able to mediate a “safe space” for tentative meaning to be jointly constructed/exist.

Today in class it became more apparent to me that several teachers found the idea of being able to change the model they were using for explanation or to change the metaphor being used as empowering towards their expression of their own understanding of various concepts like energy and force. It seems that the level of abstraction that metaphors and models offer also offers the teachers a way to become further empowered to make or change their decisions about how to explain their own thinking processes. Maybe what I am trying to say is that the abstraction provided by models/metaphors gives teachers a certain level of “safety” in expressing what they think.

A second comment I wanted to make concerning “looking where you haven't looked before” involved the seating formation of the class in a U-shape. I noticed this new formation (in comparison to the 4 separate tables) offered a new lens to look at not only the interaction between participants but also a new lens to look at the interaction between instructors and between videographers. Leslie and Stamatis seemed to have more direct contact with one another in the U-shaped formation (they were seated right next to one another), and much of their dialogue became directly explicit to the participants. It seemed rather beneficial for the participants to have the opportunity to observe the dynamic conversation between the instructors during class time. Furthermore, it seems that the U-shaped formation of the classroom encouraged the videographers (Jessica and myself) to integrate our real-time field notes during the whole-class discussion much more efficiently and much more frequently.

Finally, as more of a general note....

At this point I am finding my blogs to be a means of simply keeping track of what has happened alongside some initial thoughts. I find that as my observations sink in, new observations begin piling on top of old ones. Although a bit overwhelming, it's a great feeling to be in the middle of this accumulating "pile" of data and ideas...everywhere I look there is a new avenue to explore!

What makes it to the board: assessment via whiteboard

What initially sparked my interest in Group 6's discussion of rights and responsibilities on Day One was an exchange between Melanie and Ingrid where Melanie states "I have the right to be dumb every once in awhile. Please be nice to me if I'm on the wrong track." Ingrid then restates as "The right to be ignorant," which to me was a fascinating way to put this idea. Yet, what was ultimately put on their whiteboard was the right "To not know everything." As I blogged the last week (here), this prompted me to begin to notice the negotiation of the group in deciding what to put on the whiteboard.

There have been other posts that have dealt with interesting aspects of whiteboard collaboration, such as Kara's post from last summer about inequality of access (here) and from the PHSYLRNR listserve on "The Power of the Marker" (here). Unlike the phenomena these posts discuss, Group 6 is actually working collaboratively and productively. They are using the whiteboard as both a collaboration tool - where they can revise and refine what they have written as a group - and as a presentation space - where they are consciously thinking about how to succinctly summarize a right or a responsibility that they all recognize. Also, although there is some evidence of "the power of the marker," they are pretty good about sharing power among the group members. Thus, instead of issues of inequality of access or the power dynamics, what captured me is the idea of the whiteboard as an incomplete assessment tool. What happens to our assessment if what makes it to the whiteboard is a thin representation of an incredibly rich interaction?

The whole discussion of rights and responsibilities was about 15 minutes and this was the whiteboard they had produced at the end:
I want to focus on just a few pieces of this longer conversation, so to provide some context, below is a breakdown of how the conversation progressed (anything in quotes is something that is actually on the board):
  1. "Listen" followed by a discussion of whose R & R's to focus on
  2. "Participate/be active" and "Be Respectful"
  3. "To not know everything" (i.e. the right to be ignorant)
  4. "Turn off phone" and "Be on time
  5. "To ask questions" and "To tolerate differences"
  6. off-topic
  7. "To apply information"
  8. shoptalk
  9. not just give answers (Clip 1)
  10. "Stay on task"
  11. "guide discussion" and "wait time"
  12. "receive information" (Clip 2)
  13. Be patient
  14. Discussion of the role of videographers
Originally, there were several of pieces of this conversation that I wanted to share, but I have narrowed it down to #9 and #12 (noted as Clip 1 and Clip 2 above). There are a few other clips on the server if you are interested (#5, #7, #13).

I chose these two because Clip 1 is an example of an interesting conversation about pedagogy that never actually made it onto the board in that form and Clip 2 is a fairly lengthy conversation boiled down to a single, somewhat ambiguous phrase ("receive information"). What makes it more interesting is that these two conversations are on either side of adding "guide discussion" and "wait time" to the board and for both of these phrases, someone proposed the point and it was written right away with no elaboration or discussion.

Note: I haven't transcribed them yet, so let me know if that is necessary.

Clip 1: The responsibility to not just give answers




Clip 2: The right to receive information



Just to restate what captured my attention: we often use whiteboards as a tool for assessment, but it is not always an accurate reflection of the interactions that actually occur. How does this or even should this influence the way that we use whiteboards in our assessment of group work?

Energy in Electric Circuits

On Monday afternoon, Energy 2 returned to three scenarios that they had been talking about in last year's Energy 1 course: An inflated ball under water, the Gaussian Gun, and an ice pack. My group (table 3, Jim, Tim, Don) had spent less than half an hour on the scenario and when Leslie checked in with them, they had claimed that they had "figured it out." Leslie had left, and Linda Anderson came in and sat down at the table, and all of a sudden, the conversation shifted towards other issues with energy. Linda brought up the issue of energy in electric circuits. Since this is an issue that I have extensively discussed with Brian Frank in the past (an we still haven't resolved it), I was curious about what they had to say about it. Here's the little clip.




Transcript:
Linda: Electric circuits is one that I haven't quite figured out how to think about that, because there's matter and energy, it's like, you'd almost like have to have a matter and energy theater to try to separate out the idea of current and electrical energy...
Tim: [Yeah, I don't... I don't have a...
Linda: [It's a tough one, it's a tough idea.
Tim: We talk about electron migration and, you know, take it from electromagnetics [inaudible]
Linda: Mhm.
Tim: Do you still use a lot of [inaudible] from inquiry stuff [inaudible]
Don: What I do is, I, I'll...
Tim: [inaudible]
Don: Do you have a hand-crank-generator?
Tim: Not any more!
Don: I'd get one. They're like 20 bucks.
Tim: I had [inaudible]
Linda: Uh-huh.
Tim: Oh yeah! I think I do have one of those.
Don: And then, run it through a small bulb, (Linda: Uh-huh) have them crank it, they'll see the light, as they're cranking, pull the light bulb out- the resistance in the crank goes down by about 30 to 40 percent! And as you plug the light bulb back in, the resistance goes up again.
Linda: Oh that's cool!
Tim: Now stick your tongue in there. [laughs]
Linda: [laughs]
Don: It, it, it, to m... even... It am, it amazes [me! It amazes me!
Linda: [Really, that's cool, how much of a difference that is!
Don: Well, and then you start talking about work. And then you start linking the fact that power... they understand electric power
Tim: That is amazing [...]
Don: Cuz you know, they understand the power is just work over time, well, same thing with electricity! It's the same exact thing. Uhm, and, that just, um, so if you wanna... That is the most fundamental demonstration I can show someone, just to let them see that this energy transformation... is...
Tim: Cuz, [inaudible] this little plastic hand crank demo thing
Don: That's it, that's all you need. And they can feel the resistance. And then you mess with them and you, and you, and then to prove your point, you put in a broken bulb. That's the next thing I do, put a broken bulb in. And it doesn't change. And they're like, OK. Now somethin's up.
Jim: [inaudible] physics teacher [inaudible] He had a bicycle, a stationary bike with a generator, and across the handle bars, a series of light bulbs. And he showed the kids when they got on and start pedaling, they had to go faster to light up the subsequent light bulbs.
Linda: We had something like that [inaudible]
Jim: And then you had [inaudible]

The demo Don is talking about is very familiar to me, it is really an awesome way to experience electrical resistance and work with your body. Talking about embodied cognition! (Michael's AAPT talk about experiencing the tension in a taught spring as tension in your arm comes to mind)

Anyway, I'm mostly just posting this to flag the episode for further thinking in the future. I would like to think more about the connections between the mechanical resistance in the crank with the electrical resistance in the wire (light bulb), the work that you have to do while turning the crank and the energy in the circuit, and so on.

Also, at the end of the episode there seems to be an awesome shift in the participation framework. Jim is talking about the experiment with the stationary bike that is hooked up to a generator and a bunch of light bulbs. As soon as he is finished, Don turns his gaze away and toward his computer, Tim is turning his head, and Linda is also looking away. I haven't looked closely at this, but it seems like they're done talking. For real.

Motion Energy vs. Kinetic Energy: What’s in a name?



So I found this clip (see bottom) of a side conversation that I like and I wanted to see what other folks thought. It’s a bit too long (03:55) and there’s a lot going on, but I wanted to share it sort of well-embedded in its context.

This episode is clipped after the E1 groups have shared their energy theater versions of a ruler (bent back) smacking a metal ring. The acted out part consists of the metal ring sliding across the floor (post-smack). Before the episode included here, Lane has asked if there are differences in the representations that people feel like should get worked out. The issue of scale comes up.

A discussion ensues about whether kinetic energy refers (or should refer or can refer) to the coordinated motion of an object or the motion of molecules inside of an object. One issue in the room seems to be, can kinetic energy refer to both these scenarios at the same time? Another is, doesn’t thermal energy refer to this molecular motion? One teacher asks if this is all just semantics.

The episode here starts with a teacher in the front asking if it would be helpful in these situations to use the term kinetic or the term motion with younger students to avoid confusion later in life. At 00:58, Lane responds: motion to begin with, kinetic in the upper grades. A teacher in the back volunteers that the AAAS has avoided the term kinetic all together. Lane goes to the front and pulls up some standards to explore the language with everyone.

And here’s where I think things get very interesting: During the greater group discussion, Brian leans over to Sam and quietly asks @ 01:31, “So is heat- heat energy kinetic- is heat kinetic energy or not?”

Sam responds @ 01:36: “Kinetic energy is classically described as something that's moving as an entire body, an entire mass is going somewhere BUT in partic- particle theory heat is the vibration of particles so it is in a sense kinetic BUT the two classifications are separate.”

He pauses for a bit and then adds @ 02:36, ". . .Kinetic is not that hard to understand. Kinetic anything, kinetic just means motion, the kids can remember that, they're not stupid. One thing kids can do is remember vocabulary, if you use it enough, I mean, when we teach, we talk about kinetic learning to elementary school kids, we learn, kinetically by moving, and they know that and they tell their parents that kind of stuff and they get it. Don't treat 'em like they're dumb. They just don't know yet."

Finally, @ 3:28 Lane wraps up the discussion, "So I guess, I'm just going to go ahead and put the stake in the ground and say that if the ring is not moving then the motion energy has to go to zero." Notably, in the end, the word kinetic is absent from Lane's stake out.



Brian and Sam’s side conversation is something I’d like to maybe revisit again to figure out what’s really going on. Here, in this moment, is Brian asking Sam a question about what kinetic might mean juxtaposed with Sam kind of having a reflective moment out-loud that kinetic as a word is not that hard to figure out and everyone kind of knows what it means. Whoa!

Ultimately, what stands out to me is everyone is able to describe all these different kinds of energy events pretty well without the word kinetic. In fact, it almost seems like a lot more detail comes out in a description without the word kinetic. Isn’t that what physics is all about? Describing stuff that’s happening to stuff that’s happening in the world? I guess I see why we have to agree on common definitions of words, but do we? What kind of descriptions get lost when we give things a name?

Wednesday, August 10, 2011

The "Big Blow-Up" and being Genuine

I'm a little behind on blogging so I'd actually like to 'backfill' a little and discuss what interested me about Monday first, then catch up in another post.

The big focus Monday in E1 was the "blow up" at Table 3 when Tomme told Bill he was 'badgering' and that she 'hoped he didn't do this in the classroom'. (See Abby's post and clip on Monday "How to Interact with Others and Badgering".) I found the EPSRI discussion around this blow-up as interesting a phenomenon as the blow-up itself--the way we all read about the fight in Abby's notes in the am, talked about it over lunch, and (for me anyway, observing in the afternoon) focused on the dynamics in the group for the rest of the day, only to end by clustering around Abby's clip at 3:30 with rapt attention followed by more discussion, with many theories of why Tomme was angry at Bill, and whether Bill was in fact pushing limits and testing the group in a social sense. It's interesting to me how potent a display of anger is in this setting, and how it could consume our research attention as it did. Even today, two days later, I remain intrigued by the question of what in Bill's behavior, if anything, could have prompted Tomme's annoyance.

After the discussion with Amy and Rachel over Rogerian ideas yesterday, and Virginia's blogpost (see Tuesday's "Awkward Introductions: What are you doing here?) about feeling less authentic than she would have wished in explaining her interests in energy to the teachers, (not to mention my own fib to Virginia when she asked me what I'd done the night before, and I replied that I'd done typical toddler things when in fact my daughter was asleep by the time I got home), I've been thinking a lot about the notion of being 'genuine' and what it means in the context of the classroom. Rachel made a comment at some point (during the rights and responsibilities discussion) that as researchers one of our responsibilities is to faithfully represent the experience we're seeing in the classroom. This is interesting, because I immediately and intuitively agree with that as a responsibility, but when I examine it a little more deeply it's not clear to me to whom the responsibility is owed? Is it to the learners in the classroom (who have a right not to be misrepresented) or to the reading researchers in the PER community (who have a right not to be misled)? Both, surely. There is a kind of basic necessity for genuine-ness in faithfully representing whatever's observed which seems almost moral. But what interests me even more is that it seems to me there is an even larger more fundemental 'responsibility' to be authentic as a learner beyond the merely moral responsibility not to fake data. A researcher learns though the vehicle of her research, so if there is anything unfaithful in that research, the person it hurts the most is the researcher herself, who therefore has closed down an opportunity to learn. The real problem with misrepresenting the classroom in our notes or misrepresenting ourselves in the classroom is that it cuts short either our participation in the activity of learning, or our display of that participation. A genuine (which here also means transparent) portrayal/enactment of the learning process is perhaps the most winning form of authenticity in the classroom.

Mary Bridget made a note in Abby's blog about badgering that she felt Bill's having missed the introductions at the table on the morning of the first day may have set the stage for the "Blow Up." From watching this group in the afternoon, I had some questions about the 'genuineness' of Bill's stance as a learner... he pre-selected an 'energy event' (ice cubes melting in a drink) that before the group even left the classroom, and then tried hard to have his scenario included even though the group consensus was not leaning in his direction. The event closely echoed the lemonade probe we used in UE1 in June (Bill attended). The probe led to a great discussion in June about why we can't have cold energy instead of hot, and a decision that that really was an arbitrary decision. Bill it seemed had so enjoyed this discussion that he wanted to recreate it...even though the rest of the group was focused on events in and near the ship canal. He tried for a while to help the group to divide their whiteboards into 4 pieces so that each person could diagram a separate event. Lane constrained them however to come to consensus: even here Bill could not let go. So the group chose a kayaker, and then in deference to Bill, put a glass full of ice on the deck of the kayak. They then used two whiteboards, one of which was "inset A" referring back to the glass (tiny in the main picture.) What I wondered in reflection was whether Bill was trying to recreate the comfortable environment of UE1 because he had been yelled at in the morning? or whether he had started the day with a desire to stand a little outside the learning experience? so I went back and watched a lot of the morning's interactions in this group leading up to the confrontation. I was curious to see if there was something 'inauthentic' in Bill's approach to the group that had prompted Tomme's unhappiness.

This proved to be pretty tedious slogging, watching to see if the group abreacted to Bill's lateness (and there was a comment from (I think it's Melanie) about timeliness being a right & responsibility, but it didn't seem too pointed) as well as watching to see if Bill was checked out, or behaving in a leading manner. Right before the "blow up" Bill did begin questioning in a way that was a little difficult to watch. He kept asking, "what's in the battery?" and Melanie was obviously reaching, not connecting with the question. This is what she meant I think when she said, "this is not working for me"--her body was becoming still, sort of shrinking into itself, and it seemed as if she was having 'brain freeze'. Tomme's response, after defending her by squelching Bill, was to quietly provide her with a detailed description of what happens inside of batteries. On this second, careful, watch-through, I did not read this as a moment of Tomme resisting the free flow of questions from Bill and reverting to traditional 'teacher mode', but rather that Tomme perceived the technique of leading questions to be a little bullying when it was obviously confusing rather than intriguing the questionee. I think her statement "I hope you don't do this in the classroom" was her attempt to express a lack of safety she perceived for Melanie (as well as for potential imaginary students) and wished she rushed to secure. It wasn't a lack of genuine-ness that provoked her; it was a lack of empathy.

It looks as though Bill's effort to reach back to UE1 (and subsequent slightly less than genuine 'choice' of the ice cooling moment) was more a response to being chastised than an attitude he'd carried with him into the day from the start. This led me to wonder if lack of authenticity isn't usually a sign of some kind of internal flight from potential judgement.