Thursday, July 21, 2011

Recruiting a microphone wearer

Every class session, the microphone has to go somewhere.  This is a big decision because it determines what data you get for the session.  If you want someone to wear the microphone (instead of placing it on the table), it can also feel like a big deal socially, because you have to interact with the teachers about something that may be a little uncomfortable for them.  The more we succeed in integrating EPSRI scholars into the classroom learning community (see this and this) and sharing our research with the teachers, the less awkward this is.  Here is advice for recruiting a microphone wearer.

Choose a person who interacts a lot and who seems to be part of a good group.  Ideally, your chosen person sits in the middle of the group, for best pickup; but other considerations might outweigh this one.  For example, maybe you want to mic the same person every day (or maybe you want to mic a different person every day).  You will decide this with the other scholars for your course.

Approach your chosen person, introduce yourself if necessary, and say something like the following:
You: "Would you be willing to be one of our microphone-wearers today?  We're asking different people every day and we would really appreciate your help." **
Teacher: "Um, sure, okay."
You:  "Thank you so much.  It really helps us out.  The way it works is, you clip this part to your shirt, and put this part on your pocket or in your belt.  If you need to turn it off, here's how - you open it up, and hold down this button.  But realistically, if you leave the room to use the restroom or for a personal matter you'll go out of range anyway.  Thanks again, we really appreciate everyone's willingness to take a turn."
Participants will then make predictable nervous jokes about being recorded.  Before you go, learn their names; you will need them while taking field notes.

** Do not say, "Would you like to wear the microphone today?"  That makes it sound like they may as well let someone else have the privilege.  Of course, if someone really doesn't want to, thank them and move on to someone else.

The research half of your day

As an EPSRI scholar, you spend half of each day observing and documenting your class, and the other half of the day developing insights, questions, themes, and so on inspired by what you observed. Here are basic instructions for what to do with that time.

Preparation
  • Set up your laptop to access the Energy Project server, where the video files are stored. To access the server, connect to smb://physicsdata.spu.edu/classes. The login is "scherr" and the password is "EnergyProject." Be sure to plug your computer into an ethernet cable, since the wired connection is much faster than wireless and these are big files. Navigate to 2011 Summer; you should be able to figure out where your data is within that. Dates are YYMMDD (July 7, 2011 is 110722).
  • If you have trouble downloading files from the server, you can also get them from the hard drive where backups are stored. (Previous EPSRI scholars have recommended bringing your own hard drive so you can take home files if you want to continue research collaborations with us.)
  • Obtain QuickTime Pro from us if you don't have it already.
  • Obtain InqScribe if you don't have it already.

Episode selection
The EPSRI accumulates data at a startling rate. Each week of data collection produces approximately 120 hours of video and 200 pages of field notes. Episodes are the gold coin of the EPSRI realm, because they are entry points into an otherwise intimidating library of data. Try to produce an episode every day.
  • Think of an interesting event that occurred in your last observation session. If it's something you found yourself telling someone else about at lunchtime, or it's been kicking around in your mind overnight, it's almost certainly a worthwhile episode. Your field notes will guide you, especially if you flagged moments for later investigation. Use the field notes to identify the time of the event.
  • Find the long movie containing your event on the project server. Locate your event within the longer movie. Find a reasonable beginning and end for your episode. Try to keep a single episode down to five minutes or less, so that it's easy for another viewer to get a sense of things quickly. (If you find yourself wanting to produce a longer episode, consider identifying a short episode within the long one and keeping both).
  • Use QuickTime Pro to create a new movie file consisting of only your episode: Select the part you want with the sliders below the playback cursor, then choose Edit --> Trim to Selection. Immediately "Save as..." so that you don't overwrite your whole movie. Label episodes as follows: E1 110808 CatchyName.mov
  • Store the episode you created on the server in the relevant "Episodes" folder.
  • Add to your field notes where you created an episode, by writing "** episode: E1 110808 CatchyName" (or something similarly searchable).
  • If you can, transcribe and caption your episode using InqScribe. Transcription is analysis, and transcribing short episodes is often quite interesting and satisfying. Use the expensive headphones. InqScribe makes captioning as painless as it could possibly be (instructions here).

Reflection and sharing of insights
  • Make a blog entry. Every episode you create should get a blog entry; otherwise it is likely to go unappreciated. All kinds of blog entries are welcome, as you can see from how others have used this space.
  • Read someone else's blog post and comment on it.
  • Talk to your fellow scholars about what you have seen. Yes, this fun task is one of your important responsibilities!

Monday, July 18, 2011

Science Talk: Teacher empowerment in the context of the Energy Project

So, it’s been well over a week since I gave this presentation for the EPSRI Congress, and I’m realizing just how tricky it is to capture the essence of an informal presentation in blog form. My plan at this point is to wing it and see how it goes.

My experience as an EPSRI scholar has really gotten me all fired up about issues of teacher empowerment and how exactly professional development experiences (such as workshops and institutes) can foster this teacher empowerment. In many ways, this makes a whole lot of sense, as I have been deeply involved in K-12 teacher professional development efforts for many years at UW and I will soon be spending much of my time on similar efforts at the University of Maine. Informal discussions with Rachel and Hunter have also made me think more carefully about the role of the worksheet in such efforts.

Most of my interest, however, in teacher empowerment may be attributed to a “magical” video clip (“We’ll Make Something Up!”) that was collected on the first day of Understanding Energy 2. This clip, which is included in the post and which has also been posted earlier, raised important questions for me about (a) how teachers perceive themselves in relation to scientists and scientific thought and (b) who, according to the teachers, has the power to construct scientific knowledge. I must also thank Enrique Suarez for introducing me to the wonderful book Talking Their Way into Science: Hearing Children’s Questions and Theories, Responding with Curricula by Karen Gallas[1], which provides considerable insight into issues of learner empowerment and what it means to “do science.”

After briefly exploring some of the literature on teacher empowerment, it became clear that efforts to foster empowerment are tightly tied to the establishment of an environment in which (a) knowledge is co-constructed and its creation is guided by the learners’ questions [1,2] and (b) professional collaboration is fostered [3]. Given that teacher empowerment is an explicit goal of the Energy Project, it is not surprising that these characteristics also describe the learning environment in the Understanding Energy courses.

Clip 1: We’ll make something up (June 27). I know that I have already blogged about this clip, but I have embedded the improved video as part of this blog entry. The discussion stemmed from a series of slides that Hunter showed the class in UE2, in which he went through how high school teachers came up with a new type of energy when trying to account for the behavior of the refrigerator.


The transcript is included here.

Margaret: So [unclear], I have to say I'm a little confused.

Hunter: Yeah.

Margaret: Phase energy. I know, we don't have any, we don't have understanding or, we'll make something up. We'll call it phase energy.

Hunter: Mmhmm. Is that okay? Is that what you're asking?

Margaret: Yeah. I mean is it okay? Well, yeah, it.. you know, it accomplished I guess what they set out to accomplish, but is it real?

Akbar: That's a [unclear], yeah

Cyndi: But when water changes state, it's isn't it also said that it changes its I dunno its phase? Is that correct or?

Hunter: Yes, state and phase would be sort of interchangeable.

Cyndi: Ok, synonymous.

Hunter: Yeah

Cyndi: Okay, so, in that context, [unclear] if if because we we are causing that water...

Margaret: What's that what's that energy transfer is called?

Cyndi: Shifts.

Margaret: Shifts of state of matter, I mean what do we call it in the real word outside of the classroom?

Joe: Isn't it all arbitrary anyway?

Margaret: I don't know.

Joe: I mean, you know, thermal energy -- that's an idea. Like you could have called it pancake energy if you wanted to.

Akbar: So, in essence, it's kind of like what the experts which basically are the people that first like kinda first decided to think about it and create the benchmark or create the idea. It'd be the same thing if we called it bluebland. Once everybody agrees to that it's bluebland, as long as it conveys the understanding of what's happening to the best of our understanding, then basically it was okay. Is that kind of the... the thing?

Many issues are raised in this short clip. Do teachers perceive concepts/ideas generated by their peers (i.e., teachers participating in professional development programs) to be “real”/legitimate or simply “made up” (or somewhere in between)? Also, do teachers feel that they have the authority to generate scientific knowledge, models or does that authority only belong to experts/scientists? One of Margaret’s comments also raises an apparent disconnect between what is taught in the classroom and the language used in the “real world” (or perhaps the “world of scientists”).

Some of these issues regarding the nature of scientific thinking may stem, in part, from outsider perceptions of science, as reflected in the following quote from Latour and Woolgar (which I came across in Gallas’ text [1]): “Our discussion is widely informed by the conviction that a body of practice widely regarded by outsiders as well-organized, logical and coherent, in fact consists of a disordered array of observations with which scientists struggle to produce order. Despite participants’ well-ordered reconstructions and rationalizations, actual scientific practice entails the confrontations and negotiation of utter confusion. (Latour & Woolgar, 1979)”

Indeed, when viewed through this lens, one can see how the teachers may feel that the apparent chaos and uncertainty they experience must be something very different from proper scientific practice.

In this first video clip, I was also struck by the extent to which the teachers were turning to the authority figure in the room (Hunter) for affirmation. It happens multiple times in the clip. Margaret starts by asking Hunter if the creation of phase energy is okay. When Cindy tries to explain to Margaret why the name makes sense, she seems a bit unsure of her response and asks Hunter, “Is that correct?” Moreover, even Akbar, who reveals a very sophisticated understanding of concept creation and naming, ends his contribution to the discussion with, “Is that kind of the… the thing?”

Both Akbar and Joe (also known as Brian, at least for the blog writer) seem fine with the arbitrary nature of naming a concept or idea. Joe’s comment that thermal energy could have easily been named pancake energy really jumps out in the clip. As mentioned above, Akbar makes some great points as well, although he interestingly refers to “the experts.”

All of the interactions discussed above provide considerable insight into different aspects of teacher empowerment. I was most struck by the fact that many of the teachers (returning Energy Project participants) differ considerably in terms of the extent to which they perceive themselves as generators of scientific knowledge.

Clip 2: We made up energy (June 29). While this clip would certainly be more useful if it started a bit earlier (but I didn’t have access to the earlier portion while preparing my presentation), I mainly included the clip in order to juxtapose it with Clip 1 (and because I will probably never forget Krishna’s excitement, as reflected in the iEtherPad chat window, when it happened). In order to construct their energy storyboard for an elevator Margaret (“Is that okay?”) and Lisa came up with a new form of energy: rotational potential energy.


Here is the (very short) transcript:

Margaret: We made up energy.

Lisa: Potential rotational energy.

Margaret: Potential rotational energy.

Lisa: Potential rotational energy, yes.

Joe: [unclear]

Lisa: Ummmm.

To be honest, it’s hard to interpret exactly what is going on without carefully viewing earlier video. Are Margaret and Lisa demonstrating genuine enthusiasm because they came up with a new form of energy? Are they being flip? Did they find it particularly funny that they had to come up with this new form given Margaret’s comment on the first day? Or is this all for the purposes of entertainment? (As was discussed during my presentation, Lisa is a stand-up comic.) In any case, it raises the possibility of trying to track shifts in attitudes throughout the professional development experience.

Clip 3: Blind faith (June 30). This clip, which is a bit hard to follow at first due to the fact that multiple discussions are going on at Table 7, features a very in-depth and nuanced discussion between Anne and Cindy about the nature of science. (It is worth noting, before reading the transcript, that Lisa indicated on June 30 that all physicists possess the same large bucket of knowledge. The resulting whole-class discussion, in which we tried to indicate that this is not really the case, included contributions from Hunter, Rachel, and me.)


Here is the transcript:

Anne: Well, I guess I'm but what I'm saying is that I think that there's blind faith. I I - there's blind faith to it where maybe there isn't full understanding but just an acceptance that we call it this and that matter contains energy.

Anne: But that full understanding that you're describing I don't think physicists have it either. I think that...

Cindy: And they will be the first to tell you that they live with a great deal of...

Anne: Well if you go to the physics blogs, you can see them wondering the same thing though. And and one of these articles, it said blind faith umm in something that that we can't fully test, or....

Cindy: But, but what I tend to do as a learner, is if I see a phenomenon and I test a phenomenon and I construct a model in my mind of physics that makes sense to me in each and build in my own understanding then I feel that I've learned something. And...

Anne: Well, that's what Einstein said. He said if I can picture it I understand it... making pictures. But the act of actually imposing. Or even with Feynman, Feynman saying, well it's these you know water molecules that have to stick together close.

Anne: That's what makes me wonder. We're we're using our stories and we're putting them on the world.

Cindy: Well, and we are...

Anne: How do we, how do we know that that is really how the world is?

This discussion highlights a much more realistic view of scientists/physicists, in which they may not have a “full understanding.” In addition, there is explicit discussion of scientific modeling: “We’re using our stories and putting them on the world.” Concern about the use of models is articulated by Anne in her final comment, but the exact nature of the concern remains unclear. Is she worried about the distinction between "made up" models and "reality" (as in the first video clip)? Or is she expressing a more sophisticated concern about the limitations of models in general?

While both Anne and Cindy articulate some rather expert-like ideas about the nature of science and the development of scientific understanding, there are some interesting differences that emerge from the discussion. While Anne routinely refers to other (often famous) scientists (e.g., Einstein, Feynman, physics bloggers) throughout the discussion, Cindy seamlessly shifts the discussion from these other scientists back to herself and her own process (thereby implicitly identifying herself as a scientist/scientific thinker). While I haven’t had the opportunity to observe video of all the UE2 participants, my sense is that Cindy might be one of the most sophisticated as far as teacher empowerment and metacognition are concerned. It would be very interesting to see where she was with some of these ideas when she participated in UE1.

Clip 4: Noodle (June 30). Due to time constraints, this clip wasn’t shown. However, it was discussed in passing. Several of us felt that the presentation by the earthquake group (Scott and Anne) on the final day of class was both uncomfortable and unproductive. This made me revisit the video clip from the previous day. In the clip, Cindy (who is participating in discussions with the earthquake group) expresses her concern about the energy story (or stories) associated with earthquakes. Scott introduces a noodle analogy to support the plausibility of thermal energy ultimately transforming into elastic energy.


The transcript is below.

Cindy: Well, I think that there's parts of the lithosphere which is is constantly in a state of change due to its contact with the mantle. But, how that affects the entire lithosphere, because by the time we get to the subsurface we're at a constant, what is it, 62 degrees or something like that I mean there in temperate climates and then in frozen climates it's another temperature.

Cindy: But, umm, it it the heat somehow does disperse. But there are so many energy stories here. But it's it's I I don't know where you would begin, honestly.

Anne: Well, I guess we were beginning...

Scott: It's like a spaghetti noodle.

Anne: Yeah we were beginning with that [looks at whiteboard].

Scott: A spaghetti noodle is matter. Think of this as a spaghetti noodle. Then you put it in hot water or steam it and it becomes elastic. It starts bending when thermal energy is applied to it.

Cindy: Okay.

Anne: That's good, that's that's a good graphic for for the mantle.

Scott: Take a lasagna noodle

Anne: Yeah that's a good one.

Scott: And and that that's exactly, and that if you apply steam to it, it's gonna it's gonna start...

Anne: And if you let it cool it gets hard again.

Scott: And then when it cools down and it's at rest again and the and the thermal energy leaves, it dissipates.

Cindy: So, so I would say that you are starting with thermal energy.

Scott: That's what we started with the thing.

Anne: No, we we were, but to do it in an energy theater we don't have enough of the ropes.

Scott: Well, you don't don't...

Anne: We need more than three, right?

Scott: Yeah, don't let don't let the ropes don't let the ropes throw you.

Anne: So do you think we should redraw it?

Many (most?) features of Scott’s analogy are incorrect, but it does seem to move Cindy away from some of her concerns (which is likely not a good thing). What seems to be most interesting, particularly in light of the presentation the next day, is the fact that Cindy is trying to make connections and engage in sensemaking whereas Scott seems to be comfortable articulating isolated facts (e.g., thermal energy in the core and flexing of the plates). Indeed, Scott's noodle analogy serves to link these facts superficially and in essence circumvents the relevant mechanisms involved in the earthquake scenario. This clip made me think about classifying individuals as generators of scientific knowledge and collectors of scientific knowledge (likely inspired by Gallas as noted below). Cindy generally seems to be in the former category and Scott tends to fall into the latter category. While Scott knows a whole lot about earthquakes, he and Anne couldn’t foster a sensemaking discussion during the presentation of their energy storyboard (in contrast to many of the other presentations).

Two quotes from Gallas [1] seem particularly relevant to this discussion of Scott’s role in this interaction and the presentation:

“This is a very raucous discussion. I notice that all the children are participating except for Donald, our most knowledgeable science buff.”

“Perhaps the talks violate their sense of what science is. In other words, they have been prepared before entering school to feel ‘scientific.’ For them, science is like saving money in a bank: Acquire an extraordinary amount of information, and that makes you scientific.”

In this episode and in the presentation, however, something slightly different seems to be happening. The rapid sharing by Scott (and Anne) of collected information appears to be shutting down the sensemaking and productive “science talk” of the other teachers (e.g., Cindy). Several teachers (and videographers and the instructor, for that matter) were noticeably frustrated during the presentation. This clip and the earthquake presentation raise an interesting question about the extent to which one’s perception of what it means to do science can impact instruction (and therefore student empowerment).

What’s next? It seems that a systematic longitudinal (case study) examination of teachers’ (1) statements about science in multiple contexts, (2) behavior/roles in groups, and (3) instruction in their classrooms is needed. Such work will contribute to the development of a better understanding of the role of professional development experiences (such as the Energy Project) on teacher empowerment and student empowerment. (A final open question: How does one examine the role of the presence or absence of a worksheet on teacher empowerment?)

References

1. Gallas, Talking Their Way into Science: Hearing Children’s Questions and Theories, Responding with Curricula (New York: Teachers College Press, 1995).

2. Bellous & Pearson, “Empowerment and Teacher Education,” Studies in Philosophy and Education 14, 49-62 (1995).

3. Sprague, “Critical Perspectives on Teacher Empowerment,” Communication Education 41,181-203 (1992).


Friday, July 8, 2011

Emma's Energy Pathway

During my presentation at the EPSRI Congress I shared my own personal "energy pathway" that I developed over the course of the week. I'm not sure what the best title is for this concept (pathway, journey, itinerary, etc.), but I found that creating it really helped me understand why I think about energy the way I do and how I got to this understanding.

Over the course of the week my ideas about energy changed dramatically. In order to make sense of all that was going on in my mind I tried to track my thoughts each day and also the specific experiences that influenced my understanding of energy. This tracking can either be done day-to-day or as a reflection at the very end. I did a bit of a mixture of these two, jotting down thoughts as the week went by and then collecting them all into a full list at the end of the week.

After reflecting for a couple of days on the concept of an energy pathway, I think a distinction needs to be made between the two types of items that belong on the path. The first type of item is any change in my understanding of energy. The second is any experiences that shaped my understanding. I think it would be valuable to list both of these types of items. Of course, these two types of items don't necessarily have to be cause-and-effect. There are many instances where an experience directly changes my understanding of energy, but there are also times when my ideas change without a specific outside influence or when I have a related experience that doesn't necessarily change my understanding.

With these new thoughts on my energy pathway, here is what I have come up with (*specific experiences rather than ideas):



Initial understanding: many forms of energy
Isn't all energy just kinetic and potential?
*Discussion with Rachel who introduces the concept of field energy
Three types of energy: kinetic, potential and field?
Kinetic and potential seem like two sides of the same coin, how can field energy fit?
*Sam’s blog post about energy as a methodology for discussing cause and effect
Energy isn't stuff at all, but just an idea we use to talk about things that happen
*Discussion with Hunter about field energy
If energy can have a certain location (in fields) and certain routes (ex: traveling to lightbulb from battery) then it must be real stuff rather than just an idea
Current thoughts: energy is real stuff that is either active or perched and ready to go (kinetic/potential) and it can exist in fields

New Questions from my pathway:
What is a field?
What is a force?
If humans had evolved differently to have different senses would we be able to sense energy?



Note about formatting: I'm not very familiar with html and blogging so I couldn't make my pathway very fancy. I think it might be interesting either to list ideas and experiences in different columns or different colors. These methods would help differentiate between the two types of items.

My Week at EPSRI

First of all I just wanted to say a big thank you to everyone at EPSRI this past week. Sorry I had to run out so quickly on Wednesday. I enjoyed working with all of you and really appreciated all your support and help with my energy pathway!

Here is a summary of my presentation:

I came into the week having finished my first year at Columbia where I took the year long introductory physics course (a course about how to solve problems). My other significant experiences were my internship at SPU last spring with the Energy Project and also my various teaching gigs (religious school, math tutoring, swim lessons). My internship last spring was pretty different from EPSRI because I was watching video after the fact and could spend a lot of time on just one episode. At EPSRI everything ran at a much faster pace, which created an intense immersion experience that really engaged me both learning-wise and research-wise.

Over the course of the week my ideas developed along two different trajectories: my ideas about energy and my ideas about teaching and learning. To track my ideas about energy I created an "energy pathway" (not sure what the best name for this is yet: pathway, journey, map, etc.). I'll make another blog post specifically about my pathway, but in summary I tracked how my personal concept of energy changed throughout the week and what the different experiences were that caused it to change. I think it is an interesting idea to have the teachers in the classes do the same thing both to give themselves perspective on how far they've come during the week and to inform the scholars and instructors as to what the teachers have been thinking.

My other line of thinking concerned my ideas about teaching and learning and the relationship between teacher and student. For most of my life, at least in a physics context, I've been in the role of student rather than teacher, but observing the UE1 class really allowed me to start thinking about the role of a teacher. Through watching the interactions between the instructors and the teachers I got a much better sense of the importance of student-driven learning. Half way through the week in the evening I spent an hour tutoring math and for the first time I was super-aware of everything I was saying and how the student was reacting. Not that I directly told her the answers before, but I was now much more conscious of trying to ask questions that would promote her own thinking and help her come to the answer herself.

Over the three day weekend break from EPSRI I gained a sense of the importance and uniqueness of the environments of the UE1 and UE2 classes. After having been completely immersed in open discussion of energy for five days in a row, I suddenly found myself cut off from interactions about energy over the weekend. My progress on thinking about energy that I had made throughout the week slowed way down, if it didn't come completely to a stop. Without the constant input of new ideas and without other people there to engage with my questions and ideas I had no one but myself to keep motivating my sense-making. (Note: I did try to bring the topic of energy up at the dinner table, but I got nothing but blank stares from the rest of my family). The weekend break made me realize the importance of the group learning environment where everyone is there to support each other and stimulate each other's ideas. This environment that is sustained for 7 hours each day is not one that I have encountered in any class I have ever taken, so not only do I realize its importance but also its uniqueness.

In the rest of my presentation I focused on specific episodes that were interesting to me. The first one I chose to share was when Heather brings up the question of the necessity of forms of energy. After discussing what is or isn't chemical energy, she admits to the class that she is debating if forms of energy exist at all and if there is not just one "pure substance" that IS energy. I blogged about this moment in more detail here.

The next episode I shared was the one in which Dorothy and Lezlie work with Brian to figure out why heat moves from hot to cold and not cold to hot. I find this episode very interesting because Dorothy discovers that Brian's resistance to the hot to cold reasoning is due to his using a different framework. Once she realizes this discrepancy she is able to explain the arbitrary decision physicists have made to use the reference frame of absolute zero for measuring temperature. I blogged about this episode here.

Finally I shared a comparison between an episode of Brian on day one and an episode of Brian on day five. Both episodes concern his thoughts on entropy. On the first day he directly asks Bill, a teacher who seems to know a fair bit about energy, what entropy is. All this thinking about energy has gotten Brian thinking about what happens "at the end" of the energy story. He comments that he finds depressing the idea that all the energy in the universe eventually spreads out and gets colder and colder. Then on the last day of the class he brings up the idea of entropy again and it is clear that he hasn't really changed his mind about it very much. He talks about the poet (Frost) describing how the world will end. In fire? In ice? And reiterates that he is very disturbed by the idea that energy will eventually dissipate. I found it interesting that his thoughts don't seem to change very much and that the issue was really emphasized for him as he learned about energy throughout the week.


At the end of my presentation I discussed what may come next for me. I will return to Columbia in the fall for my sophomore year and continue taking physics and astrophysics classes. I'm sure that my energy pathway is not finished and that it will continue to develop and reshape as I am exposed to new ideas; however I don't think it will ever progress as quickly as it did during the intense week of EPSRI. I also hope to take my new perspectives on teaching and learning and the student-teacher relationship and apply these new ideas to my various teaching ventures. Also, I'm confident that this experience working closely with a group of researchers has prepared me for whatever research I take part in next. Whether it's research about astrophysics, volcanoes, or physics education, I'm sure that my experience working with the rest of the scholars will inform the next research project I'm involved in.

Thursday, July 7, 2011

I.D.E.A.: "Interest-Driven Education Always"

This post is a summary of my EPSRI Congress presentation.

That I.D.E.A. acronym was Margaret's last word in Understanding Energy 2, and it's too good.  In reflecting on the week, I thought about two kinds of interest-driven education -- mine, and theirs.

My own interest-driven education this past week was primarily about my direct relationship with the teachers and the development of my personal definitions of energy, forms, and force.

My direct relationship with the teachers:  I originally posted about this on the first day of class.  Here is a photo that is moving for me, because I am on the other side of the camera.  I am having a really enjoyable and informative conversation with Lisa and Margaret, and I feel really grateful to be included seamlessly in what they are doing.  They called me over to the table because they wanted someone to talk to about elevators.


This is the first year that I have engaged in such a direct relationship with the teachers.  In earlier years, we all (teachers and videographers) pretended that the videographers were invisible:  even though we were right there in the same room, we really never spoke to each other, not even at breaks.  This was really awkward.  This year, teachers were talking to scholars through the mic in what felt like a very charming and natural way: "Who's listening to us now - Enrique?  Is that you?  Could we ask you something?" It was Krishna, and he went over to the table to talk to them.  I felt like the openness helped them perceive our presence as benevolent.

My personal definitions of energy, forms, and force: see this earlier post.

My observation of the teachers' interest-driven education has me thinking about their proliferation of questions and their sense of self-efficacy to pursue those questions.

Teachers' proliferation of questions
Teachers' sense of self-efficacy

What's next for me?  A primary goal for me in 2011-2012 is to support the Energy Project in producing full papers on our work.  So far we've given a lot of presentations and written (or are writing, this week!) a bunch of proceedings papers.  That's great, and appropriate for a new-ish project in which many of the participants are just coming on to the research scene.  I think that now our work is mature enough that we are ready to (and ought to) be submitting full papers.  I am hoping to first-author one on embodied learning activities; I hope Sam will first-author one on energy forms (you can see she's been thinking about it a lot), and I hope Hunter will first-author one on gesture/concept differentiation (or however he sees it).

Also on my mind are the August EPSRI, the changes on the Energy Project team as the Closes move to Texas and new colleagues arrive here, and the potential for elementary classroom observations in 2011-2012 with some of the teachers who we now know well.  For the first time ever, they approached me to invite me to observe.  The Energy Project has no elementary classroom data yet.

In writing this up I realized that I had asked everyone else to say who they were, in order for us all to better understand the significance of the EPSRI week to each scholar... but I didn't do that myself.  I am Project Director and Senior Researcher for the Energy Project, and am the EPSRI Director along with Sam.  My primary research interest is in analyzing richly detailed (video) records of successful learning activities in order to better understand what is happening in them.  The teacher professional development that takes place at SPU provides a teaching and learning experience (and a data set!) that is richer, more inspiring, and more complex than any other I have seen; I spend all year analyzing what we record in the summer and I feel like I'm not even scratching the surface.  The EPSRI provides the Energy Project (and me) not only with mission-critical data collection and management, but also with valuable insights, research questions, themes, intellectual resources, and professional community.  It might be my favorite thing that we do.

Crazy smart

Lisa and Margaret (UE2) were supposed to be discussing the Duckworth reading (the introduction to The Having of Wonderful Ideas).  Margaret had not done the reading, but was happy to talk to Lisa about students they both know who have amazing ideas.  Lisa then offers her theory that some people are "crazy smart," like Feynman and Einstein, and quite possibly some of their own students.  Elementary teachers, however, are not likely to be crazy smart, because to be a good elementary teacher means relating to people who have a hard time understanding something.  Ouch.