- 120 hours of video. At about 2G/half-hour, this works out to approximately 1T of data.
- ~30 video episodes. Each episode gives us a useful entry point into the data corpus.
- 170 pages of field notes, documenting the minute-by-minute action of the class in a searchable format.
- 40+ blog posts, each representing a bit of insight into the data, technical expertise, research question, reflection on the methodology, etc.
- New technical expertise regarding HD cameras, iEtherpad, and wireless headphones in particular.
- New relationships: scholar-scholar, scholar-instructor, and scholar-teacher, significantly expanding our professional learning community.
Insights and updates from Interdisciplinary Research Institute in STEM Education (I-RISE) Scholars, directors, and collaborators
Wednesday, July 6, 2011
EPSRI products (Understanding Energy)
Reflections on learning path
Wouldn't it be cool to ask the teachers in our course to write this kind of reflection essay about their path of learning? Not only because it would be neat for us to learn what they've made of it all, but also because it would be useful for us to demonstrate to the rest of the world what they've made of it all. Some people in the PER Community have expressed concern over whether what's happening in our courses really adds up to all that much, and this might be just the kind of thing to help not just alleviate those fears, but demonstrate the cool stuff our teachers are doing.
Tuesday, July 5, 2011
What we learned about technology last week
Camera brands - We needed two new cameras for the EPSRI this year. The model of video cameras we have used in the past, Canon FS200, have been discontinued, and the new model, Canon FS400, does not have a microphone jack. As an alternative, we ordered a couple of the Canon Vixia HF R200, which was nearly the same price, but records in HD, which seemed like an unnecessary but possibly nice feature. These cameras turned out to be a huge headache. They record in a weird file format (.mts), which can be watched but not edited, and it takes forever to convert them to an editable format. In addition, if there is any high speed motion (which there often is in our data), the picture becomes blurry. So much for HD being higher quality! This never happened with our old cameras. We're sending these cameras back and ordering refurbished FS200 cameras.
Wireless headphone brands - Last year we started using Sennheiser wireless headphones so we don't have to be near the camera to take field notes. This year we decided it was critical to have four sets of these so all the scholars taking field notes could listen without being tied to the camera. However, the headphones only have three channels (926 MHz, 927 MHz, 928 MHz), so we couldn't use four sets without them interfering. I did some research into different brands and found that Sony makes wireless headphones which have three channels that are different (915.5 MHz, 916.0 MHz, 916.5 MHz), so we ordered a couple sets of these.
After trying out both brands, I think the Sony headphones are definitely superior. They have less static, are easier to tune, and the headphones fit more comfortably on your head. Also, they have a nifty feature where they turn on automatically when you put them on your head and turn off when you take them off. We had to read the user's manual to figure out how to turn them on, but now that we know, it's pretty cool. They do need to be charged for 16 hours before you can use them, which is important to know. We ordered one refurbished set that just wouldn't charge at all, but I think that set was just defective and we sent them back.
Monday, July 4, 2011
Open vs. Closed Circuits and Inventing a Metaphor
Is this bridge metaphor, and specifically the way it invokes open and closed, useful to someone who doesn't have some physical model for how a circuit works? The open bridge image invoked by the metaphor and the hand gestures reminds me of a knife switch or actually completing a circuit with wires. If you've never manipulated a circuit or otherwise developed that mental model, does this metaphor make clear what open and closed mean? As I observed this episode, I was initially very taken with it.
Then, I thought to myself that if you didn't know about drawbridges, open and closed is the same for a bridge as it is for a gate. So I made up a story that this metaphor might be more compelling for people from the region because of the number of drawbridges in Seattle (plus Enrique and I had just watched a drawbridge go up the evening before, which is pretty wicked awesome).
But then Siri pointed out that (I'm paraphrasing here) that while it might be conceivable that an "open" drawbridge might be ok as a synonym for an "up" bridge, she wouldn't use "closed" to mean the bridge was "down". And neither would I, actually.
So I still wonder if this bridge metaphor works for someone who doesn't have a mental model of a circuit. Or of even more interest to me, would someone be able to _construct_ a mental model of a circuit consistent with a drawbridge metaphor? As Lakoff & Johnson argue, metaphors highlight the similarities between the target domains, and hide the differences. And our physics models do the same thing: highlighting where the model successfully predicts/explains the phenomenon, and hiding where it does not.
Also, I was struck by how Hunter validated Alia's idea about open vs. closed in circuits, using language and metaphor to offer an explanation for why Alia might have had that idea, in what I saw as respect for her sense-making and prior understanding and an effort to help her transform her initial understanding.
Friday, July 1, 2011
ET as an insight into global warming
Kathy mentioned that ET demonstrates the fact that you only have a finite amount of energy and with each different scenario that we represent we see that thermal energy is always emitted. At this point Wendy claims that ET basically explains global warming. Kathy thought that ET stressed the idea that it's important that we find alternative ways to use kinetic and other forms of energy that give off the least amount of thermal energy. They all agreed that these ideas are really important to expose kids to because their generation is going to be faced with difficult decisions about how to best deal with global warming.
I thought this was an interesting purpose/benefit of ET that may not have been thought of before!
Freedom of not having a "scientific" definition
The first thing Eleanor said about the answer was that there is no scientific consensus on how to answer that question. In response to that remark Heather alone said "YAY" again. It seemed to me that she was very excited (any maybe even relieved) to hear that even scientists (whoever those people are out there who package up this information ready for consumption) don't have a full answer. I think this response makes sense because she had been working the whole week to try and come up with an idea about energy that felt good to her as a learner, but that also wasn't "wrong" based on what scientists said. By hearing that scientists actually didn't know what to say completely she was suddenly free to in fact go off on her own road and make ideas that make sense to her. I think she began to express some of this feeling of freedom today during the discussion with the videographers. I'm not sure if the video from this morning or this afternoon will be ready in time for me to look at, but it might be interesting for someone else to track her progression.
On a slightly different note about videographer-teacher interactions:
I'm still very impressed with the number of ideas that Heather and I have shared this week in our thinking processes about energy. I'm a little jealous of the UE2 class where it sounds like the videographers had more interaction with the teachers. There were so many times where I felt like I was right with them and I really wanted to participate in the conversation or at least let them know that I was right there on the same page with them. Also, the teachers in the UE2 class seemed to like having the interaction as well.
open letter from the videographers to the participants
A lot of you have been asking what we do with the video we collect and what we are learning by watching you.
We have been learning an enormous amount from you this week, not just about how elementary teachers think about energy, but about energy itself. You may ask, how can physics PhD’s learn about energy from elementary teachers?
In our training in physics, we have learned a lot about how to do calculations with energy and how to predict the results of experiments using energy. We have not learned about what energy really is, or what it means. Our schooling has not been at all like the course you are now engaged in, in which participants grapple with philosophical issues to which no one, not even the instructors, knows the answers.
What you are doing now is more like the experience of physics research, where physicists collectively grapple with new ideas and come to consensus. We have had that experience in the context of our specialties, but it is only through you that we have been able to have that experience in the context of energy, a seemingly basic, yet very deep, concept that is central to physics.
Physicists have defined some forms of energy and not others based on what problems they were trying to solve at the time. These forms have been canonized into rigid structures like SCREAM, but there is no reason why it couldn’t have been otherwise, and no reason we couldn’t come up with different structures. By watching participants in last years’ program invent phase energy to explain how a refrigerator works, we were able to gain new insights into how a refrigerator works ourselves. Phase energy turned out to be useful, even for us PhD’s, to understand something in a new way. By watching you grapple with forms of energy in a germinating seed, we are learning what forms of energy are for, and why we subdivide them in certain ways.
People, even scientists, imagine that after scientists make a discovery, it is ready for consumption by learners. In fact, educators do a huge amount of additional work to package scientific knowledge for learners, and in doing so, they change the way we all think about that scientific knowledge, which feeds back into the thinking and discoveries of the next generation of scientists. In this course, you, the learners, are also contributing to that packaging and to the way we, as educators and education research, think about scientific knowledge.
Your questions and your explorations challenge what we know about physics and how we think about what we know. By thinking about how to respond to your questions, we are forced to develop new tools for constructing physics ideas.