Friday, July 1, 2011

Motion Energy Outside the Ball

Here is a short video in which Alicia suggests that the motion energy in a falling basketball is outside the ball rather than inside the ball. Her group does a really beautiful job of helping her articulate this idea and then build consensus about how they will use motion energy.




CO2 Cartridge in a Vacuum

If you punch a hole in a CO2 cartridge in atmosphere it gets much colder as the gas goes out. Does the same cooling effect happen in a vacuum?

Lane's model say yes. Krishna's says no.

Do Students Need Teachers?

On Tuesday afternoon in UE2, the Guitar group (Elyse and Joe) directed the first Energy Theater using a storyboard. There was lots of engagement and sense-making, and when I have access to the editable video, I'll point out what I see as instances of individual sense-making attempts. Here's the thing I was struck by, which you can see for yourself in "UE2 110628 1356 Front":

At 18:03 minutes into the clip, Hunter leaves the room. I observe no change in the nature of the interaction of the Energy Theater "actors", who continue to talk with each other (a little) and with the "directors" a lot. This continues until 26:13 minutes into the clip (so a little over 8 minutes) before anyone even comments that Hunter isn't in the room, but aside from that very brief comment, the work continues with same intensity until Hunter rejoins the group at 26:56 minutes into the clip (and the work continues).

So this community of learners, engaged in work with form they are quite familiar with (Energy Theater) but content they are not (since most of the participants were actors and not directors), sustained the pace and complexity of their discourse and inquiry, even when the "authority figure" (Hunter) was not physically present. I'm not sure why I'm so struck by this episode, because I've seen many other groups working together for long periods of time without instructor intervention.

Story-Board Stories, part II

In Story-Board Stories, part I, I posted images of whiteboards in progress and for public presentation from the different groups in UE2. I couldn't get them all in that post, so here are the rest.

Elevator (Lisa, Margaret) note: their understanding progressed considerably as they continued to work, so what they presented to the class (which interestingly they did _not_ do as Energy Theater) is quite different than this. I don't know that we have a still image of their final presentation board, but we definitely have video, and maybe I can extract a still from that video to include here.

at lunch break:


at end of day:


Even though we don't have an intermediate board from them, I've included Alia and Akbar's final board here.

Falling Book (Alia, Akbar)
final presentation board (Alia used this for the Energy Theater):

Story-Board Stories, part I

(my first post!)

The white boards have lots of uses. Two of the frequent ones in UE2 are as a workspace and as a presentation space. Early in the week, Hunter introduced (or maybe reminded?) the participants about "Energy Storyboarding". The context here is very similar to the storyboards done for movie pre-production. One idea was this would help the teams "direct" the Energy Theater for their projects. Since the teams had a long time to work on their projects, they had a lot of time on the white-boards, and it's interesting to see the progressions (in thinking though that's hard for me to make much sense of from static images, in purpose from workspace to presentation space) and also the many different representations. On Tuesday, we were able to take pictures of whiteboards at the lunch break and then again at the end of the day. I've shown all the whiteboards here except for Alia & Akbar, for whom we only have the final storyboard (but I'll talk about their storyboard in a different post). Also, every group that has so far directed an Energy Theater has used their storyboard in some fashion. Here they are:

Toaster (Charlene, Meg, Michelle)
at lunch break:














at end of day/ for Energy Theater:


Pump/Air/Balloon (Cindy) <-- note that many people have commented favorably about Cindy's artistic abilities at various points through the week.
at lunch break:

at end of day (I think this is the same as what she uses for her Energy Theater):


Guitar String Sound (Joe, Elyse)
at lunch break:

at end of day/for Energy Theater:


Earthquake (Anne, Scott)
at lunch break:

at end of day:


(to be continued...)

We need closure (UE2)

There were a lot of interesting episodes in yesterday's (06/30) UE2 afternoon session, and I will try to blog as many of them as I can. The one I would like to start with, though, is an episode that started off with Joe and Lisa, and quickly spread to the whole classroom.

After Lisa and Margaret seemed to be done talking about the elevator situation, Joe turned around and said something the effects of: "So, I feel like there have been a lot of conversations about things that are being discovered, and I would like a review from the instructor on the subject." He then said: "I think that would bring some closure, and a direct explanation, and then move on. And that wouldn't disrupt too much the open-ended nature about things," to which Lisa agreed. (Disclaimer: I'm quoting from the field notes and paraphrasing; once the videos are available, I will post a clip).

They both agreed that they should talk to Hunter about it, and Joe raised the issue for the whole group. Joe explained that he appreciated what Hunter was doing, but he felt like a few bullet points on what, of all they came up with, is relevant and accurate, and what is not. Hunter said that he would be more than glad to do so, but he was convinced he had done it yesterday, towards the end of the conversation about Lisa and Margaret's elevator. And then Michelle said: "but we might be in a different place today. So even if you say exactly the same thing, we might be in a position to hear it."

I see two things happening in these exchanges:

1) Despite Joe and Lisa (and others) being very comfortable with posing new questions, trying to figure things out within a group or by themselves, and being comfortable with the open-ended-ness of the workshop, they still need a science 'authority' to confirm or dispel their ideas. But it seems to go even further than that, since what they seem to want is for the 'authority' to establish a minimum for the amount of knowledge, by summarizing the most relevant concepts and ideas of that topic. And to make things even more interesting, they are perfectly fine with questions left unanswered, as long as the 'authority' admits to it, i.e., "yes, these questions were unanswered on purpose." So, it seems to me like, as the teachers want their constructed knowledge to be validated, they also need to know that there is a meta-structure they may not be aware of, represented by the instructor confirming the intentionality of leaving questions unanswered. And I think these are two perfectly reasonable expectations. Firstly, as human beings (let alone learners) most of us constantly seek validation in what we do, especially when exploring uncharted territory. And, secondly, most of us have a need to feel like there is a 'master plan', an invisible structure that gives meaning to what we do, and are not left to the whims of an inattentive instructor who is not aware that students still have questions.

2) All this brings to the second phenomenon (if we can call it that) I observed. When presented with the request, Hunter says: but I did that yesterday! (which he did, when talking about the difference between having an elevator with cab and counterweight, or just the cables). What's curious about this is that the teachers didn't feel like they were being given a summary, but they saw it more as Hunter taking part of the conversation and trying to figure out what was happening. So, it seems to me like the difference between giving an explanation during a conversation and a summary, is Hunter's role in the learning community. If he becomes just another participant, then he loses some of his cred as a 'physics authority', and things that are he says 'casually' are taken 'casually'. However, if he would have stood in front of the classroom and prefaced his comments with "this is a summary," then the teachers would have thought "these are important things to remember, this is what the canon tells us about elevators."
Adding another layer of complication, we can also talk about this whole issue of: when is it a "good time" for learners to hear a summary, or definitive statement, about a certain topic? It could very well be that the teachers needed a day (figuratively, and perhaps literally) to digest all the new information they had generated and heard, reorganize their knowledge (or retrace connections between resources), and then be ready to recognize what is a summative statement.

At first I thought of both these points as issues of self-empowerment as learners, but now I'm thinking that maybe this is part of being a human learner. Of course there is a continuum for each of these points, i.e., relying on the authority and needing a summary may happen with a range of 'intensities.' And, hopefully, any expert can finally feel like neither of them are necessary. But, quite frankly, I do not feel like I am an 'expert' of anything, so I do sometimes feel like they did yesterday.

Field Energy - my own curiosity

Throughout this week not only I have I observed the teachers going through different thought processes about energy, but I've also been watching myself having very similar ideas as well. On Wednesday at lunch I was pretty much ready to give up the idea of forms of energy and just say there is one kind of "energy" (whatever that may mean) and it acts in different ways and is stored in different ways (the same thought that Heather came to, which I blogged about here). More or less, I was ready to just say there is potential energy and kinetic energy.

At lunch Rachel asked about light energy and where that would fit. She mentioned the idea of field energy as a third kind of energy. I was intrigued but also had no idea what field energy could possibly mean. In fact, over the course of the day and evening I decided that field energy sounded less and less like a good idea. Kinetic energy and potential energy seem very intertwined: energy is either active and going around doing stuff or it is perched and ready to strike at any moment. Where could there possibly be a third option between those two? Clearly, I needed to find out more about field energy.

I remembered reading about the energy stored in the theoretical inflaton field which would (theoretically) trigger the inflation that happened right after the big bang. So I went back to the book (Brian Greene's The Hidden Reality) and looked up field in the index. The magnetic field, for instance, is defined informally as "a 'mist' or 'essence' that fills space and does the magnet's bidding." Well that didn't seem to be a very revealing definition...

But I kept reading and came to the part about fields carrying energy. Could this be what is meant by "field energy" that Rachel talked about?
"Fields carry energy. Qualitatively, we know this because fields accomplish tasks that require energy, such as causing objects to move. Quantitatively, the equations of quantum field theory show us how, given the numerical value of a field at a particular location, to calculate the amount of energy it contains."


So if fields can carry energy then fields (whatever those are!) seem to just be some kind of medium in which energy can either be stored (potential) or active (kinetic). In that case it seems like it's really not a third kind of energy in the same way that kinetic and potential are. In fact MAYBE field are really the only medium for energy. Greene also talks about all the other kinds of fields that exist (strong, weak, electron, quark, neutrino, etc.) Maybe that's what a field IS: the medium for energy. And maybe that's what energy IS: the thing that lives in fields. At least that's the point I've come to after preliminary research. I still need to understand fields in a more involved way than I can with the informal definition above.