Wednesday, June 29, 2011

The curious case of Margaret (and Lisa)

Today (06/29) Rachel and Mac had the (great) vision to set a camera on Table 6 , and observe/listen to what Margaret and Lisa were discussing. This was sort of initiated by Margaret's observation regarding "Phase Energy" and whether or not we should use it in the "Real World" (See Rachel's post from 06/28, titled 'We'll make something up').
What I find striking, and very interesting, is Margaret's attitude to what's happening in the UE2 classroom and her differentiating between being a real scientist and 'pretending' to be one in this special setting. Quoting Mac's post:
(...) these teachers seem to feel that they are acting and making stuff up and that this is not the real world. The questions at the end of some of the teachers' statements may even suggest a lack of confidence and a deference to authority.

(here's the full post: We'll make something up)

So, Margaret seems to fall under the type of teachers Mac is describing above when she seems to question this idea of "making up" terms, since the real scientists have already told what to call phenomenon X, even if the made up term helps her understand X better.
However, there are several instances throughout the day in which Margaret seems to forget how she feels about not using canonical knowledge. All of a sudden she seems to gain confidence in herself, and starts asking really sharp questions, and she won't quit until she feels like she has a pretty good sense of what's really happening.
Here are some examples: (taken from field notes; will make clips and post when vids are ready)

1) Margaret: If a supernova explodes in space does it make a sound? It seems like it would, but does it really?
Joe: There's no air to vibrate
Margaret: But crystal can transmit sound
Joe: But there needs to be molecules
Margaret: So what HAPPENS to the sound in space?! "The space shuttle must have a horn!!" Does the horn create a vibration?

2) Margaret: I didn't realize force played a role in transferring energy.
Lisa: how did we think all these units of energy had been moving around? We could say: these units go from here to there. But we hadn't thought about how they get there?
Margaret: so, what's force?
Lisa: I thought energy were these little balls there.
Margaret: i thought of them as magnetism. But, apart from gravity, what's a force?
(...)
Margaret: acceleration - force is mass times accelration
Lisa: any influence that makes a free body change speed, direction, shape. (reading from the internet)
Margaret: so, looking at those books together --
Lisa: gaining or loosing weight is not a force.

3) Margaret: the heat is causing the free body - water - to change its shape. so, is heat a force? or is it a catalyst for a force? and the force is just the thermal energy?

4) Margaret: Is a single molecule, a solid?

5) Making up "Potential Rotational Energy" when talking about what happens with the pulleys present in the elevator system. (great catch, Krishna!)

And like these examples, many others that I didn't quote or are not on tape. It has to be recognized that Lisa plays a very significant role in these moments, or at least I think so, since she seems to indulge Margaret's intense questioning, and even participates. So, I find it fascinating that the same teacher who was reluctant to use a made up term, and implicitly question scientific knowledge authority, completely switched and began firing these incredible questions about things that most just take for granted. At this point I'm not sure on whether this is the new Margaret, after reflecting on "Phase Energy" and realizing that she does have the power to question whatever she wants, or if it's under certain special circumstances that she feels comfortable to doubt the canon. I guess following her closely in the next couple of days will help me figure this out. Actually, I should go back to her participations from UE1 (Sum '10) and look for a similar pattern. Hmmm...

Theater resources

In UE2 this morning, the teachers were discussing "Energy in Action: The construction of ideas in multiple modes" (E. Close et al).  Scott related especially strongly to the idea of observing physical action in the classroom.  It turns out he has a theater background and uses many of what he understands as theater practices to facilitate interactions among his students.

When the data becomes editable, I'll create the clip -- all I can do now is watch it (because of the file conversion problem we're having), but that's still fun.  You can watch it too by going onto the server:  It's UE2 110629 0828 T7, 22:50-25:30.  I especially like his action for "closing a discussion" at 24:35:  arms outstretched, brings arms together and closes pair of fists, "zzzhhhh-kom!"

Forms of Energy Part 3 - discussion of names and separation

On Tuesday afternoon Eleanor had the class (as a large group) fill in a table about forms of energy. One column had forms of energy (motion, heat, sound), and the other column said "How do we know it's that form?" This was a fascinating discussion, with lots of concern about the names of forms of energy and when to distinguish things as different forms or lump them together.

Regarding names, teachers kept asking what the "scientific" names were, which names they should use, and whether it was OK for their kids to use certain names. There was definitely a sense of deferring to authority: they wanted Eleanor to give them the ANSWER. Someone asked about the term mechanical energy, and Eleanor said that she doesn't find it useful and it's not in the standards. In response, one teacher talked about having to "sanitize" otherwise good curriculum that used that word. Most of this discussion was definitely in the realm of my category 1 - categorical.

Then they got into a great discussion about whether sound energy was the same or different from motion energy. There seem to be two threads of argument here: one about whether you can actually hear the sound - if it's too quiet to detect is it still sound energy? - which they resolve quickly (category 2 - evidence), and another about whether there is anything to sound other than the motion of molecules (category 3 - mechanism). Heather says to resolve this, they would need to find out whether sound travels in a vacuum. If it does, then sound energy is a different kind of energy than motion, because it can exist independently of the motion of air molecules. If not, it's not. Eleanor offers to set up the experiment during the coffee break, but then it turns out that the vacuum pump is broken, so she shows them a youtube video instead, demonstrating that if you put a bell in a bell jar and pump all the air out, you can't hear it anymore. After seeing this, at first most people want to say that sound energy is not a distinct form of energy, but after a long discussion with many meandering tangents, a discussion of how the air molecules are vibrating rather than actually going anywhere (category 3 - mechanism), and lots of discussion about the distinction between energy and objects, they conclude that the question of what's a separate category and what's not is really complicated!

UE2 - Teachers' Energy Framework (06/27/11)

On Monday afternoon, Hunter asked the teachers to come up with what he called an 'Energy Framework' (EF), a collection of questions they would like answered when talking about energy in a certain scenario. As an example, Hunter brought up the 'Car Framework,' and teachers volunteered: mode, make, color, number of doors, etc. Going back to the EF, Hunter mentioned "What form of energy is there?", "Where is the energy located?", and "How does it transform", as useful questions to have in their EF.
Once the activity was over, we were able to take pictures of the whiteboards the teachers had
written on, and compiled their questions on the following table:




(You can download the full file from here: files.me.com/easo/dp44bk ; password: EnergyProject)

It is very interesting to see how Hunter's suggested questions were used either as questions in their own EFs, or as 'parent questions' that helped the teachers come up with more detailed questions about the situation ("if it transforms, where, how, and maybe why?"). Most of the groups felt satisfied with the the EF very quickly, and proceeded to talk about other school-related issues, like the presence of energy in the curriculum.
I was observing Table 3 (Meg, Charlene, Michelle), and this is the progression of how the EF was built:
  1. They repeated Hunter's questions to each other, decided on whether they were valuable or not, and, if they were, proceeded to write them down on the board. Once they had covered all of his questions, they started asking more detailed questions, like "Where did the energy come from?", or "What evidence do we have of either of the above questions?"
  2. The conversation about the EF was put on hold on hold for a while, and they started talking about how, and when, Energy was taught in their schools, and the amount of resources available for them to teach it (kits, lesson plans, activities).
  3. After they all went around the table explaining how things were done in their schools, they came back to the energy question they had written down and revised them, adding some more questions.
I do wonder about how the teachers are using the EF, though, because when they were analyzing Hunter's "dropping the basketball" scenario, it seemed like they were just plowing through the questions, and didn't seem to be paying much attention the 'evidence' that pointed to their answers. For example, a very common form of energy that came up was 'chemical energy', which was present when Hunter was holding the ball before letting it go. But it seemed to me like they never took the time to explain why there was 'chemical energy', or if the 'chemical energy' that Hunter used to lift the ball had actually transformed into 'gravitational potential energy' (a term that didn't come up in tables 3 or 7), etc.

Forms of Energy Part 2 - why don't we already have a name for this stuff?

Krishna asked me yesterday what physicists call "phase energy" and I gave him our standard answer: In thermodynamics, they call it "internal energy," which I guess is OK, but not terribly descriptive or helpful, since this phrase could also be applied to a lot of other stuff. The closest term we have is "latent heat," but this is actually the change in phase energy, not the phase energy itself. Maybe we should call it "latent energy."

Then he asked me another question that really got me thinking: Why don't physicists have a name for phase energy? How have we managed to get by for all these centuries without naming it?

My guess is that it's because we normally talk about phase changes in the context of thermodynamics, where thinking about forms of energy is just not part of the model.

I recently read a pair of papers about the relationship of forms of energy and thermodynamics:
Kaper, W.H. and M.J. Goedhart (2002), "'Forms of energy', an intermediary language on the road to thermodynamics? Part I". International Journal of Research in Science Education 24 (1), 81-95.
Kaper, W.H. and M.J. Goedhart (2002), "'Forms of energy', an intermediary language on the road to thermodynamics? Part II". International Journal of Research in Science Education 24 (2), 119-137.
Apparently in the 80's the British Department of Science and Education decided that school kids shouldn't learn about forms of energy at all because this language is technically incorrect in all sorts of ways (e.g. you can't really separate spring energy from thermal energy once the spring is deformed), and it is subsumed by thermodynamics, which is more technically correct. These papers address the question of whether it might be OK to introduce forms of energy as an intermediary language on the road to thermodynamics in the same way as we introduce classical mechanics as a lead-up to quantum mechanics even though it's technically not right.

Never mind that teaching school kids thermodynamics instead of forms of energy sounds completely insane in the same way that it would be insane to teach them quantum field theory instead of Newtonian mechanics. Aside from that, it seems to me that thermodynamics is just inadequate to describe things like balls rolling down hills and compressing springs (which is why physicists don't use it for this), because it doesn't make enough distinctions. Thermodynamics doesn't use forms of energy, not because we don't need them anymore once we've learned thermodynamics, because it only deals with a narrow range of situations where making all these distinctions isn't as relevant.

But maybe these distinctions actually are relevant. Thermodynamics textbooks always talk about refrigerators and Carnot cycles, but I've never met a physicist who felt that they actually understood how a refrigerator works. That is, until we started working on it. I felt that I understood a refrigerator for the first time when I saw Hunter's FFPERPS/FFPER talk in which he broke it down in terms of forms of energy, including phase energy. And I know I'm not the only one who had this reaction. Introducing phase energy provides a new window into what's actually going on in a refrigerator, even for those of us with PhDs in physics. It separates things that have been blurred together in our minds. It clarifies mechanism. It satisfies us in a way that our previous treatment can't.

So I want to make the argument that there is pedagogical value to introducing forms of energy into areas that we have previously treated only with thermodynamics, not just because inventing new terms is what scientists do and students should be able to do it too, but because these new terms actually help us to make distinctions that we were not able to make before.

Should this be the thesis of our phase energy PERC paper?

Tuesday, June 28, 2011

We'll make something up


During the first morning of Understanding Energy 2, Hunter shared some of the slides from his FFPER talk on Energy Theater with the returning participants. My sense is that he was aiming to be transparent about the broader Energy Project effort and also intending to remind the participants of the power of ET. He included the refrigerator analysis in his presentation, discussing the creation of the concept of "phase energy." This sets the stage for the clip that I am discussing, which is really very interesting on many levels. (Note that the video is of a different table, so you should mostly just focus on the audio.)

In the clip, it's clear that Margaret is concerned about the notion that the participants featured in Hunter's slides were just making stuff up. As she says early in the clip, "I know, we don't have any, we don't have understanding, we'll make something up. We'll call it phase energy." She goes on to raise the issue of whether or not it is real. The language she uses suggests that she perceives this whole construction as fake and perhaps nothing more than play. Without getting into too much detail, there is a sense throughout the clip that some of the teachers feel that there is a huge difference between their behavior in this professional development experience and the behavior of "experts" who have the authority to develop concepts and name things. Indeed, these teachers seem to feel that they are acting and making stuff up and that this is not the real world. The questions at the end of some of the teachers' statements may even suggest a lack of confidence and a deference to authority (Hunter). These attitudes and feelings are seemingly at odds with the Energy Project's efforts to foster teacher/learner empowerment.

I find it particularly interesting that the teachers can productively engage in such activities, articulate very clearly what they (and the so-called "experts") are doing, but still somehow separate what they are doing from what "experts" do. It will be interesting to see if such attitudes shift over the course of the week. Also, are there other interactions/discussions in which these same ideas become apparent?

Forms of energy - part 1 of many

There is a ton of interesting stuff happening in both classes on forms of energy. I'm a little overwhelmed by it all, but plan to get some of it down tomorrow. First, here's the background on what I've been thinking about going into this class:

We've been working for a while on writing a paper about teachers negotiating novel forms of energy (like phase energy). We know we've got some good stuff, but have been having trouble articulating our thesis. At the FFPER conference in Maine a couple weeks ago, Warren presented a poster on this topic and we got some great feedback from conference participants. Based on that, on the plane ride home, Rachel, Hunter, and I came up with something the following: People use at least three different epistemological frames when talking about forms of energy:
1) categorical - what general kind of a thing is this form about? e.g. thermal energy is the kind of energy that has to do with heat and temperature.
2) evidence-based - what is the evidence that we can actually observe that this form of energy is present? e.g. there's thermal energy because it's hot.
3) mechanism-based - what is physically happening in the system that is indicated by this form of energy, whether you can observe it or not? e.g. thermal energy means the molecules are moving faster.
We have observed that people tend to use these three frames at different times in conversation for different purposes, and we suspect that each is important, and that it's important to know which frame your students are in at any given moment so as to focus on the right thing in their conversation and not derail them by trying to help them correct something they've said "wrong" or missed because it's just not part of the frame they're in. We suspect that knowing about these frames could greatly improve formative assessment around forms of energy.

We have video data from a group of secondary teachers last summer inventing the term "phase energy" to describe the kind of energy that a gas has that a liquid doesn't. Early in the conversation, they use the term "thermal energy" to describe it. I get the sense that they know this term is wrong, but they use it as a placeholder, because they're focusing on mechanism (category 3), not names (category 1). Later in the conversation, after they've worked out the mechanism, they discuss what to name it, and there is no discussion of mechanism because they've worked it all out. It would be easy to look at the first discussion and say, "They're using the term thermal energy wrong, we need to correct them," but doing so would have derailed them from their productive conversation about mechanism. And it would be easy to look at the second discussion and say, "They're not talking about mechanism, just throwing out names!" without realizing that they've already talked about mechanism and that isn't the goal of this discussion anymore.

I think we've already seen lots so far this week to support these arguments, but will blog about that tomorrow.